ipl-logo

Essay Comparing Frankenstein And The Birthmark

1706 Words7 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: The Role of Science in Frankenstein by Mary Shelley

Science is a powerful tool for a human to study because it can lead to numerous possible opportunities. Science may be used it several different aspects such as curing sickness, breaking down the process to understand how life works, or to even understand how life is started. But, when it comes to the novel Frankenstein and the short story “The Birthmark” the key characters in these stories take a bold and unusual step in science. In these stories, the two characters have a similar situation, but different intentions and outcomes. The characters try to push their limits on their intelligence playing the role of God by trying an experiment that has not been done before. Along with their experiments, then leads into the consequences of being …show more content…

In the novel and the short story, both of the key characters who were the scientist, both ended up losing someone significantly due to their experiments. First in Frankenstein, since the monster did not have any companionship and could not get to know anyone before they started running off because of his monstrous looks, the monster had requested a second creation from Victor. Victor had agreed at first to the agreement, however ended up changing his mind, destroying the second project. Because of his actions, the result of this was of how the monster got extremely upset, threatening Victor that his loved ones will be the ones suffering. In the novel, Frankenstein, by Mary Shelley, it stated, “‘I shall be with you on your wedding-night’ (168)… She was there, lifeless and inanimate, thrown across the bed (195)… The murderous mark of the fiend’s grasp was on her neck” (196). Unfortunately, the result for Victor was undesirable as shown of how the monster has killed his newly wedded wife on the night of their wedding. This provides evidence, because of Victor not negotiating with the monster, the death of his wife was in the hands of himself and he could have prevented the situation from

Show More
Related
508 Words | 3 Pages

Some think of science as advantageous, while others believe it can be immoral. Acts of science can lead to manipulation of the natural world and cause those performing the experiments to “play God.” Nathaniel Hawthorne 's short stories “Dr. Heidegger’s Experiment,” “Rappaccini’s Daughter,” and “The Birthmark” each incorporate characters that attempt to alter a natural aspect of life and in turn are met with failure. It is through his short stories that Nathaniel Hawthorne reveals opinion of science: Men should not engage in scientific studies that require them to act as God.

Read More
505 Words | 3 Pages

When Victor has nobody left in his life he makes up his mind to kill the monster in an act of violent passion. He sets out to hunt the monster, but gets sick and dies on his journey. The monster comes to Victor's dead body, and is saddened by his foes death. With his foe dead and only chance of creating a companion gone he wanders off into the snowy north to die. These deaths were included to “end plot complications”.(90)

Read More
947 Words | 4 Pages

Frankenstein and The Birthmark Writers' Project The writers’ project for both Frankenstein and The Birthmark is to show that sometimes knowledge has a dark side. In both of the stories knowledge led to the death of many people. Such as William, Elizabeth, and Henry in Frankenstein and Georgiana in The Birthmark. In both stories knowledge was used to strive for happiness but the opposite was found.

Read More
349 Words | 2 Pages

Victor decides to keep it a secret, but when he got home, he discovered that Justine, their servant and friend, had been accused of the murder. Elizabeth believed Justine was innocent, but the rest of the family wasn't too sure. Victor was the only one who really knew the truth, and he was very sad. Victor did not expect any bad thing to happen. He calls the monster a demon and continues to call it names.

Read More
536 Words | 3 Pages

This feeling of not being able to control what we create frightens scientist. This an example of how science becomes more a a hazard of orr safety than it does to help our society. Paradise lost begins with the introduction of Adam and

Read More
966 Words | 4 Pages

“This was my duty; but there was another still paramount to that. My duties towards the beings of my own species had greater claims to my attentions, because they included a greater proportion of happiness or misery” (Shelley 184). Dr. Victor Frankenstein was a brilliant scientist whose ideas were to bring both not only success but death upon others including his own loved ones. Like most scientists in real life today and from the past, they tend to struggle with whatever knowledge they can learn about. The only problem was that the education they possess shows that they have no idea of the outcome of their experiments until tested and by doing so scientists can easily temper with the laws of nature on animals, humans and even the environment, not to mention defying information from other scientists to prove their own theories correct and to

Read More
151 Words | 1 Pages

This story involves the characters’ journey trying to find companionship and quench their thirst for love. Victor and the monster yearn for relationships with others to share their lives , yet there’s a constant struggle , and many times fail to make this type of connection with others. So when the monster has pleaded for Victor Frankenstein to make him a love interest and Victor has destroyed the only possibility to help the monster achieve true happiness. I accept what Victor did and think it was an excellent idea for him to dismember the woman, before he brought something into the world he would forever regret and would wreak havoc upon the world. To give some insight why Victor may have done this, what if the woman is a mass murder, also

Read More
983 Words | 4 Pages

The theme of science is illuminated by the notion of electricity and "[its] potential to reanimate corpses" (Brown "The Science"). The theme of religion is connected to religious books, philosophies, and actions. One prominent conflict between the themes revolves around Victor Frankenstein's idea of creating life. Throughout most of his career, Frankenstein was involved with the sciences and gained a great interest in the "human frame" (30) and "the physical secrets of the world" (19). He started an experiment for the sake of science, but saw it as a "[success] in discovering the cause of generation and life" (31).

Read More
675 Words | 3 Pages

This unquestionably exhibits his egocentric conventions as he places himself above everyone else even in matters of life and death. Furthermore, if Victor himself is willing to take responsibility for her death then it becomes unambiguous as to whether he should be held accountable for the actions of his creation. Throughout the story, the monster struggles with the repercussions brought about by his creator which leave him in turmoil. He does eventually overcome these obstacles, although it is undoubtedly too late.

Read More
1801 Words | 8 Pages

Victor Frankenstein's passion for science expands the boundaries of his modern science to create life from essentially nothing. Frankenstein tells the captain the story of how he came to be found in the icy waters by the ship's crew; "So much has been done, exclaimed the soul of Frankenstein—more, far more, will I achieve; tread in the steps already marked, I will pioneer a new way, explore unknown powers, and unfold to the world the deepest mysteries of creation" (3.4). There are always unintentional consequences that negatively affect society when boundaries are crossed; with modern science, scientists do their best to map out contingency plans to deal with successes and failures, including what to do with a synthetic material that doesn't meet the guidelines established for it. With genetic engineering, some of the negative consequences that must be dealt with include legally protecting the patents awarded for testing DNA and creating synthetic materials. There are currently several studies being completed to determine the impact of genetic diagnostic testing practices and the associated licensing practices.

Read More
233 Words | 1 Pages

I have a secret about my life. One that is obvious to my friends and family, but is still a secret nonetheless. A secret that hinders my chances at everything in this world. There is a monster in my closet. One that is large and grey and has hollow eyes.

Read More
1055 Words | 5 Pages

I wouldn’t say that I am a monster. I’m not even sure that evil is the correct word that should associated with my name. I have done wrong things in the past, but that was not the real me. I was misunderstood, neglected; I wasn’t seen for the good things that I had done. It was never my intention to hurt Adam and to ruin our friendship, I meant to make my pain noticeable to others but I may have gone about showing this in the wrong way.

Read More
1662 Words | 7 Pages

Victor Frankenstein’s Creation and the Role of God The main character in Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein, who is Victor Frankenstein, is regarded by literary scholars as imitating the role of God through his acts of creation. David Soyka describes Victor Frankenstein’s creation as “[being] much the same way as God create[d] man in [h]is own image” (168). Frankenstein is accused by many as playing God due to, not only, his purposes for the creation, but also his initial reactions to his own creation.

Read More
883 Words | 4 Pages

Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein Critical Analysis About the author Naomi Hetherington is a member of the University of Sheffield, the department of lifelong learning. She is an early researcher in sexuality, religious culture, the 19th-century literature, and gender. She holds a BA in Theology and religious studies, an MA and a Ph.D. in Victorian Literature. She currently teaches four-year pathway literature degree at Sheffield University for students who have already attained foundation degrees. Among the books, she has written the critique of Frankenstein.

Read More
909 Words | 4 Pages

Is Sherlock Holmes doing what's best for the people of London or is he above the law in his own way? Throughout the stories and tales of Sherlock Holmes, the constant recurrence of catching the villain and solving the case is apparent throughout Holmes’s legend, but is he really doing anything to save the people of his city and stopping crime? Holmes’s mythos always starts with a crime seen through Dr. Watson’s eye, and we see the conclusion of the case through however the crime is never stopped before hand. Within the book, The Improbable Adventures of Sherlock Holmes, The detective always uses the crime as a starting point to the mystery however he never prevents a life to be lost before the crime is committed.

Read More

More about Essay Comparing Frankenstein And The Birthmark

Related Topics

Open Document