ipl-logo

Compare And Contrast What You Eat Is Your Business And Don T Blame The Eater

927 Words4 Pages

Two well-known authors both have their own viewpoints on nutritional health, but they, metaphorically, may as well live on different planets. Radley Balko is the author of “What You Eat Is Your Business”, which explains that the government is taking too much responsibility away from the public; which is making it too easy on them, as the people hold a very slim amount of accountability over what they’re eating. On the complete flip-side, David Zinczenko, author of “Don’t Blame the Eater”, explains that there is not enough governmental interference, and that they should step in more. He believes that it isn’t only the people’s fault that they are unaware of what they’re consuming. However, no matter who accepts responsibility, they both agree …show more content…

David Zinczenko expresses his concern that in a grocery store, every item of food is labeled with the proper nutritional facts to show the consumer its health benefits or disadvantages. However, at fast food restaurants, David mentions, these nutritional facts are either not shown or are highly inaccurate. These could be extremely beneficial to the general public, but they’re not helpful if they’re not discernable. To prevent this, one would think that the easy fix is to choose more sustainable foods such as fruits and vegetables from local farmers markets. However, Radley and David both agree that unfortunately, fast food chain restaurants are much more convenient than a farmers market. Radley Balko, on a similar note, mentions that the people should care about what they’re putting into their bodies, but that they have no incentive to. If the government is paying for their (obesity-related) medications, then they have no reason to change their eating habits or their lifestyle choices. Radley indirectly states that the only way to ensure personal responsibility is for the government to demand the people to finance the consequences of their habits and choices. Radley Balko and David Zinczenko both believe that the people should pay more attention to what they’re …show more content…

Radley mentions the costs of everybody’s healthcare costs, ranging from premiums to general doctor visits, have gone up drastically; he goes as far as to say that it may affect what age he’s able to comfortably retire. On a similar note, David takes it a step further to mention that from 1969 to 2002, diabetes treatments have jumped nearly 97.4 billion dollars; and that isn’t including other health-related conditions. Even if some people pay attention to what they’re intaking, they’re still suffering financially at the fault of the ones who don’t. The two authors can undeniably agree that the rise in this cost is a direct consequence of the people’s eating habits and lifestyle

Show More
Related

What Is The Chapter Summaries In Defense Of Food Pollan

830 Words | 4 Pages

He goes on to insist that the medical community just like the food industry also make money off of theories. New theories mean new drugs, treatments, procedures, and let’s be real here the medical industry does not make money off of healthy people it makes money off of sick people. When using this argument Pollan (2008) refers to Walter Willett who said, “You would not expect such a medical community to be sensitive to the cultural or ecological dimensions of the food problem-and it isn’t. We’ll know this has changed when doctors kick the fast-food franchises out of the hospitals.” (pg. 142) Denis Burkitt presents and answer to the question of what to do to stop the western diet.

Read More

Obesity In The Fat Tax, By Jonathan Rauch

334 Words | 2 Pages

In the article “The Fat Tax,” Jonathan Rauch ironically discusses the new public policy concern with obesity. Although the article is a satire, it’s economic analysis is actually valid. In order to get his point across, Rauch uses sarcasm, appeals to logos, and degrades the issue of obesity to help Americans better understand the “big picture.” Moreover, if the diet of American consumers does not change then maybe advertising more exercise to lose weight will cut down the obesity rate; but to be just as effective, enacting the fat tax will improve health as well.

Read More

Rhetorical Analysis Of Are You Responsible For Your Own Weight By Radley Balko

1008 Words | 5 Pages

In his article Are You Responsible For Your Own Weight?, policy analyst Radley Balko argues that the Government has no business interfering with what individuals eat. Kelly Brownell, a Yale Chairman, and Marion Nestle a New York University professor state otherwise by arguing that the Government should intervene to create conditions that lead to healthy eating. Balko has a strong argument led with in depth examples, logical support, and credentials to support his tone along with minor fallacies. Kelly Brownell and Marion Nestle fail to go more in depth about her argument, but rely heavily on trying to counter the claims given by the opposing side. The lack of rhetorical devices in her article and inadequate organization weakens her tone as well as the appeal to their audience.

Read More

Summary Of Michael Pollan's Unhappy Meals

565 Words | 3 Pages

In recent decade, the United States has seen supermarkets continuously get filled with packages labeled with things like “Low sodium” or “No Trans Fats.” Companies stick these labels on their food to match the current fads of what is good for you and what is not. In his essay Unhappy Meals, Michael Pollan advocates a return to natural and basic foods, and deplores nutritionism. Pollan argues that nutritionism does not actually tell people what is healthy or not, and that the only way to be sure you are eating healthy is to eat natural, fresh food.

Read More

Canadian Lifestyle Choices: A Public Health Failure

309 Words | 2 Pages

“Canadian Lifestyle Choices: A Public Health Failure” by Daniel Rosenfield et al. is a journalistic essay published in the Canadian Medical Association Journal aimed at medical professionals as well as those with a passion for good health. It examines extensive factors that contribute to poor health in Canada, cunningly convicting the government as the major, if not sole, culprit of this issue. Health concerns with respect to cardiovascular and pulmonary illness arise in the wake of the author’s devious presentation of arguments regarding faulty food labeling. It audaciously emphasizes the characteristic health discrepancies between the past and current society, consistently commenting on the government’s constant failure to prevent issues

Read More

Analysis Of What You Eat Is Your Business By Radley Balko

1089 Words | 5 Pages

He also states that the government should allow the citizens to access their health care funds account to support his conclusion, that, people will be more responsible for their health if someone else isn 't paying for their health problems. However, Balko fails to to provide evidence for to support his claim. Even though the problem of obesity is important, the Shorthorn should not publish "What You Eat Is Your Business" because it poorly argued and not interesting. Radley Balko’s central claim is that the government should not interfere in public health and diet. According to him people have no incentive to maintain their health when public money funds health care.

Read More

What You Eat Is Your Business By Radley Balko Analysis

1610 Words | 7 Pages

In “What You Eat Is Your Business,” Radley Balko tackles the issue of who is responsible for fighting obesity. Balko argues that the controversy of obesity should make the individual consumers culpable for their own health and not the government (467). As health insurers refrain from increasing premiums for obese and overweight patients, there is a decrease in motivation to keep a healthy lifestyle (Balko 467). As a result, Balko claims these manipulations make the public accountable for everyone else 's health rather than their own (467). Balko continues to discuss the ways to fix the issue such as insurance companies penalizing consumers who make unhealthy food choices and rewarding good ones (468).

Read More

The Omnivore's Dilemma By Michael Pollan

2089 Words | 9 Pages

In The Omnivore’s Dilemma, Pollan encourages us to change the way we eat but he never instructs us on what consumers should be eating. He educates us on what we are eating and informs us of all the events that go on behind closed doors. By building and building on our knowledge, he can reel us in instead of driving us away with offensive remarks. He never attacks the fact that most of us eat without thinking about it. In doing this, he can calmly approach his audience with the facts.

Read More

Maxfield Eating Healthy

683 Words | 3 Pages

Eating Healthy Michael Pollan, a health food spokesperson, made some interesting critiques on how he believes that there is an American paradox such as, “a notably unhealthy population preoccupied with… the idea of eating healthy” (Maxfield, 442). The idea taken from Michael Pollan’s quote is that he believes the definition of healthy eating has more to do with how it is “driven by a well-funded corporate machine” (Maxfield, 442). He is also claiming that the food industry is benefiting on our lack of knowledge on how to eat properly when it comes to being healthy. In her article Food as Thought: Resisting the Moralization of Eating, Mary Maxfield directly attacked Pollan’s claims, pointing out the hypocrisy in his words because he is sharing

Read More

Review Of The Omnivore's Dilemma By Michael Pollan

1173 Words | 5 Pages

Few people have ever thought of food as more than just a source of energy, a fount of nutrients, or a delight to our taste buds. The only parts of our body involved in the work of eating are our mouth and digestive system-or so we think. But that’s only a fraction of the whole picture. The book The Omnivore’s Dilemma by Michael Pollan reveals the evolution, science, and thinking behind the simple action of eating. In this book, Pollan argues that a long time ago, humans were able to solve the dilemma they had about what to eat, but now, at a time when we think we’re so much more advanced, this dilemma has not only been made harder, but we’ve become even less healthy, and forgotten the point of eating, especially in America.

Read More

What You Eat Is Your Business Rhetorical Analysis

490 Words | 2 Pages

His argue is that, politically, the health care system is becoming more and more socialist. Likewise, our government is too concerned on intervening with our nation’s junk food problem, and should be modeling and encouraging American citizens on personal health, responsibility, and self-awareness. The author feels that “we’re becoming less responsible for our own health, and more responsible for everyone else’s.” (897) Balko seems to hold more credible sources, and being the fact that he is a “self-descried libertarian” (896), he knowledge also helps greatly with his opinion on this topic of

Read More

Don T Blame The Eater Analysis

1610 Words | 7 Pages

Some people are unable to read the confusing nutrition labels on the back of food products. For this reason, nutrition labels should revise the format of labels which would then result in people clearly knowing the outcomes expected of intaking certain foods and condiments. In some cases, nutrition information is absent on packages and cause confusion as to what people are eating. This is demonstrated as Zinczenko claims “Complicating the lack of alternatives is the lack of information about what, exactly, we’re consuming. There are no calorie information charts on fast-food packaging the way there are on grocery items” (7).

Read More

What You Eat Is Your Business Analysis

434 Words | 2 Pages

Blako says that this is the wrong way to fight obesity; The government should be trying to teach and foster us about our health but that government is doing the opposite. He says that for a long time now the people are worried about what the other people instead of the self’s “For decades now, America’s health care system has been migrating toward socialism. Your well-being shape, and condition have increasingly been deemed matters of “public health” instead of matters of personal responsibility”(Balko 467). He says that all democratic candidates for president boasted plans to push heath care more in to public sector to make the sates charge less money for the insurance who are healthy, other people’s health problems are effecting Balko’s health insurance go up. The best way to remove public obesity is remove public health he says that it does not belong there any way; the public don’t care about what people put into their body’s, the public only cares when they are asked to pay for the consequences of those

Read More

Dont Blame The Eater Summary

774 Words | 4 Pages

He expresses that “For decades now, America's health care system has been migrating towards socialism.” He asserts that rather than it being a moral duty to carry on with a solid life, it is people in general's obligation to pay for your unfortunate ways. As he puts it, “Your heart attack drives up the cost of my premiums and office visits.” Radly contends that if the administration will pay for your solution because of your poor eating and living propensities, what inspiration does a man need to eat and live right? He trusts that in the event that we are altogether considered responsible for our eating and wellbeing decisions, we'll settle on more intelligent

Read More

What You Eat Is Your Business Essay

656 Words | 3 Pages

Americans today are well-known for their eating habits. With all the options the food industry gives us it makes it hard to go to the grocery store and resist picking up that bag of barbeque-flavored chips or blueberry flavored candy. Due to these processed foods obesity is a growing epidemic in our country and who is to blame for it? In an article entitled “What You Eat is Your Business” by Radley Balko, Balko argues for less government intervention. Balko believes is it our responsibility to take care of ourselves and make it a priority.

Read More

More about Compare And Contrast What You Eat Is Your Business And Don T Blame The Eater

Related Topics

Open Document