ipl-logo

Character Analysis Of Eli And Charlie In The Sisters Brothers

939 Words4 Pages

Sigmond Freud suggested that personality is created with three factors; the Id, ego, and superego. Each of these factors affects the thinking process, and the way they interact with each individual is different creating individual personalities. Patrick DeWitt thought up and wrote the characters Eli and Charlie in The Sisters Brothers, and within their story, these three factors of personalities are displayed. Both brothers show the effects and presence of the Id, ego, and superego, and prove the theory of personalities by Sigmond Freud. The Id The most important of the three is the Id, which is by definition the unconscious part of the mind that controls immediate desires such as libido, aggression, and destructive tendencies (Stangor, …show more content…

It takes all the information given from the Id and superego and gives the person the correct output on what to do. The ego is the only conscious personality, as the person in question can affect the outcome of the ego's choices (Mcleod, 2021). Eli presents the use of the ego when confronting the boy in the middle of the desert, “Showing him the gold, I told him ‘This will get you back home…’” (DeWitt, 112). As said in the section above on the Id, Eli’s first thoughts were to harm the boy to shut him up. His conscience (superego) would not allow that, so his ego decided that giving him gold and sending him away was the perfect …show more content…

The superego counters all the Id wants with criticism and logical consequences, and can be described as a conscience. (Britannica, 2023). Charlie, even without his immediate thought process, can be shown showing his superego in action when he shows remorse for Tub, “‘Don't you remember? The tooth doctor’s numbing liquid?’... ‘Well? How about giving Tub a splash…’” (DeWitt, 231). This scene happens after a fight between the brothers, and both lose undetermined amounts of trust in one another. Charlie is a person who throughout the book usually lets his Id take over, doing what he wants or what he needs to do to survive. At a stop where Eli’s horse Tub is dribbling blood from every orifice on his face, he offers to give the horse some pain relief. Not once before had he offered even if he had the liquid even during Tub's makeshift operation. Guilt might have taken over, and that would be because of the superego. To make sure the ego takes its side, the superego will use rewards and punishments. Guilt is a common way the superego helps a person follow

Show More
Related
891 Words | 4 Pages

During his lifetime, he developed many theories including id, superego, and ego. The id is our source of motivation and it also includes our sexual and aggressive drives. The superego includes our morals and ideals and lastly, our ego is made up of a group of mechanisms, like reality-testing, judgement, and impulse control. On one

Read More
756 Words | 4 Pages

What is the meaning of Ego? In today’s world, it means “a person’s sense of self-esteem or self-importance”, it is to be self-centered and care for nothing else except for one's self or, in other terms, being an individualist. Today, people have been told to care for others instead of themselves, but that is not completely true. For example, Prometheus in Anthem by Ayn Rand- is not what one would consider to be a total egotistical person. Searching through different types of definitions and reasons about the definition of ego, the assumption is that egoism is not immoral or virtuous but the balance in between.

Read More
564 Words | 3 Pages

The concept that the id, ego, and superego control

Read More
1466 Words | 6 Pages

Later on, Tub, is attacked by a bear and terribly wounded. As most people would shoot their horse and purchase a new one, Eli refuses to do so. He instead tends to, cares and shows more compassion towards Tub. This is the first occurance in which we see Eli not as a killer but a human with a soft and caring heart. As his journey continues Eli is forced to kill many men but

Read More
515 Words | 3 Pages

This is a strong positive of the Superego because it shows a change in his character for the better, as well as his improvement in recovery. Through the movie, Henry is in constant trouble of finding and obtaining a healthy balance between the use of his superego and ID. Overall, the complex use of the two will create both positives and negatives in Henry’s

Read More
522 Words | 3 Pages

Superego in Lord of the Flies Sigmund Freud, a very famous psychiatrist, created three different terms, id, ego and Super ego; super ego is the brain’s conscience. It also gives the brain the ability to do the right thing. Piggy, who is a character in Lord of the Flies constantly represents superego, always turning the other cheek and doing the right thing. Piggy is a perfect example of superego in Lord of the Flies written by William Golding. Superego is a part of the brain or conscience that recognizes inappropriate behavior and also wants you to choose right over wrong.

Read More
1365 Words | 6 Pages

Within the unconscious mind exists three different apparatuses: Id, Ego, and

Read More
1480 Words | 6 Pages

These do not stand for physical areas of the brain, but more of the mental functions. ID translates to instincts, Ego is reality and Superego is morality. These three central functioning's make up “… the personality—instinctual needs, rational thinking, and moral standards.” (Ronald J. Comer). Dwight Schrute has a very poor ego, which in turn off-sets his ID and Ego.

Read More
1085 Words | 5 Pages

The superego is the part of the mind that wants

Read More
823 Words | 4 Pages

Land of the Lotus Eaters In Book 9 of The Odyssey by Homer there is a section that describes people who eat and live by the Lotus flower, the Lotus Eaters. These are a peaceful people that Odysseus and his men fall upon in their journey.

Read More
713 Words | 3 Pages

I think that applying psychoanalytic to this passage we see the clashing of the Superego and the Id in the moment when the manager becomes angry because of the answers Marlow had given him. The Ego intercepts, "a movement of furious annoyance, he yawned" (Conrad 58). It is here that there is tangible evidence of the three parts of the psyches coming into play. The Ego, who plays the mediator between the Superego, the morals, and the Id, the instincts, stopped the show of violence prompted by the Id's need to exert its anger. It also seems to suggest how being in that place deteriorates the effectiveness of the Ego, allowing the Ifo to slowly garner more control over the impulses of everyone.

Read More
1945 Words | 8 Pages

Lastly, there is the ego, the balance between the id and superego. The ego represents reality. Focusing on Victor Frankenstein and the monster he created, one can better understand their personalities by examining

Read More
1315 Words | 6 Pages

In “Freudian Theory and Consciousness: A Conceptual Analysis”, Avinash De Sousa emphasizes the relationship between the three: “Psychoanalysis regarded everything mental being in the first place unconscious, and thus for them, consciousness might be present or absent” (Avinash). According to De Sousa, the id is the reason that the ego and superego forms. In Fight Club, as the narrator suffers from the lack of love from his parents, his desires then develops the id then the ego and at the end, superego. The narrator behavior keep bouncing from the three stages as the story approaches its climax when he decides to kill his innermost desire himself, Tyler. The id, ego and superego have an important role which help explain the narrator’s actions and

Read More
523 Words | 3 Pages

In the story “Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde” by R.L.S three characters represent Freud’s psychoanalysis of the id, ego, and superego. Freud describes id as the devil sitting on your shoulder or the evil side. In addition, the superego is a human moral conscience. Finally, the ego is a good balance between good and evil. The characters in Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde represent Freud’s psychoanalysis by each other's character have a different personality as Utterson happens to be good is he is the superego, Jekyll is the ego because he is most like a human and is both good and bad, and Hyde is like a devil and bad so he represents the Id.

Read More
2186 Words | 9 Pages

The Id, Ego and Superego make complete sense to any person who might be interests in learning about the Psyche. Freud’s use of the psychoanalytic theory is relevant when explaining my current behaviour in regards to my past experiences that have occurred throughout my lifetime. Freud’s theory does apply to my own life as he made his theory a way to help understand and focus on the behavioural problems of the human being, and to resolve them in a way that forces me to accept my own destructive

Read More

More about Character Analysis Of Eli And Charlie In The Sisters Brothers

Related Topics

Open Document