ipl-logo

Duluth Rape Case Study

1459 Words6 Pages

On June 14th, 1920 Sandra Teal went to the fair that was in town with her boyfriend Robert Walsh, and later that night she claimed six black circus workers raped her. The report of the rape was called in early morning of June 15th by Robert Walsh’s father. There was little to no evidence to support these claims and an examination of Sandra by Dr. David Graham, a family physician, showed no physical signs of rape or assault. Six black men were arrested that day and immediately brought to the Duluth police station. As news spread around Duluth about what allegedly happened, a mob started to form and by the time the mob decided to force its way into the police station estimates had the mob as large as ten thousand people. All the men who were …show more content…

Murnian issued an order that the police were not to use their guns or their night sticks on the crowd. The police could only use their fists and fire hoses. After the lynchings were over and the National Guard arrived Lt. Barber was given credit for giving the order not to use guns, he was highly praised for this. Commissioner Murnian was angry with this and called in a reporter for himself and told them that it was he who issued the order not to use guns. An investigation carried out by General Rhinow concluded that “Since Commissioner Murnian has served as Commissioner of Public Safety, he has taken no active steps toward inaugurating the proper discipline in the functioning of the police force. It is the opinion of the undersigned that Com. Murnian erred appallingly in not requesting assistance of the Sheriff or the state militia at a much earlier time than he did. . . . He, having been present in the police station during the assembling of the mob, and the ultimate lynching, and not having exercised the duties required of him by his office, is guilty of malfeasance in office.”(pg.147) Despite this hearing Murnian was reelected the following …show more content…

Morgan finally got a break when Sandra agreed to talk to his as long as her mother was there. After his conversation with her Morgan was unconvinced that she was telling the truth so he went to talk to Doctor Graham who said “I don’t think the girl was raped” and when asked if there would be outward signs of abuse after an assault like that Graham replied with “You would think so.” The report filed by Morgan never got to the defense of Max Mason because the governor of Minnesota wanted to take a hands off approach to the

Show More
Related

Case Study Of Duke Lacrosse Case: First Degree Rape

1574 Words | 7 Pages

The Duke lacrosse case implicated criminal actions of: first degree rape, first degree sex offenses’ and kidnapping charges against three Duke University lacrosse players; Collin Finnerty, Reade Seligman and Dean Evans (North Carolina State Bar v. Nifong, 2007,p.18-20). According to Mosteller (2007) the case started with “gang rape allegations” by Crystal Mangum, a black exotic dancer who was also a student at North Carolina Central University on the morning of March 14th, 2006 (p.1337). The alleged rape occurred during the Duke lacrosse teams’ party at 610 North Buchanan Blvd (North Carolina State Bar v. Nifong, 2007,p.1). Suspiciously Mangum could not make any identifications of her attackers even after viewing most Duke lacrosse team members including the names mentioned above and the lacrosse team members who actually lived at 610 North Buchanan Blvd (Mosteller, 2007, p.1407). Mosteller (2007) also mentions that Mike Nifong had to know that

Read More

Research Paper On The Great New Orleans Kidnapping

1361 Words | 6 Pages

The Great New Orleans Kidnaping Case Essay #2 The Reconstruction Era, in the history of the United States, has two meanings: the first covering the entire nation from 1865 to 1877 following the Civil War; and the second covering the transformation of Louisiana from 1862 to 1877. Reconstruction was a prolonged and difficult process that still impacts the state of Louisiana, as well as the United States today. In The Great New Orleans Kidnapping Case: Race, Law, and Justice in the Reconstruction Era, the author and historian, Michael Ross, argues that the public reaction to Mollie Digby’s kidnapping and the trial of her suspected kidnappers can help readers understand the history of “New Orleans and the Reconstruction era.” Several details must

Read More

Compare And Contrast The Trial Of The Scottsboro Boys

851 Words | 4 Pages

On March 25, 1931 the lives of nine black teenagers changed after they were allegedly accused of being involved in a gang rape of two white females. This began when a fight broke out on a train after a white male named Orville Gilley stepped on the hand of a black male named Haywood Patterson who was hanging from the train itself (Linder, “The Trials of the Scottsboro Boys”). The white males involved went to a stationmaster to report the alleged assault which resulted with posse members coming to take the nine black males away. (Linder, “The Trials of the Scottsboro Boys”). Two white, female mill workers named Ruby Bates and Victoria Price also accused the nine black males to raping them.

Read More

Key Facts And Critical Issues In The Wayne Williams Case

1002 Words | 5 Pages

Introduction In this paper, I will discuss the key facts and critical issues presented in the Wayne Williams case. Dissuccion In 1979, a travesty began unfolding in Atlanta, Georgia when young black males began disappearing then turning up dead some time later (CNN, 2010). The trail was cold as investigators continued to receive reports from families around the city.

Read More

Southern Horrors Lynch Law In All Its Phases Summary

1195 Words | 5 Pages

Southern Horrors Lynch Law in All Its Phases Book Review Da B. Wells-Barnett has written the book under review. The book has been divided into six chapters that cover the various themes that author intended to fulfill. The book is mainly about the Afro-Americans and how they were treated within the American society in the late 1800s. The first chapter of the book is “the offense” band this is the chapter that explains the issues that have been able to make the Afro-American community to be treated in a bad way by the whites in the United States in the late 1800s.

Read More

Press Coverage Of 1891 Lynchings In New Orleans

531 Words | 3 Pages

There have been many cases revolving around lynching. For instance, the famous case of Emmit Till, a young African American boy brutally murdered. Before the murder, Till decided to whistle at a white woman named Carolyn Bryant. Consequently, little did Till know that the funny joke of a whistle would cause him great misery and agony. On the night of the tragedy, two men, Roy Bryant, and J.W. Milam, went to Till’s granduncle's house looking for Till.

Read More

An Informative Essay: The Murder Of Mary Phagan

1407 Words | 6 Pages

Ever since the murder of Mary Phagan, which occurred on April 26, 1913, there has been a lot of discussions of who may have called the sweet, little Mary Phagan. Could have it been the black man, Jim Conley, or was it the white, Jewish man, Leo Frank? Did the killer get away with murder, or was justice served through the act of lynching? During this time, no one could have convinced another person that Jim Conley indeed killed Mary Phagan, but that Leo Frank was the definite killer in the eyes of the people. The point that everyone can agree upon is that the murder of Mary Phagan could never be forgotten.

Read More

Mayella Newspaper Article

247 Words | 1 Pages

There is breaking news in Maycomb, Alabama. A rape has occurred where an 18 year old white caucasian woman Mayella Ewell was raped by a dirty negro named Tom Robinson who was 27. The negro was supposedly going in the fence to break up some kindling that miss Mayella had. Miss Mayella was gonna give the negro a dime but the negro “did it for free”. The next evening miss Mayella went inside to get the dime for the negro.

Read More

What Was The Tulsa Massacre Dbq

481 Words | 2 Pages

(Doc-A) Initially, the events of the Tulsa Massacre were not widely reported in the media and were largely ignored by the white population. At the time, the African American community was subject to derogatory remarks and violent actions, perpetuating harmful stereotypes and dehumanizing the victims of the attack. (Doc-J) Over time, however, our understanding of the events of the Tulsa Massacre has changed

Read More

Mary Bell: The Murder Of Betty Bell

210 Words | 1 Pages

In 1968 Mary and her best friend Norma Bell killed; Martin Brown and Bryan Howe. Mary and Norma were said to have strangled Martin Brown. Two months after her first murder, Mary strangled Brian Howe, cut off his penis and carved a “N” which later was turned into a “M” on his chest. Mary was then convicted and Norma was acquitted. Betty Bell, Mary’s mother sold stories to the media

Read More

Why The Tulsa Race Riots

409 Words | 2 Pages

HOOK. The Tulsa race riot was a night of rioting caused by the controversy of a possible rape in Tulsa. Many of the facts of the situation and following riots are unknown, which makes it an interesting and debatable topic. In 1921, a white, female elevator operator accused a black man of sexual assault: the event caused a large riot in Tulsa; the newspaper that released the information may have over exaggerated the facts; and the amount of casualties is still unknown. To begin, the riot and what caused it will be discussed.

Read More

Abolitionist William Lloyd Garrison Analysis

818 Words | 4 Pages

On July 16th, 1935 a black man named Reuban Stacy knocked on Mrs. Marion Jones’s door in Ft. Lauderdale, Florida. She let him in and he asked for a drink, afterwards she screamed and threating him with a knife until he ran off. He was arrested and handed off to Broward County Sheriff’s Department to Sheriff Walter Clark, where he denied attacking Marion Jones.

Read More

Examples Of Darkness In To Kill A Mockingbird

1947 Words | 8 Pages

Not only are there rays of light in fictional stories, they take place in our everyday life, and provide the world with hope and positivity for a change. Lynchings in Duluth is a nonfiction story about three men who were hanged by their community for a false accusation in 1920. Michael Fedo was an author who wrote the truth about the horrible lynchings that took place that day in Duluth, Minnesota, “Fedo’s book resulted in a persistent interest in the lynchings. Periodically efforts have been made to publicly remember the tragedy” (“Duluth’s Shameful” n.pag.). The impact Michael Fedo’s book produced was exactly what he was looking for, he wanted everyone to know that what had taken place that day, was not right and should not be forgotten, but be remembered as a time to never go back to.

Read More

William Faulkner's Trial

655 Words | 3 Pages

On February 6th 1863, William Faulkner was arrested for the molestation of white nine-year old girl by the name of Mary Brown. According to Mary and Ellen Hoover, a friend of the young girl who was also the same age, they were walking to Michigan Avenue to mail a letter. En route, the two passed Faulkner’s bar and were coerced into coming inside, where Mary was allegedly assaulted. A crime of this nature already arises an outraged and disgusted response. However, the response was made worse by innacuries published in the Detroit Free Press.

Read More

Campus Rape In College

89 Words | 1 Pages

In regards to college campus rape I have a personal interest in this because I am a college student whose statistic of being raped is higher. This subject is relevant to me and my life. I know this is a problem because 1 out of every 6 American women has been the victim of an attempted or completed rape. Women 18-24 who are in college are 3 times more likely than women in general to be raped. Rape should be addressed seriously, so students know what constitutes as rape.

Read More

More about Duluth Rape Case Study

Related Topics

Open Document