ipl-logo

Evaluating Our Reconstruction Plan Improved Many Aspects Of The Original One

694 Words3 Pages

Evaluating Our Reconstruction Plan Despite the fact that our Reconstruction Plan improved many aspects of the original one, there were still some pitfalls within it. Our plan had the pitfall of requiring southerners to accept paying higher taxes in return of employing the modified Freedmen's Bureau. Southerners will dislike this as they'll have to pay for the freedmen's support. Since southerners are also racist, they will not appreciate having to pay for freedmen’s benefits. They will likely not abide by these terms, so a compromise might be necessary. Though, freedmen need additional benefits due to practically starting off of nothing in society. Another pitfall in our plan is the requirement that two-thirds of the population in the southern …show more content…

Our Reconstruction Plan differed from the original plan by making two-thirds of the southern states’ population take an oath of allegiance to the Union, rather than the ten percent that the old plan required. This makes it harder for southern states to be readmitted into the Union. The 10% Plan made it too easy for the South to rejoin the Union and gain political power once more. After being readmitted into the Union, southern political power rose drastically. This resulted in the South having more control over the former Confederate land, leaving black people to be controlled and taken advantage of due to the fact that their government was racist. With our plan, the South does not gain as much power and it will take time for all southern states to rejoin. Another aspect of the Reconstruction Plan that our group did better in was making sure new amendments were enforced. Increased and stronger military occupation in the South could make it so the new amendments were enforced and white supremacist groups would be controlled and ended. This did not happen with the original plan, meaning discrimination and terrorism against black people ran rampant. Though, the original Reconstruction had done better at making sure the Freedmen’s Bureau did not affect southerners as much. The original plan made sure that freedmen got their land without harming the South. With our plan, we provided more benefits, but at the same time would have made the South angry because we would have made them pay higher taxes. This could have led to another outrage and possibly another secession. If secession did not occur, then most likely white supremacist groups would have increased and done much more terrorist attacks. In conclusion, even though we significantly improved upon the initial Reconstruction Plan, there were

Show More
Related

Congress Plan Pros And Cons

213 Words | 1 Pages

Although most of the plans Congress has come up with are good, all plans have cons, even congress 's. Since the right to vote was given to the freedmen and made them citizens they are going to be treated equally. The Southerners very recently considered the freedmen as their slaves and won 't like the idea of them be equals. The southern states get to keep their property but they have to pay for the damages. They are losing

Read More

How Did Abraham Lincoln's Plan For Reconstruction

260 Words | 2 Pages

This week I was going to bring Abraham Lincoln 's plan for reconstruction to the table. It is said that Lincoln started to plan for reconstruction post war. The plan was to address three key areas for concern. First the proclamation allowed full pardon and restoration of any property to anyone who was considered a rebellion or a member of the confederate army with exception of the highest officials and leaders (which is interesting). It also allowed for a state government to be formed once ten percent of the population took an oath of allegiance to the United States, and it encouraged the southern states to deal with slaves in such a way that it would not compromise their freedom.

Read More

Compare And Contrast Presidential And Congressional Reconstruction Plans

200 Words | 1 Pages

The Presidential Reconstruction and Congressional Reconstruction plans were frequently different from one another. As I continue, I will state in my opinion the most significant differences between the two plans. To begin, Lincoln and Johnson’s plans were far too lenient with the Confederate states. The Presidential Reconstruction plan under Johnson allowed former Confederate states to be part of the Union, when they accepted the 13th amendment and swore to the Union. While, the Congressional Reconstruction plan was to allow those states to rejoin the Union if and only when they accepted the 13th, 14th, and 15th amendments.

Read More

Compare And Contrast Andrew Johnson's Reconstruction Plan

747 Words | 3 Pages

Abraham Lincoln’s vs Andrew Johnson’s Reconstruction Plan Lincoln shared the uncommon belief that the confederate states could still be part of the union and that the cause of the rebellion was only a few within the states which lead him to begin the reconstruction in December of 1863. This resulted in plans with lenient guidelines and although they were challenged by Wade-Davis Bill, Lincoln still rejected his ideas and kept his policies in place. Lincoln also allowed land to be given the newly freed slave or homeless white by distributing the land that had been confiscated from former land owners however this fell through once Johnson took office. After Lincoln’s death when Johnson was elected many things started to turn away from giving blacks equal rights and resulted in many things such a black codes which kept newly freed slaves from having the same rights as whites. When Lincoln first acted after the civil war, he offered policies that would allow the confederate slaves to become part of the union again and would allow a pardon for those states.

Read More

Reconstruction Dbq Essay

1152 Words | 5 Pages

By 1877 the congressional reconstruction plan set in motion by radical republicans ended by the compromise of 1877 in the United States of America. The congressional reconstruction plan had aimed to better the lives of freedmen in the United States of America, and essentially equal to their white counterparts, I think it was unsuccessful attempt, because of how the lives of the slaves turned out to be and how it allowed for the creation of the Black codes. The reconstruction plan had aimed to abolish slavery, Freedman's bureau to raise living standards and lastly provide voting rights. Before the 13th amendment there was no law that stated that African Americans were free, they were called freedman, and the lives of the slaves weren't dogmatic.

Read More

Reconstruction Dbq

769 Words | 4 Pages

Reconstruction from 1865 to 1877 aimed to reunify, or rather reconstruct, the Union following the Civil War and abolishment of slavery. The goal of Abraham Lincoln, the president who introduced the 10% plan and charted the Freedmen’s Bureau, was to introduce the Confederate States back into the United States, ensure their loyalty, and improve Black people’s conditions. The ratification of the 13th, 14th, and 15th amendments, as well as the establishment of the Freedmen’s Bureau and other educational reforms, gave way to a rise of radical Republicanism that introduced bold and transformative actions that were unheard of. Although the impact and success were limited to its premature end by the 1877 Compromise, the fundamentals of Reconstruction

Read More

Reconstruction Dbq

953 Words | 4 Pages

The Reconstruction, one of the roughest and controversial era in American history, took place after the Civil War between 1865 and 1877. This began the process of bringing the Nation back together and giving former slaves equals rights by three new Constitutional amendments.    From the beginning of the Civil War in 1861, Lincoln’s goal was the restoration of the Confederate states to the Union. In 1863, Lincoln proposed the Ten Percent Plan that granted amnesty to those Confederate states which swore an oath of allegiance to the Union. It would have given a general pardon to all southerners excluding high-ranking Confederate army officers and government officials.

Read More

Short And Long Term Effects Of The Reconstruction Plan

1746 Words | 7 Pages

When the Civil War ended, the southern states were obviously in difficulty because of it. The southern states were in ruins because of the war. The war was so chaotic that it destroyed so much businesses, homes, hospitals exc. It had a scar in history and even to this day, it still had its effects. So President Abraham Lincoln pulled thorugh with his promise and a successful plan was created, The official plan called the Reconstruction plan.

Read More

Impact Of The 10 % Plan

597 Words | 3 Pages

One plan of Reconstruction that had an impact was Lincoln’s original plan. Lincoln’s plan was named The 10% plan. The 10% plan was the first plan to be used and was favored in the South because it was not severe and very easy. Lincoln’s plan was that 10% of white voters in the South had to take an oath of loyalty to the U.S. to be able to join it again and any Confederates who served would be offered amnesty, this included everyone but the leaders who would get punished but only minimal amount. If the state swore loyalty they would again be a U.S. state which means that they would get a representative in Congress.

Read More

Reconstruction: A Success Or Failure

281 Words | 2 Pages

In my opinion I believe that the reconstruction was both a success and also a fail. The reason that it was a success was the simple fact that the United States got its name back again. The reconstruction era helped the United States become a unified nation. Another pro from this era was the fact that the North and the South no longer had any form of separation. During this time, three new amendments were added to the constitution.

Read More

Radical Republican Restoration

460 Words | 2 Pages

To repair a country that has been split in half requires making significant strides that will create harmony between both sides. After the American Civil War multiple phases were required in order to mend the broken country. These phases were Presidential Reconstruction and Radical Republican Restoration. Presidential Reconstruction was the reconstruction plan put in place by President Johnson who had to step into the role of the man who would fix the country after Lincoln’s assignation. While Johnson’s reconstruction plan did not anger the southerners whom he was trying to get to support, his methods were too lenient towards the south as he allowed for mostly states rights.

Read More

Was Reconstruction A Success Or Failure Essay

664 Words | 3 Pages

But after 30 years, there were none. Reconstruction was also a success because it Restored the U.S as a unified nation, as stated in Reconstruction (1865-1877) by sparknote, “Reconstruction was a success in that it restored the United States as a unified nation” This evidence shows that reconstruction was also a success because because it Unified the United States, there were new laws invented by it. Reconstruction failed mostly, but had some good outcomes, it failed because of the president and not treating racism seriously. But there were some good things that

Read More

Essay On Was Reconstruction A Success Or A Failure

539 Words | 3 Pages

After the Union won the major battles that is when Lincoln had put the ten percent plan on the table, this plan was when ten percent of the state’s eligible voters pledge oath to US then they could join the Union. To begin with, there are a few reasons why one would say that reconstruction in the south was a failure. One of these reasons being that, even after the civil war in the South’s government passed laws to limit the rights of the free African Americans. In document C we can see this is evident where it states “No negro or freedmen shall be allowed to come within the limits of the town of Opelousas without special permission of his employers. Whoever breaks this law will go to jail and work for two days on the public streets, or pay a fine of five dollars.”

Read More

Economic Inequality During The Reconstruction Era

1464 Words | 6 Pages

Although many attempts were made to prioritize freedom and equality for all, these values were undermined by racist Southerners who wouldn’t accept equality. In the end, Reconstruction had failed and former slaves endured another hardship akin to slavery. However, Reconstruction still could have prospered. There are multiple events that, if they had occurred, Reconstruction would not have failed. For example, had the government continued to fund the Freedmen’s Bureau, then the South would have legislated their discriminatory laws much later, if not at all.

Read More

Essay On Failures Of Reconstruction

835 Words | 4 Pages

Reconstruction caused prejudice and inequality. To elaborate, the creation of the Ku Klux Klan and the Black Codes were both in the time period of reconstruction, which caused chaos and violence throughout the Union. One of the goals of reconstruction was to repair the economy in the South, because it depended on slavery, which was now illegal, due to the thirteenth amendment. The South’s economic system now depended on Sharecropping, which caused former slaves to be in constant debt and was unjust to the black society. The reconstruction time period, was a time of dispute between the Union.

Read More

More about Evaluating Our Reconstruction Plan Improved Many Aspects Of The Original One

Related Topics

Open Document