ipl-logo

Clear Boundaries Of Amanda's Minuchin Family Systems Theory

1073 Words5 Pages

Family Systems Hypotheses
Amanda’s approach-avoidance behaviors with her mom provide a sense of how her family functions. Minuchin family systems theory postulates that the “Heart of Family” is the marital subsystem and emphasizes the need for clear boundaries around the marital dyad. Clear boundaries allow family members to meet their appropriate developmental needs. Additionally, clear boundaries are permeable and adaptable and allow emotional contact, independence, and change as the needs of family members evolve over the course of development. Within the Blue’s family, the marital subsystem seems to be out of sync, appears to have no clear boundaries which can explain the confusion and dysfunction that is present in the home. Amanda’s mom …show more content…

Korean culture is primarily collectivist which fosters group harmony, respect for elders and authority, and values the importance of family, friendship, ancestors, and traditions. Irish American culture, on the other hand, is less cultured, assimilated in the American culture, the female dominance of domestic life and child-rearing, overt affection not prevalent, and the father is a distant figure. In Amanda’s household, the Irish American culture from her dad’s background seems to be the more dominant culture in the household as her mom does the child-rearing and her dad is hardly around and out working. Of note also, within the Irish American culture, shaming, belittling, ridicule, and embarrassment are acceptable negative terms used with children in the household. Amanda’s mom is from a small family which values education highly and may have attributed to Amanda’s consistent self-critical obsession with wanting to be a perfectionist and being hard on herself. In Individualistic cultures, high arousal emotions are valued and promoted more than low arousal emotions while low arousal emotions are valued more in collectivist cultures. Culture impacts the was emotions are felt and expressed and shapes the way people should feel in certain situations. Emotions are also influenced by environmental, social, or cultural situations. Amanda’s mom reported that she does “not do feelings well” which could be associated with the Korean culture and may have inhibited Amanda’s ability for learning feelings identification and expressions in the

Show More
Related
1135 Words | 5 Pages

A family contains young minds that are at first taught the building of personality or character and controlling the emotions of him or herself, while also being taught how to set goals for life (Ritter) But as new generations came of age, the family became a weakened and fractured unit as husbands and wives gave way to the human nature of adultery in a widespread manor. Here in America, the family has been under constant assault and broken marriages and broken households are now a normal thing to see. Few fathers show the guidance and teaching to their children that is needed often requiring the mother to take on both roles. As children grow up being more spoiled and pampered to, they are never learning to accept and recover from setbacks.

Read More
1793 Words | 8 Pages

The girls have been permanently placed in their home, and have been with them for two years. What makes this family unique is that all four girls have some degree of attachment disorder. The Circumplex Model allows one to integrate systems theory and family developmental theory

Read More
1154 Words | 5 Pages

Stone writes about three essential functions of family stories– to pass on the family’s standards, to identify family characteristics, and coping strategies. The first of the three functions is the standards of the family since the family act as the “first culture,” teaching people what their family values and their opinions on certain situations like marriage and illness, mental or physical (Stone 384). The second factor is the family’s characteristics and their traits that bind them together, which act as the family member’s confidence boost (384). Furthermore, this boost makes them value themselves more than the next family, so that the family members contently remain together (384). The third factor is influencing how families cope; these “teaching stories” tell each family how to function outside of the family (385).

Read More
1291 Words | 6 Pages

Family is one of the most sacred and wonderful groups in the world, but the effects on its members are not universally positive. Sometimes, ordinary family bonds are broken, and the family unit becomes an agent of great destruction. Within abnormal situations like these, we can often see more clearly a person ’s problem solving ability. Due to a lack of support from family members, they can be sent into more primitive instincts of survival.

Read More
244 Words | 1 Pages

In today’s society, there is a wide variety of family configurations which are constantly changing and adapting to things such as cultural diversity, divorce rates, sexual orientation, and religious beliefs. The “typical” family, (commonly seen in American 1950’s television sitcoms) is a rarity in 2015. Problems with communication arise when one makes assumptions about another person’s family dynamic. For example, people with careers in fields like teaching, law, and healthcare have to be especially aware and sensitive to the fact that not all families display the “traditional” European American family model which consists of a household with parents of the opposite sex, their biological children, and a strong value placed on individualism.

Read More
935 Words | 4 Pages

Alice presents the idea that the relationship between Chinese children and their parents is one quite different from that of Australian children and their parents. ‘These were questions Chinese children never asked their parents.’ (Page 144) She suggests that different etiquette and customs are undertaken and that the bond between them differs. Alice alludes to the idea that these differences in the home are the foundation for the differences Alice perceives socially.

Read More
678 Words | 3 Pages

Understanding the internal structure of a family, the assessment must look at six different aspects of the internal family structure: family composition, gender, sexual orientation, rank order, subsystems, and boundaries (Wright & Leahey, 2013). Each different aspects contributes a piece to the internal structure of the family. Within the family composition, assessing the family unit or system, whether or not members are blood related, does the family contain children, the future commitment obligations (if any), and any caregiving functions to unit members (Wright & Leahey,

Read More
342 Words | 2 Pages

Today we ask ourselves, what defines a family? Will we ever be able to pinpoint one exact answer? Meanings and explanations of our past have been rightfully challenged. The family structures and dynamics that we see today have evolved great lengths from what they once were in the 1950’s. The 1950’s consisted of “standard” families.

Read More
617 Words | 3 Pages

Parents life long goal and desire is for their children to grow up in the best environment and become successful in society. Especially when immigrant parents come to a new country to have a life with more opportunities. Cultural differences are always present when living in a new foreign country, which can affect the development in our lives. In the essay, “ The Good Daughter,” published by Newsweek, the author, Caroline Hwang, writes about her dual culture as a Korean daughter living in America and the struggle between her dreams versing her immigrant parents’ dream. Hwang confronts her parents by asking them why they never bothered to correct her pronunciation of her last name, but they replied that they never cared to correct her and

Read More
534 Words | 3 Pages

“His father was always beating him up, and his mother ignored him, except when she was hacked off at something, and then you could hear her yelling at him clear down at our house. I think he hated that worse than getting whipped”(Hinton 12). Through family, many look to their parents for support, but some instances of a family are not the same as the tradition Mother, Father, and children;

Read More
952 Words | 4 Pages

Chelsea admits that she still feels as if she is a child in his presence. The father belittles and patronizes her at every opportunity. Through the lens of the family systems theoretical orientation, the focus is on patterns that develop in families to defuse the tension and anxiety. According to Brown (1999), a key generator of stress in families is the perception of either too much closeness or too much distance in a relationship. The degree of anxiety in this family can be determined by the current levels of external stress and the sensitivities to particular themes that are transmitted through the generations.

Read More
684 Words | 3 Pages

Family structure talks about family arrangement and composition which includes the roles and interactions (Edelman, 2014). According to Minuchin (2012), the family structural theory emphasis on the important of the family structure and its changes that occurs and how the individuals in the family relate collectively over time to put up and accept each other. Minuchin says further that a well-functioning family will choose how to solve and handle the family experience with a positive outcome. The goal of a structural family is to express the strengths in each other in critical moments, and helping each other through it. Developmental theory is the methods used as the viewpoint of family tasking and development through phases of life (Edelman, 2014).

Read More
375 Words | 2 Pages

Bowen family systems theory is used for understanding both family emotional and relationship processes (Knauth, 2003). Kolbert, Crothers, and Field (2013) suggest that although there are few publications on Bowen family systems theory, it provides counsellors with a framework for clients, specifically with helping adolescents understand how their functioning and identity have been influenced by their family. Bowen’s differentiation of the self has been argued to be equivalent to identity, and an individual’s balance both togetherness and individuality within their family, family members are both borrowing and lending aspects of themselves between each other (Kolbert, Crothers, & Field, 2013). Bowen, (1978, p. 188) suggested that individuals

Read More
1589 Words | 7 Pages

There is a growing complexity and diversity in families. Family systems theory provides a foundation for analysis of such complex and diversified families, making it easy to understand for effective therapy (Zastrow &

Read More
1568 Words | 7 Pages

Families are said to constitute realities in which most of one’s attributes are constructed, based on the family interactions, beliefs, values as well as the behaviours that are seen in the specific families one is brought up into (Archer & McCarthy, 2007). However, even though most of one’s personal characteristics may be heavily influenced by their families; people do have a sense of individuality that makes them unique from any other person in the family (Becvar & Becvar, 2013). Therefore, one may argue that it is these differences that may cause misunderstandings in families.

Read More

More about Clear Boundaries Of Amanda's Minuchin Family Systems Theory

Related Topics

Open Document