ipl-logo

Comparing Kierkegaard's From The Hellenic Sky To The God-Man

1230 Words5 Pages

Provisional Title: 'From the Hellenic Sky to the God-Man: Kierkegaard's critical reading of the Phaedo in respect of the immortality of the soul, with reference to the concept of irony, and his doctoral dissertation published under the same title'

Introduction/Goal of Study: the purpose of this paper is that of analyzing a portion of Kierkegaard's early work and doctoral dissertation The Concept of Irony. In close dialogue with the figure of Socrates and with Plato's thought, Kierkegaard sets out to discuss the concept of irony and how the practice of irony marked Socrates' figure. Following Hegel, Kierkegaard's reads Socrates as someone imperfectly Christ, and Platonism as opening the way for the advent of Christianity.1 In this regard, one of the many aspects in which Socrates prefigures Christianity is by holding a belief in the immortality of the soul. Nonetheless, Kierkegaard holds that Socrates holds a defective conception of the soul, of its relationship to the body, and of the immortality of the former.

In a nutshell, Kierkegaard objects to Socrates his incapacity of thinking beyond the opposition between the soul and the body. Unable to achieve the Christian speculative union between the body and the soul – crystallized by the the Christian teachings of bodily …show more content…

As regards the secondary sources I will make mainly reference to the series Kierkegaard Research and Kierkegaard International Commentary, respectively published by Routledge and Mercer University Press. Rather than testing Kierkegaard's reading of Plato in the light of contemporary scholarship, my method will be that of taking Kierkegaard's positions at face value. I find this justified insofar as my intention is that of exploring what is Kierkegaard's concept of immortality, rather than checking the correctness of his interpretation of

Show More
Related
1000 Words | 4 Pages

Father Spitzer presents an argument for the existence of the physical soul, and examines the possibility of the body being merely physical. Through the presentation of veridical data and a sound argument, Father Spitzer asserts that accounts of veridical experiences during clinical death help prove the human soul’s existence. Father Spitzer’s argument relies on veridical data and accounts provided by patients in multiple case studies. His argument, ultimately, falls to the amount of data gathered by the dead during clinical death, which can later be reported accurately. This argument is inductive, and provides many reasons to believe the ultimate conclusion, that the body is not merely physical, and there must be a presence of a type of soul.

Read More
1459 Words | 6 Pages

However, the idea that the soul is a separate entity, then the body, is outdated. The understanding that the soul and body are one is vitally important, especially in the context of resurrection. The idea that the body and the soul are two distinct entities, limits the extent and incomprehensibility of the

Read More
242 Words | 1 Pages

In the entry of Phaedo, Plato claims that the soul is immortal and that when the body dies the soul gets reincarnated. Throughout his story, Socrates provides arguments that help support his claim about the soul being immortal. I will be explaining and evaluating 2 of Plato’s arguments that will help him support the statement that the soul is immortal. An argument Plato uses is called the argument from opposites, which is the first argument he uses in the selection.

Read More
990 Words | 4 Pages

At the end of Book I of Plato’s Republic, Socrates attempts to persuade Thrasymachus that the just lead a happier and more flourishing life than the unjust (354a). He argues that justice is the virtue of the soul, which allows the soul to perform its ergon, or function, with excellence. Because the soul’s function is to live, justice allows the soul to live with excellence. In this paper, I shall present and critically examine Socrates’ reasoning behind this conclusion. The argument subtly commits the fallacy of equivocation because the term function is ambiguous.

Read More
920 Words | 4 Pages

This is a central idea of the Christian faith and is related to the idea of receiving the body and blood of Christ in the Eucharist. The child's new respect for her body is a realization that her body is not something to be ashamed of or to envy, but rather something to be cherished and respected. O’connor states "She had always thought a body was a terrible burden anyway, subject to sickness and death and deformity(O’connor). " This quote shows the Christian idea that the body is imperfect and temporary, and that the soul is what truly matters. The Eucharist is seen as a way of transcending the limitations of the body and connecting with the

Read More
1374 Words | 6 Pages

and body are different kinds of substance. Interaction between mind and body is to be explained as a manifestation of the correlation between two

Read More
525 Words | 3 Pages

Finally, both texts convey the concept of the body being the vessel of the mind and soul. Yusufali insists that, "It [the body] is the vessel of an intelligent mind and strong soul." (page 52). She states the importance of the body, that after all it should not be objectified as a mere tool of advertisement or to be jeered

Read More
615 Words | 3 Pages

This beautiful metaphor for the united church shows that not one part or spiritual gift can work to make the whole body. There needs to be variety to move in all of the different ways the Spirit can move. As educators, we can choose to see our classrooms as small bodies of Christ with each child serving as an organ. Therefore, there will be hearts, ears, eyes, feet, hands, and many other vital parts of the body and in the classroom.

Read More
786 Words | 4 Pages

The distinctions that Socrates makes between the two will be discussed further on in this paper, and the effect those distinctions have on Socrates’ and my arguments. Before death occurs, the soul is “in a kind of prison, and that one must not free oneself or run away [from]”, which is what Socrates considers the body to be, a prison (62b). During a human life, the body and soul are together with the soul providing the body life and the body imprisoning the soul. Socrates

Read More
1082 Words | 5 Pages

The soul, being immortal and eternal, attains an awareness of Forms before entering a human body and descending on earth and can remember these ideas. This is the aforementioned ‘doctrine of recollection’ or ‘anamnesis’. This doctrine is inevitably interlocked with his theory of ‘immortality of the soul’. This theory is elaborated primarily in the three dialogues of Phaedo, Phaedrus and Republic. In Phaedo Plato holds that death is but “freedom and separation of the soul from the body” (280).

Read More
1013 Words | 5 Pages

Socrates in the dialogue Alcibiades written by Plato provides an argument as to why the self is the soul rather than the body. In this dialogue Alcibiades and Socrates get into a discussion on how to cultivate the self which they both mutually agree is the soul, and how to make the soul better by properly taking care of it. One way Socrates describes the relationship between the soul and the body is by analogy of user and instrument, the former being the entity which has the power to affect the latter. In this paper I will explain Socrates’ arguments on why the self is the soul and I will comment on what it means to cultivate it.

Read More
524 Words | 3 Pages

In the Republic, Plato gives an argument saying the soul is immortal. In this paper I will present his argument and show that his argument is invalid. I will show why the conclusion is not true and restate the argument to make it valid to help with Socrates’ claim. Plato’s argument on why the soul is immortal: 1. Something can only be destroyed by the thing that is bad for it.

Read More
1152 Words | 5 Pages

It never changes and yet causes the essential nature of things we perceive in the world. These two perceptions are what Plato describes as the divided line or the journey of self discovery. This progression of the spirit, that can never be reached, becomes the ideal. Plato’s discussions include the involvement of the soul. It is clear, that the main reason for dealing with the soul is to achieve this state

Read More
526 Words | 3 Pages

He argues that the body and soul are two elements that have the same underlying substance. He maintains that a person’s soul is the same as his nature of body; however, he argues that the mind differed from other parts of the body as it lacked a physical feature. In this case, he maintains that the intellect lacks a physical form, and this allows it to receive every form. It allows a person to think about anything, including the material object. In this case, he argues that if the intellect were in a material form, it could be sensitive to only some physical objects.

Read More
1528 Words | 7 Pages

In other words, by recognizing the “I” of the foreign living body as the zero point of orientation of the spatial world, we have consequently categorized the foreign living body as an “object-constituting consciousness and have made it relative to the outer world (Stein, 92). It then follows that the “I” of a foreign living body has already been interpreted as a spiritual subject. Therefore, we have already entered the realm of the spirit when we undertake every literal act of empathy. Moreover, feelings and expressions have further constituted the “world of values” just like the physical nature is constituted in perceptual acts (Stein, 92).

Read More

More about Comparing Kierkegaard's From The Hellenic Sky To The God-Man

Related Topics

Open Document