ipl-logo

Comparison Between Staples-Office Depot Merger (1997)

818 Words4 Pages

Comparison between Staples-Office Depot proposed merger (1997) and Office Depot-OfficeMax merger (2003)
Abstract: Both of Staples-Office Depot merger in 1997 and Office Depot-OfficeMax merger in 2003 are horizontal mergers between leading office supply stores, while the Federal Trade Commission denied the Staples-Office Depot merger in 1997 and approved the Office Depot-OfficeMax merger. The changes in the Federal Trade Commission’s decisions are derived from the significant changes in the office supply market, such as the stiff competition in the office supply market and the technology impact. This article compares these mergers from three respects in the Federal Trade Commission’s decision: relevant product market, anti-competitive effect …show more content…

However, after seven-month investigation, the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) blocked this merger in awe of the great market power caused by the proposed merger. At that time, Staples was the second-largest office superstore company in the United States and Office Depot was the largest one. And Staples was the first company which invented “Office Superstore” (OSS). Staples did not possesses 550 stores in 28 states until 1996. At the same time, Office Depot had more than 500 stores in 38 states.

In 2013, Office Depot decided to pay $1.2 billion for acquiring OfficeMax. The FTC approved this merger in the same year because there was increasingly competition in the office supply industry with the development of electronic commerce. And the FTC believed that the merger between Office Depot and OfficeMax would not cause the anti-competitive effect.

Given that all of Staples, Office Depot and OfficeMax are major office supply companies in the United States, these mergers are horizontal mergers. Faced with the mergers acquisition from top three OSS companies, the judge gives total different attitudes towards these horizontal mergers. The comparison between these two horizontal mergers are essential for investigating the reasons that why the FTC changes …show more content…

Firstly, the FTC states that OSS firms are different from Non-OSS firms even though both of them provide same categories of goods,office supplies. OSS firms are able to provide a wide variety of office supplies and to possess considerable amount of stock. But Non-OSS firms generally maintain an extremely limited number of goods which is unable to cater for the huge demanding from office managers. On the other hand, OSS is famous for one-stop shopping. Consumers do not need to waste time on gathering information concerning products, price and visiting different kinds of stores to purchase products because they can buy what they need on a single visit in an OSS company, which it saves their time cost. Not only can people buy a notebook but also a laptop in the Staples or Office Depot, which it cannot occur in the CVS, a Non-OSS company. As a result, customers preferred OSS to Non-OSS. For this matter, OSS are so unique that consumers are loyal to OSS companies instead of Non-OSS

Show More
Related
268 Words | 2 Pages

Organizational decisions differ from individual consumer decisions in the following ways: the manner in which products are purchased, what products are purchased, and the involvement of people in the purchasing decisions. Organizational buyers are defined as “people who purchase goods and services on behalf of companies for the companies’ use in manufacturing, distribution, or resale” (Solomon, 2017). The buyers have a complex job in ensuring that the items that are purchased on behalf of the company is in correlation of past demands and future projections of necessity. For example, an organizational buyer for Hobby Lobby would have to ensure that fall, and Halloween products are purchased at the correct volume ( basing off of the previous

Read More
1050 Words | 5 Pages

Annual Reports and Press releases The annual reports and press releases of both companies slightly differ though with a portion of similarity. Although, Home Depot’s annual report is composed at the headquarters of giving an inclusive report on all of the retail stores in the world, through the company’s website these reports posted can be found. Therefore, this being impartial and all-inclusive to an extent of analysis it would have to be done on the contrasts, similarities, profitability, and performance of different retail stores in different regions or countries. However, the shareholders and customers analyze the summary provided to know the general performance.

Read More
322 Words | 2 Pages

The United Sates v. Microsoft anti trust case was based on the United Sates Justice Department’s assertion that Microsoft was monopolizing the software industry and making it too difficult for competitors to engage in the industry. Specifically, they were focused on the fact that Microsoft included software for their own web browser, Internet Explorer, with the purchase of each Microsoft PC. The plaintiff claimed that this was unfair to competing web browsers such as Netscape. The Justice Department had already had issues with Microsoft’s business practices prior to the 1998 anti trust case.

Read More
1256 Words | 6 Pages

Dick Smith – External Influences, Markets Article: http://theconversation.com/dick-smith-couldnt-compete-and-that-is-why-it-failed-52755     Dick Smith – Markets Dick Smith couldn’t compete with the external influence of existing and rising markets, and this is why it failed to reach targets causing it to go into receivership. Although Dick Smith was also impacted by internal influences, the main impact on the business was the external influence of markets. Because of the size of the existing market it failed to compete with big brands that have begun to expand and/or launch into the retail market of technology in the past 5 years such as JB HIFI, Harvey Norman, Aldi and Office Works.

Read More
2466 Words | 10 Pages

(3) tax effect, combined firm pays less than individual companies in taxes. (4) differential efficiency, management of the new company can increase value due to one of the firms being weaker, pre-merger (5) increased market power because now less competition in the market (p.868).” Society would benefit from operating and financial economies, allowing for products and services to be sold to society at a value through management efficiency. Management of the newly formed companies, post merger must execute identified

Read More
199 Words | 1 Pages

The learning curve, supplier relations, and capital investment that used to be required to enter the industry has decreased but are not insignificant. The large economies of scale that department store possess will allow them to continue to produce at cheaper prices than the new entrants and they also do not have the same brand loyalty as old stores. Degree of Rivalry The level of rivalry between existing competitors is at an all-time high. Despite this universal market decline, mid- range department stores is the weakest segment.

Read More
845 Words | 4 Pages

Throughout the years, Best Buy has become one of the most famous electronic retailer in the US, necessarily be the definition of “electronic store” for many of us. However, tracing back to history, music played a vital role to the company’s early days and helped shaped the company as we seen it today. In 1966, Richard M. Schulze and a business partner opened Sound of Music, an electronics store specializing in high fidelity stereos in Saint Paul, Minnesota (Weimer, 1998). By 1969, Schulze had bought out his business partner, Sound of Music had three stores and the company became a publicly held company listed on the NASDAQ exchange. Since then, Sound of Music operated nine stores throughout Minnesota by 1978.

Read More
331 Words | 2 Pages

In the article “Are You Paying Too Much for That Acquisition?” authors demonstrate that due to the too much payment of the target firm, the most acquisitions are not able to add value created into the acquiring frim or assist it to establish various kinds of competitive advantages in order to expand the market size, reduce the manufacturing or operating cost, and have more market share. In terms of some expensive payments of acquisitions, the reason of unprofitable acquisitions might be associated with the in accurate financial analysis based on the estimated value of the target firm and the value of combined firm with the synergy assumption. At the present, the purchasing price of an acquisition are always decided by taking account of

Read More
215 Words | 1 Pages

I have been a part-time employee for one of the Staples retail store located in Silver Spring Maryland for two years, and our store is one of the many that are affected by this problem. Stapes was founded by Tom Stemberg, who was an executive in a supermarket chain in 1985 (staples: our story 2003). After opening the first store in Massachusetts Staples has expanded nationally and internationally over the past thirty years. Statista an online statistics portal shows that in 2015 Staples has grown to 1,907 stores all over the world, managed by a regional corporate office (Statista 2015). The big expansion of retail stores and the high demand of products in a growing population changed the way department stores provide the service from the traditional

Read More
822 Words | 4 Pages

Amazon has become one of the most popular stores in America. The company increases their business daily. For this reason, individuals wonder if Amazon has become a monopoly. The definition of a monopoly:“the exclusive possession or control of the supply or trade in a commodity or service.” Since Amazon does business online, no real competitor has challenged the company for e-commerce.

Read More
177 Words | 1 Pages

I was aware of that the Kmart merged with Sears, several years ago. Through your post, I was able to learn that Kmart also merged with Shell. The merge was an

Read More
661 Words | 3 Pages

Comcast and Time Warner Cable have recently struck a deal. The two cable companies are waiting for their merger application to be approved by the Federal Communications Commission, the government agency that regulates communications through the media. Both Comcast and Time Warner claim that this merger is more to the benefit of their consumers, increasing services provided by the companies. However, this “merger” is nothing more than a takeover by Comcast, the company trying to increase the monopoly it is becoming.

Read More
884 Words | 4 Pages

An example of inorganic growth was Bibby Line Group 's acquisition of Garic Ltd in 2008. Garic is a plant and equipment hiring company to the construction industry. A merger usually involves combining two companies into a single larger company. The combination of the two companies involves a transfer of ownership, either through a stock swap or a cash payment between the two companies.

Read More
1442 Words | 6 Pages

Apple Inc. embraces diversification strategy as a means of promoting its viability in the market. Largely, the creation of the three products lines compounds the sources of the company’s income. In fact, the company does not rely on a single source of income because the product design belongs to different categories. This strategy cushions the business from suffering risks of associated with depending on a single business. According Hitt, Ireland, and Hoskisson (2014, p.135), the benefit of handling many products is that when one product fail or does poorly in the market, the business is would shift its attention of the best performing products.

Read More
1508 Words | 7 Pages

Social identity theory Social Identity theory (SIT) was founded by Tajfel and Turner in 1979, as a social-psychological perspective. Social identity theory explains that the identity of people is built out of perceived memberships to groups, like gender, age, religion and organizational membership, and self-image partly derives from the social categories which the person feels he belongs to. As people join several groups, one has different identities and behaviours to align with a specific group. The theory predicts that intergroup behaviours are explained by the perceived group statuses, legitimacy and stability of these differences and the possibility to change groups (Tajfel and Turner, 1979). Tajfel and Turner explain three assumptions

Read More

More about Comparison Between Staples-Office Depot Merger (1997)

Related Topics

Open Document