ipl-logo

Controversial Teaching In Dead Poet's Society

1199 Words5 Pages

Controversial Teaching In the movie Dead Poets Society Mr. Keating is a new teacher to his alma mater, a strict all boys school. Along with being the youngest teacher, Keating’s beliefs as of how to teach are quit different then what the academy is use to. Although his colleagues frown upon it, Mr. Keating continues to teach his students to think for themselves and not feel the need to follow conformity. Mr. Keating’s message has a tremendous effect on Neil Perry, Knox Overstreet, and Charlie Dalton; as a result their lives have changed and will never be the same. Mr. Keating not only taught his students the English curriculum he also taught his students how to think for themselves. For his first lesson he had the students rip out pages from the textbook, these pages consisted of instructions for the “right” way to evaluate a poem. Ripping out these pages demonstrated that …show more content…

Keating’s lessons have taught his students that their opinions do matter and they ultimately learned that they should have confidence in themselves. With this in mind Knox Overstreet, one of Keating’s students, was able to find enough confidence to win over a girl that he previously was too afraid to talk to. Without the help of Mr. Keating, Knox would never have even been able to call the girl, let alone skip class and sneak away to go see her. Now Knox is dating the girl of his dreams and has the confidence needed to fight for other things he desires, such as future job opportunities. Along with Mr. Keating providing Knox with confidence Neil Perry also gained enough confidence to follow his lifetime dream of becoming an actor. Although he was afraid to audition, because his dad did not approve, he received the leading role in the play. While practicing for the play and learning how to act was fun, he was clearly having the time of his life during the performance. Mr. Keating’s lessons brought such joy to those two boys and many other students that it appeared his message was a great

Show More
Related
803 Words | 4 Pages

Early in the movie you meet one of the boys teachers Mr. Keating. Mr. Keating is very different compared to the other teachers. He isn't strict and lets the kids minds roam freely . As the movie progress each character takes on their own development and grows as a person. At the end of the movie Neil Perry kills himself after doing a play and his father disapproving.

Read More
1150 Words | 5 Pages

All his life Neil had been obedient to his father, until English teacher John Keating instilled some spirit in him and helped Neil pursue acting, an art Neil has always admired. After auditioning, he received the lead role in the play and processed to forge a permission slip to give to the headmaster so he could attend rehearsal; this is the first time Neil has done anything against his father’s wishes. Eventually, Mr. Perry hears about his son’s doing and goes to the school demanding him to quit the play, command Neil only pretends to obey. On opening night, Mr. Perry shows up and stays to watch the show, although he is not

Read More
770 Words | 4 Pages

Neil is similar in the way of lying in which even after confronting Mr. Keating about his dreams of being an actor and how he has kept his role in a play from his father, he continues to lie about quitting the play to his father as well as telling Mr. Keating that he had confronted his father. Neil did this solely to keep his father pleased and to make Mr. Keating proud of

Read More
1080 Words | 5 Pages

In Dead Poets’ Society there is a group of young men in Mr. Keating’s class who show the traits of transcendentalism under the guide of Mr. Keating. Throughout the movie the boys and Mr. Keating grow closer, and he starts to guid and show the kids how they can live their lives and to follow what their heart desires. Later in the story Neil Perry is the lead for a play even though his father specifically told him not to do it, but Neil listened to Mr. Keating and did the play. When Neil 's father saw him in the play he told him that he was gonna send Neil to military school and take him out of Welton Academy, later that night Neil took his father 's gun and shot himself. The school did a investigation on the death and in the end they said it was Mr. Keatings fault that it happened and

Read More
554 Words | 3 Pages

The students in this case have chosen a class that has taught them how to bring meaning to the works given to them. These students, for a number of weeks had been continuing to do the same things with other assignments, making it a reasonable argument that these students had become accustomed to performing in this manner and interpreted this assignment in this way because they trained themselves to do so. “Even so, one might reply, all you’ve done is demonstrate how an interpretation, if it is prosecuted with sufficient vigor, can impose itself on material which has its own proper shape… it is only a trick that allows you to transform it into a poem, and when the effects of the trick have worn off, it will return to its natural form and be seen as an assignment once again” (Fish 328-329). People argue with Fish, saying that the class only saw the text as a poem because Fish misled them, leading them believe what Fish had told them about the assignment. The students had no reason not to believe their professor so they believe and do as he says, making something out of

Read More
756 Words | 4 Pages

"Introduction to Poetry" by Billy Collins and "How to Read Poetry" by Gail Hemmeter both convey their viewpoint of understanding poetry. However, Gail Hemmeter's "How to Read Poetry" is more effective at conveying his viewpoint of understanding poetry. This is because he give a list of things to do in order to help understand poetry and he explains the different aspects of poetry and what they mean. In this essay I will be arguing why Gail Hemmeter's "How to Read Poetry" better conveys his viewpoint of understanding poetry.

Read More
1467 Words | 6 Pages

He understood that his father would disagree with this decision, but he wanted to follow his dreams of acting. Without the influence of Mr. Keating, Neil might have never been influenced in the way he did. A more strict teacher, like the rest of the teachers at Welton, might have only threatened him to focus on his studies, much like Neil’s father might have

Read More
652 Words | 3 Pages

He was not, for what he taught his students was to pursue their dreams, and break free from the chains of society, furthermore to be their true selves. Mr Keating tells the boys in this scene “Boys you must strive to find your own voice because the longer you wait to begin, the less likely you are going to find it at all. ”(DPS) This quote is only a positive piece of advice for the boy,and many of them such as Todd, Knox and Perry followed it, and pursued their wishes, however the Principal Mr Nolen did not like this way of teaching. Mr Nolen is an anti-transcendentalist, and that is someone who focuses on the limitations and destructiveness of the human

Read More
465 Words | 2 Pages

He was not an ordinary teacher, he taught differently from the other teacher in this school. One day during their lesson, Mr. Keating, was telling them about “The Dead Poet Society” and how he was an active member in the club. At the end of the movie, Neil finishes the play and his angry and anxious father drove him all the way home. When he gets home, his mother is sitting in her chair while his father tells him why and what he is doing wrong with his life and that he will be attending military school behalf on his behavior.

Read More
581 Words | 3 Pages

The Ability to Persevere     The boys in the Boat by Daniel James Brown, takes the reader through the life of one of the main characters named Joe Rantz. The reader follows Joe through his highs and lows he endures throughout the story. Joe is a very determined, strong, and eager young man. He is six feet and two inches, a freshman, strongly built, blonde, with gray-blue eyes (Brown, 12).

Read More
705 Words | 3 Pages

In the world, society has set standards most people follow. They must dress, act, and look a certain way for them to be accepted by others. Several do not understand that they are being conformed to be someone who they are not. Some movies challenge others to look beyond the standards of society. For example, in movie “Dead Poets Society”, Mr. Keating 's teaches his students to form their own ideas and opinions.

Read More
934 Words | 4 Pages

He realizes that he would rather be an actor than a doctor, and he forges his dad’s signature on the permission slip for the play because he thinks his father won’t find out. He goes on with the play, which is Shakespeare’s “A Midsummer Night’s Dream,” and his dad catches him. This makes is father so angry that he takes Neil out of the private school and threatens to put him in military school. Neil can’t handle the pressure his dad and future put on him, so he kills himself. Because Mr. Keating taught these boys to think for themselves, the school blames him for Neil’s death and fires him.

Read More
1371 Words | 6 Pages

Keating's fault for his unorthodox method of teaching, and encouraging Neil to go against his father wishes. Others may argue it was the fault of Mr. Perry for controlling Neil, and directing him down a path that seemed to be influenced by Mr. Perry’s own failure to accomplish his plan of becoming a doctor. Regardless of the influence Mr. Keating had on Neil, it is my strong belief that Mr. Perry’s controlling, selfish, and intimidating ways trumped any of Mr. Keating's contribution to Neil’s discovery of his inner creativity and expression.of interests. Mr. Keating helped open Neil’s eyes to a whole different side of things which his father prevented him from seeing for his entire life. Why should Mr. Keating be at fault when he tried his very best in providing an educational experience that brought him success when he was in Neil’s age?

Read More
1000 Words | 4 Pages

In the movie Mr. Keating made many students become more independent in their decisions they make. In the movie he made Neil one of the main character more independent, Neil’s dad, Mr. Perry seems like he was controlling Neil. By telling him what he should and should not do. He became

Read More
718 Words | 3 Pages

1. How are students portrayed throughout the movie? At the beginning of the movie the students are viewed a responsible, and conservative students. One of the students in the movie is Neil Perry; he is portrayed as a student who wants to please his parents.

Read More

More about Controversial Teaching In Dead Poet's Society

Related Topics

Open Document