ipl-logo

Ethical Issues In An Endless Tribal Water Fight

1557 Words7 Pages

Ever since the market economy was introduced, our land and water are no longer managed by the local communities, rather they are regulated by the government. Some may believe that this transition is the ultimate problem to the decline and mistreatment of our water resources and land. Whether it is the main problem or not, one thing is for sure, our current ways of distributing our water and water rights are not as equitable as they should be. Often times the way the government distributes water it not the most efficient way possible. This issue greatly affects the people residing in the Southwest, including tribes from Arizona like the Hopi and the Navajo. One of the Senate Bills that involved the water rights of the two native tribes was …show more content…

In response to this discussion, Senators Kyl and McCain wrote the article, “An Endless Tribal Water Fight,” in hopes of defending the intentions of their bill. On the other hand, Navajo representative, Ed Bencenti wrote the article, “Senate Bill 2109 Seeks to Extinguish Navajo and Hopi Water Rights,” in which he exposes the real intentions of the Senate Bill. Both Kyl and McCain do a good job of presenting their claims to support their interests. However, the intentions of the Senate Bill are not ethical and efficient; instead of attempting to alleviate the issue of the scarcity of water, it is contributing to this problem by taking away the water that belonged to the tribes’ and giving it to coal …show more content…

The top priority of the Senators is clearly not the lives of the Navajo and the Hopi, but rather the “powerful mining and energy corporations” (Bencenti 1). What is more disturbing is that the corporations that Senators Kyl and McCain show interest to are one of the reasons why the water that the Navajo and Hopi tribes used to have access to is no longer readily available. According to Brian H. Hurd’s powerpoint “Who Owns Water? Water in the Southwest States,” a water right is the right to divert and use water beneficially. While it is hard to determine whether or not water is being used beneficially amongst the Southwest states, I would argue that the way the Senators claim to use the water that belongs to the Hopi and Navajo tribes is not beneficial. Giving coal corporations access to the water that belongs to the Hopi and the Navajo will only aid the rapid rates of the scarcity of water. The coal business will use the water to generate electricity; this process pollutes and effects the quality of the waters and wells that used to be readily available to people like the Navajo and the Hopi. The coal corporation is also violating one of the cornerstones suggested in Hurd’s powerpoint which states “new appropriations…must not harm, impair, damage, or diminish the rights of other appropriators.” The fact that the Bill plans on taking away the water of the Hopi and Navajo tribes and

Show More
Related
617 Words | 3 Pages

The song “Don’t Drink the Water”, by Dave Matthews can be viewed as reflecting a common theme during the late 1800s and early 1900s; Native Americans being forced to give up and move off of their land. Although this idea reflects the reality of what happened during this time period, it does not accurately reflect the two land policies that the US government passed regarding settlers in the West. The first of these two acts, the Homestead Act, gave settlers 160 acres of public land in exchange for a small filing fee and the promise to live on the land for at least five years. Or, the settlers could buy the land from the government for $1.25 an acre after living on it for six months. Thousands of people took advantage of this act, including many exodusters, or

Read More
284 Words | 2 Pages

In “Wrong assumptions,” Art Cullen, an editor of The Storm Lake Times, disputed Gov. Terry Branstad’s strategy to resolve the problems of polluted landscapes and contaminated water in Des Moines, Iowa. As a citizen of Iowa, Cullen is concern about the effects the controversy might influence not only his daily life but also the residents and community. Despite Cullen commending Branstad’s efforts to solving this conflict, Cullen points out that there were flaws in Branstad’s plan by stating in the article that “We have a few problems with the assumptions (Cullen, para 2).” In addition, Cullen suggested that the foremost solution would be using the Clean Water Act as the main point to how they will resolve their complications in the most fashionable

Read More
2026 Words | 9 Pages

With the construction of this pipeline going right over the Ogallala aquifer, this puts Nebraska landowners at risk of not only contaminating their drinking water, but their irrigation water for their crops, too. The Ogallala aquifer is “one of the world’s largest known aquifers and the primary source of groundwater for approximately 20 percent of U.S. agricultural production” (Keystone 295). This puts Nebraska land owners at risk of not only contaminating their drinking water, but also “jeopardizing its use for farming” (Keystone

Read More
897 Words | 4 Pages

Annotated Bibliography Topic/Case Study: Edwards Aquifer v. Day Thesis Statement: Public opinion can be swayed for or against withholding property rights in Texas, but the role of the officials in the Texas Political system is to focus on the greater good of all Texans; in this case, since the aquifer does no stop or originate on Day’s land, he should forfeit the right to uphold the water from serving the people of Texas. Sources BOADU, F., MCCARL, B., & GILLIG, D. (2007). An Empirical Investigation of Institutional Change in Groundwater Management in Texas: The Edwards Aquifer Case. Natural Resources Journal, 47(1), 117-163.

Read More
1678 Words | 7 Pages

Yuma, Arizona a state that was officially established in 1912 came to be one of the most and main important areas in irrigation and agricultural history as it grew and progressed and was founded by many. All Southern Arizona contributed to the significance of this history along with Yuma as well. With the Colorado River as the main supply and running through these areas supplying water creating other dams and canals such as the Yuma Siphon, Yuma Main Canal, Laguna Dam, All American Canal etc. Question Number one, Describe in detail how irrigation changed Yuma/ South Arizona.

Read More
754 Words | 4 Pages

In this article of “The New Water Czars” by Daniel Kraker explains about the historic water of the Indian community be brought back to its roots or just be turned into a big power broker. He begins to explain how the operations of the Gila River Indian Community are a big agriculture in the south of Arizona. There is a settlement that has been nearly 80 years in the making trying to help the community fewer than 20,000 with more than 650,000 acre-feet of water enough to serve the residential needs of almost 3 million people. In that case it will put the Pima and Maricopa people in a place of marvelous power.

Read More
1376 Words | 6 Pages

Hopi Tribe v Snowbowl Resort LTD. Issue: The issue is whether the tribe has sufficient standing to bring a common law public nuisance claim against the defendants. Rule: The use of reclaimed wastewater causes tribal members a special injury, different in kind from that suffered by the general public by interfering with places of special cultural and religious significance. Discussion: Gravity of the harm:

Read More
778 Words | 4 Pages

The confusing part is, is that the government spends $1,000,000 flying in bottled water. Instead of giving these First Nations only $250,000 to fix their treatment plant give them some of the $1,000,000 that 's spent

Read More
1198 Words | 5 Pages

In Senator Jay Rockefeller’s statement on Inhofe Resolution, Rockefeller argues that the resolution of disapproval is unsafe and a threat to many jobs of West Virginians. This sixteen minute speech was given on June 20, 2012 in front of the state senate. The Inhofe Resolution of disapproval is a resolution wanting to block the Environmental Protection Agency’s MACS or MACT rule. The rule limits mercury, acid gases, and other toxic pollution from power plants. The resolution of disapproval was proposed by Senator James Inhofe, who wanted to block the rule to “end Obama’s war on coal.”

Read More
965 Words | 4 Pages

In the book Coming of Age in Mississippi, author Anne Moody tells her life story growing up in the American South and how her experiences lead to her becoming a civil rights activist during the Civil Rights Movement. She grew up on a plantation, in a community of sharecroppers. Her parents worked as sharecroppers, and after her father left the family with another woman, Anne, her mother, and her siblings move to various houses in six years. While her mom got a waitress and maid job, their family still suffered in poverty. They usually ate food such as bread and beans, which Toosweet brought home from the restaurant.

Read More
470 Words | 2 Pages

The government is backing out of its agreement. You left us on land that is too small a size and most of it cannot be farmed. The government should give more land back, not kick us off the leftovers” (Erdrich 197). The Indian tribe members are irritated with the Termination bill and attempt to communicate their thoughts with the Government. Additional members speak up with their concerns about the bill and they take a vote.

Read More
1245 Words | 5 Pages

The environment is one of the key points of our energy productions; without it, the U.S and other countries won’t get their resources they need to survive. But there are some people who don’t want hydropower to block waterways and want the dams that produces energy to be torn down. In “Stop Wasting America’s Hydropower potential” it talks about the environmental issue it has from a certain group who wants dams to be torn down. “Compounding the roadblocks are environmental groups that claim to adhere to sound science but hold remarkably outdated views of hydropower and its benefits. Rather than acknowledge technological advances and the environmental safeguards in our laws, these groups have filed lawsuits to dismantle dams or stop their construction” (Murkowski 8).

Read More
246 Words | 1 Pages

Throughout American history treaties have been signed in an effort to “protect” the Lakota Nation and their land. However, these treaties have continuously been violated and the amount of land the Lakota have been allowed to occupy has continued to shrink. In 1851 the treaty of Fort Laramie was signed, which set the boundaries for the Lakota nation. Nine years later, this treaty was not even brought into consideration when the government allowed the Transcontinental Railroad to travel through the Lakota territory. Less than a decade had passed when the Indian Appropriation Act was signed.

Read More
670 Words | 3 Pages

The government’s mishaps don’t stop with casinos. The Sioux do not deserve for their water to be contaminated. Originally the government intended for the pipeline to pass through Bismarck, yet the risk of contamination in states capitol lead to relocation through reservations (Sidder). Unlike the BP oil spill that affected many animals, an oil spill of the North Dakota Access Pipeline would affect humans. We are to question are federal laws protecting indigenous land doing their justice?

Read More
487 Words | 2 Pages

Congress passed the treaty in order to relocate the Indian tribes living east of the Mississippi River to lands in the west. Although, the act did not order the removal of the Indians, it did allow the president to negotiate land by exchanging treaties with tribes living within the boundaries of the states ” (2008-2015). This shows that the government did not have the right to do what they

Read More

More about Ethical Issues In An Endless Tribal Water Fight

Open Document