ipl-logo

Contradictory Feminism In Herland By Charlotte Perkins Gilman

731 Words3 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Charlotte perkins gilman ( 1860- 35) essay

Contradictory Feminism in Herland
Herland by Charlotte Perkins Gilman is widely celebrated as a feminist utopia. In the novel, three men, Terry, Jeff, and Van, venture to a fabled country that is theorized to contain only women. They arrive to find a society that is extremely “happy” and “civilized” despite the fact that there are no men, which was a striking picture for 1915. Furthermore, this female-only society proves to be superior to the men’s home country of America in many ways, especially the quality of life the citizens have. The women prove that they can build a society more successful than one with men. While Perkins Gilman succeeds in critiquing the patriarchy with Herland, her female-only utopia still perpetuates many flawed ideologies …show more content…

When describing the women the male narrator, Van, explains, “They had the evenest tempers, the most perfect patience and good nature–one of the things most impressive about them all was the absence of irritability” (Perkins Gilman 46). The general message this sends is that, to be successful the women have to dull themselves down, which is a common narrative in society. This feeds into the stereotype of the agreeable, docile woman that is very appealing to men. Van also states, “With these women the most salient quality in all their institutions was reasonableness” (Perkins Gilman 76). This kind of rhetoric gives the impression that the society the women have created is only successful because the women are so intelligent and reasonable and lack raw emotions such as anger and sadness. It conveys the message that, although the women in the novel are considered valuable, it is only because they are a specific kind of curated women that do not exist outside of Herland. This message is proved further with the themes of eugenics and breeding better people (Perkins Gilman 59). By dulling down the women’s emotions to happy, intelligent, and fair-minded, Perkins Gilman feeds into another stereotype– that women are only valid if they are passive and

Show More
Related
1183 Words | 5 Pages

This show of misogynistic ideas and practices is in correlation with Pride and Prejudice by Jane Austen. Elizabeth bennet’s her sisters are undervalued and ticketed of as victims of misogyny and male dominance. The novel was published in 1850 around the same time of the suffrage movement. The first wave of feminism took place in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, emerging out of an environment of urban industrialism and liberal, socialist politics.

Read More
79 Words | 1 Pages

The late 19th century was period of repressive Victorian era societal and gender roles that plagued and deprived women of their agency and rights. This was period of patriarchal hegemony that impacted women in both the private and public sphere of society. By, attempting to navigate through this malaise of despondency and loneliness, Moreover, Gilman not only faces an existential crisis, but the narrator had to confront her depression as well as evaluate the conflicting relationship with her

Read More
431 Words | 2 Pages

Although this book was intended to portray a feminist lens, there is still a lot of patriacary shown throughout the story. In the novel men have emotional control over the women, leaving them in a submissive trance towards men. Feminism is defined as ¨the advocacy of womenś rights on the basis of the equality of the sexes.¨ This novel does not provide much equality between the sexes.

Read More
982 Words | 4 Pages

The work is not yet complete, and is evident by looking at the domination of women throughout the centuries, specifically the 19th and 20th century, which was the height of the women’s rights movement. By analyzing two literary works from two different eras, “The Yellow Wallpaper” written by Charlotte Perkins Gilman in the late 19th century and “Aunt Jennifer’s Tigers” written by Adrienne Rich in the mid-20th century, one can conclude that while there have been improvements to women’s rights, there is still discrimination prevalent. Although set in two different time periods, the main

Read More
1611 Words | 7 Pages

There is no question that women have struggled over many years to be seen as equals by their male counterparts. Years of struggle and oppression continued throughout time, but the oppression took different forms over the course of history. Susan Glaspell wrote, “Trifles” which explores a woman’s status in society during the 1920s and the political leanings that perverted society at the time. The play demonstrates how women were subjected to mental abuse and viewed as intellectually inferior as dictated by American society and politics. “Trifles” exposes how political leanings in the government favored and enabled a patriarchal society as well as displaying how the Women’s Rights movement was beginning to combat these prejudices.

Read More
1075 Words | 5 Pages

It may skew her thinking and at times be subjective. The intended audience is someone who is studying literature and interested in how women are portrayed in novels in the 19th century. The organization of the article allows anyone to be capable of reading it.

Read More
3628 Words | 15 Pages

In February of 1963, Friedan, a feminist author, published The Feminine Mystique, a novel that challenged traditional gender norms and inspired women to fight for the eradication of these stereotypical positions (Miller 279). Friedan’s novel became instrumental in the feminist movement. Her novel “helped shape feminism in the 1960s through its discussion of how the domestic sphere of motherhood, for educated women like herself, was akin to a ‘cultural concentration camp’” (Schneider). After the incredible success of her novel in creating conversation about women’s rights, in 1964, Friedan helped form NOW, a group that focused on resolving equity issues such as equal pay and equal work opportunities in male-dominated fields like medicine, higher education, and law (Schneider).

Read More
893 Words | 4 Pages

If a reader looks at a novel through the feminist lens, they will, just like the real world, a world mostly ruled and defined by men. When reading “Their Eyes Were Watching God” by Zora Neale Hurston, the reader finds themselves witnessing a time where women couldn’t express themselves and are only seen as an object. However, the main character, Janie, has made it her goal to defy that as seen through her actions throughout the novel. Because of this choice, she is judged by the town and shamed by the people around her for they cannot reach their potential or personal goals themselves from their little determination. Body Paragraphs: In chapter 10 of the novel, while the town is off enjoying the ball game, Janie is running the store.

Read More
958 Words | 4 Pages

Gender Equality Throughout America’s history, women have struggled to obtain basic human rights, gender equality, and general respect from men. These issues continue on into our current day-to-day life and will seem to continue for many years to come. In American literature, there are two women, Elizabeth Cady Stanton, and Sojourner Truth, amongst many, who voiced their struggles as women in America. Stanton’s piece, “Declaration of Sentiments”, is a revised version of the “Declaration of Independence”, and it outlines the many rights women have been withheld from.

Read More
544 Words | 3 Pages

Many women were in fact belittled by the ideal of true womanhood and exhibited characteristics such as submissiveness or piety. Gilman also employs somber diction throughout the story, such as “crawl”(55) and “creep”(58) to suggest that covert agency is the only way for women to improve their situations at

Read More
626 Words | 3 Pages

She is told that her female nervousness was probably caused by her writing and can only be cured with rest. I feel like that is how Gillman saw the world. Sure women had ‘equal rights’ but many women still found themselves obeying a husband or working for a male superior. Women are free to do as the men suggest them to do. Ultimately the woman’s oppression brings her to

Read More
1141 Words | 5 Pages

Furthermore, the author displays a dystopian society completely dominated by a totalitarian and theocratic state. The main subject of this novel is the role assigned to women, mainly represented by the handmaids. In Gilead, the made-up country where the novel takes place, women are completely subjected by the government, and especially by men, who clearly have a higher status than women. Moreover, women’s freedom is entirely restricted, as they cannot leave their house at their will, they are forbidden to hold properties or jobs, they cannot read or write, and they are treated as sexual slaves whose only purpose in life is to bear children for elite spouses. The other option is a miserable, short life at the Colonies (a type of concentration camp), and death.

Read More
1344 Words | 6 Pages

Ambition is the desire to achieve a goal through determination and hard work. Undoubtedly, the secret of America’s idea of success corresponds with ambition and the lack thereof when measuring reward. Although every man may not have the same definition of success, throughout the continuing lifespan of America, success has revolved around accomplishing one 's goals. Historically, America has become one of the most successful nations in the world, and throughout history. While its ambitions prod it toward achievement, this also condemns it to failure.

Read More
1091 Words | 5 Pages

Gender Inequality: A Woman’s Struggle in “The Yellow Wallpaper” In “The Yellow Wallpaper”, Charlotte Perkins Gilman captures the lives of women in a society based on societal expectations during the late nineteenth century. She focuses on the issue of gender inequality where women were often discriminated against and expected to fulfill the role of a perfect wife and mother. The narrator is based on on Gilman’s personal experience of suffering from her treatment for postpartum depression due to the social restrictions on women which represents a reflection on women's social status in society. The narrator, who remains anonymous, is depicted as a depressed and isolated prisoner who is oppressed under her husband’s control and struggles to break free.

Read More
918 Words | 4 Pages

Cloning to Save a Species For centuries, there has always been a strong fascination with science and the countless things it can offer. One of the most popular topics is cloning, animal and human. However, many proponents of cloning do not take the consequences or risks of cloning into consideration. Some people do think about the possible outcomes of cloning but they are not realistic.

Read More

More about Contradictory Feminism In Herland By Charlotte Perkins Gilman

Related Topics

Open Document