ipl-logo

Compare And Contrast A Patriot's History And Chapter 10 Of The American People

1100 Words5 Pages

There are two sides to every story. This is especially true when it comes to the history of the world. The two textbooks that we read for this class, A Patriot’s History of the United States and The American People, are great examples of this idea not because they cannot agree on the events of American history, but because they have different viewpoints on the significance of events, and the impact of some controversial topics. This essay will discuss the similar and different perspectives of the two textbooks mentioned above, while talking specifically about Chapter 6 of A Patriot’s History and Chapter 10 of The American People. More specifically, this essay will cover the books contrasting interpretations of societal, political, and religious …show more content…

As we have talked about at length during lecture, the nineteenth century, prior to the start of the Civil War was a time of constant change, in a variety of aspects of American life. One of the earliest and longest lasting reform efforts in nineteenth century America was The Second Great Awakening. Both textbooks agree that it resulted in such things as a renewal of religious sentiment and the arrival and new popularity of multiple branches of Christianity. However, the difference comes in the coverage of the topic, and the authors opinions of why it started. The authors of A Patriot’s History argue that “the emergent Industrial Revolution caused huge changes in the lives of Americans, an upheaval that, in part, explains the urgency with which they sought spiritual sustenance” (Schweikart and Allen, 233). While Schweikart and Allen believe that the Industrial Revolution caused the Second Great Awakening due to new individualistic and work-focused ideas that were pushed during this time, Nash gives no …show more content…

Nash never mentions the Industrial Revolution, nor does he give any reason for why it started, choosing to focus instead on where the ideas of the movement had the most impact, in areas such as Western New York. Another difference that arose out of The Second Great Awakening was the debate regarding what the message of the revival was. A Patriot’s History discusses how the movement was centered on the idea of “perfectionism” (Schweikart, 233-235). According to Schweikart and Allen, “the Second Great Awakening was thus a radical extension of the religious enthusiasm of the Puritan migration and the First Great Awakening” (Schweikart, 235). In contrast, Nash disagrees with this sentiment, instead arguing that “revivalist preachers de-emphasized doctrine in favor of emotion, softening strict tenets such as predestination and original sin” (Nash, 255). The most interesting aspect of compare and contrast within the assigned chapters of the two textbooks, was their polar opposite view and interpretation of Andrew Jackson as a leader, in the military and in government, as well as an individual. From the very beginning of the section regarding Andrew

Show More
Related
606 Words | 3 Pages

Seven Events That Made America America: And Proved That the Founding Fathers Were Right All Along is written by Larry Schweikart. Schweikart is an American historian as well as a professor of history at the University of Dayton. As a child he grew up in Arizona where he would later attend Arizona state university. While there, Schweikart completed an M.A. and later earned his Ph.D. in history from University of California, Santa Barbara in 1984.

Read More
50 Words | 1 Pages

The industrialization of America had a monumental impact on the citizens. With change comes the upsides and the downsides, so there were critiques such as Henry George and Edward Bellamy. Also this was a time of change for woman, questions regarding ‘place’, purpose, and morality were too brought to light.

Read More
1167 Words | 5 Pages

The chapters of our textbook, America: A Narrative History, written by George Brown Tindall and David Emory Shi, takes us on a historical yet comparative journey of the road to war and what caused the American Revolution, an insight into the war itself, and a perception to what life was like in America after the war was over. The essays of the book, America Compared: American History in International Perspective, collected by Carl J. Guarneri gives us a global context and a comparison between the North and South Americas in the dividing issues of labor, slavery, taxes, politics, economy, liberty, and equality. Part One These chapters in our textbook Tindall describes; the road to the American Revolution, the road to the surrendering of the British, and the road to the American colonists receiving their independence and developing the government which the people of the United States will be governed by. The road to the American Revolution consisted of several events, which escalated to the war that began April 19, 1775, as the tensions between the American colonies and the British Government advanced towards breaking point.

Read More
1606 Words | 7 Pages

“The Kingdom of Matthias,” provides a powerful insight to the turbulent effects the religious revival known as the Second Great Awakening and the Market Revolution had on the individuals that lived through these events in the United States. Although both of these events were striving for a more perfect society were everyone had an equal and prosperous chance of living, some individuals were unhappy with such outcomes and sought to keep the traditional society that served the basis for American society. As a result, the clashing difference between the rural communities and the urban life became apparent in the accounts of Elijah Pierson and Robert Mathews as both men have difficulties in adapting to the societal structures, in terms of gender,

Read More
837 Words | 4 Pages

During the WWII, post WWII, and Cold War era throughout the 20th century, the United States of America was faced with many domestic and foreign conflicts. It was a time of change, action, and movements. Amidst the conflicts, the US was forced to make very controversial decisions. Through its government, the United States acted on these many problems and affected the quality of life of the people. Unfortunately, with these decisions made, the US failed to promote the liberty, equality, and justice for its citizens and the people of the world.

Read More
1141 Words | 5 Pages

The history of the United States of America has often been punctuated by moments of triumph, and also by grievous lapses in moral and ethical judgements. For years, students have learned about the entirety of our country’s history in school. However, a school board in Colorado recently attempted to prevent this from happening. Their decision to alter the American history curriculum in order to promote patriotic values angered many students, who then protested this decision. Leonard Pitts, a journalist for the Miami Herald, openly criticized the school board’s move.

Read More
362 Words | 2 Pages

During the 19th century, the American people were experiencing a revolution concerning both the economy and religion, in what is recognized today as the Market Revolution and the Second Great Awakening. A rapid increase in the population within the countryside, and the development of new technology outburst a change in the economy from one of local exchanges to one governed by capital and capitalists. Family owned businesses began to expand and sold their items not only among a small community, but now products were being shipped to different ports along the colonies. The industrialization movement was rapidly approaching that “Indian removal was necessary for the opening of the vast American lands to agriculture, to commerce, to markets, to

Read More
1956 Words | 8 Pages

History Term Project: Primary Source Analysis Danielle Marshall Professor Ahad Hayaud-Din & Professor Sinclair 1301-2305 Learning Community Fall Semester 2017 2379 Words November 25, 2017 The United States has had many foreign and domestic problems that shaped American society; fear, impacted civil liberties, escalated worldly crises and evoked counter threats from the start of the Reconstruction era throughout our nation’s current history. Some of these problems were depicted in political cartoons, newspaper articles, presidential speeches, proclamations, and photos. Many cruelties in the Reconstruction era came from racial violence, nationalism, and American Imperialism as implied in these documents.

Read More
994 Words | 4 Pages

Fariha Fawziah | Chapter Three In chapter three, the books A People’s History of the United States and A Young People’s History of the United States by Howard Zinn provides a different historical viewpoint that is more descriptive and gives more insight than the textbook American History: A Survey by Alan Brinkley. The Zinn books additionally displayed the perspective from the indigenous peoples like Arawaks and the African blacks, the ones that faced prejudice and oppression in history, this can change one’s point of view on previous concepts on specific events or even a person.

Read More
1135 Words | 5 Pages

The American Revolution is arguably the turning point of American history as it resulted in somewhat of a significant, positive change in politics, economics, and society as a whole. However, from 1775 to 1800, the effects of the revolution on the American society were subtle as most principles glorified by revolutionists contradicted the examples set forth by colonial reality. Perhaps most alike to revolutionary beliefs was the American economy and how it participated in free trade or encouraged the independence of hard labor. Politically, the states did apply Enlightenment and republican ideas as promised, but more often than not, the benefits of such ideas were limited to rich, land-owning, protestant, white men. This glorification of

Read More
992 Words | 4 Pages

Where they really all that different? Theodore Roosevelt Jr. and Thomas Woodrow Wilson, became the 26th and 28th Presidents of the United States (Brinkley, 497,503) and are known as two of the nation’s greatest. On the surface, they appear to be so very completely different in their lifestyles, style of governing and solutions in foreign and domestic policy. Below the surface though, were these two men more alike and fighting for the same goal? Growing up in the mid 1880’s, these two men exhibited some distinct commonalities, however, there were many differences as well.

Read More
1182 Words | 5 Pages

The United States-- a country of economic strength, freedom, and an endless sea of opportunity promises all of its citizens the unalienable rights of life, liberty, and happiness. This promise coupled with the hope of a brighter future attracted those from all walks of life. It also appealed to those who suffered political and religious persecution ; overall its divided branches of governing gave off the illusion of a fair and just political policy. Thus, when hit with the slightest of problems, the public was quick to turn to the government for a solution. The increase in governmental power can be linked to the ratification of the Constitution – which aimed at protecting the rights of individuals and limiting governmental powers.

Read More
768 Words | 4 Pages

Industrialization was a time in which the lives of Americans were changing drastically. It was an era, that help shape America to the form that it is today. During the Industrialization, many may argue that it was a time where our people and land was treated horrible. But, this time period led us to greater and farther things that we didn’t know was possible. This Revolution was a step towards a dramatic and positive effect to America.

Read More
726 Words | 3 Pages

As America saw an end to World war 1 and entered the 1920s, the country was faced with rapid changes in American society. These changes challenged the old traditional American values and introduced tension between modernists and traditionalist. Tension grew in churches and schools after new scientific discoveries were being made which supported the idea of evolution, rather than the bible. American society saw dramatic changes in it’s old, familiar culture as the Harlem Renaissance emerged and women gained more rights, which began taking affect on the customary American lifestyle. After World War 1, science became the main contributing factor to the controversy over religion during the 1920s.

Read More
158 Words | 1 Pages

Undoubtedly, America has confronted many adversities throughout its history. Moreover, during the course of these challenges America prevailed, and ultimately formed a nation that has the ability to continuously adapt. There exists a myriad of examples that would support this claim; however, this essay will focus on four major events occurring between the 1860’s and 1920’s. The first event is how the American social status changed before and after Abraham Lincoln’s assassination. The second event is how the Civil War played a role in creating a need for Reconstruction, and how Reconstruction culminated in the Industrial Revolution.

Read More

More about Compare And Contrast A Patriot's History And Chapter 10 Of The American People

Related Topics

Open Document