ipl-logo

Arguments Against Physician Assisted Suicide

1065 Words5 Pages

Physician Assisted Suicide: Murder or Compassion? One of the hardest and most justifiable situations taking place in the health care field right now is whether it is acceptable to permit physician assisted suicide. There are many ethical issues that cause this act to be controversial, especially since it deals with willingly terminating someone’s life. This form of euthanasia allows doctors to give patients medication to help end their life. Though illegal in most states, there is a large debate going on about legalizing physician assisted suicide. Both advocates for and against physician assisted suicide have realistic reasons behind their feelings and facts, but ethical issues will be present either way. In the states that physician assisted …show more content…

People who are against physician assisted suicide often argue that those who want to end their life through euthanasia are often just calling for a “cry for help” as psychiatrists say (Ahmed). Advocates for euthanasia often say that there must be some sort of psychiatric evaluation before any other steps are taken. There was a study done that proved that many of those who were considering or committed suicide before, had some sort of physiatrist disorder (Ahmed). Out of the many people who had attempted suicide before in this study, 75% of them were unsure about whether they wanted to end their lives (Ahmed). Studies also show that those who do attempt suicide are mostly mentally ill (Ahmed). These are all reasons as to why people believe that it is hard to people to make a mentally sound decision to not live any longer, therefore needing a psychiatric evaluation. This is why it is said that before any actions like this are taken, there must be more research done to see how humans make judgement calls …show more content…

They may not want to fight back at that time in their lives or have any energy to do so. Sometimes the elderly can feel lonely and depressed because they do not want to burden their family members for any longer. Going along with family members, some elderly feel guilty for burdening their family with medical bills so they think that this is good way to go and reduce the money load on them. Ronald Dworkin, author of Life’s Dominion, says that “many people . . . want to save their relatives the expense of keeping them pointlessly alive . . .” (De La Torre). They can also feel like they are a burden to society. Doctors and nurses are supposed to be able to determine whether or not they believe an elderly person is wanting assisted suicide due to the pressure of other family

Show More
Related
157 Words | 1 Pages

Today’s medical staff faces ethical dilemmas that are more perplexing, challenging, and controversial than ever before. As medical technology develops and we create more ways and machines that serve to prolong life, we face the legal and ethical debates over quality of life, patient autonomy, professional integrity, beneficence, social consequences, nonmaleficence, and the definition of death itself. Raising more ethical, moral, and practical issues than any other issue is physician assisted suicide. Physician assisted suicide is the provision of the means of ending his or her own line with the assistance of a medical professional. Arguments in defense of and in opposition to assisted death have traditionally been centered on the same bioethical

Read More
1869 Words | 8 Pages

Physician-Assisted Suicide and its Ethical Dilemma Alexandra N. Gionta California State Polytechnic University, Pomona Physician-Assisted Suicide and its Ethical Dilemma Introduction As an aspiring nurse in California, an ethical dilemma that I am likely to come across is that involved with patient euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide (PAS). In voluntary active Euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide, a doctor administers a treatment upon request of the patient that will initiate their tranquil death. This is usually done in the case that the patient is of a certain age and diagnosed with a terminal illness that causes them suffering. A common misconception is that PAS is the same as euthanasia, but there is a distinct difference between the two.

Read More
523 Words | 3 Pages

Sometimes the patient and Physician agree that suicide is in the patient’s best interest. Thus Physician-Assisted Suicide is morally permissible. Objections:

Read More
739 Words | 3 Pages

Physician-assisted suicide is a widely controversial issue that is discussed in today society. There are debates over whether it is ethically correct or whether assisted suicide should be legalized for the terminally ill. Each side of the arguments have different viewpoints concerning individual aspects of physician-assisted suicide. Such as certain guidelines that should exist if legalized. Advocates of physician-assisted suicide argue that it should be legal under circumstances such as great suffering through terminals illness.

Read More
791 Words | 4 Pages

Physician assisted suicide should be decriminalized because, from an ethical and economic perspective, those with terminal diseases have a right to choose death. Many patients feel that even though they will eventually die due to their illness that ending their life will be the best way in the end, but due to expenses they can not

Read More
577 Words | 3 Pages

The concept associated with Physician Assisted Suicide holds a critical position within the contemporary generation as a number of different perspectives exist based on slippery slope arguments surrounding ethical understanding. Based on my current knowledge, my conceptual ideas, support the pro aspect behind physician assisted suicide for various reasons. For instance, free will and autonomy (Wong, dartmouth.edu) when it comes to life and death, terminal illness that has no possible cure and lastly, being able to provide the assistance in order to end the suffering being experienced by the patient as well as the family if the patient chooses to carry out the euthanasia. Further, individuals within society are permitted to practice natural human rights and should be given the

Read More
1015 Words | 5 Pages

Physician-Assisted Suicide (PAS) is the voluntary termination of one's own life by administration of a lethal substance with the direct or indirect assistance of a physician. This has been a quite controversial topic, being a debated issue for nearly two decades and counting. There are two sides to this topic, opponents arguing that PAS is genuinely against fundamental codes of medicine. In contrast, I agree with the proponents of assisted suicide, which argue that the government should allow sickly individuals to choose their fate in a critical time. Experts have noted assisted suicide as a large concern for our government due to its extremely tricky nature.

Read More
2141 Words | 9 Pages

Physician assisted suicide is by far one of the most controversial topics that has arose in the last decade. As such, there are many moral and ethical arguments both for and against the act of physician assisted suicide. Because of this, it is important to explore in detail the arguments made both in favor and against physician assisted suicide so that one can better grasp what exactly this sort of act entails. In his book “Understanding Assisted Suicide: Nine Issues to Consider”, Seattle University School of Law professor John B. Mitchell highlights many key points of why physician assisted suicide should be legalized.

Read More
1257 Words | 6 Pages

The moral question of whether or not it should be legal is an issue too complex to attack with a thesis of one sentence but we believe Doctor assisted suicide should be legalized. However, the most effective way to confront this issue would be to create distinct boundaries between physical pain and economic struggles and the extent of an individual’s experience with their health related problems. If physical pain translates to a terminally ill issue in which the life of the patient is simply being prolonged, a request regarding a suicide assisted by a doctor should be taken into account, properly analyzed and accepted if the circumstances are aligned. The economic component of a physician assisted suicide should not be taken into account however, the economic burden of keeping alive our patients who are on the brink of death should be noticed and

Read More
1176 Words | 5 Pages

Based on these biomedical ethics guidelines, physician assisted suicide can be argued as unethical. For physician-assisted suicide to occur, a physician must prescribe lethal medication to a terminally ill patient. Judges on this case argue "the distribution of prescriptions for lethal dosages of

Read More
812 Words | 4 Pages

Currently physician assisted suicide is only legal in 7 states within the United states. Those for the legalization of physician assisted suicide are also thinking about this situation in an ethical manner. They believe that patients have the right to say whether or not it is their time to go. If a patient is suffering or hooked up to multiple ventilators and machines while lying in a hospital bed, then they should have the right to legally let a doctor help them die through their authority. When considering the idea of legalizing it, people like to make you think about the idea of you being in that person’s shoes.

Read More
1379 Words | 6 Pages

While assisted suicide is not as controversial a topic as abortion or gun control, it is quite controversial nonetheless. The idea that a medically licensed doctor can help someone end their life, the exact opposite of their job description, is mind boggling. Many people feel as though this is wrong and religiously a sin, but others feel as though it is every person’s decision how they live and, in this case, how they end their lives. Those who are for physician-assisted suicide have probably had some sort of contact with it, whereas those who are so against it, probably have no reason to try to understand why someone may want to take their own life this way.

Read More
932 Words | 4 Pages

Mercy or Murder Medically assisted suicide is “the suicide of a patient suffering from an incurable disease, affected by the taking of lethal drugs provided by a doctor for this purpose.’ Although this is different from euthanization, when the drug is administered by someone in the medical field, it does not change the moral issue, professional issue and the potential of abuse. Many people in today's society would say that an assisted suicide by any medical personnel would go against the sanctity of life. Religious and traditional people would say that taking one's life is wrong. Since assisted suicide is initially killing someone this goes against these beliefs.

Read More
906 Words | 4 Pages

The American College of Physicians states, “the organization of 152,000 medical professionals stands against the legalization of physician-assisted suicide”. The organization is calling this act “the practice of which raises ethical, clinical, and other concerns”. (“Fewer Doctors Support Assisted Suicide Poll Says”) On the other hand, the number of physicians who support physician-assisted suicide is increasing. In 2010 forty-six percent of physicians were pro-euthanasia.

Read More
2549 Words | 11 Pages

Some say that physician-assisted suicide is an unethical practice that causes harm to patients. Others say that physician-assisted suicide is going to be used unethically and pushed onto those who may not have other options. Although physician-assisted suicide has been thought to contradict medical ethics, the practice's success in Oregon has shown this to be a beneficial form of palliative care. Evidence from Oregon demonstrates that this practice can be used ethically. In addition, physicians can do less harm by abbreviating the dying process.

Read More

More about Arguments Against Physician Assisted Suicide

Related Topics

Open Document