ipl-logo

Essay On The Red Umbrella

657 Words3 Pages

The Red Umbrella, by Christina Diaz Gonzalez and “ Band Aid for 800 Children”, by Eli Saslow both show the subject of Immigration and how it changes families. The Authors use different techniques to help the reader know the subject. Although they also use the some of the same techniques to express the the subject to the reader. It can show the effects of Immigration and how it changes families. Both of the texts have many differences and similarities. Here are some Similarities from both text. They both portray the tone of Sadness or Hurt. In the “Red Umbrella” it says “ He offered it to her while his own tears fell to the floor.” An example from” Band-Aid for 800 Children” says “She does this as a volunteer and often at her own expense, not because she …show more content…

In “Band-Aid for 800 Children” it shows that the Character is hurt or sad because she was the only one who wanted to help Children with deported parents. These examples both state a tone of sadness or being hurt making it similar. Another similarity is the topic of Family Separation. In “The Red Umbrella” it says ”We’ve made plans for you to leave Cuba … tomorrow.” An example from “Band-Aid for 800 Children” says “A few thousand of those children lose both parents. “Immigration orphans,” is how the government refers to this group.” Both of these examples from the text show a topic of separation because it states the family would be seperated. The last example of a similarity is a theme about taking a risk can be beneficial and for the better good. In “ The Red Umbrella” Papa says it will be for the better good and it will be a risk so they are not taken away. In “ Band-Aid for 800 Children” it states that Nora is taking a risk of being responsible for children and that it will help them by taking the Risk. Both of these statements show risk

Show More
Related
785 Words | 4 Pages

I´m comparing The Red Umbrella by Christina Diaz Gonzalez and “Band-Aid for 800 Children” by Eli Sastow and the common subject in the texts is a sacrifice. There are many similar techniques they use but there are other techniques that are different. The following are some similarities that show sacrifice between the texts The Red Umbrella by Christina Diaz Gonzalez and “Band-Aid for 800 Children” by Eli Sastow. One similarity is they both have a point of view of how Lucy’s thoughts are always with Me or My shown in the text like ¨My head seemed to nod on its own, without any instruction from me¨. Also from Nora Sandigos point of view since she 's the only person who expresses her feeling and speaks throughout the text like “Dios Mio,” she says, my God, because these are not just things she hopes to get done but things she needs to get done — things she is in fact legally responsible for doing”.

Read More
235 Words | 1 Pages

The nonfiction story, Band-Aid For 800 Children, written by Eli Sastow and the fiction story, The Red Umbrella, written by Christina Diaz Gonzalez, are two different stories focusing on family separation. Both stories are written throughout perspectives, showing struggles families have to go through. Both stories have similarities and differences, however, this will be focusing on the similarities. Both stories revolve immigration and family separation.

Read More
481 Words | 2 Pages

This shows that the book focuses on Salva while the poem focuses on all the boys. Another difference between the book and the poem is that the book tells us the details of what happened to Salva, but the poem

Read More
684 Words | 3 Pages

they both trigger the same emotions by the letter being informative, logical and calmly written and it states fact which will most likely get the audiance to see the logic in it all and the image is a direct attack to mr turnball saying we know what your doing and we want everyone else to understand and feel enraged at the fact mr turnball can do something so terrible to a child. both letter and image has adressed the issue and is finding a way to solve the

Read More
1677 Words | 7 Pages

These both show that even against seemingly impossible odds you can still thrive and overcome any hardship and grow into a successful and honorable person. This also shows how much a child’s caregiver and the way they are raised can affect them. Abuse is a very serious issue and going unnoticed can have very harmful

Read More
721 Words | 3 Pages

The story “The Red Umbrella” written by Christina Diaz Gonzalez and the photograph by José Hernández-Claire both have the same subject. That subject is Separation. This subject is a big topic in both the story and the photograph because it literally revolves around separation. Even though they have something in common; and in “The Red Umbrella”, the kids are being separated from their parents and being brought to the U.S so that they can live a better life and so that they are safe. there is also something different about the story such as the techniques that make it easier to show the subject.

Read More
771 Words | 4 Pages

In “The Red Umbrella,” the story is written through Lucy’s point of view. She is experiencing immigration first hand by leaving Cuba during the Cuban Revolution to get to the U.S. without her parents. Sandigo in “A ‘Band-Aid’ for 800 Children,” is the guardian of 800 children whose parents were either detained or sent back to the country from where they came from because of illegal immigration. This shows that both the main characters have experience with immigration. Another way that the texts are similar is through tone.

Read More
355 Words | 2 Pages

In these stories Red Umbrella and Band-Aid for 800 children both show that the subject is family separation of children or parents being seperated by their families. A subject is a topic of the story and both of these stories Red Umbrella by: Christina Diaz and Band-Aid for 800 children by : Eli Sastow show family separation. In both Red Umbrella and Band-Aid for 800 children some similarities are they both use point of view. In Red Umbrella Lucy uses her point of view to show why it was not a good idea of her parents sending them to the US and not coming with them.

Read More
959 Words | 4 Pages

Both are eager to be independent and are not afraid to break away from the family if they have to, and both are ultimately caught in family duty. The desire of being independent and being able to do what they want to do is a theme that prevails in both stories, and it is classic theme in second generation immigrants. Both characters are Americanized and have abandoned many traditional values, but are ultimately tied to the families they come from, because family, to some extent, is what defines a

Read More
422 Words | 2 Pages

In Krystyna's story says the were going to get Liquidated and the Nazis did that. Both people in the stories wanted freedom from the Germans. In the Butterfly, Pavl wants to fly be free like a butterfly. In Krystyna's story she keeps asking her dad if they could be free.

Read More
1026 Words | 5 Pages

he topic of immigration tends to be a touchy one when discussed about. The topics of poverty and racism also surface once this subject comes up in a conversation and these can be quiet controversial within in argument. In the novel, Drown, by Junot Diaz, he illustrates in his short stories about how immigration, poverty, and racism affect’s the characters lives on a day to day basis. There are also many connections between racism and poverty the character’s experiences within Diaz’s novel. The issues of poverty and racism that are faced by the characters within Drown are quite similar to the ones faced by the immigrants of the United States which makes these situations more relatable to many.

Read More
1448 Words | 6 Pages

The character Robert is left reeling emotionally after instinctually shooting an innocent German Solar and experiences shock. Ellen goes through a similar experience after running away from the farm during the wind storm and having her baby die in her arms. She too is in shock over a death. These two works, despite one being a novel and one a short

Read More
772 Words | 4 Pages

This shows us that the language barrier can not only have an effect on the immigrant themselves but also their children. Furthermore there are situations where the immigrants affect the country both positively and

Read More
1204 Words | 5 Pages

Precisely, the article is subdivided in several parts that effectively complement each other which makes it easy for the reader to capture the theme of the content. The author starts with an introductory part that cites from the personal experience example to capture the minds of the reader not only on the challenges faced by immigrants but also on what it takes to be an refugee in a country such as United States (Nunez, n.p.). After the introductory part, the author highlights the challenges faced by immigrants chronologically starting with the basic/major ones with regards to how they supplement each other. For instance, Nunez starts with challenges in speaking English followed with the problem of raising children, securing jobs, accessing housing, getting healthcare services, transportation problems and later cultural barriers (Nunez, n.p.). Precisely, Nunez depicts that the difficulty in learning and speaking English deters immigrants from securing jobs which automatically denies them housing, health care and transportation services.

Read More
613 Words | 3 Pages

The same actions that happen in both of the story were that they both have to let go of something they really love. They are both old. They both live alone and with no pets or kids. They were always kind to the strangers no matter what happen, the old couple would let them in their own house and let them stay for a night. The Aunt Misery would let the people in her house people that she did not even knew, but the old lady would always let them in.

Read More

More about Essay On The Red Umbrella

Related Topics

Open Document