ipl-logo

Comparing Cinderella And Catskinella

1432 Words6 Pages

Literature of Childhood
3 February 2017
Analysis of the Fairytales Cinderella and Catskinella Fairytales have been stereotypically read to young children for many centuries, although, adults can also benefit from reading these classic stories. Two alternative versions of the original Chinese version, Ye Xian, are the fairytales, Cinderella, by an American, Walter Disney, and Catskinella, by an African American, Virginia Hamilton. Both stories portray the main character as a woman who has a wicked and unkind family. The stories display the ways in which the protagonist finds her true love through each of their different personalities, other characters, and conditions in the storyline. Although both versions both have similar narrative elements, …show more content…

The fairy tale, Cinderella expresses the main character as being unconfident and having less to say than in the other version. For example, the only phrase you can note that Ella says is, “Oh, no! It’s midnight. I must go” while the prince kissed her, asked her to dance and cried for her to wait as she was running away from the ball (Disney, 14-15). This part of the story portrays the male character to be more verbal than the female character; which reflects the gender stereotype as males expressing themselves more dominantly than females. The protagonist’s phrase also displays her lack of confidence to stay at the party even though she would like to. She is not bold or courageous enough to disobey her godmother’s requests for her to return by midnight. Ella’s personality is much different in Disney’s story than in Hamilton’s story, even though they are headed to the same outcome; Ella or Catskinella marries the prince. In her model, Hamilton allows her main character to be more confident and verbal than the prominent figure in Disney’s story. Her courageousness is apparent when she runs away to a king’s castle to escape her imminent marriage and her father’s wrath. Catskinella is even bold to one of the prince’s maidens when one of them requests her to bake something; “Why should I bake him a cake? Oh, well. He found me a place to work and a cabin to live in” (Hamilton, 26). If Ella from the other version were in Catskinella’s position, she would have obediently obeyed with a response such as, “okay”. However, both characters’ dispositions change as their almost identical outcomes come closer to revealing their ending

Show More
Related
235 Words | 1 Pages

Like the Disney version, the cruel stepmother and wicked stepsisters put Ella and Edna through the same burdens. But Cinderella’s gloomy attitude, tendency to mope and her dependency on others are the reasons for her unhappiness. In contrast to Cinderella who is as fragile

Read More
716 Words | 3 Pages

In an interview, Miranda states “The dramatic license I had to take was first making Angelica single and to push the sons of Philip away. . .” (Miranda; Genius Interview). Miranda alters this character to change the plot but it also causes the audience to believe that these characters were exactly how they were portrayed in the musical. This is how Lin-Manuel Miranda’s altering of characters and events changed how the audience perceived the events of

Read More
680 Words | 3 Pages

Compare and Contrast Essay Once upon a time there was a story about a girl named Cinderella. There have been many versions of this story written. There is a version for almost every culture, but they all lead back to the original version told by the Brother’s Grimm. Although the story has changed through time, the main plot stays the same. Cinderella is a young girl who is forced into being a servant for her family.

Read More
873 Words | 4 Pages

”(act1) To transforming and saying things like “The difference between a lady and a flower girl is not how she behaves, but how she is treated. ”(act2) Eliza realizes this whole time she has been taught to be a lady but all she really needed to do is to be nice and be much more lady like.

Read More
417 Words | 2 Pages

It is made known to readers, that like Emma, Cher, to boost their egos and pride, also do not guide Tai and Harriet as a result of the goodness of her heart. These similarities in both protagonists reveal a better likeness to each other than in the original

Read More
811 Words | 4 Pages

She has no more of a title or position than Perrault’s Cinderella, but we are given the opportunity to watch as she manages to rebel in a hundred different ways and to let her stepmother know that she refuses to quietly expect the arranged marriage, has setup in order to get her out of the way. This is not only entertaining for us as the viewers to watch, but also far more realistic in nature, when compared to that of Perrault’s Cinderella, who by the content of the story just seems to blindly expect the overwhelming cruelty shown to her by her stepmother and stepsisters, who throughout the story continue to try her as a

Read More
809 Words | 4 Pages

It treats women poorly to cause them to comply with gender expectations. Not only do women have to face pressures of conformity in real life, but they also face intimidation in fairytales. Grimm’s Snow White and Cinderella perpetuate society’s notion that a woman is the inferior being whose value lies not only in her beauty but also in her abilities to perform domestic work and satisfy men. Grimm uses the characters of Cinderella and Snow White to perpetuate the idea that women should lead quietly domestic lives. In Cinderella, Cinderella spent most of her time in a kitchen.

Read More
700 Words | 3 Pages

Similarly, in Walt Disney’s “Cinderella,” she is also treated horribly, and awarded a beautiful outfit by her fairy godmother, letting her attend a ball, encountering her true love. Cinderella gets married to the prince, however, the step-sisters are forgiven and live with Cinderella at the castle unlike the original story. Both stories have many similarities, especially in the climax. However, the

Read More
1008 Words | 5 Pages

A Cinderella Story The Cinderella story is a popular archetype that has been present in almost every culture, representing a girl's dream of achieving a happy and wealthy marriage. However, a careful reading of some "Cinderella" folk tales reveals instances of abuse and even incest. In the past, for many girls, the only relief available from abusive households was to marry well. In modern times, some authors present the Cinderella myth in a positive light, while others offer a more feminist interpretation.

Read More
642 Words | 3 Pages

Cinderella is also portrayed as a young woman suffering silently, without taking any action and waiting for her Prince Charming to rescue her from her horrible life. This is as much a fairy tale convention as it is a gender expectation for women to be beautiful and silent. However, this wasn’t as much as a gender expectation in the 1800s as it is today. Cinderella’s father does not appear to be home as much as the stepmother, and this illustrates the type of work and expectations for women’s and men’s jobs in the 1800s. The father is probably commuting to work, and this is evident through the fact that he never sees the cruelty experienced by Cinderella.

Read More
1916 Words | 8 Pages

Moreover, it should be underlined that the main character was born from "A gentleman who has fine lands and houses," (Jacobs 166) but, in spite of her wealthy origins and the degradation and abuse she receives daily, she is dedicated to her job as a scullion even going back to her occupation after every ball - this way providing the cook with the opportunity to bash two more objects on her head - thus demonstrating humility and strenuousness. Ergo, after everything Catskin tolerated throughout her existence, her

Read More
605 Words | 3 Pages

The core of the story has become very flexible in terms of how it can be portrayed. In the article, “A Girl, A Shoe, A Prince: The Endlessly Evolving Cinderella”, the author, Linda Holmes, talks about the durability of the story when she states “All it takes is a girl and a dress and a shoe; people get it. There are countless versions” (11). Holmes gives many examples of stories and movies that have portrayed the Cinderella Story. She stressed the work “countless” in her arguments to emphasize how far this folk tale has come.

Read More
1330 Words | 6 Pages

While the other male characters such as Scuttle and Flounder were unintelligent and dependent. These ideas that men are superior to women are shown by female disney characters, and the portrayal of masculinity and femininity in movies and media to people from a young

Read More
1371 Words | 6 Pages

In other words, females are expected to mannered, weak, and homemakers such as a Disney princess, at the same time the typical men are figured to be powerful, rude, governing and willing to rescue the princess in need anytime. What is more, these are not the only stereotypes which has been embedded into the young generation. Disney holding on a stable "women banking on men to achieve happy ending" theme. When we have a closer look at Disney movies such as "Cinderella", "Snow White" and "Aladdin", Disney 's princess portray is feeble and desperately in need of intelligent, strong savior. When young girls watch these movies, they are modelling Disney princesses on their

Read More
88 Words | 1 Pages

Anne Shirley is known as an imaginative and pretty girl whom everyone regards highly. Katherine Brooke however, is a girl with a cutting mouth and a bitter heart, whom everyone dislikes immensely because of her hoity-toity personality. They are so different, yet so alike, showed in their later formed sisterhood and past. They both had a early childhood without any joy. However, while Anne escaped from that sadness to live with the Cuberts, Katherine had her childhood spiral into even more sorrowful events when she became an

Read More

More about Comparing Cinderella And Catskinella

Related Topics

Open Document