ipl-logo

Ethical Egoism Flaws

1335 Words6 Pages

Ethical Egoism was attempted to be introduced as a functional ethical theory. Unfortunately, it was embedded with several flaws that deemed it unfit to provide a good guide to action for people. The theory’s premise contains several objections that cause a contradiction paradox. Therefore, the purpose of this essay is to provide insight of how these contradictions prove the flaws of this theory.
To understand the objections towards the theory of Ethical Egoism, we first need to understand what the theory emphasizes. The person who created the theory of Ethical Egoism is Ayn Rand. This woman was of Russian Jew decent, hereby witnessed the cultural revolution in Russia. Rand witnessed millions starve to death under the Communist Government …show more content…

Altruism translates to uphold the interest of others by sacrificing your own. This causes you to be a selfless person since you are no longer seeking your own best self-interest. According to Rand’s theory all Altruistic actions are immoral. Since Altruism was added to the equation of Ethical Egoism, the theory had to provide reasoning as to why Altruism may be permissible. The theory explains that perhaps one might be obligated to help others, but it must maximize our long term self-interest. The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy states “Each person needs the cooperation of others to obtain goods such as defense or friendship. If I act as if I give no weight to others, others will not cooperate with me” (2014). It is explained that the reason for cooperating is in order to gain something, and to pretend that one values the self-interest of others. It appears to be that the meaning of weight is allowing other people to think that they should act in the best self-interest of X person. Hence, X person’s egoism is returned as the other person may perceive their good deeds towards X person as Altruistic.
At this point we can clearly see that the theory fails to provide a guide to action. The theory provides the primary premise. It also attempts to justify the reasoning behind its actions, yet there is absolutely no consistency in what one should do. The lack of consistency is attributed to the plethora of contradictions that it contains. These contradictions are the base of why this theory has failed to be an ethical theory. Ethical egoism already has several objections that point out the flaws. However, the responses to these objections are what bring the contradictions to the

Show More
Related
756 Words | 4 Pages

What is the meaning of Ego? In today’s world, it means “a person’s sense of self-esteem or self-importance”, it is to be self-centered and care for nothing else except for one's self or, in other terms, being an individualist. Today, people have been told to care for others instead of themselves, but that is not completely true. For example, Prometheus in Anthem by Ayn Rand- is not what one would consider to be a total egotistical person. Searching through different types of definitions and reasons about the definition of ego, the assumption is that egoism is not immoral or virtuous but the balance in between.

Read More
1271 Words | 6 Pages

Nonetheless, no one can speak on behalf of the agent or “even be certain what conscious motives” dictate their actions (Feinberg, 588). Though a psychological egoist would defend that desires are the sole reason for a person to commit an action, non-psychological egoists would respond with the (notion) that certain actions can be self interest driven but others can be purely selfless and

Read More
833 Words | 4 Pages

This theory believes that it is our moral responsibility to help those in need. For example, Peter Singer states this principle “requires us only to prevent what is bad, and not to promote what is good, and it requires this of us only when we can do it without sacrificing anything that is, from the moral point of view, comparably important”

Read More
1278 Words | 6 Pages

Ego is a weed we cultivate for it to ultimately be destroyed. It is said to be the root of our sins, but is really the cause of individuality in this world. Egoists tend to separate themselves from others; we made egos to experience ourselves as different, rather than the ordinary being. Egos are depicted to reflect a bad connotation. In the novella Anthem by Ayn Rand, the protagonist, Equality 7-2521, is an egoist, but not in the way expected.

Read More
514 Words | 3 Pages

“If civilization is to survive, it is the morality of altruism that people must learn to reject.” -Ayn Rand. To be compassionate and unselfish seems to be a noble and magnanimous pursuit. Altruism is admired, it is beautiful, and it is praised.

Read More
1775 Words | 8 Pages

Biologically, altruism is defined any behavior that increases the reproductive fitness of other organisms at the expense of itself. In simpler words, the biological definition of altruism does

Read More
386 Words | 2 Pages

Chapter Three: Egoism was contextualized in Chapter Eleven: Abortion. The concepts presented on egoism somehow shed some light on the motivation a woman might have to resort to abortion, e.g., it would be for the best interest of the woman to pursue her constitutional right to privacy and personal happiness (MacKinnon, 2012). The first part of the chapter on Egoism made me question my motivations behind all the deeds I performed in the past that I thought were ‘good’ and done in the spirit

Read More
799 Words | 4 Pages

Admiral William H. Mcraven addressed the 2014 graduating class at the University of Austin, Texas with more than eight thousand students in attendance. The address given by Adm. Mcraven touched the hearts of millions from all around the world by his inspirational message of how one person can change the world if they simply helped change the lives of ten others in their lifetime. I chose this speech for my rhetorical analysis because of the simple message it portrays, how helping a few can eventually help many. Adm. Mcraven’s address was especially effective for his audience, much due to how he relates to the students by reminiscing of the day he graduated from UT while providing advice for young college graduates preparing to begin their adult lives.

Read More
498 Words | 2 Pages

Instead, ethical egoism turns things around. Rather than the highest moral principle being self-sacrifice, it is the achievement of your own happiness. By a person's happiness will their morality be evident. And it may be that helping others is moral under ethical egoism – but only if it truly is based on the selfish pleasure one may get from it.

Read More
1044 Words | 5 Pages

Ethical Egoism is a simplistic approach to morality which reduces notions of justice and ethics to mere self-indulgent desires. This philological approach asserts that an action which satiates an individual 's desires or inclinations is right, while an action that goes against an individual 's wishes is categorically immoral. In sum, Ethical Egoism puts the individual 's wants, interests, and aspiration at the forefront of morality. The movie Rain Man is riddled with instances and scenarios of the protagonist Charlie Babbitt (Tom Cruise) employing Ethical Egoism. In fact, the entire premise of the movie and the development of the plot rely on Charlie continually using Ethical Egoism to make decisions.

Read More
501 Words | 3 Pages

James Rachels argued that Ethical Egoism is not accepted as a moral theory. Ethical Egoism believes that individuals should live their life, concentrating on whatever brings the most benefit to that individual. Rachels takes for example a racist to disputed Ethical Egoism, which is discriminating treatments are justified when there is a substantial difference between the people. But there is none of them, so racist is an arbitrary as Ethical Egoism is. We cannot find substantial difference between us, so we should aware that other people’s need should be satisfied as mine because of we are the equal.

Read More
1653 Words | 7 Pages

Ethical egoism is a moral theory focused on improving a person’s well-being. There are many arguments for ethical egoism such as the Self-Reliance Argument and the Best Argument for Ethical Egoism, both presented by Shafer-Landau in The Fundamentals of Ethics. However, in this paper I will discuss how objections presented by Shafer-Landau and Dr. Thomas Carson are fatal to ethical egoism, while keeping in mind arguments for this moral theory. I will discuss objections such as ethical egoism permitting or sometimes requiring murder, theft, or rape, in order to promote oneself’s well-being, egoists subconscious belief of their lives being more important than others, and an argument presented in class that if egoists must do what is best for their

Read More
482 Words | 2 Pages

I agree when Rachels says that the best argument in establishing Ethical Egoism as a viable theory of morality is Thomas Hobbes principle that we should do unto others because if we do, others will more likely to do unto us (Pojman and Vaughn, 2014, pg. 527). People should avoid harming others because we should care about the interests of other people for the very same reason we care about our own interests; for their needs and desires are comparable to our own (Pojman and Vaughn, 2014, pg. 532). Therefore, I believe that Rachel makes the better case regarding ethical

Read More
879 Words | 4 Pages

Heroes have always stood out in time as wondrous beings. In literature they possess certain special traits. These traits are ones such as courage, strength, selflessness and intelligence. Theseus an Athenian hero possess some of these great qualities,“... he was as compassionate as he was brave and a man of great intellect as well as great bodily strength” (133).

Read More
1017 Words | 5 Pages

Psychological egoism asserts that people always act selfishly and self-centered. Ethical egoism asserts that people should always act in his or her own self interest. Psychological egoism defines how we are as human beings. It is the prime idea that selfless acts do not exist. It is the belief that all people are selfish.

Read More

More about Ethical Egoism Flaws

Related Topics

Open Document