ipl-logo

Discretion In Policing Pros And Cons

896 Words4 Pages

Criminology 100: Introduction to Criminology Policing and Discretion
“In context to Negative aspects of discretion”
Uday Partap Singh Sidhu
802397 Columbia College
Date: March 22, 2017 Instructor: Josh Murphy Discretion means the freedom to take decision, freedom of judgement, in context to policing, Discretion is a major police power. Discretion here means ability to choose between multiple options, a police officer has a choice to take a decision. For instance; while encountering an overspending vehicle, a police officer has multiple options, either he can issue a speeding ticket on the spot, or else he could just warn the driver to take care next time, it totally depends on the officer, he may choose any option in regardless of his discretionary powers. Discretion has both pros and cons. While, Leniency, Informed decisions, Zero-tolerance, Arrests, Detention are some positive aspects of discretion in policing whereas partiality, discrimination based upon age and gender, racial profiling, wrongful arrests, harassments contribute to discretional abuse. However, discretional abuse in increasing rapidly, the public …show more content…

The police activities are no more secretive. The advancement of technology has changed it all. The mass media keeps on focusing upon increasing awareness about the civil rights, the ill-practices of police are always highlighted and dramatically presented by news-media making common people aware and scared. The surveilling trend on police is hiking, people are now always on their toes to record something suspicious about police related activities on their smart mobile phones. Though sometimes the sources such as videos are manipulated and posted on internet or displayed by new channels making things worse, but this is surely limiting some of misuse practices carried out by police. (Dr Murphy, McKenna. 2014). Discretionary abuse has been limited by media emphasis, public awareness, and advancement of

Show More
Related

Summary Of Cops See It Differently

1271 Words | 6 Pages

Ideally, the police are not corrupt and are fair, and if these qualities were more prevalent in police culture, then society would not have a mistrust. Discretion is a privilege that one earns through expression of the above listed

Read More

Police Brutality In Formation By Trayvon Martin

1880 Words | 8 Pages

“Frequent exposure to media reports of police abuse or corruption is a strong predictor of perceptions of misconduct and supports the belief that is common.” (France-Respers 1). But unfortunately, it also brings me disheartened feelings. Recently, I was on twitter and I stumbled across a video of a young white male who was roughly about twenty to twenty-five years of age who was being handled so aggressively by about six officers while he was NOT resisting.

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of Police Discretion

210 Words | 1 Pages

This creates a situation that allows police officers discretion in the way they think about what they see and how they handle those with whom they come in contact. There has been an effort by the research community to examine issues concerning how police act and respond in general and what police do specifically when they interact with citizens. A conspicuous void in the research effort has been the lack of attention paid to the process by which police officers form suspicion about a suspect whether or not a formal intervention such as a stop was made. Officers in Savannah, Georgia were observed and debriefed after they became suspicious about an individual or vehicle. Observers accompanied officers on 132, 8-hour shifts, during

Read More

Book Report On Cop In The Hood

1681 Words | 7 Pages

This gives each officer the ability to make their own choices based on the situation. I think that this is important, because it gives the officer more freedoms. There are certain situations that a person is “required” to act against the law. They have a reason why they went against the law, and if the officer finds the reason valid they might change the punishment, or just give the person a warning. Moskos in the book, Cop in the Hood, showed the important of discretion because it allowed him to make decisions based on the situation, instead of the requirements of his

Read More

Why Are Police Body Cameras Important

185 Words | 1 Pages

In the last 10 years, we saw many conflicts between police officers and citizens, which result into dead of innocent people and it was not a good image for police department. One of the issues is that the law enforcement gives the police

Read More

Stop Question And Frisk Case Study

1113 Words | 5 Pages

What is discretion? Discretion is the availability of a choice of options or actions one can take in a situation. Police officers have to make an instantaneous decision when they are in a situation. It all depends on the scenario for them to decide whether they want to use deadly force, stop and frisk or writing traffic summons etc. Stop question and frisk are the practiced by which a police officer initiates a stop of an individual on the street allegedly based on reasonable suspicion of criminal activity.

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of Policing Tactics

1212 Words | 5 Pages

Policing Tactics are Unjust In 2012, an African American was murdered every 28 hours by either police officers or persons of authority (Hudson). Of this amount, 43% of murders occurred as a result of racial profiling (Hudson). Police officers are tasked with the duty of protecting people across the nation; however, in a time of urgency, officers are instead harming the people. Although some believe police are behaving in a justified manner, the unnecessary brutality and racial profiling is caused by an inherent belief of white superiority and an internal fear of African Americans.

Read More

Pros And Cons Of Defunding The Police

1452 Words | 6 Pages

The authors noted that police decisions are often driven by political, economic, and social factors and that the

Read More

Haig's Opinions On The Generals Of World War I

1093 Words | 5 Pages

Many say that the generals of World War 1 were donkeys and the infantry were lions lead to their death by their generals. Although many historians have their own opinions on the generals of World War I, a lot of highly acclaimed historians believe that the infantry were courageous and brave soldiers who laid down their life for their country. They also believed that the generals were cowardly and sat 30 miles behind front lines and stayed in luxurious conditions compared to that of the infantry and never saw the action of the front lines. I for one agree with this.

Read More

Nsw Police Force Essay

1513 Words | 7 Pages

The officers failed to consider the broader context and potential ramifications of their actions. It could be argued that alternatives, such as engaging with the youths, building a rapport and educating them, as well as treating them with respect and fairness, rather than escalating the situation and disparaging the character of the youths, could allow officers to not only comply with policy and legislation, but also more effectively police their community by building positive relationships, channels of communication, and reduction of future crime (Chan, Bargen, Luke and Clancey 1997). However, these alternatives require the appropriate use of discretion which the officers failed to

Read More

Examples Of Racism In The Criminal Justice System

2042 Words | 9 Pages

Although we hope our Police force will use their powers for good, but sometimes police misconduct can occur. Often, the police are under great pressure to act as quick as possible, espcially in a murder case and if the murder victime is white, a child, police officer, or prominent. For example, In the 1990’s the case of Rodney King, that not only shows a racist issue within the criminal justice system, but also the issue with abuse from police officers, but changed the country’s views on the LA police force. Twenty- Seven years ago,Rodney King was brutally beaten by Los Angeles police officers.

Read More

Causes Of Racial Profiling

1496 Words | 6 Pages

We were given wide discretion and told to follow our hunches. If we wanted to stop and search someone or some persons, we would stop and search. Any possible violations such as speeding, or improper equipment, were afterthoughts (Kocieniewski and Hanley).” The approval of law enforcements being taught how to profile someone can affect not only minorities but can alter that individuals beliefs for what is right. He continued testifying

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of Community Policing

725 Words | 3 Pages

Sadly, during the last few years the relationship between the community and its police has significantly deteriorated. This has been due to the way some officers have handled certain situations in which the use of violence or deadly force could have been avoided. Because of this, some sectors of the community no longer trust their police; such distrust has gotten to the point that they rather take matters into their own hands than calling them for help. Although not all officers misbehave and abuse their power “it only takes one bad apple to spoil the bunch”. The media has also contributed in promoting the idea that most cops are bad by transmitting, over and over, videos of police officers abusing their power.

Read More

Pros And Cons Of Police Discretion

319 Words | 2 Pages

Police officers are faced with array situations each day they decide to wear the uniform for their department in which they work for. Each day is a different day with different situations that they will encounter and no two situations are ever the same. When responding to a call officers are already in the position of having to make a decision on how to handle the situation they are about to respond too. This is normally done with little supervision and advice from their fellow co-workers, this is where the heart of a police officer discretion comes in. In today’s society officers in some areas can face situations when extreme force will be necessary.

Read More

Essay On Police In The 21st Century

2169 Words | 9 Pages

From a time immorial the police have been a very intrigal part of the our social life. Be it the gupta period or the shivajian era, or the dark times of the east india company. Police has been omni present in the social order. One can not overlook the importance of police in the peaceful wellbeing of the state. But with the change in the attitude of the state towords its citizens the roll of police has also changed.

Read More

More about Discretion In Policing Pros And Cons

Related Topics

Open Document