ipl-logo

Best In Class By Margaret Talbot

679 Words3 Pages

In “Best in Class”, Margaret Talbot reveals the stressful lives of students in high school. The majority can relate to her essay since most have endured this unforgiving time in life. The main point Talbot debates is the competition for valedictorian. The author shows that being valedictorian is a respectable honor; however, in recent years it has been corrupted and should be modified by implementing passionate pathos and understanding persona. Talbot is able to use great pathos to advance her message regarding valedictorian. Most of her pathos can be found in the students’ quotes. Stephanie Klotz, a former student, said that she “wanted to make sure the school knew how traumatic something like” competing for valedictorian can be (Talbot …show more content…

This type of pathos is very resentful. The reader can trust in these claims because the source they come from is so credible; therefore, one can more thoroughly understand these feelings. This particular quote shows the painful extent one goes through to reach the top; it also shows how much hatred this person bears towards those supervising the valedictorian position. This use of pathos implies that the competition is unnecessarily cruel to the hard-working competitors. Kimberly Belcher, another student contestant for valedictorian, said that she “felt betrayed. [She’s] not angry anymore, but, boy [she] was angry then” when she lost (Talbot 224). This pathos shows obvious hate and anger. The author portrays the cruelty of the competition, and she …show more content…

She proves she isn’t biased in her writing by depicting each side and at the end, comes up with a solution. Talbot stated that “[m]aybe the answer is to stick to one valedictorian but to make the rules of the contest clear” (231). By showing she is open to alterations for the sake of others, the reader may less reluctantly accept her claims and allow themselves to listen to her. By being unbiased, she can convey various solutions that will be more accepted by her audience. It greatly contributes to her message because an open mind attracts readers; it is a quality that benefits an author. This quality allows the author to spread her message and better convinces the audience of her viewpoints. Throughout the essay she incorporates interviews of people who want to kill the tradition of naming valedictorians, yet towards the end she says, “...perhaps something is lost if schools eliminate valedictorians” (Talbot 321). This here is her concession. If the reader stopped halfway through the essay they would most-likely assert that the author wants to eliminate the contest. However, Talbot is merely open-minded and actually aspires to perfect the competition rather than completely discarding it altogether. Upon viewing this, the reader knows that Talbot is unbiased and simply wants to help. The reader is drawn in because they know that they still can make up their own opinion

Show More
Related
720 Words | 3 Pages

In many high schools across the nation, valedictorians are appointed to represent the senior class at graduation. Many people see the valedictorian as the best student in the entire class or maybe just the most popular. Either way, stakes are high when appointing a single student to this position, and much controversy has been discovered as to what qualifies a student to become the one. Academics are generally the aspect that principals consider most when deciding. In “Best in Class,” author Margaret Talbot uses rhetoric devices such as effective quotes and expressive personal anecdote, two assets tied to ethos, to support her claim that appointing a single valedictorian is an unfair custom among U.S. high schools.

Read More
1463 Words | 6 Pages

“I’m here because I love New Orleans.” Although I can not personally resonate, the graduating class of Tulane University certainty can to this statement because they too share a love for New Orleans. By expressing her love, Ellen is trying to connect with her audience on a personal level. Because she says this towards the beginning of her speech, the audience becomes fully engaged making them want to hear what else she has to say.

Read More
491 Words | 2 Pages

This argument still needs emotion to get an audience behind it. This is where Talbot’s use of anecdotal interviews come in to help to appeal to her argument’s pathos. Without being able to put her own emotions into her argument, which would greatly risk her establishment of ethos, Talbot uses the emotions of others that this has affected to do this for her. Talbot interviewed many and placed their stories into this article. This is even seen in the very first line of the article where Talbot states that “Daniel Kennedy remembers when he still thought that valedictorians were a good thing” and when she talks about Kimberly Belcher, George Kennedy, Jim Corney, Denise Clark Pope, and many others who this has personally affected.

Read More
701 Words | 3 Pages

“Authorizing torture is a bad and dangerous idea that can easily be made to sound plausible.” This is a shockingly true statement. Heymann’s purpose in writing this article is to persuade readers to agree with him that torture should not be authorized. Heymann uses the persuasive appeal of pathos primarily in this article to convince his readers to agree with him. Although that is not to say he did not use other forms of persuasive appeal, heymann also used Logos and Ethos, just not as strongly as Pathos.

Read More
1580 Words | 7 Pages

“Song of the Hummingbird” by Graciela Limon is a book about Huitzitzilin an old Mexica woman who in the book tells both her life stories and sins to a young Catholic priest named father Benito. Throughout the book Huitzitzilin describes to father Benito how the Spaniards took the homes of her people and how they killed two of her kings. It showed how the the Indians were forced to fight back only because the Spaniards took advantage of their hospitality they were offered. Eventually the sad truth was that the Spaniards made the Indians weaker than ever from those diseases they brought with them. Which is the most important reason why Huitzitzilin lost her people and home.

Read More
794 Words | 4 Pages

In his article for the New York Times “Evictions at Sorority Raise Issue of Bias”, Sam Dillon conveys to light the stereotypes created from sororities and how this profiling influences those saw as undesirable. In 2007, the national officers of Delta Zeta at DePauw University interviewed 35 of its members because they were viewed as “socially awkward” (515). The purpose of the interview was to improve their image, and because they feared of the negative portrayal would result a decline in future membership of the sorority. After the interview, regarding their dedication to recruitment, 23 of 35 members were viewed as uncommitted and asked to leave the Delta Zeta, because they were overweight, Korean and Vietnamese.

Read More
846 Words | 4 Pages

Upon hearing the word “valedictorian,” many visualise an incredibly intelligent, studious young person who must be better than the rest, which to some can seem unfair--rewarding one student in front of so many hardworking others-- it’s a bit discouraging. On the other hand, one thing a valedictorian can do is write an impressive essay. In Margaret Talbot’s article “Best in Class,” she illustrates her idea that the idealistic of valedictorian isn’t necessarily awful, but can be improved upon in order to appeal to a larger group of hardworking people. Talbot uses various testimonies and anecdotes from previous students throughout her piece in order to establish her logos and/or ethos. For starters, the first example Talbot pulls is from a former

Read More
329 Words | 2 Pages

In Pat Conroy’s book, “The Lords of Discipline”, the main character often expresses his attitude toward the Institution. In one paragraph, Will expresses a particularly negative attitude. Will’s attitude in the passage is disappointed and even a little bit rebellious. The reason why Will is disappointed is because the Institutes’s plebe system was “destroying the ability or the desire of the freshmen to use the word I.”

Read More
244 Words | 1 Pages

In high school, the pressure to fit in with the crowd often overshadows the need for individuality; however, the protagonist in “Initiation” discovers that staying true to herself is what would make her happier when given the option to join a high school sorority, and this is seen as the theme of the story. As Millicent goes through the initiation process, she learns about the strength of herself by completing the tasks, her ability to connect with different people and her need for originality. For instance, her sister Beverly ordered her around and was generally rude to her, yet Millicent continued to follow her commands although, “rebellion flooded through her.” Furthermore, the task assigned to her of going around a bus and asking strangers

Read More
837 Words | 4 Pages

The Foibles of Bernice and Her Desolate Generation From a dull bromide to a free-spirited flapper, Bernice undergoes several character changes throughout F. Scott Fitzgerald’s “Bernice Bobs Her Hair.” In the perspective of the Lost Generation, Fitzgerald depicts this forlorn, oblivious girl who seeks validation and social acceptance via feeble and repetitive tactics. Weary of incompetence, she appeals to her cousin Marjorie, a veritable expert in the business of conformity, for advice on public image. Several key devices used to express Bernice’s character development, from dramatic irony to figurative language to hyperbole, show that humans who define themselves on the basis of societal paradigms are susceptive to arbitrary and often shallow

Read More
882 Words | 4 Pages

The author, a 19th century women’ rights leader, intends to justify her voting act was not a crime but rather an act based on her constitutional rights and further claims that since all women are also people, all women should not be discriminated because of their gender: just like how negroes should not be segregated because of their skin color. In order to effectively and strongly build her argument, the writer, Susan Anthony uses various writing techniques: use of emotional and deep-seated terminologies to describe the unfair intolerance; analogies with the ‘negroes’ engage the readers; repetition of phrases to emphasize her statement. First of all, the use of the narrator’s sentimental words and phrases enhances her argument’s verity and

Read More
659 Words | 3 Pages

Ellen DeGeneres, an internationally known talk show host and comedian was asked to give a commencement speech for the students of Tulane University on May 16th, 2009. She spoke to the students about the benefits of being true and accepting of yourself, as well as the rocky path that leads to success. Ellen also referenced to her own personal struggles in dealing with the public’s opinion of her sexual orientation and how she overcame this battle. Ellen uses pathos in the form of humor and sympathy as well as ethos stemming from her celebrity image and self-made success in the entertainment industry to present an argument of persuasion for these young graduates to be themselves and love themselves no matter what other people consider to be bad or a failure, and for these students to go out into the world not afraid to fail, because they can conquer anything.

Read More
1464 Words | 6 Pages

“Time,” Marc yelled. William stared at the second hand on his watch in disbelief. “Four seconds,” William said. Marc pressed the button.

Read More
877 Words | 4 Pages

Her speech is a motivational speech for the graduates but as well a form of occasion speech because it has experience, comfort, empathy, and humor. She gives encouraging words to make them proud of their achievements. The target audience is the graduates, their families, and the teachers. Her tone in the speech

Read More
590 Words | 3 Pages

President Obama used pathos the most in his speech because connecting the audience emotions into the speech would typically catch their attention due to the fact that it is something they can connect their feelings with. The way obama persuaded with this rhetorical appeal was by quoting Benjamin Mays who served as president of Morehouse college for over 30 years which is something Morehouse students can connect with. “It will not be sufficient for Morehouse College, for any college, for that matter, to produce clever graduates — but rather honest men, men who can be

Read More

More about Best In Class By Margaret Talbot

Open Document