ipl-logo

Ethical Arguments Regarding Tarasoff Case

983 Words4 Pages

Ethical Arguments Regarding Tarasoff Case In 1969 when Prosenjit Poddar informed his psychologist, Dr. Lawrence Moore of his intent to kill Tatiana Tarasoff, a long standing debate began (Beauchamp & Childress, 2001). The death of Tatiana led to a prominent ethical dilemma in terms of the duty to report threats of violence. This issue has many opposing views that attempt to defend the right to confidentiality. Based on religious beliefs, there are also arguments that can be made for how someone with Jewish or Catholic beliefs might feel towards the Tarasoff case. Personally, I believe that no right is above the right to life and that as a medical professional, I believe that you must inform the individual of potential harm. The Tarasoff …show more content…

Due to mental health being a difficult topic for people and the act of seeking out treatment is often a difficult task, confidentiality is needed for individuals to seek out assistance (Beauchamp & Childress, 2001). The reluctance around getting help for mental health concerns is often alleviated by the assurance of confidentiality. Another argument made for the necessity of confidentiality is that it is crucial to allow for full transparency and disclosure from the patient (Beauchamp & Childress, 2001). Due to the nature of psychiatric treatment, a patient must feel comfortable to disclose their innermost thoughts to truly participate in therapy. The final argument made for the need for confidentiality between therapist and patient is due to the ability to form a confidential relationship based on trust (Beauchamp & Childress, 2001). If the therapist breaks that trust by divulging private information, the entire therapeutic relationship is broken and that ability to participate in therapy is severely …show more content…

They both utilize teaching from the Bible and follow commandments. While the healthcare ministry views respecting the sacredness of every human life to be the right of life and adequate health care, there is another angle that this can be viewed in (Ethical and Religious Directives for Catholic Health Care Services, 2009). To respect the sacred human life is to respect their length of life and assist with prolonging a quality life if able. Catholic views also encourage the strive towards the common good (Ethical and Religious Directives for Catholic Health Care Services, 2009). In order to achieve this common good is to ensure protection for fundamental rights of all individuals. A basic fundamental right is the right to life. This indicates that by Catholic ethics a therapist is obligated to ensure longevity of life and the sanctity of the right to

Show More
Related

NAADAC I-2 Informed Consent In Counseling

1121 Words | 5 Pages

Counselors comprehends they are placed with the responsibilities ensuring the rights of each participants and completely well-versed of the approach and directions of their treatment. This will include that all information’s shall be provided in a flawless and comprehensive language as it contains to the limitations, risks and financial costs of all treatment services being render, along with providing realistic substitutions, and most importance the clients rights to decline services and their right to withdraw consent within time frames delineated in the

Read More

Physician Assisted Suicide Summary

1953 Words | 8 Pages

Gill argues that keeping a person healthy cannot be a physician’s only moral duty because in cases of terminal ill patients, they can no longer be treated or healed (372). If a physician’s only duty were to heal patients then they would not tend to the terminally ill because there would be nothing else that they could do, which is something that most people would find to be morally wrong (Gill, 373). No one would be okay with a doctor not helping a person at all who has received a terminal sentence. So instead of promoting health in this case, the physicians must find a way to reduce the suffering of the patient. This means that the physician should be able to reduce the suffering in the way that the patient asks for.

Read More

A Death Of One's Own Movie Analysis

642 Words | 3 Pages

The ethical principle of autonomy provides for respect for the patient’s autonomy to make decisions and choices concerning their life and death. Respecting the patient’s autonomy goes against the principles of beneficence and non-maleficence. There also exists the issue of religious beliefs the patient, family, or the caretaker holds, with which the caretaker has to grapple. The caretaker thus faces issues of fidelity to patient welfare by not abandoning the patient or their family, compassionate provision of pain relief methods, and the moral precept to neither hasten death nor prolong life.

Read More

Sissela Bok's Lying: Moral Choice In Public And Private Life

1070 Words | 5 Pages

She advocates for the goal of disclosure and an atmosphere of openness, hoping to restore trust between the physician and the patient. Communicating truthful information, even if it may be life-changing, will promote more beneficial medical practices. However, she also acknowledges that there may be cases in which concealment of information may be necessary. In such cases, Bok suggests that truthful information should go to someone closely related to the patient which will promote a more open and trusting environment. A concern arises, then, about what the physician should do if the patient explicitly communicates that they do not want to be told about a diagnosis or treatment option even if it may better promote their

Read More

Post Traumatic Transgenders Case Study

1544 Words | 7 Pages

Therefore, we will handle issues of confidentiality with great caution. It is our primary obligation to protect our client 's information and to recognize the limits of the confidentiality. Since we will be conducting a group counseling session, it is not always guaranteed that the other individuals in the group will maintain confidentiality. Consequently, we would make it a point to discuss in every session the importance of confidentiality and the ethical component of their actions (McClanahan, 2014). We will be most understanding with their questions, doubts, and issues in the matter.

Read More

Henry Fonda's Arguments Against Abortion

696 Words | 3 Pages

Will you suggest that the mother not act upon or even try to save her life put to leave him alone even though he could potentially end her life. Now I believe you wouldn’t such as in the case of the child of not having a clue to what threat he is putting on the mother. The mother wouldn’t just wait for her child to kill her but, act upon it because she herself has the right to life especially if it is being

Read More

Pros And Cons Of Legalizing Physician Assisted Suicide

789 Words | 4 Pages

An example of how important ethics is in the healthcare profession is the Hippocratic oath that all physicians swear to before they start practicing and do their best to adhere to throughout their careers. The Hippocratic oath is an ethical principle that the Greek physician, Hippocrates employed during his practice as a physician. In simple terms, the oath states that a good physician practices ethics through beneficial treatment of patients, passing on of medical knowledge, and establishing doctor-patient confidentiality. Also included in the oath is the promise not to intentionally harm patients; and this is where both arguments for and against physician assisted suicide become ethically complicated and extremely

Read More

Partnership Working In Health And Social Care Essay

461 Words | 2 Pages

By communicating effectively and sharing information, practitioners can ensure that the individual receives a coordinated and comprehensive care. Confidentiality is maintained by respecting the privacy of individuals, not sharing their personal information without their consent and ensuring that all records are kept securely. This is important to protect the rights of individuals and maintain

Read More

Essay On Physician Assisted Suicide

1424 Words | 6 Pages

Most people would agree that taking a human’s life is almost certainly wrong. Despite this, the seemingly obvious moral rule becomes blurry with the mention of ending a terminally ill patient’s life as they wish. Physician-assisted suicide involves a doctor administering drugs to end a patient’s life at their request. Many argue that this is unethical and should remain illegal. By applying their beliefs and opinions on the value of life to explain the necessity for it to be illegal.

Read More

Physician Assisted Suicide Argumentative Essay

1149 Words | 5 Pages

On the other hand, Catholic morals and values can reject assisted suicide. Many Catholics believe that God created you thus only God can take you away from your life. This would hold true even if a patient is suffering and wants to die. Catholics believe that no physician could help kill a patient; only God can take the patient from the Earth. Although some people do belief this, I believe that all humans can make their own choices and if someone’s choice is to die through assisted suicide because they feel that they aren’t getting any better than it should be that patient’s doctor to help get them there.

Read More

The Ethical And Legal Dilemma Of Confidentiality

1059 Words | 5 Pages

The Ethical and Legal Dilemma of Confidentiality Tatum Reynolds Department of Psychology, North Central University PSYC 370: Crisis Counseling Professor Doucette April 30, 2023 In the article When to Break Confidentiality as a Therapist, the authors explain the concept of confidentiality in counseling. The authors also list the exceptions to confidentiality in therapy, describing the legal ethical dilemmas involved. To begin, the TheraNest Team explains that the client-therapist relationship involves legal and therapeutic elements, controlled by laws that require confidentiality (2022). This means that counselors must consider more than what their clients are saying and feeling‒they must take into account laws and ethics that pertain to each particular case.

Read More

Confidentiality In Nursing Essay

2128 Words | 9 Pages

If we as nurses respect the confidentiality of a patient, we should do so for all the patients. However, Griffith (2007) argues that the duty of confidence should not be absolute and nurses should always consider sharing information if required. Though the principle of respecting patient autonomy and their right to confidentiality is broken here, the principle of beneficence and non-maleficence is uphold. Nurses have an obligation to protect patient’s confidentiality but the duty to warn an innocent party of imminent harm is far more critical. Therefore, breaking confidentiality here is potentially doing more good than

Read More

Person Centered Therapy Essay

2624 Words | 11 Pages

Therapists must access their own internal process such as their feelings, attitudes and moods. Therapists’, who are not receptive to the awareness of their flow of thoughts and feelings, will not be able to help clients be aware of theirs (Kahn, 1997, p. 40). Though congruence does not mean that therapists have to share personal issues with clients, a therapist must not conceal their inner process from the client, and not be defensive but transparent (Kahn, 1997, p. 41). By being open sometimes a therapist learns more not only about their client but about themselves

Read More

Argumentative Essay: The Right To Die

1321 Words | 6 Pages

Terminally ill patients have right to die through refusal of medication such as withdrawing a respirator and refusing food and water until dying in about ten to twelve days because of their religion. Being a Christian has a lot to deal with this, especially physicians because the tradition doesn’t allow murder and that only god decides what to give and what to take. It’s hard for them to take their own life because of their own religion. Christianity has a role in both patients and

Read More

Importance Of Confidentiality In Counselling

1090 Words | 5 Pages

It is important for them to put their thoughts aside and place themselves in their client’s feelings and remain empathic. Any individual who are struggling to cope, are all authorized to contact counselling services. As counsellors they have to uphold equal opportunities as they are there to help clients think differently. The importance of confidentiality within counselling is extremely valuable as every individual has the right to say how their information can be accessed. Before starting a counselling session, counsellors agree not to disclose any information with anyone.

Read More

More about Ethical Arguments Regarding Tarasoff Case

Related Topics

Open Document