ipl-logo

Compare And Contrast Anthem And Harrison Bergeron

408 Words2 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: What are 3 similarities and 3 differences between harrison bergeron and anthem

Two Dystopian Literatures
“They were equal every which way”(vonnegut 1).”Harrison Bergeron” and Anthem are both a collectivist society, that try to make the world smooth and have more peace in their society, but instead becomes a dramatic dystopia. Although “Harrison Bergeron” and
Anthem are both dystopian literature, they both differ in their families and technology.
In harrison bergeron, they have families, and this is seen when the story says… “George and Hazel bergeron 14 years old son.”(Vonnegut 1).This proves that in this society, they have
Families. In “Harrison Bergeron” they also have technology, it states in the passage…”George and Hazel were watching TV” (Vonnegut 2). This shows that in the Novel “Harrison bergeron” there …show more content…

In Anthem, the reason why they have no technology and families is because the society accepted collectivism as an honorable idea. Anthem states “I am I think I will”(Rand, 94). The characters used “we” instead of “I” which clearly shows that collectivism overtook the society. The government believed everyone should be equal. Men and Women Spend one night in a palace of mating and they produce the newborn and as soon as the baby is born they take the baby and raise it by the states, so the parents don’t know who their children are and visa versa. “Men may not think of women except for one night during the Time of Mating” (Rand, 41). This claims that they don 't have families or relationships they are forced to reproduce by the government. They have no technology as well, they use candles light so when Equality 7-2521 discovers the light bulb... “Equality 7-2521 is on his way to a discovery even more critical than electricity” (Rand,53). This proves that in the society the don 't have any technology they use candles, and once the home of the scholars except equality’s invention will later change their society.
Anthem and harrison bergeron have major differences in their societies, and become a dystopia. You can 't make a society greater by making everyone equal, using people 's differences to their advantage is how people should really live. There is no point in living if you are living with hatred or living in fear.The people should live in happiness but there is also not perfect world on everyone being happy. As Martin Luther King Jr. said… “The time is always right to do whats

Show More
Related
414 Words | 2 Pages

Both stories: Harrison Bergeron and Anthem are pieces of dystopian literature with similarities and differences between family and technology. Family in Harrison Bergeron is very different from family in Anthem. In the story of Harrison Bergeron, family is legal, “George and Hazel were watching television” (Vonnegut 1).

Read More
1145 Words | 5 Pages

Through Ray Bradbury’s “A Sound of Thunder” and Kurt Vonnegut Jr’s “Harrison Bergeron”, give us two different stories about societies in a dystopian future and the consequences of what the future may or not await us. Dystopian literature has long been a popular genre that imagines dark and oppressive futures where societal norms and values are twisted, and the human condition is questioned. Ray Bradbury's "A Sound of Thunder" and Kurt Vonnegut Jr's "Harrison Bergeron" are two short stories that go into dystopian visions of the future. While both stories share common themes, they also have different perspectives on the consequences of technology, the dangers of government control, and the impact on individuals and society. This essay will provide

Read More
844 Words | 4 Pages

Anthem Essay The city that is portrayed in the novel Anthem by Ayn Rand relies heavily on its strict rules and regulations. Some of these rules are put in place to protect the wellbeing of the citizens, where others are to prevent the citizens from living happy lives. In a way, every rule in Anthem is needed or has a specific reason however some of the rules are simply in place to keep away individuality. To begin, the city of Anthem has several rules and guidelines. Some of them can seem harsh and a little bit unnecessary.

Read More
634 Words | 3 Pages

In both stories Fahrenheit 451, and Harrison Bergeron they have similar themes and ideas with mysterious, corrupt societies all about the concept of knowledge, and not letting people have it with stupid reasons. In the stories, it is all about being born into communist type countries, who really like rules as well as limits on stupid things held by the governments such as in Fahrenheit 451 it is reading books, because the ideas upset you, and in Harrison Bergeron it is just the traits of being smart, ugly, just equality in general is not acceptable because they want people to be mis-uninformed about everything because of amendment #211, and #212 which is equality all in the same way One similarity is when Guy Montag meets all of the homeless on page143 it says "Welcome back from the dead." Montag nodded. Granger went on.

Read More
714 Words | 3 Pages

Comparing and contrasting 2081 to Harrison Bergeron Admit it, one time you were bored or sat down with nothing to do and couldn’t help but imagine how life would be if everyone was equal, don’t even try denying it, you’ve thought of that at least once in your life, but as any good writer would do, they’d write their thoughts down and turn it into a story, that’s exactly what Kurt Vonnegut did. Just imagine living a life where no one gets compared to others in any way. We all wish for a society like that, but Kurt showed us how equality can negatively affect our society. But that’s not the our main idea in this essay, our main idea is to highlight the comparisons and contrasts between the story “Harrison Bergeron” and the movie version “2081”. To begin with, Both the story and the movie had the same introduction/ Opening; “Everybody was finally equal.

Read More
319 Words | 2 Pages

2 societys What are the differences between 2 societys,Anthem and “Harrison Bergeron”. Anthem is about a boy named Equality 7-2521 who is smarter than everyone in the society.he meets a girl and then runs away to the forest. ”Harrison Bergeron”is about a boy would needs to have a handicaps to be average. Rand Anthem and vonnegut “Harrison Bergeron” is different with family relationships and mind control. Family relationships are different in many way in Anthem and “Harrison Bergeron”.

Read More
565 Words | 3 Pages

Two Different Stories, Still a Dystopia Although Anthem and Harrison Bergeron are two different stories there are so many similarities and differences but all lead up to the same outcome, a dystopia. Now here are some ways they are mostly the same. For one in both Harrison Bergeron and Anthem they are both being controlled by some type of leader.

Read More
986 Words | 4 Pages

Everyone is equal to each other, they all have the same thoughts, and they all work to provide for each other. These ideas are the same in North Korea, although they are actually able to know who their families are. In the books civilization the children are not allowed to know who they are actually related to, they just brothers and sisters to each other. The citizens of the fictional civilization are also assigned a time and place for mating whereas in North Korea they have at least the freedom of choice given to them when it comes to relationships and children. Rand Paul in his argument against the Energy Independence & Security Act of 2007, while using the book Anthem to solidify his argument, states “The collective has no place basically for individual choice” which is the overall mentality of the citizens within the book, they are all seen as equal and are lead to think that they should work as one, not individuals.

Read More
764 Words | 4 Pages

Collectivism is the idea that a group 's needs must be put before the needs of oneself and the society functions as “we” rather that “me”. Throughout the stories one sees how each author portrays the use of a collectivist society though uniqueness, equality, and transgression. There are many similarities between the novella Anthem by Ayn Rand and the story “Harrison Bergeron” by Kurt Vonnegut Jr. In Anthem and “Harrison Bergeron” one could see that a similar theme is that going against the grain causes consequences. According to “Harrison Bergeron” a ballerina states that “ ‘Harrison Bergeron age fourteen,’ she said in a grackle squawk, ‘has just escaped from jail, where he was held on suspicion of plotting to overthrow the government.

Read More
376 Words | 2 Pages

Kurt Vonnegut’s Harrison Bergeron is considered a dystopian literature due to its demonstration of the attributes of a typical dystopian society through the categories Types of Dystopian Controls and The Dystopian Protagonist. Under the category Dystopian Controls more specifically the Bureaucratic control is shown throughout the short story showing a dystopian society. The people in the society follow the orders of the government blindly without any hesitation or resistance. The government says everyone must be equal in every way so that's what the people do like demonstrated by George, “He was required by law to wear it at all time... Every twenty seconds or so, the transmitter would send out some sharp noise to keep people like George from

Read More
1042 Words | 5 Pages

Equality comes when each person has the same opportunities and rights as every other in their country, state, et cetera. Some authors in their writing like to challenge the idea of equality and the boundaries of how far some governments, fictional or not, are willing to go for their own idea of equality. The societies in Anthem and “Harrison Bergeron” can be compared in their “successes” by making everyone think they are equal, and their failures in which they are not able to keep everyone contained. The novella Anthem provides a better criticism of government because it goes into more depth about how the citizens are not held back physically by the state, but mostly by their own upbringing and beliefs. These societies, which do differentiate in many ways, successes’ compare in that they are both able to complete the task of making everyone think they are equal.

Read More
1349 Words | 6 Pages

Anthem: A Collective Society Throughout their lives, the residents of the society described in Anthem, written by Ayn Rand, would be separated and meticulously moved according to their ages, gender, and jobs. The most prevalent example of this is the separation of the ages. The collective society in Anthem chose to meet the demands that came with the issue of aging by creating a very controlled and organized environment for the citizens to live in.

Read More
709 Words | 3 Pages

Harrison Bergeron and The Pedestrian: Equality and Conformity Imagine you are the exact same person as everyone else, living under an oppressive government, in a dystopian society. Harrison Bergeron by Kurt Vonnegut and The Pedestrian by Ray Bradbury both envelop dystopian societies. In Harrison Bergeron, Vonnegut establishes a dystopian society where a totalitarian government handicaps the talented and controls all aspects of every citizen 's life. In The Pedestrian, Bradbury describes a society where everyone stays inside watching television because a totalitarian government believes this is the best way to progress in society. These governments instill conformity through the use of force, consequently causing society to lose its individuality.

Read More
1823 Words | 8 Pages

Kurt Vonnegut uses characterization to describe how the characters act in this society. Vonnegut also uses style to show how he uses science fiction and dystopia in “Harrison Bergeron”. The theme demonstrated in “Harrison Bergeron” is equality is not meant to make one person better than another. Kurt Vonnegut in “Harrison Bergeron”, demonstrates that equality based on characteristics is not a good thing for society. Harrison Bergeron is a short story based on the year 2081, where everybody is equal.

Read More
610 Words | 3 Pages

The story, "Harrison Bergeron" is a dystopian literature by Kurt Vonnegut, Jr. As is, "Anthem" by Ayn Rand. From each

Read More

More about Compare And Contrast Anthem And Harrison Bergeron

Related Topics

Open Document