ipl-logo

Confucius Vs Socrates Research Paper

648 Words3 Pages

Two of the greatest philosophers, Confucius and Socrates, were placed in a hypothetical situation. Socrates was put on trial for corrupting the youth of Athens. His defense was discussed in the Apology, written by one of his disciples Plato. A jury of 501 Athenians were asked to listen to his speech and decide his fate. Another philosopher, Confucius, was from a different time and place but for the purposes of the paper he was a part of the jury. The two philosophers had a common goal for society, but ultimately I believe Confucius would have found Socrates guilty from their conflicting views on a virtuous life and his lack of obedience to superiors. As for the philosopher’s standings on ethics, I would say they both have a common goal. Each …show more content…

He split society into five relationships and said social harmony could be attained by social hierarchy. “He who exercises government by means of his virtue may be compared to the north polar star, which keeps its place and all the stars turn towards it,” (The Analects 2). Confucius believed everyone should follow orders, rules, and will. I think he would have had difficulties with Socrates’ conception of virtue because it lacked the obedience to social superiors. Socrates stated, “God only is wise; the wisdom of men is little or nothing...And so I go my way, obedient to the god, and make inquisition into the wisdom of anyone,” (Apology 203). He would have defined the virtuous life as the right to question authority in search for the truth. Throughout Apology, Socrates protests against his fellow Athenians. He even went as far to say, “Men of Athens, I honor and love you; but I shall obey God rather than you… I reproach him with undervaluing the greater, and overvaluing the less…” (Apology 203). Socrates has a lack of admiration and obedience to his superiors. His statement expresses the direct opposite of Confucius’ beliefs in the order of relationship. Their views on virtue differ, which was the key conflict that would have influenced Confucius to vote Socrates guilty. Confucius once said, “If the will be set on virtue, there will be no practice of wickedness,” (The Analects 4). I think those would be the same

Show More
Related

How Did Socrates Attempt To Appease The Apology

630 Words | 3 Pages

In this paper I will examine why Socrates did not attempt to appease the jury in his Apology. Socrates is put on trial for corrupting the youth and believing in gods other than the gods of the city. I believe he chose not to appease the jury for three reasons: he is a man of pride, he does not fear death and additionally finds it shameful to fear death. Socrates is a man of pride.

Read More

Comparing Socrates In The Apology, Crito, And The Republic

802 Words | 4 Pages

Comparing Socrates words in the Republic for the philosopher to rule to the words of the Apology where philosophy is viewed as something that is punishable by death, this is where the defense or importance of philosophy is realized. For if the philosophers were the ones to rule, nobody would question whether or not what they were doing was right or wrong because the philosopher-kings make the rules through wisdom and knowledge. Plato wants to paint a portrait of the philosopher as not only something the city should want to have, but also as someone who would be fit to rule above all others. This contrasts, again, to the points made by the jurors to Socrates in the Apology for they saw Socrates as someone who brings the city

Read More

Comparing Plato's Apology And The Crito

1739 Words | 7 Pages

Crito is shocked and confused when Socrates turns down his escape plan, because of the fight that he had put up in court to prove his innocence. Crito asks Socrates why he is not making an effort to escape jail and Socrates states that he is just an old man and is no longer a benefit to society. In this paper, I argue that there is indeed a tension between Socrates view on the charges that he was accused of in the Apology versus his views of the charges in the Crito. There are many occasions throughout these stories that support Socrates change in perspective on his charges that will further be discussed in this paper. Socrates is indeed fighting to prove his innocence in the Apology, but in the Crito, he has a dramatic attitude change to the point where he feels that he needs to sit in prison and face the consequences that he has acquired for the crimes that he knows that he did

Read More

Why Was Socrates Guilty

1641 Words | 7 Pages

Since the day of the judgment between Athens and Socrates in 399 year B.C. many historians, philosophers, and students wonder to know whether Socrates was Guilty. Philosopher was accused in corrupting the youth, not believing in the recognized gods and introducing new divinities and in the rejection of civic life in democratic society. It is very difficult to answer on this question, may be even impossible. In my opinion, there are three types of people: 1.

Read More

From Socrates 'Morality Of Athenians' Consent According To Socrates

565 Words | 3 Pages

As Socrates address the central issue of escaping without the Athenians’ consent, he emphasizes his stance as a non-consequentialist, a person who determines rightness using reason, obligation, duty, or virtue. He does his best to avoid the consequentialist stance, which focuses on the outcomes or consequences that are used to determine the rightness or wrongness of an action. Standing firm as a non-consequentialist, Socrates made the right decision of not escaping with the reasoning of his first argument: a person must never cause harm. Socrates is contradicting himself with one of his major points that a person must never commit wrongdoings. It is difficult to find any opposition against Socrates’ first argument, especially in the moral perspective.

Read More

Private Life In Socrates's Apology

1021 Words | 5 Pages

In Apology, Socrates faces possible execution as he stands trial in front of his fellow Athenian men. This jury of men must decide whether Socrates has acted impiously against the gods and if he has corrupted the youth of Athens. Socrates claims in his defense that he wants to live a private life, away from public affairs and teachings in Athens. He instead wants to focus on self-examination and learning truths from those in Athens through inquiry. Socrates argues that "a [man] who really fights for justice must lead a private, not a public, life if [he] is to survive for even a short time" (32a).

Read More

A Rhetorical Analysis Of Socrates 'Apology'

1314 Words | 6 Pages

Socrates was a greek philosopher who found himself in trouble with his fellow citizens and court for standing his grounds on his new found beliefs from his studies about philosophical virtue, justice, and truth. In “Apology” written by Plato, Socrates defended himself in trial, not with the goal of escaping the death sentence, but with the goal of doing the right thing and standing for his beliefs. With this mindset, Socrates had no intention of kissing up to the Athenians to save his life. Many will argue that Socrates’ speech was not very effective because he did not fight for his life, he just accepted the death sentence that he was punished with. In his speech he said, “But now it’s time to leave, time for me to die and for you to live.”

Read More

Viety And Corruption In Plato's Apology Of Socrates

736 Words | 3 Pages

Charges of impiety and corruption of the youth were brought against Socrates and he had to desperately defend himself to try and prove his innocence. Although, with a deeper look into his arguments in Plato’s Apology of Socrates a different conclusion for the purpose of his speech arises. Certainly, Socrates is a passionate philosopher and master at ethics; however, he admits he is not afraid to continue to philosophize or even die for his cause. Socrates even proposes that his punishment be only a small fee when the jury convicted him as guilty. Thus, with further analysis of the speech; it can be concluded that Socrates planned his own death.

Read More

Socrates: Plato's Decision To Accepting The Death Penalty

1434 Words | 6 Pages

In this essay, I will present an argument that shows that Plato will convince Socrates to reconsider his decision to receive the death sentence. Plato would show Socrates that his three reasons for staying to receive his sentence is unjust because his action is fuelled by injustice. I will also show that Socrates will agree with Plato about the unjust consequences that his actions may bring after Plato reasons why Socrates is doing an injustice. Finally, Plato would then proceed to show Socrates that his decision to stay cannot result in happiness and justice which in turn will cause Socrates to re-evaluate accepting his death sentence according to his own ideals of a happy and just life.

Read More

The Corruption Of Socrates In Plato's Apology

560 Words | 3 Pages

Socrates claims that he did not consciously corrupt the youth of Athens, and he gives many reasons why he is not at fault for these actions. In his defense to the jury, he tells them that by looking at the facts, they will see Meletus is accusing him of something that is not true. The way Socrates defends himself is well-thought out and logical. He ask Meletus a serious of questions and Meletus answers, Socrates then moves on to the next question to support his claim.

Read More

Socrates And Crito Argumentative Analysis

1382 Words | 6 Pages

Socrates bases this view of justice on the worth of living a good life. “And is life worth living for us with that part of us corrupted by unjust actions” (47e) If we corrupt our soul with injustice, our life would not be worth living, therefore one must never commit an injustice. “When one has come to an agreement that is just with someone, one should fulfill it.”(49e) It is this agreement with the Laws that Socrates would be violating, if he were to

Read More

Plato Apology: The Trial Of Socrates

606 Words | 3 Pages

“Plato Apology” relates the trial of Socrates (469-399) B.C.E known as the father of Western Philosophy. Socrates, a son of sculpture and the midwife had a queer with most Athenians due to his point of view on values and beliefs. Charged with impiety and corrupting the Youth, Socrates’ defends himself by persuading the jury of his innocence with tangible reasons which made his arguments effective.

Read More

Apology Socrates Apology Analysis

1012 Words | 5 Pages

Socrates believed that you must never disobey the state so he stood by his commitment to morality even though it cost him his

Read More

The Role Of Politics In Euthyphro, By Socrates

666 Words | 3 Pages

In his defense, Socrates recalls a time when he denied an order from the Thirty to arrest Leon of Salamis stating that his only concern was “to commit no unjust or impious deed” (Plato 85) “never [conceding] to anyone contrary to the just”, government officials included. Socrates’ own moral examination and individual judgment helped decipher whether or not to engage in political activity. After being convicted by the jury, Socrates states that “the unexamined life is not worth living” (Plato 92), suggesting that the individual that fails to analyze their own practices and morality forfeits their right to truth and is incapable of living a life worthwhile. After being sentenced to death Socrates foretells of the rise of philosophers, affirming that the best way to avoid reproach is “to equip oneself to be the best possible” (Plato 94) implying that philosophy will live on and the best way to cope is through self-reflective

Read More

Three Acts Of The Mind: Understanding, Judgement, And Reason

969 Words | 4 Pages

Philosophical thinking uses three acts of the mind: understanding, judgement, and reason. In order to have a sound argument all of the concepts must be applied. Socrates didn’t want to please the people by saying or doing what they wanted him to say or do. Socrates thought it was not important to seek wealth or fame; he was concerned with truth and virtue. He wanted to create an impact on humanity by relying on the truth and shining a light in people’s lives, even if they put him on trial.

Read More

More about Confucius Vs Socrates Research Paper

Related Topics

Open Document