ipl-logo

Dred Scott V. Stanford Case Analysis

635 Words3 Pages

A little girl is sitting in a classroom where everyone is wearing white converse, however she is wearing black. Everyone is ignoring her, even the teachers. What is the difference between neglecting people because of the color of their skin or their shoes? Nobody should have to experience any type of judgment. The Civil Rights Act changed this nation immensely. In addition, the act not only almost completely ended racism, but stopped discrimination against religion, gender, and national origin. Many cases led to the Civil Rights Act. The Civil Rights Movement had many powerful cases: Dred Scott v. Stanford, Shelly v. Kraemer, and Loving v. Virginia.

Dred Scott v. Stanford was a valuable case that helped the United States lead to the Civil Rights Movement. In this case, Dred and Harriet Scott sued for their freedom from slavery. Even though this was a successful case, it lasted about eleven years. This case caused a lot of media. Furthermore, slavery was the number one issue in politics in America. Therefore, the Scott's were almost guaranteed to win. The case became more and more popular as it went to the Supreme Court. However, Chief Taney stated that "slaves were not citizens of the United …show more content…

Kraemer, Shelly just wanted to buy a house. They should be able to live in their home in peace. Additionally, Shelley (a black petitioner) bought a home where thirty out of thirty nine of the other members of the neighborhood signed a restrictive convent that stated that "no home was to be sold to any person who was black, which led to the suit by the neighborhood to undo the sale of the property to Shelley." (Shelley vs. Kraemer) The Fourteenth Amendment is about equal protection. Therefore, nobody can prohibit the restrictive boundary where someone else can buy property. In fact, the action of the state court in requiring the precise covenant deprives the petitioner of the rights that is assured by the Fourteenth Amendment and the acts of

Show More
Related
550 Words | 3 Pages

Summary of Source The editorial discloses the power that the Court adheres to and whether it should be accountable for the decision making of fugitive slaves. The writer had discussed that in no way did the verdict of the Dred Scott case follow an act of law, but was merely “nullity.” During the settlement, they decided that since Dred Scott’s master had brought him on free land in Missouri or of the United States without having a citizenship, which resulted in him having no case. It continues on to say that the jurisdiction of the case was influenced by opinion, which did not involve any legalities.

Read More
509 Words | 3 Pages

Dred Scott Vs SandFord The case, Dred Scott vs Sandford, (1857) better known as the Dred Scott case was a crucial decision that affected America and it’s black population. Free blacks in America weren’t able to sue the court. The concept of popular sovereignty was also questioned, and blacks with ancestors were imported to America was slave could no longer become citizens. The Case ruled that slaves in free countries are still slaves.

Read More
489 Words | 2 Pages

The Results of Dred Scott v Sanford had different effects on American history. This also contributed to the start of the civil war. Dred Scott v Sanford was a court decision on if Dred Scott could sue for his freedom. " According to Supreme Court History, Dred Scott could not sue for his freedom because he was not a citizen. " This was otherwise known as an illegal case.

Read More
839 Words | 4 Pages

The Civil Rights movement was so big, that marches were being held across the country no matter white or black, south or north for equal rights. This was such a big case since it was the tipping point of having a better judicial system in place that will never take into account

Read More
1459 Words | 6 Pages

It is a historical inevitability leaded by many different factors. "Dred Scott Case" is one of the most controversial events in American history. Dred Scott was an African American black slave born in 1795. He was taken by his master John Emerson, an army surgeon in the United States of America, from the slave state of Missouri to the free state of Illinois and then to the free territory of Wisconsin. He lived there for a long period of time.

Read More
882 Words | 4 Pages

The white American race at the time were very arrogant and prideful. People like Martin Luther played a big part in the civil rights movement. Some of the cases that effected the civil rights movement were commonly known as, Plessy v. Ferguson, Brown v. Education, and Bakke v. California. The court case Plessy v. Ferguson played a big part in what is commonly known as the civil rights movement. It had created many laws that enforced a process called segregation.

Read More
601 Words | 3 Pages

In 1857, an African American man named Dred Scott sued for his freedom in the Supreme Court. His owners brought him along on their trips across free states. Dred Scott failed in suing before his case was presented in the Supreme Court. Roger B. Taney was the fifth chief Justice of the United States when he wrote the Dred Scott vs Sandford decision. The Dred Scott vs Sandford case ended with the decision that African Americans, free and enslaved, had no rights and could not become citizens because they were property.

Read More
427 Words | 2 Pages

Unfortunately, there have been events proving such statement and it is upsetting to know that after all the decades of fighting for equality this is still an issue for blacks, especially for African-Americans living in our country. African slaves first were brought to America in 1619 to the colony of Jamestown, Virginia. They served as the foundation of a new nation by working on crop production such as tobacco and cotton, and became a solid importance to the South´s economy

Read More
429 Words | 2 Pages

In Shelley v. Kraemer. These intense court cases supported the civil rights movement by inspiring people to stand up for their rights. First is Brown v. Board of education which a court case in which colored people were fighting to have equality in schools and have equal educational programs. Black and white kids were separated too much and were not treated equally in schools by teachers, students, parents, any of their peers. Equality is a natural right that every person deserves no matter the color of their skin.

Read More
1800 Words | 8 Pages

For many years, African-Americans had been treated as slaves or subsidiary to whites. Even after blacks were hypothetically supposed to have been granted freedom and equality (Plessy v. Ferguson), blacks found themselves in a world of segregation and inequitable standards. African-Americans began stand up for equality after the first steps of desegregation in the military and defense. The Civil Rights Movement did not fail because blacks never loosened the grip on the fight for equality, even though blacks were harshly treated, and in some cases with brutal violence and murder, but blacks pushed for civil rights throughout the movement until the goal was reached at last. Each event throughout the course of the Civil Rights Movement contributed to the impetus for protests and served an important purpose that many African-Americans will never forget.

Read More
574 Words | 3 Pages

The Chief Justices that were on the case are Roger B. Taney, Samuel Nelson, John McLean and Robert Grier. Chief Justice Roger B. Taney, a supporter of slavery said that African American people were not allowed to become citizens. Justice John McLean and Benjamin R. Curtis argued that Dred Scott should be freed under the Missouri Compromise (Dred Scott Case). The majority opinion of the case was 7 to 2. The Supreme Court ruled Dred as not being about to bring a suit in the federal Court.

Read More
489 Words | 2 Pages

The forefathers of the United States built this country on the ideals of freedom and equality for all people. Unfortunately, the fight for equality and freedom did not end with the revolutionary war. The fight has continued throughout the decades. Many of these issues were fought in the courtroom. Auburn University created an online Alabama Encyclopedia, there, the following quote stated, “Scottsboro became an international cause celebre that dramatically encapsulated the American south troubled post reconstruction history of legal and extralegal racial violence, the social and political upheaval of the great depression, and the lingering cultural divide between the north and south.”

Read More
531 Words | 3 Pages

Buchanan took it upon himself to avoid any issue that had to do with slavery in the territories. Not wanting to face any consequences on the matter, Buchanan push all matters of slavery to the Supreme Court; such as the Dred Scott case. Dred Scott was a slave who decided to sue his slave owner for freedom after he had been taken into territories where slavery was banned. The Supreme Court Justice, Roger Taney, ruled against Scott; “…not only ruled that slaves were property, not people, but also invalidated the Missouri Compromise of 1820, which barred slavery in much of the Louisiana Purchase” (Sheets, 331). Therefore, abolitionists were enraged and “were now convinced that the time had come for more radical, violent action” (Griffin, PP4,

Read More
473 Words | 2 Pages

The world we live in today would not be how it is if we didn't go through these three court cases. These court cases were about slavery and black rights, things we take for granted in today's society. Three different Supreme Court Cases influenced the Civil Rights Movement by declaring that under the Constitution, Dred Scott was his master's property, Segregation is universally recognized as within the competency of states in the exercise of their police powers, and Judicial enforcement of a racially restrictive property covenant is a violation of the Equal Protection clause of the 14th Amendment. This first case is about Dred Scott, he had lived as a slave with his wife for a few years and then went into a free state as a slave. They sued their owner for their freedom, the odds weren't against them, many had won their freedom like this before.

Read More
528 Words | 3 Pages

The Civil Rights Act of 1964 is hailed by many as one of the most important legislations in the American history. The act was passed into law 52 years ago under a lot of pressure and resistance from white senators and African American activists. The act, which was largely known as the “Bill of the century” was aimed at bringing equality for blacks and whites and end racial prejudice. The act was targeted to revolutionize America where blacks and whites would eat together in the same hotels and enjoy similar rights in public places without any discrimination.

Read More

More about Dred Scott V. Stanford Case Analysis

Related Topics

Open Document