ipl-logo

Dna Profiling Pros And Cons

714 Words3 Pages

Serious issues, both positive and negative, arise when DNA profiling is used to identify suspects and/or individuals potentially involved in crimes. Ethical issues are most often related to the storing of DNA profiles in a National DNA Database. Not only does this database include DNA information from suspected criminals, it contains DNA information from victims, volunteers and suspects who were not deemed guilty. DNA is the genetic make-up of a person’s body and many people argue whether it is fair or not to keep such private information in such a large database as this, especially those who had nothing to do with the crime. “It is debatable whether the benefits to society of having a national DNA database outweighs an individual’s right to …show more content…

“Who owns the genetic information and who controls what happens to it and how it is used?” The people/group of people responsible for the protection and privacy of each DNA profile is uncertain, therefore causing concern for individuals with their DNA information on the …show more content…

This can progress to people being acquainted with depression or mental health issues caused by being convicted of a crime and then finding out they are actually innocent. Despite this, police send small samples to multiple independent labs, which helps to reduce the possibility of an error which would affect the final results. Again, this can be related to the ethical issues of DNA profiling, as DNA evidence is being passed through multiple labs, meaning the individuals private DNA information has the potential to be used in a different crime than originally sort out. However, it is stated in an article on “Forensic Databases: benefits and ethical and social costs” that “Public support has been presumed on the grounds that all law-abiding people want criminals to be caught and convicted and the ‘innocent’ have nothing to fear from DNA technology.” Therefore it can be concluded that the public want criminals to be caught, so having DNA evidence passed through these independent labs, helps in a faster, more accurate identification of these criminals and if you are actually innocent then you should have nothing to worry about, as your DNA evidence will not arise in this

Show More
Related

Podcast Of Serial: Sarah Koenig's Case

1460 Words | 6 Pages

It can refute a claim of self-defense and put a weapon in the suspect's hand. It can change a story from an alibi to one of consent. The more officers know how to use DNA, the more powerful a tool it becomes.” This proves that DNA evidence is very reliable and is hard evidence that cannot be argued upon. DNA is either found at the scene of the crime or isn’t.

Read More

Why Is Gary Ridgway Called The Green River Killer?

657 Words | 3 Pages

Without the help of DNA, connecting offenders to their victims and the scene of the crime, so many cases would be left unsolved. Shockingly enough, it wasn’t until 1984 where DNA was used for biological identification. Once DNA started to play such a big role in criminal justice, many cases where they didn’t have enough evidence to prosecute, were brought to court and finally solved. Even though there was such a large gap in when the offenses were first committed and when they were solved, there was still justice for the victims and their families. An important case where DNA changes everything would be that of Gary Ridgway, otherwise known as the green river killer.

Read More

Rhetorical Analysis Of Who Was She By Copeland

1171 Words | 5 Pages

Who Was She? A DNA Test Only Opened New Mysteries Libby Copeland, in “Who Was She? A DNA Test Only Opened New Mysteries,” discusses the increased popularity of DNA testing, the process, and the impact the results can have on the people who choose this path. In the article, Copeland effectively uses structure, tone, word choice and other rhetoric devices to establish her purpose of informing her readers about the effects of DNA testing. Copeland writes the article not only to inform, but also to engage and interest the general public, or anyone considering DNA testing.

Read More

Comparison Of Ancestrydna And Atlas Biomed

1740 Words | 7 Pages

The main issue people have with DNA tests is privacy. An individual's DNA is immensely more exclusive than a social security number and in the wrong hands, your life could be at risk. If a database filled with millions of DNA samples from people all around the world; it takes only one person to breach the “security” and peoples DNA would then be readily available to anyone in the public. People can potentially analyze your DNA and see what bacteria or viruses your DNA is most vulnerable to, and use it against you. Additionally insurance companies could potentially obtain the results of a DNA test and see that you have an incredibly high probability of developing breast cancer.

Read More

The Case Of Timothy Cole

2295 Words | 10 Pages

The impact of Tim’s case was also felt on a national and even international level, as it shed light on the importance of using accurate and scientific evidence in the legal system and the need to reform the criminal justice system to prevent wrongful convictions. Tim’s story has inspired many other cases to be re-opened and re-examined, leading to the exoneration of several other innocent individuals. Overall, the case of Tim Cole has had a profound impact on the criminal justice system and has helped to bring about important changes in the use of DNA

Read More

Research Paper On The Central Park Five

2014 Words | 9 Pages

Every day people are wrongfully convicted and imprisoned due to untested/false DNA, misconduct

Read More

Rubin Carter Analysis

1934 Words | 8 Pages

According to the Australian Law Reform Commission, “A match between the crime scene profile and a defendant’s profile does not prove that the defendant committed the particular offence.” This error however is close to always due to human error. Also according to the Australian Law Reform Commission, “It has been suggested that sample mishandling, mislabelling or contamination is more likely to compromise a DNA analysis than an error in the analysis. Contamination may occur at any stage of the collection, transport or analysis of a DNA sample.” This form of error can be easily prevented by better training the professionals.

Read More

Jonathan Douglas Richardson Death Penalty

1693 Words | 7 Pages

DNA testing and other methods can now provide accurate and certain results that are irrefutable. For example, in the U.S., as of September 2011, 273 people including 17 death row inmates have been exonerated by use of DNA tests. The increasing use of DNA testing to help confirm the innocence or guilt in capital cases is

Read More

Dna Profiling Pros And Cons

1349 Words | 6 Pages

While admitting that the CODIS has been successful in fighting crime, Pearson and DeLascio argue that DNA profiling represents an unwanted invasion of privacy. Because it has proven useful in law enforcement, government at all levels have attempted to expand the range of criminals required to submit DNA samples. Although it is not yet legal at the federal level, some state and local jurisdictions have passed laws requiring DNA from juveniles as well as those who commit only minor crimes In some cases, DNA is taken from innocent Americans and knowingly stored after the individual has been found innocent. Even more threats to civil rights come from unspecified retention timelines of DNA profiles.

Read More

Examples Of Wrongful Conviction

969 Words | 4 Pages

Wrongful conviction has been an emerging and tremendous dilemma in our society since the discovery of DNA analysis. This is a very recent study that has presented another form of evidence that can prove an individual's innocence in ways never before. Forensic scientist collect DNA evidence and run tests to see if there is a match to DNA samples collected at the crime scenes. However, the justice system has not taken this new science into consideration because many influential individuals, such as judges, prosecutor, jurors, and attorneys, do not understand this new science. This leaves the burden to forensic scientist to explain DNA testing to representatives of the court system.

Read More

Post Conviction Dna Testing Essay

957 Words | 4 Pages

All state justice systems should allow post-conviction DNA testing and the collection of DNA from suspects. This will help the wrongly convicted to prove their innocence and avoid the death penalty, and also have the chance at exoneration. Law enforcement should collect DNA from suspects to prove if suspects truly are innocent or guilty. As well as require state officials to properly catalogue and preserve biological evidence for as long as the suspect is incarcerated. DNA testing is an important way for those who have been wrongly convicted to prove their innocence.

Read More

Persuasive Essay On Misdemeanor Convicts

661 Words | 3 Pages

While there are many arguments out there as to why an individual who has been convicted of a misdemeanor crime should have his or her DNA collected, we must not only look at the practicality of this, but also the facts. A law of this magnitude could open the flood gates to a massive invasion of privacy. Many supporters of this law claim oftentimes misdemeanor convicts go on to commit more serious crimes, so having their DNA in the system will help identify them sooner if they commit a crime. This invasion of privacy not only assumes that a misdemeanor convict will become a serious convict in the future,

Read More

Forensic Testing Essay

1095 Words | 5 Pages

This could be fatal because then a person could be wrongly convicted of a crime or even let free if he committed the crime and who knows if he won’t do it again? ● The equipment used in forensic testing can be very expensive and will cost a lot of money. ● Misleading or false DNA can easily be placed at the crime scene. As a result the wrong person will be arrested and the people who actually committed is still running around free. ● The DNA information is on a computer and can be vulnerable to exploitation from hackers.

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of Genomic Medicine

1011 Words | 5 Pages

Depending on the expectations of genomic medicine and the specific examinations performed, there are likely to be great implications economically, socially and politically. Many groups are involved in the outcome, from various communities, diverse populations, families and individuals. Conflicting interests on all group’s behalf pose the question of, how should this information be shared with the world. How will this information be understood and how will the drawbacks be prevented from hindering the very populations it is intended to assist (Gail E. Henderson, 2012, p.

Read More

Pro Death Penalty Essay

694 Words | 3 Pages

There are many cases where recent DNA testing has exonerated innocent persons after many years. Errors in the initial investigation, lies, previous criminal history, age, and laboratory errors all have contributed to the wrongful

Read More

More about Dna Profiling Pros And Cons

Related Topics

Open Document