ipl-logo

David Gale Vs Dead Man Walking

620 Words3 Pages

Katy Turl Professor Harden English Composition 1 15 March 2024 The Life of David Gale vs Dead Man Walking Essay “When you kill someone, you rob their family - not just of a loved one, but of their humanity. You harden their hearts with hate, you take away their capacity for civilized dispassion, you condemn them to bloodlust.” -Constance Harraway. Is the death penalty an acceptable law when it comes to executing people? Is redemption possible for those who have committed heinous crimes? The Life of David Gale and Dead Man Walking are both similar and different in numerous ways. David Gale, professor of philosophy, father, husband, and anti-death penalty activist, was falsely accused of rape by one of his former students, Berlin. He loses everything, …show more content…

David Gale was executed on the ground. After the execution, Bitsy gets a tape that reveals what happened. Sister Helen Prejean, a nun who works with children and the poor in New Orleans, Louisiana. She answers a letter from a death row inmate, Matthew Poncelet. Later, she visits Matthew on death row. Matthew is on death row for the rape and murder of the teenage couple, Hope Percy and Walter Delacroix. Sister Helen then becomes Matthew’s spiritual advisor, which deeply hurts and angers the victims’ families. Towards the end, Matthew confesses his guilt. When he slowly walks to his execution with fear and guilt, he apologizes to Hope and Walter’s families, and then he is executed. Both the men in these two stories are criminals and they both were convicted of the same crimes. In the Life of David Gale, David was falsely accused of raping one of his former students, Berlin. He was also found guilty of rape and murder of his very own best friend, Constance Harraway. In Dead Man Walking, Matthew Poncelot also committed the same crime. He raped and killed the teenage couple, Hope Percy and Walter Delacroix. These crimes are massively important in the storyline, because that’s how they ended up on death

Show More
Related
1440 Words | 6 Pages

Opinions are great, they start conversations and or even solve problems but having an opinion in the justice system can be overwhelming when you are a nun. Dead Man Walking is a Novel written by sister Helen Prejean, she describes in depth about her experiences in being pen-pals with two death sentenced inmates in Louisiana’s State Penitentiary located in Angola. Going through spiritual transformations she decided she was against the death penalty, after exchanging several notes and letter with the first inmate she came in contact with. Elmo Patrick Sonnier, number 9528, was convicted of murdering a lovely couple after kidnapping both and rapping the female. This crime was taken place with the help of Sonnier’s brother, Eddie.

Read More
807 Words | 4 Pages

Two Sides of a Story: Death Penalty Debate Let us begin by looking at why the death penalty is morally wrong on many levels according to Stephen B. Bright, president of the Southern Center for Human Rights, and a teacher of criminal law. He wrote an essay on this debate called, “Why the United States Will Join the Rest of the World in Abandoning Capital Punishment.” We will also look at the other side of the debate (story), as to why the death penalty is morally legitimate in the views of Louis P. Pojman, whose essay is called, “ Why the Death Penalty is Morally Permissible,” which is just an excerpt from, Debating the Death Penalty: Should America Have Capital Punishment? First, there are innocent people being executed for crimes they didn’t commit. Whether it be from forced confessions, where people have been interrogated too long, yelled at, and threatened to the point of exhaustion, and because of this, they give a false confession.

Read More
1667 Words | 7 Pages

Ursula Turner Mrs. Baker English 4 21 November 2017 A Lethal Shot Too Far A shot ends a life. One single, lethal injection ends a convicted felon's life. The death penalty has been a punishment for serious crimes for as long as cultures have been around. “Since the earliest recorded execution in the United States in 1608, our country has put to death approximately 16,000 men and women” (Sarat).

Read More
334 Words | 2 Pages

What is an acceptable punishment for a murderer? In the U.S. murderers can undergo the consequences of their crime by life in prison or the death penalty. However, the death penalty is unconstitutional and has many defects. The physical effects of the electric chair, gas chamber, and lethal injection should be taken into consideration when determining the most humane method of execution.

Read More
783 Words | 4 Pages

Steve Harmon is one who had done this in order to get his life back. The book Monster by Walter Dean Meyers ends with this young man found not guilty; even though he had been involved in a theft that ended up becoming a murder. Though finding him not guilty was the wrong conclusion, and that is not what Steve Harmon should have received, there was too much of a reasonable doubt to find him guilty.

Read More
475 Words | 2 Pages

The thought of the death penalty is simple really, if the accused person is too dangerous to be around society without endangering those around them, then society has the right to eliminate them.

Read More
542 Words | 3 Pages

Although the majority of executions are a result of a murder conviction, there are other non-murder related crimes; including the rape of a child, treason, aggravated kidnapping, drug trafficking, and aircraft hijacking, that state statutes allow the punishment of the death penalty to be administered(Death Penalty Information Center, 2017a). The death penalty is a volatile ethical topic often dividing people into two different categories. Those who are in support of it often come from the viewpoint that the punishment should fit the crime, an eye for an eye mentality. While those whose viewpoint is in opposition of it often view the very act of punishment by death as synonymous with murder.

Read More
2434 Words | 10 Pages

The death penalty has sparked a national debate in the united states for a number of reasons. These reasons, include the responsibility of the government to protect the general public by removing dangerous criminals society while not violating the constitutional prohibition against cruel or unusual punishment. Another element of the debate on the legality of maintaining the death penalty include the cost of incarcerating criminals for life. Finally the moral element. Is it right for the state to kill it's own people.

Read More
1463 Words | 6 Pages

Death Penalty Is the death penalty acceptable in the United States? While many countries have outlawed it, some countries, like the United States, practice capital punishment at the state level. Each state has the right to decide whether to perform the death penalty or use life imprisonment. The death penalty is a highly controversial practice in today’s society. Throughout the history of the United States, there have been many different tactics for execution.

Read More
461 Words | 2 Pages

The death penalty in the United States has been a controversial issue for many years now. The question if the death penalty is an effective deterrent will never not be a societal problem. This has not only caused arguments between people who support and people who don’t support capital punishment, but also with the government, constitutional rights, economy and happiness of the citizens. One of the main concerns with allowing the death penalty was how to execute.

Read More
844 Words | 4 Pages

Killing the Death Penalty Is murder ever justified? In terms of safety, there are times when the well-being of one person is put on the line in order to save others. When we look at controversial issues such as the death penalty, we want to debate with one another stating our opinion on the matter.

Read More
830 Words | 4 Pages

Did you know that in 2014, 2,466 completely legal murders took place. Those murders are known as the “death penalty.” The death penalty should not be allowed anywhere in the world. The death penalty is a cruel, inhumane practice and has no place in the justice systems of the world. I will be convincing you that the death penalty is hypocritical.

Read More
484 Words | 2 Pages

In extremely heinous crimes, the death penalty is a possible form of punishment for the offenders. Although it may seem acceptable to kill a person for taking away another person’s life, that method is not always the most beneficial choice. Punishing murder with more murder is an extremely ineffective way of dealing with criminals. There are many reasons why the death penalty is an inconvenient and pointless procedure, including its costliness and permanence. Death is the most permanent and definite thing that exists in the world and it is not escapable, avoidable, or undoable.

Read More
911 Words | 4 Pages

Capital Punishment – A Potentially, but Unfortunately Optimal Choice The death penalty is an extremely controversial topic, strongly because of the morals oriented around our country’s roots. America had the impulsive motivation to free ourselves of oppression. Many of the “utopian” ideals involving freedom were exaggerated, leaving us with the American stereotype in which there was a “freedom-blanket” thrown over the entire country. This past still distorts our view of right and wrong to this day as we idolize a dream founded out of impulse purely due to patriotism. There are three logical ideologies behind the validity of capital punishment that bring clarity to morality.

Read More
588 Words | 3 Pages

Recently, though the death penalty has lost support, and gaining more opposition. “According to a Gallup poll released October 25. Gallup reported that 60% of respondents said they support capital punishment—off one percentage point from last year—while opposition remained at 37%, matching its highest level since the U.S. Supreme Court struck down the death penalty in 1972” (J. Jones). Due to the lack of support lately, many people are pondering whether the death penalty should be authorized. “50% of respondents believe the death penalty is applied fairly, the lowest level in the question's 17-year history, and 44% believe it is applied unfairly, the highest level in 17 years” (J. Jones).

Read More

More about David Gale Vs Dead Man Walking

Open Document