ipl-logo

Comparison Of Mill And Mona Caird's The Subjection Of Women

1191 Words5 Pages

The women’s rights movement is one of the most important movements that occurred in the Victorian Era. In this period, middle and upper class women fight back against social stratification and seek social freedom. Female and male writers alike describe their feelings regarding women’s rights. John Stuart Mill and Mona Caird are two writers that serve as advocates for women’s rights. Mill’s The Subjection of Women explains how making men superior to women hinders the progress of human society. In Marriage Caird argues that women should have independence in marriage and that males and females should be co-educated. These two authors’ ideas complement each other nicely and can be compared. In addition to supporting women’s rights in the Victorian …show more content…

He argues “the subjection of women to men being a universal custom, any departure from it quite naturally unnatural,” (Mill 1106). By this he means that the oppression of women is taught by society, therefore it seems natural. He adds to this argument by using historical and cultural facts. He explains that in the feudal ages, it did not seem strange for women to be independent and/or involved in politics because women were, in fact, involved in such (Mill 1106). This gives the impression that if women’s independence were normalized, it would no longer seem strange. Mill also compares the women’s movement to the start of the English House of Commons, because the deputies of commons at the time thought it was impossible to have the sort of power they developed (1107). Caird’s opinion coincides with Mill’s. She confidently states, “every good thing that we enjoy to-day was once the dream of a ‘crazy enthusiast’ mad enough to believe in the power of ideas and in the power of man to have things as he wills” (Caird 1631). In the case of women’s rights, this means that although women’s independence may seem like an outlandish idea, it is achievable, and it will be achieved. By explaining that the idea that women cannot be independent is a concept created by society, Mill and Caird bring women closer to a status of

Show More
Related

Analysis Of The Cult Of True Womanhood By Fanny Fern

165 Words | 1 Pages

For the 19th century America, the two sexes were to be separated into distinct spheres, the man’s public sphere and the woman’s private one. It was most common for the two sexes to spend their time mostly in the company of their own sex, and advices were given to the younger members of the society on the proper way of behaving according to one’s sex. Even though both sexes had to be instructed on how to perform in each other’s company, it was the shaping of a woman that needed to undergo through a series of instructions on the proper way to be a woman. A woman had to follow the rules of the Cult of True Womanhood to be considered proper and wife material. Fanny Fern in her writing appeals on and discusses the attributes of piety, purity, submissiveness,

Read More

Dbq Enlightenment Essay

618 Words | 3 Pages

Philosophers believed that men act like tyrants and act immature so they need to change their ways. In Document F-1 Mary Wollstonecraft says “But if women are to be excluded, without having a voice, from participation of the natural rights of mankind, prove first, to ward of the charge… there is not a shadow of justification for not admitting women under the same.” Wollstonecraft is fighting for equality, believes the only reason women are not equal is based off of old tradition, and it is time for change.

Read More

Summary Of Declaration Of Women's Rights Tocqueville

1437 Words | 6 Pages

Women in society did feel “aggrieved, oppressed and fraudulently deprived of their most sacred rights” [2]. Writers like de Gouge were of the opinion that the “tyrannical nature”[3] of men had to end and they believed that “woman is born free and lives up equal to man in her rights”(Art 1)[3]. The Declaration of Rights of Man and Citizen states that every citizen has the right to participate in the foundation of laws, “personally, or through his representative”(Art 6)[4]. Women were not considered citizens and were not allowed to participate by the male dominated society in the formation of laws. Marriage was the only way for women to become a part of the civilized society of men and thus getting married seemed like the best possible option even though marriage rendered a woman “civilly dead”[2].

Read More

Civil War Dbq

1203 Words | 5 Pages

People such as John Stuart Mill were passionate advocates for women’s rights. In document 1, Mill begins by saying that traditionally, the vocation of a woman is the place of a wife and mother. He believes that one is supposed to consider of women in that way, but in truth, he recognizes that by denying women the same opportunities as men, the world is denied of the talents of women. He wrote The Subjection of Women with the help of his wife. Though he was already an advocate for fairness, his wife educated him on the real-world consequences of women’s legal submission.

Read More

Dehumanization Of Women In The 1700's Essay

718 Words | 3 Pages

Essentially, marriage in the 1700’s was seen merely as a means of birthing heirs and finding a way to financially support yourself, so it resulted in both men and women being devalued. It is universally known that women were often treated as inept and helpless rather than sophisticated people with autonomy and capabilities. In fact, during this time, “married women were consistently compared with minor children and the insane-- both categories of people considered incapable of caring for themselves. To marry a woman was, in one sense, to ‘adopt’ her-- or at least to adopt responsibility for all the circumstances of life with which she entered the marriage” (Teachman 39). Furthermore, when women got married, they would legally cease to exist.

Read More

Women's Role In The 1800s

968 Words | 4 Pages

At the start of the 1800’s, the terms ‘separate spheres’ and ‘true womanhood’ began to describe the expectations of women at the time (Dr. Etcheson, Women). The responses ranged from complete agreement to total rejection. This caused debates and conferences to discuss the true place for women in the society of the day. Individuals such as Elizabeth Cady Stanton, Lucretia Mott, and Sojourner Truth fought for their ideas and beliefs on the role of women in society at the time. Despite their efforts, there was still controversy over where the woman fit into the equation.

Read More

The Crime For A Citizen Of The United States To Vote By Susan B Anthony

746 Words | 3 Pages

She references historical documents like the Declaration of Independence and the US Constitution stating they, “propose to protect the people in the exercise of their God-given rights. Not one of them pretends to bestow rights.” Her use of these documents emphasizes her argument that governments are not allowed to retract the alienable rights of the people, including women. Since governments are mainly run by men, they have the jurisdiction to decide who is allowed what and who is not. Unfortunately, this included women’s basic rights such as suffrage; however, as Anthony stated, historical documents promptly contradict these laws men have created and state that everyone deserves basic rights.

Read More

Compare And Contrast Mill And Marx's Oppression Of Women

1463 Words | 6 Pages

According to Mill, there exists a “legal subordination of one sex to the other” (Mill 1) where the oppression of women is a form of a “primitive state of slavery lasting on” (Mill 6). Thus, where on one hand for Marx, oppression of women has nothing to do with law, for Mill, on the other, it exists because of “the law of the strongest” (Mill 6) that enforces that women “shall never in all their lives be allowed to compete for certain things” (Mill 20). Not only this, but for Mill, unlike Marx, the oppression of women in society goes a lot further to include enslavement of the

Read More

Leadership In Lord Of The Flies

928 Words | 4 Pages

Boys to Lead and an Island to Leave “Leadership is not a position or a title it is action and example,” (Cory Booker). In William Golding’s fiction novel Lord of the Flies, Ralph and Jack prove that leadership comes in many forms. In the writing, a group of young boys desperately search for a way to leave the island with which they are stranded on after their plane had been shot down. This happens around the 1950s when families sent their children out of Britain in fear of being bombed by the Nazi regime, consequently the boys were then free of rules and structure.

Read More

Transcendentalism In Psychology

1586 Words | 7 Pages

John Stuart Mill wrote The Subjection of Women (1869), arguing in favor of equality between sexes. Mill compares the position of women with slavery in which control by the male sex is based on chivalry and generosity, using bribery and intimidation instead of brutality to secure obedience, deference, and gratitude for protection. Bribery and intimidation effect women economically and morally by having them depend on men, law completes intimidation by discriminatory statues. Much like Wollstonecraft had argued 70 years’ prior, Stuart took cause for women’s education.

Read More

Women's Rights In Frankenstein

1494 Words | 6 Pages

Women in England during the 1800s faced restrictions to participate in movements and were limited in their political speaking and voting capabilities. Although many women accepted their fate, some fought for a different social role. (“The Women 's Rights Movement”) Women such Mary Wollstonecraft, Jane Austen, and Mary Shelley inspired a new way of radical thinking towards human rights, specifically the rights of women (Surgis). Thanks to these inspiring individuals, there was a change in women’s attitude regarding their options to become part of the work force, gain an education, and have equal rights in marriage (Surgis).

Read More

The Women's Suffragist Movement

934 Words | 4 Pages

In fact, gender affect women’s opportunities in retrospect mainly because of the male dominate patriarchy. These social changes illustrate the suffragist movement as an immense battle for women who were against the male dominate patriarchy. Thus, women attempting for many years during this movement to have their voices heard; on the upside they were relentless until they achieve their ultimate goal, which was to have the right to vote. In essence, one should never underestimate how social change affects one’s society mainly because it is a chain reaction towards one’s way of living life. The women’s struggles in order to have equality through the suffrage movement in the years 1848-1920 was an ongoing vicious battle.

Read More

Analysis Of Mary Wollstonecraft's A Vindication Of The Rights Of Women

750 Words | 3 Pages

Mary Wollstonecraft’s A vindication of the rights of women written in 1792 can be considered one of the first feminist documents, although the term appeared much later in history. In this essay, Wollstonecraft debates the role of women and their education. Having read different thinkers of the Enlightenment, as Milton, Lord Bacon, Rousseau, John Gregory and others, she finds their points of view interesting and at the same time contrary to values of the Enlightenment when they deal with women’s place. Mary Wollstonecraft uses the ideas of the Enlightenment to demand equal education for men and women. I will mention how ideals of the Enlightenment are used in favor of men but not of women and explain how Wollstonecraft support her “vindication” of the rights of women using those contradictions.

Read More

Analysis Of Mary Wollstonecraft's Essay 'Vindication Of Women'

760 Words | 4 Pages

Mary Wollstonecraft an early feminist philosopher, writes about the ideals of equality and freedom both in her political rebuttal essay “Rights of Men” and her follow-up essay “Vindication of Women” in response to philosopher Jean-Jacques Rousseau. Writing the “Vindication of the Rights of Men”, has led her to explore and express her opinions about the inequality of women during the Romantic period. As the opposition to post-revolutionary sentiment, extending rights as a just act to include the upper middle class of men, over maintaining the traditional rights given to men of nobility. Wollstonecraft interjects that women are also a vital importance to society and also deserve allowances of rights.

Read More

Essay On Women's Rights In The 20th Century

934 Words | 4 Pages

Their role in society was believed to be that of wife and mother but our mind was changing. Women started to fight for some rights such as the access to the labour force during World War I, the improvement in education allowing women to attend university, and the equality within the marriage, in order to avoid subordination of women. Probably their greatest achievement was the access to the electoral process in the United States of America. Earning the right to vote meant a recognition of women power and intelligence, as well as their ability to participate in politics. This essay will analyze how women fought for their right through some feminist movements.

Read More

More about Comparison Of Mill And Mona Caird's The Subjection Of Women

Related Topics

Open Document