ipl-logo

Compare And Contrast Essay On The Catcher In The Rye

652 Words3 Pages

Why “The Catcher in the Rye” Should Not Be Made Into a Movie The Catcher in the Rye is a book written by J.D. Salinger, published in 1951, about a boy called Holden who struggles through the stage of becoming and adult and still being a teenager. The character Holden is a very complex character with many feelings, which has turned The Catcher in the Rye into a famous book, and as a result many people have been wanting to turn this piece of literature into a movie. However, I think that The Catcher in the Rye should not be turned into a movie because the story is told in first person and is mostly the main character’s thoughts in his head, the characters in The Catcher in the Rye are all very complex, especially Holden, and it would be nearly impossible for these characters to be portrayed by actors. Lastly, J.D. Salinger did not want the book to be turned into a movie, so it would be wrong to create a movie out of The Catcher in the Rye. …show more content…

Most of the story wouldn’t be able to be told just because you can’t really express thoughts without speaking, and most of the book is told in thoughts, and there is little to no dialogue. For example, if you take the part in the book where Holden talks about people like Jane Gallagher or talks about his brother Allie or pretty much anything else, he goes on and on about whatever he is talking about, and that would be bad material for a movie. You can’t really act out what a person is thinking in his head. More than half the book is in self dialogue, so the most important parts that happen inside Holden’s head that tell about what he is feeling and what he is going through can’t be told because those can’t be acted

Show More
Related

Catcher In The Rye And O Brien Analysis

1157 Words | 5 Pages

Meanwhile, in “The Catcher In The Rye”, Holden states clearly at the very beginning that “I’m not going to tell you my whole goddam autobiography or anything. I’ll just tell you about this madman stuff that happened to me around last Christmas just before I got pretty run-down and had to come out here and take it easy” ( The Catcher In The Rye, 1), meaning that Holden is only going

Read More

Comparing The Catcher In The Rye, By J. D. Salinger

876 Words | 4 Pages

Everyone experiences intricate and difficult events throughout their lifetime. Regardless of the choices and paths an individual takes, blockades and challenges will stand in the way. However sometimes these challenges tend to leave us scarred, changing the way we live our lives. In The Catcher In The Rye , J.D Salinger reflects a post World War II era in which the rippling effects of the war result in more fearful behaviors Survivors of World War II feared change in their life, in The Catcher In The Rye this idea represents itself through the way Holden fears growing up. In the book when reflecting upon the museum he used to go to as a kid Holden says “The best thing, though, in that museum was that everything always stayed right where it was.

Read More

Compare And Contrast Holden And The Catcher In The Rye

945 Words | 4 Pages

Using these characters as the point of which we view the story has high, and low points in relation to the telling of the stories, and they can sometimes strengthen as well as weaken a the text. A noticeable strength in Catcher regarding the use of Holden as a narrative tool, is exhibited in the beginning of the book as he goes through the remainder of the day at school. During this time we get to learn a lot about Holden as we are being showed his thoughts and innermost feelings about his school and personal life, which allows the reader to connect to him, as they learn so much about him. However, a weakness of using Holden's voice in the text is the fact that we are sometimes only presented with pieces of information that we would learn much more of if the novel had a third person point of view. We can see this happening when Holden talks about his parents, whom we never meet in the novel, as we realize that we have no information as to what they look like or how they act since there was no direct interaction between Holden and his parents within the novel.

Read More

Comparing The Catcher And The Rye, By J. D. Salinger

525 Words | 3 Pages

The novel The Catcher and the Rye by , J.D. Salinger follows the trials of a mentally ill teen on the run from his school in an attempt to reconcile his life. Holden wants to protect all those who are innocent, but due to his disgust for the phoniness of the world, this leads him to disengage from society. Isolation causes Holden tremendous distress leading to severe depression. The author uses ducks to symbolise innocence in the novel; along with Holden’s obligation to save all things pure due to the guilt he bears in not being able to save his brother from leukemia. This guides the reader through Holden’s journey with the hope that he will be capable to adapt to the changes in his life and obtain emotional stability.

Read More

Catcher In The Rye Critical Lens Essay

722 Words | 3 Pages

In the whole story you read all Holden´s thoughts and feelings. If the story was written in a different way, it would be imposible to know hugely importan memories, like when Holden was talking about the time he was playing checkers with Jane. Also, in some parts of the novel, Holden pretends or thinks he is acting in some certain way, when he is truly acting completely different; an example would when he was goin gout on a date with Sally and he started to shout, but he thought he was not. So if the story was written in a different person, you would not know Holden´s thought or mood. “Anyway, I keep picturing all these little kids playing some game in this big field of rye and all.

Read More

Why Is Catcher In The Rye Banned

1022 Words | 5 Pages

The Catcher in the Rye is paramount to American literature. It has been banned for its inappropriate word choice and ideas. The main character, Holden Caulfield, is an outsider, similar to the author, J.D. Salinger. During his three day journey in New York, Holden shares his opinions on life to the audience. Through the works of Sean Penn’s Into the Wild, and J.D. Salinger's Catcher in the Rye, both Holden

Read More

Similarities Between Europeans And Native Americans

1170 Words | 5 Pages

Diversity between the Native American and European World Before 1650 Stephania Reid WOH 1012 19/07/2016 Professor Young Introduction This paper specifically focuses on the comparison and contrast of the culture of Europeans and Native Americans. The inferred question is how these regions way of life should be understood as a human experience. Additionally, the question refers to the diversity of human cultures, norms and to their values, as well as to religions and source of livelihood. Diversity can also be seen where their living conditions transform into different cultural expressions that become our history.

Read More

Catcher In The Rye Truths

671 Words | 3 Pages

This book is also fantastic because it holds many real-world truths. Holden had a pretty horrible childhood; he did not have a lot of parental guidance, he lost his younger brother,

Read More

Literary Analysis Essay On Catcher In The Rye

2150 Words | 9 Pages

In the book Catcher in the Rye by J.D. Salinger, Holden Caulfield states that he wants to be a catcher in a field of rye. Holden wants to give kids the opportunity to stay innocent. He wants to give them the opportunity to be caught, to be saved from all the responsibilities that one acquires when becoming an adult. He wants to catch them and push them back into their youth, back to where they had someone to talk to, and when they had friends that they could talk to and have fun with. In Holden’s life, he has suffered an immense loss, the loss of his little brother Allie.

Read More

Literary Analysis Essay On The Catcher In The Rye

686 Words | 3 Pages

“It always rains the hardest on the people who deserve the sun” (Quotes New) In the book The Catcher and the Rye there is events throughout the novel that force the reader to consider why bad things happen to good people. This question first surfaces when Holden details Allie’s tragic death. “God he was a nice kid, though. He used to laugh so hard at something he thought of at the dinner table that he just about fell off his chair.

Read More

Compare And Contrast Essay On The Catcher In The Rye

541 Words | 3 Pages

In J.D. Salinger's The Catcher In The Rye, he tells the story of Holden; a sixteen year old boy who is alone in Manhattan and is .... In both novels the main characters are forced to mature far too early in their lives, causing loss of innocence and harm in their older selves. Sadly, both Holden and Mud endure the absence of parents, the expectation that they engage in sexual activity and the death of loved ones at such young ages. Throughout the novels, both Holden and Mud do not have the support of their parents; whom only appear in one scene respectably.

Read More

Catcher In The Rye Literary Analysis Essay

1322 Words | 6 Pages

In the novel Catcher in the Rye by J.D Salinger readers are introduced to a young man named Holden Caulfield who introduces himself and begins to tell his story of how and why he left his school; Pencey Prep. In the story, Holden explains how he is being kicked out of school and doesn't want his parents to know and so leaves school early. throughout the story, Holden explains what happens to him before he must go home and act like he is home from school for a break instead of being kicked out. When it comes to the topic of Author's purpose of The will of individual vs the will of the majority some will think the purpose is to show that Holden going against the will of society to rebel, however, I think the author’s purpose of The Catcher in the Rye was to show that the individual will manifest in his desire for isolation comes from his is fear and damage done by fear of pain, failure, rejection, and is unwilling or unable to go along with the majority. This all shown through Imagery, symbolism, and diction.

Read More

Catcher In The Rye And 1984 Comparison Essay

672 Words | 3 Pages

The Catcher in the Rye is a story about loner Holden Caulfield who recounts his past few days where he was kicked out of school, left to visit New York, and shares his thoughts on almost everything in his everyday life, such as women and his dreams to be a catcher in the rye. First, to establish the shabby setting, Salinger uses similes. When Holden travels to his former teacher's home, he sidetracks from his original thought to complain about the bed he is sitting on. Salinger writes Holden thinking, "'It is. I was.

Read More

The Catcher In The Rye Analysis

1433 Words | 6 Pages

Usually considered a controversial novel The Catcher in the Rye by J.D. Salinger can often express the feelings of being an outcast and the desire to find a meaning in the world. Holden Caulfield, the protagonist of the novel, though often complains of the phoniness of the world around him, has a way of creating a deeper meaning within the readers. While the truth may be that Salinger purposely set the story in such a way that the readers will be able to connect with Holden, not often do readers find it easy to do so. While Holden believes that everything around him are wicked and phony, there is part of him trying to protect the innocence of those not corrupted by such phoniness. Although Holden wants to protect and save the innocence of children, can he really do so if cannot protect himself and trust those around him.

Read More

Catcher In The Rye Research Paper

628 Words | 3 Pages

Even though this may be a valid point of view, the life lessons taught to the reader greatly outweigh the old nature of the book. The book discusses Holden’s dead brother, and the suffering that Holden goes through after this event. Holden like many teens today is going through hard times. Everyone goes through frustrations in life, and the book reinforces this idea and makes it clear that people are not alone in what they are feeling. Article 2 further discusses this idea by saying, “[the book] can help readers understand that they aren't the only ones coping with problems” (source 2).

Read More

More about Compare And Contrast Essay On The Catcher In The Rye

Related Topics

Open Document