ipl-logo

Can Aid Ever Be Neutral Or Impartial Essay

573 Words3 Pages

Can aid ever be neutral or impartial? Should it? Founded by Henri Dunant in 1863, the International Red Cross movement forms one of the oldest and the largest humanitarian movements in the world. In principle, like many other humanitarian organisations, it is impartial, neutral and independent (“Who We Are”, 2017). Modern humanitarian organizations have largely been born out of waror battles (SLIM, 1996) and humanitarian action seems to ensue military action. While aid in principle should be impartial and neutral, foreign policy is not. Aid inevitably is often inseparable from international politics. Aid, although a humanitarian gesture by nature, is often forced to be selective, choosing to target its limited resources firstly to those who can benefit and be saved, and putting aside for later those who may not have hope (DE WAAL, 2010).Aid itself isvolatile and limited, …show more content…

After the tsunami in Indonesia,among the hurdles that had to be crossed were the safety of the aid workers, mobility and ability to reach the most affected areas, and working in the same geographical space alongside thousands of other foreign humanitarian workers (SMIRL, 2008). In many ways, the work of aid workers and what soldiers do can draw parallels (SLIM, 1996), as both are connected by their opposite roots in war.That is not to say that they are alike. While soldiers may find it acceptable to carry out humanitarian work, aid workers and agencies do not find it morally right to be militaristic and violent. However, the common agenda that follows in the wake of war is an area that has potential for discussion and coordination between the military and humanitarian agencies. Many humanitarian agencies make an effort to remain neutral, but the reality on the ground and the reality of global politics often renders that impossible. Humanitarian organizations often make choices about where to draw the line of

Show More
Related

Summary Of Ellie Wiesel's Night

413 Words | 2 Pages

Rather than the ones who will fight for civilians, that endures humanitarian

Read More

Summary: Operation Iraqi Freedom

79 Words | 1 Pages

In the recent major military operations such as Operation Iraqi Freedom 1, it clearly demonstrated the need for a full spectrum and joint force by combining different services capabilities to increase the potency of combat power. With the recent concept of operation which includes the participation in operations such as humanitarian relief operations also demands tight interoperability across the Services and external agencies. These operations have evidently demonstrated the need to pool resources, expertise and manpower across all

Read More

Summary Of Imagine Dying By Rick Loomis

451 Words | 2 Pages

Not only are the soldiers affected by war, but regular civilians living at home are as well. Many people feel that soldiers show absolutely no emotion and are extraordinary people. However, in “Imagine Dying” written by Rick Loomis, the author proves his audience wrong when he states “here was a group of men, 37 in all, whom [he] viewed as courageous warriors, well-trained and well-equipped, and they seemed to be falling one by one right in front of him” (3). Although the majority of a population feel soldiers are extremely brave and are seldom afraid of their circumstances, this is untrue. Loomis spent a long period of time with a group of soldiers and came to the conclusion they are everyday, ordinary people simply fulfilling the role of

Read More

Romeo Dallaire PTSD

1861 Words | 8 Pages

Throughout the history of the world’s conflict, soldiers have suffered in a multitude of ways. On the battlefields of the American Civil War, both Union and Confederate soldiers witnessed gruesome wounds. In the trenches of World War I, chemical warfare was a constant threat, and a very dangerous one, at that. Most recently, in Afghanistan, Iraq, and Iran, warriors and civilians alike fell victim to a kind of guerilla warfare never before seen; suicide bombings. This was in conjunction with the use of weapons such as landmines that terrorized cities for years after conflict ended.

Read More

Against Conscription In Canada

652 Words | 3 Pages

Citizens gain an understanding and appreciation for the sacrifices people in the military make. However, despite this… without the recognition of human rights, peace still can’t be achieved, whether its individual, cultural, or gender based rights. Even though forced labour is considered a violation of human rights, the practice of compulsory military service isn’t. The United Nations Commission on Human Rights only moved towards recognizing the right of individuals to object to military service in 1987.

Read More

War Wounds That Time Alone Can T Heal Analysis

556 Words | 3 Pages

In Jane Brody’s alarming article, “War Wounds That Time Alone Can’t Heal” Brody describes the intense and devastating pain some soldiers go through on a daily basis. These soldiers come home from a tragic time during war or, have vivid memories of unimaginable sufferings they began to experience in the battle field. As a result these soldiers suffer from, “emotional agony and self-destructive aftermath of moral injury…” (Brody). Moral injury has caused much emotional and physical pain for men and women from the war.

Read More

Short And Long Term Effects Of Sputnik

1836 Words | 8 Pages

“HIstory more often records the brilliant successes and spectacular defeats of contending forces rather than the effect of war on the common people”-Mildred Cable. The Cold War was a conflict which started on March 17th, 1947 and ended December 26th, 1991. It started due to ideological differences between The Soviet Union and The United States, The Soviets wanting the world to be communist ruled while The United States wanting the world to consist of mostly capitalist countries. The Soviets had already started to turn countries they liberated from the Nazi’s into communist countries under their rule, these countries consisted of Ukraine, Georgia, Belorussia, Uzbekistan, Armenia, Azerbaijan, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Moldova, Turkmenistan, Tajikistan,

Read More

Moral Confusion In The Things They Carried

645 Words | 3 Pages

The Vietnam War leaves a legacy of moral confusion with each and every soldier who serves. Soldiers are fighting for a cause they do not necessarily believe in, killing people who do not necessarily deserve it, and watching their brothers die beside them. Tim O’Briens’ book, The Things They Carried, illustrates the soldiers struggle to define morality throughout the confusion of the war. On the Rainy River, Tim O’Brien faces what he feels is his moral obligation to answer his country’s call and fight in Vietnam, and a personal moral issue with the reason for the war.

Read More

Us Foreign Policy Essay

1699 Words | 7 Pages

The United States’ foreign policy is formed by a variety of factors, varying from standard operating procedures, the power dynamic in the President’s administration, as well as the organizational set up of how the United States responds to threats. This can be seen on large scale events such as the invasion of Iraq or Afghanistan, however it can also be seen in smaller foreign policy events, such as the deployment of troops to fight against Joseph Kony in Uganda. First it is crucial that we take the United States’ involvement in Uganda and place it in the framework of the history of US foreign policy. Traditionally, the major point for the United States in terms of foreign policy was to maintain and expand its hegemony.

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of Foreign Aid

1498 Words | 6 Pages

The consequence of wars, the political turmoil in countries or simply a country in debt; these all warrant a need for foreign aid. Although it may seem like the obvious act to do, is it really the right thing to do? It is firstly important to note what is the fundamental characteristic of foreign aid and what it entails, both for a country providing and the country receiving it. The aspect of aid can take many forms, ranging from goods and services or capital from foreign country to country in need. As situations in different countries continue to take new forms, aid can also be provided concerning military, economic means, etc.

Read More

Genocide Convention Research Paper

1481 Words | 6 Pages

Protect civilians in armed conflict, including through UN peacekeepers;3. End impunity through judicial action in national and international courts;4. Gather information and set up an early-warning system; and5. Take swift and decisive action, including military action.” (UN).

Read More

Foreign Aid Argumentative Essay

1035 Words | 5 Pages

The foreign aid program is created to bring an end to poverty, conflicts and other difficulties that poor-developed countries are enabled to solve it. Everything is not about money, but it is about power, political view or group society. In many well-developed countries, corruption and political control are being reviewed by the UN and other governance, because they could be penalized or have sanctions. In a less-developed country that are already being helped with foreign aid, the governance and other aid programs must have their hands tied when it comes to penalized or sanctioned, because they are already in need, therefore corruption is created in those less-developed countries and hunger follows. There is the end of hungriness that is currently trying to be solved in the world, but there are still conflicts with political control that keeps the foreign aid to cause hunger in

Read More

Advantages Of Bilateral Foreign Aid

1357 Words | 6 Pages

Subsistence aid: it is given by the developed counties to those which do not possess sufficient resources to maintain their territories . For example US supports to Jordan 3. Bribes and pension aid: it is prevalent in the 19th century.under this aid the governments paid a pension or bribe to the foreign minister or ambassador for the services rendered to them. 4. Military aid: it covers not only giving the weapons but also the sale of military goods at lowest rates.

Read More

Morton Deutsch's Theory Of Conflict Resolution

1011 Words | 5 Pages

He contends that when an individual or group is denied its major requirement for identity, security, acknowledgment or equivalent investment inside of the general public, extended conflict is inescapable. To determine such conflict, it is essential that needs that are debilitated be distinguished and along these lines rebuilding of connections or the social framework happen in a way that needs of all people and groups are suited (Burton John, 1991,p82). For instance, this model can be helpful in the cases of African conflicts, for example, that of Darfur, Burundi, Dr Congo and Rwanda conflicts, where there are limitations on opportunity and support of its nationals in political and monetary

Read More

Important Things To Remain Neutral Essay

312 Words | 2 Pages

We 've all heard the curious stories about celebrities that decided to write some interesting fiction and facts about themselves on Wikipedia. Some of the celebrities even went overboard. They systematically edited all the rotten stuff out of biographies that were written about them by other Wikipedia writers. Does it help their cause, reputation, or popularity, to take such dramatic steps? Well, according to Wikipedia neutrality is the key to writing successfully on the site.

Read More

More about Can Aid Ever Be Neutral Or Impartial Essay

Related Topics

Open Document