ipl-logo

Distributive Justice In Health Care

418 Words2 Pages

Ethical Complexity of Distribute Justice and Rationing
Medicine is a practice based on moral standards applied to clinical values and judgments, also known as medical ethics. Ethical values consists of beneficence, nonmaleficence, autonomy and justice. However, these ethical principles are affected when distributive justice and rationing of health care resources are implemented “…in a world in which need is boundless but resources are not…” (Scheunemann & White, 2011, p. 1630).
The historic Hippocratic Oath described the four main principles of medical practice and established a moral conduct for clinicians. Beneficence demands that health care providers develop and maintain skills and knowledge, consider individual circumstances of all patients, and strive for the patient’s benefit. Nonmaleficence requires that a procedure or treatment does not harm the patient involved or others …show more content…

Nevertheless, “Health care providers will never be given enough resources to satisfy all demands placed upon them by a community that is becoming increasingly informed and demanding” (Capp, Savage, & Clarke, 2001, p.40). In addition, due to the scarcity of resources, it has become debatable whether health care is a privilege or a human right (Bodenheimer, 2009). Therefore, limited resources make rationing unavoidable and ethically complex.
Rationing can be described as the limitation of potentially beneficial resources to a patient due to resource insufficiency. An example of rationing in medicine is the process for organ transplants. In actuality, rationing has become more ethically complex due wasteful spending of health care resources in the United States. It is hypothesized that control of resource wasting will improve rationing ethics (Brody, 2012). Although, rationing is a controversial concept, without it, other basic components of society would be

Show More
Related
893 Words | 4 Pages

These are examples of The Virtue Approach and The Rights Approach. In “Should I Protect a Patient

Read More
118 Words | 1 Pages

Your discussion presents an interesting perspective on business principles. Managing financial needs of a hospital and patient’s satisfaction goes hand and hand in the hospital field. This also can create a negative impact when it comes to prescribing pain medication. An ethical dilemma arises for emergency room providers who in relation to new reimbursement tactics centered upon patient satisfaction scores (Kelly, Johnson, & Harbison, 2016)

Read More
788 Words | 4 Pages

The topic and history of medical ethics has consistently been a strongly debated issue. With numerous case-specific situations concerning as well as qualifying the matter, perhaps one of the most influential and debatable stories may be that of Henrietta Lacks. With non consensual tissue samples taken, unauthorized distribution of her cells, and seemingly careless radiation treatment for cervical cancer, it might be fair to adjudicate that the lack of ethical practice was apparent and almost even fatal. In the case study of Sofia (“Ethics in The Medical Field:

Read More
848 Words | 4 Pages

The oath created by Hippocrates known as the ‘Hippocratic Oath’ states the obligations and the correct conduct of a doctor. It is taken during the studies of a medical student at medical school (Early World History Blogger). The well-known ‘Hippocratic Oath’ is valued all around the world. It details the values and responsibilities of physicians at all times (Dawson). The ‘Hippocratic Oath’ is sworn by physicians as of today and the main principle to 'work with purity and with holiness' (Hippocrates) is correlated to our modern values.

Read More
2086 Words | 9 Pages

193). Healthcare providers are called to follow beneficence, the duty to promote the wellbeing of others (Essential learning: Law and ethics, 2022). More specifically, they can utilize paternalism, which is the ability to override the patient’s autonomy for their best interest. Some of the healthcare staff thought of following beneficence as using paternalism to heavily sedate the patients to the point of euthanization to prevent them from suffering a slow, painful death. They were using paternalism to decide that euthanization was more in favor of the patient’s best interest as most of the patients receiving sedation were not conscious enough to make the decision for

Read More
876 Words | 4 Pages

The police jumped into action and treated this case with urgency. The type of injustice that this conflict displayed was distributive injustice. Distributive injustice “is concerned with the criteria that lead you to feel you received a fair outcome” (Deutsch, 2007, p. 44). I believe in most cases involving black people the news make the police out to be bad guys. The most recent cases with the killing of African American males will make you think that the police don’t care about Blacks.

Read More
1010 Words | 5 Pages

They must ensure that they are providing adequate services to patients and at the same time ensuring that insurance companies are getting paid (Saint Joseph’s University, 2011, Para 6). Along with that they must secure that they are getting paid. Furthermore, physician moral and ethics are challenged as well; Thus, causing them to rethink how they take on their responsibilities as a medical care provider by trying to keep patients best interest, insurance companies interest and their own interests. This conflict with trying to meet the needs of several different stakeholders causes strain on the physician because they must walk fine line to please each. While trying to please a specific stakeholder another holder could be compromised.

Read More
542 Words | 3 Pages

In the case of Donald (Dax) Cowart, one can determine that the conflict is between Beneficence and Autonomy. The doctors were morally right in choosing to treat Donald despite his autonomy by using the principle of beneficence. Firstly, doctors entire training is about how to save lives, so in a sense it is something they are morally obligated to do. Patients go to hospital in the hopes of being treated.

Read More
1438 Words | 6 Pages

Equitable Treatment The second lens to view this alternative with is the Equitable Treatment lens, which focuses on fairness. The question that must be answered with the Equitable Treatment lens is, “Would keeping the nativity scene bulletin board up be treating all of the claimants in this case equitable?” Priority Principle. In the context of this case, there are at least a couple of stakeholders that we know for sure feel that the nativity scene is unconstitutional and improper, because they formally made anonymous calls and complained.

Read More
570 Words | 3 Pages

Health Care in the US is arguably available to all who seek it but not everybody has had the same experience and treatment when walking through the doors of a healthcare facility. In many cases, people are discriminated against due to their gender, race/ethnicity, age, and income and are often provided with minimal service. Differences between groups in health coverage, access to care, and quality of care is majorly affected through these disparities. Income is a major factor and can cause groups of people to experience higher burden of illness, injury, disability, or mortality relative to another group.

Read More
692 Words | 3 Pages

The primary motivation that has led me to pursue an advanced degree in bioethics at Columbia University is the direct applicability the field has to my interests in medicine. Today, the physician needs to contend with an increasingly pluralistic and multicultural society that can create pressure to compel him or her to accommodate patients ' diverse values. Each person and each physician who come together in the medical relationship have expectations, hopes, and needs. Only after these are understood and respected can appropriate technical measures be applied. My decision to apply to Columbia University is based on the belief that this program provides the optimal environment for me to investigate ethics as it pertains to medicine to prepare myself for the ethical requirements of a physician.

Read More
795 Words | 4 Pages

Distributive Justice and Health Care There are five distributive justice theories: utilitarianism, egalitarianism, libertarianism, deontology, and pluralism (Ledlow and Stephens, 2014, p. 255). Each of these theories can be used to justified distribution of health care resources. Distributive justice works to create a framework for the division of benefits/trials of economic movement (Ledlow and Stephens, 2014, p. 254).

Read More
499 Words | 2 Pages

l. What was the unethical issue(s) identified in the article? Matas (2008) on his proposal to a regulated system of compensation for organ donation argued that providing incentives for kidney donors will increase donations of kidneys available for transplantations, thus, decreases the prevalence of death and suffering from patients waiting for transplantation. In order for the research to be ethical the four core ethical principles such as beneficence, non-maleficence, autonomy, and justice should be present (Melnyk et al., p. 515). These principles might be favorable to the recipient but not the donor.

Read More
731 Words | 3 Pages

There is a common phenomenon in the China that many people treated with inequality and injustice in health care. As as Martin Luther King, Jr.’s saying goes “Of all the forms of inequality, injustice in health care is the most shocking and inhumane”. From my point of view, i firmly agree with this point in that each individual has equal right to enjoy the suitable health care. It is intolerable for the whole society to make the health care injustice as a seriously public health problem. In this essay, some facts about the injustice will be given.

Read More
1610 Words | 7 Pages

The practice of health care includes many scenarios that have to do with making adequate decisions when it comes to a patient’s life, and the way they are treated. Having an ethical code in all health care organizations is very important, because it helps health care workers with reaching a suited and ethical decision when it comes to the patient. In health care, patient will always be put first, and their autonomy will always be respected. Nevertheless, when there is a situation where a patient might be in harm, or might be making their condition worse because of the decisions they made. Health care workers will always be there to

Read More

More about Distributive Justice In Health Care

Related Topics

Open Document