ipl-logo

Ethical Issues In The End Of Sex

919 Words4 Pages

In his book The End of Sex and the Future of Human Reproduction, Hank Greely conceives of a future where sex is no longer the source for creating babies. Instead, babies will be created through preimplantation genetic diagnosis (PGD) and in vitro fertilization (IVF). While these procedures are seen as a solution for overcoming infertility and other reproductive barriers, these procedures also have ethical implications. The purpose of this essay is to explicate these ethical issues and to engage with Greely’s presentation. In doing so, I will summarize Greely’s presentation and envision what Greely’s work would look like through a feminist lens. At the onset of his presentation, Greely sets the stage, by disclaiming that “the end of sex” does …show more content…

A woman’s or man’s decision to procreate is not made in a vacuum. The decision is made in the context of that individual’s personal life, the life of that individual’s partner (if there is a partner) and the wider societal context. Since reproductive autonomy expands beyond the parents, more discussion needs to focus on relational autonomy. Relational autonomy recognizes that an individual is free to make life goals and act upon these goals, however individuals are also socially situated. Sometimes the decision an individual makes, is not completely free. All decisions are made by social constraints and even though PGD and IVF are an option for some, not all individuals have an actual choice due to financial constraints. Moreover, the parents’ autonomy must be weighed against the child’s future autonomy. But, the problem of PGD and IVF is not solely …show more content…

Though Greely mentions fairness issues, PGD and IVF can lead to not only a justice issue in terms of fairness, but also reproductive injustice and structural injustice. Despite having a constitutional right to procreate and to parent, physicians can turn individuals away from IVF due to their sexual orientation and their marital status. By allowing physicians to refuse to aid non-traditional heterosexual couples, states have allowed physicians to determine who should be allowed to be a parent and who should not - thereby maintaining the idea of what a family is “supposed” to look like. So, not only does PGD and IVF allow for the potential for physicians to discriminate against which individuals should have access to these technologies, but also in regard to what kind of babies should be born, i.e. babies without certain disorders and without disabilities. But, who is to say which kinds of lives are worth living and which are not? Whose voices will be heard and listened to if we as a society are drawing this line? While Greely acknowledges that society’s view of disabilities has an effect on fairness, Greely does not acknowledge how intersectionality plays a vital role in PGD and IVF. “These socially constructed identities, [i.e. sexuality, race, gender, ableism etc.,] overlap and create an interdependent system of

Show More
Related
257 Words | 2 Pages

Jessica Cohen, a graduate of Yale, has written the essay “Grade A: The Market for a Women’s Eggs” regarding her experience on donating her eggs to a fastidious infertile couple. The primary reason for her consideration was $25,000 that the couple was willing to pay for the right donor. Although such large amount of money sounds extraordinary to a college student, Cohen wasn’t qualified for the couple’s satisfaction due to her credentials therefore Cohen would not be creating their “perfect child”. She explains many viewpoints of the process of egg donation, health risks correlating with egg donation, and the medical process of conception from donated eggs. After all, creating the ideal child is too easy especially if the person can afford it.

Read More
1351 Words | 6 Pages

In her pilgrimage to fight for women’s rights, activist Margaret Sanger created a speech on a severely controversial topic not only during her time period, but during our present time period as well. While many firmly disagreed with her and still do, she did bring to light a major disparity between sexes and social classes. By vocalizing her qualms with the rights of women, mainly in the middle and lower classes, to decide for themselves if they wish to have children or not. By voicing her opinions in an extremely misogynistic era she made herself a totem in women’s history. Women do have a right to decide for themselves if they wish to have children or not.

Read More
1529 Words | 7 Pages

Such considerations fundamentally shape human life and family relationships. A women needs to be aware of the various psychological and social factors that contribute to the decision such as “that human parents, both male and female, tend to care passionately about their offspring, and that family relationships are among the deepest and strongest in our lives—and, significantly, among the longest lasting.” These key intrinsic goods- in this case factors such as human life, parenthood, and family relationships- are ultimately worthwhile are not to be taken without due

Read More
1206 Words | 5 Pages

There are many disagreements on how to handle unplanned pregnancies and abortions is one of the options that sparks a lot of controversy. Many women seek abortions due to the fact that they aren’t financially stable or having a baby will interfere with their work or school. Elizabeth Stoker Bruenig, a journalist for The American Conservative, argues that providing an allowance to women who aren’t financially stable to help care for their kid will help reduce the amount of abortions low-income women have. One thing that is not taken not account is the household the new child will be entering and the emotional stability of the mother. Starting from their teenage years both women and men should be educated on ways to prevent unplanned pregnancies

Read More
798 Words | 4 Pages

.. The exercise of her right to decide how many children she will have and when she shall have them will procure for her the time necessary to that developmental of other faculties than that of reproduction.” (Young, 277) Going back on the phrase voluntary motherhood, Sanger stresses the ideas of woman getting to choose what happens with their bodies. They should be allowed who they wish to have a child with, when and even how many children they wish to have. This is very important because during that time woman did not have much control even though it was their body they were looked down upon when it came to abortions or contraceptives.

Read More
1267 Words | 6 Pages

Rather than stating the argument, Willis poses it as a question, “Are the fetuses the moral equivalent of born human beings?” (Abortion Debate 76), thus showing how modern feminists can only support one side of the argument in their chosen stance, and cause limitations by doing so. In doing so, Willis shows how to some “extent… we objectify our enemy and define the terms of our struggle as might makes right, the struggle misses its point” (Ministries of Fear 210), which implies that feminists have completely missed the point of the argument by getting caught up in an answer. Rather than looking for a compromise or gray area, they exert their stance as the only solution that woman can have. Willis also shows how feminists fundamentally “see the primary goal of feminism as freeing omen from the imposition of so called ‘male values’, and creating an alternative culture based on ‘female values’”

Read More
692 Words | 3 Pages

Why would a business decide to subscribe to Fan CONNECT? Let's take a moment to talk this out and you be the judge if it makes sense to you. Let's start first with identifying what restaurants and retailers want. There are 3 things every business wants and they are all tied together. More sales, customers, and profits.

Read More
516 Words | 3 Pages

The girls in favor of pro-choice shared that sometimes these children are left without parents. They are either left in orphanages or in foster care. Not all children have the right support and may feel unwanted as they grow up. Furthermore, some families cannot afford to have a child because they are not financially stabled. Some people feel they are not prepared to be parents.

Read More
499 Words | 2 Pages

When it comes to women getting pregnant they need options like whether they want to keep their baby, put their baby up for adoption,

Read More
228 Words | 1 Pages

Have you ever wondered if Thomas Edison?s statements support the idea of student-centered learning. Edison says you have to keep working and learn from mistakes just like student-centered learning. I?m going to tell all about how Edison?s statements support the ideas of student-centered learning. This is one of Edison?s statements that support the ideas of student-centered learning. According to the text ?

Read More
1444 Words | 6 Pages

Fortunately, there are other methods to having kids, such as adoption. II. Thesis

Read More
2187 Words | 9 Pages

III. The support side of the Teenage Pregnancy strategy was backed up by an intervention that targeted areas of high deprivation with high conception areas. This would help pilot a government initiative that aimed to reduce the risk of long-term social exclusion associated with teenage pregnancy that helped by providing intensive support for parents and children to help them with housing, healthcare, parenting skills, education and child care. (1) “The claim that all humans, whatever their race, gender, religion, or age, have the right to life seems evident enough”.

Read More
930 Words | 4 Pages

While some people belief that by using IVF the people are destroying the natural cycle of life. They belief that a baby should be born through a natural process and that by using IVF the people are “playing God”. They also argue that IVF “dehumanize women and reduce them to empty vessels waiting to be filled with babies for the benefit of men” (Farris Naff 19). They believe that women go through the process of IVF because they want to satisfy their partner instead of themselves. Even though, IVF can be convenient for women, it is known that IVF can have some bad outcomes to some.

Read More
1042 Words | 5 Pages

Everyone is entitled to choose their own lifestyle, whether they want to have a child or not. Some females who seek to have children find it easy, although some are unfortunate. There are numerous of reasonings, such as being too old to be pregnant, damage to the Fallopian tube or uterus and cancer radiation or chemotherapy. As our generation goes on, many discoveries revolving biology is produced and one of it is the In Vitro Fertilization or “IVF”. It is the procedure of fertilization where they save sperm sample, take an egg from the women and physically combining it in a laboratory dish where the egg and the sperm is now called an embryo.

Read More
593 Words | 3 Pages

Why are we so against arranged marriages but so for a woman keeping a child she doesn’t want or can’t support? Thesis Statement The stigma and laws against should be lifted because it should be solely the parents’ or woman’s decision, it has been beneficial in many cases and the betterment of the life already being lived should take residence over the embryo’s possible life.

Read More

More about Ethical Issues In The End Of Sex

Related Topics

Open Document