ipl-logo

Controversial Women In The Life You Save May Be Your Own, By Alice Walker

1077 Words5 Pages

Short stories are a delicacy in literature. Some short stories have comparable plots, themes, or even characters. Lucynell Crater from “The Life You Save May Be Your Own” by Flannery O’Connor and Maggie Johnson from “Everyday Use” by Alice Walker are two controversial women created in the American Literature movement. Lucynell and Maggie are both vulnerable characters that depend on others for survival in life through different experiences of innocence, race, and class in the American South. While Lucynell and Maggie both represent innocence and goodness in their stories, they both face physical challenges in their everyday lives. Lucynell “…who is completely deaf and has never said a word in her life …” (p 430) lived a simple life with her …show more content…

Lucynell is raised only by her mother on a small family farm that needs extensive maintenance for holes in the front and back steps, the need for a new hog pen, and a fence that needs restoring (430). The need for a man or someone to provide for her is why Lucynell’s mother married her to the first guy available. As stated earlier, it did not work out for Lucynell when she was abandoned by her newlywed. Likewise, Maggie did not live the luxury life either. She was arranged to get married as well to a mossy toothed man named John Thomas (914). Although her independence throughout the story outshines the thought of her getting married. The difference with Maggie is that she is in tune with her family and traditions despite her poverty. She embodies the values of her hereditary past like when Dee asked about the dasher, she knew that Aunt Dee’s first husband whittled it (917). Little details add up and prove how much Maggie values and appreciates her family legacy. Both women were classified as rural poor people. (392). President Harrison A. Williams Jr. wanted to help people like them and read a speech about the need for rural social welfare reforms. Also, President Lyndon B. Johnson’s antipoverty task force and civil right activists exposed the reality of poverty to show the nation leading to action. There was a massive problem with poverty in the rural south and Lucynell and Maggie were just a couple examples of

Show More
Related
386 Words | 2 Pages

Reading this story, from Mama’s point of view, limits our ability to understand the viewpoints of the other characters involved. Mama describes Maggie as being “simple and not very bright”, but she may just be very introverted and if you heard this story from Maggie’s vantage point, she may come across as very caring and wise beyond her years due to the tragedies she experienced in losing her home to fire and in being burned. Also, in Dee’s defense she has the right to feel proud in regards to her education and “making it” in the outside world. Her personality is flamboyant and she is portrayed as being highly motivated which contrasts sharply with Mama and Maggie’s personalities. Mama may be misunderstanding her actions due to their very

Read More
1052 Words | 5 Pages

Maggie is also oppressed by society and Dee, and, though to a further degree than her mother, her view of herself attacks her equality compared to the rest of the world. The subject is immediately introduced. The story begins with Maggie and her mother waiting for Dee. They waste their time in order to be available to Dee as soon as Dee

Read More
336 Words | 2 Pages

Once the “War on Poverty” was launched, society started to break into havoc because of the sudden interest towards the impoverished. However the impoverished began to protest. The Poor People's Campaign (PPC) was created on December 4, 1967, by the Southern Christian Leadership Conference (SCLC), addressing the issues of unemployment, housing shortages for the poor, and the impact of poverty on the lives of millions of Americans (“Poor People’s Campaign”). President Johnson finally heard their concerns and created more legislations that would benefit everyone. Although most of the Americans who were apart of the higher class still envisioned the impoverished as invisible, some of the them (mainly women) had their perspective changed (Harrington

Read More
182 Words | 1 Pages

Poverty can be fixed with the help of everyone, but why should the rest of the population be forced to help the poor. President Johnson wants America to fight the war on poverty. With one of every fifth person in America in poverty real change needed to take place. There needed to be

Read More
1792 Words | 8 Pages

This story is about two different views on heritage and differing perceptions through inherited objects. Maggie is the first sister we see in this story, and as we read on we realize that she is the opposite of what her sister Dee is; she is shy, has low confidence,

Read More
512 Words | 3 Pages

Lyndon B. Johnson declared the war on poverty during a Union address in January 8th, 1964. This was in response to national poverty rates being around 19 percent at the time of his speech. Lyndon B. Johnson’s success in lowering poverty rates during the “war on poverty,” was due to legislations such as VISTA, Job Corps, Head Start, Medicaid, Medicare, and HUD. One major Legislation is VISTA.

Read More
343 Words | 2 Pages

Poverty has become a big societal problem that it has become a major topic in political debates. Politicians have been debating on the best course of action to solving the poverty problem. Former President Lyndon B Johnson understood that poverty was a problem and it needed to be addressed. The Former President Lyndon B. Johnson believed that society has a responsibility for its citizens. He declared War on Poverty in 1964.

Read More
342 Words | 2 Pages

In Phyllis Schlafly's The Power of the Positive Woman, he mentions where women seem to stand in society, adding on a comparison between men and female. In a male dominated society, women are constantly trying to prove themselves. One of the biggest differences Schlafly points out is the fact that women can have babies whereas men cannot. However when it comes to physical differences there are many including, men having more water in their body, and less fatty tissue. “Falwell”, in Major Problems depicts the image of the American family and how it is a fundamental block of our society.

Read More
221 Words | 1 Pages

Lyndon B. Johnson saw a need for public assistance and he made an attempt at correcting the problem, however, correcting the problem was not his original goal. During his speech he declared that he wanted to address “...the causes, not just the consequences of poverty.” The programs he put in place had an impact on the needy, however, it was not successful in actually addressing the cause of the problem and putting a resolution in place. The war on poverty is a never ending battle.

Read More
1032 Words | 5 Pages

Sarnowski describes Maggie by stating, “She ekes out an existence on the family farm and has neither the intelligence nor the physical attributes of Dee/Wangero” (Sarnowski 278). This statement shows that Maggie lives a conservative type of farm life, and due to this lifestyle, she is less intelligent than her sister. This statement also shows how the character Maggie is described in a sense as inferior to Dee because of her lack of education and physical attributes. Maggie’s traditionalist ways show, however, when she tells her mother, “"She can have them, Mama,” … "I can 'member Grandma Dee without the quilts"” (Walker 6).

Read More
716 Words | 3 Pages

So, even though her isolation protects her, she is still a victim of this type of isolation. She suffers from shyness and lack of education. Maggie’s relationship with Dee is filled with jealousy and admiration. Mama mentions how Maggie always thought Dee had been gifted with an easy life.

Read More
610 Words | 3 Pages

The story goes beyond these traits to deal mainly with the way in which the two sisters value their heritage. Maggie knows nothing but her heritage, for she has never left home. On the other hand, Dee seems to have

Read More
240 Words | 1 Pages

War on Poverty was a war established by President Lyndon Johnson. There was many debates whether or not Johnson’s programs were worthy. Democrats were declaring income inequality the circumstance and the republicans believe the War was a failure. President Johnson wanted to take action towards the national poverty rate. “Conventional wisdom suggests that a rise in federal expenditures designed to help low income groups should produce some reduction in poverty and thus some reduction in measured income inequality.”

Read More
609 Words | 3 Pages

In conclusion,Alice Walker used two characters to carry out a deeper meaning of a short story. It showed similarities and differences to my family, and the family in “Everyday use”. Also it show how maggie and Dee are two very different characters. Maggie and Dee didn 't share a bond with each other throughout their,but I am glad my brothers and I

Read More
1026 Words | 5 Pages

Maggie did not go to school, does not dress in colorful attention-getting African garb, and does not have a fancy boyfriend, but she does slam a door which indicates her feelings about the quilts and butter churn her sister has come to claim out from under her feet. The temper has flared, and Maggie gets her quilts. In conclusion, the story seems to tell how different Maggie and Dee were from each other; with few comparisons between the two girls to suggest that they had anything in

Read More

More about Controversial Women In The Life You Save May Be Your Own, By Alice Walker

Related Topics

Open Document