ipl-logo

Examples Of Obedience In Hamlet

1502 Words7 Pages

Mark Sun
Deborah Cox
ENG4U1
8, January 2023
An Exploration of the Usage of the Word “Obey” in Hamlet
In Hamlet by William Shakespeare, Ophelia, Rosencrantz, Guildenstern, and Hamlet are subservient to Claudius and Polonius. Polonius and Ophelia’s conversation, Rosencrantz and Guildenstern’s service for Claudius, Hamlet’s pursuit of revenge, and these characters’ usage of the word “obey'', demonstrates the characters’ understanding of their expected obedience towards Claudius and Polonius. The characters’ behavior that then arises from their understanding of obedience is illustrative of how authority figures such as Claudius and Polonius enforce compliance when the people disagree with their decisions. Ophelia’s usage of “obey”, and her conversation …show more content…

Ophelia is like this because of Polonius’s manipulations. Polonius’ and Ophelia’s conversation in Act One demonstrates the results of his manipulations and shows Ophelia’s understanding of obedience to the audience. For whatever reason, Polonius does not want Ophelia to be in a relationship with Hamlet. So he stops their relationship by making Ophelia question herself and follows his orders. Polonius manipulates Ophelia by making her think that she invalidates her family’s honor, that she does not know anything, and that Hamlet is manipulating her among other things he says. When Ophelia says, “I do not know… what I should think” (I.iii.104), it indicates that these techniques work. Polonius instills the idea that he is always more right than Ophelia through a variety of techniques. Some of the techniques he uses during this scene are, “scare tactics” and, “gaslighting”. He scares Ophelia that she endangers her honor by loving Hamlet, and “gaslights” Ophelia by telling her that everything she knows about Hamlet is wrong and that she should trust …show more content…

This understanding also demonstrates how rulers like Claudius can use financial incentives to enforce their decisions. Like Ophelia, Rosencrantz and Guildenstern also use the word “obey” in an affirmative manner; however, whereas Ophelia serves Polonius because she believes it is the right thing to do partly due to her believing it as her duty as a daughter and partly because of Polonius’ manipulations, Rosencrantz and Guildenstern obey the king for personal gain. Claudius promises them, “such thanks / As fits a king’s remembrance” (II.ii.25-26) in exchange for their services to spy on Hamlet and help Claudius. Whether they are aware of Claudius’ schemes or not and whether they truly want to help Hamlet or not is arguable in Act Two. However, by Act Four, where they knowingly escort Hamlet to exile and where Hamlet labels them as a, “sponge” (IV.ii.13) for the king; they are not on Hamlet’s side and are willingly helping Claudius harm their past best friends for their benefit. These events show that Rosencrantz and Guildenstern simply view obedience as a transaction, they will do whatever anyone demands of them, no matter how morally reprehensible, as long as it is profitable. They are mercenaries. Rosencrantz and Guildenstern’s

Show More
Related
714 Words | 3 Pages

When having a conversation with Ophelia, Polonius says, “I would not, in plain terms, from this time forth/ Have you so slander any moment leisure/ As to give words or talk with the lord Hamlet./ Look to’t, I chanrge you. Come your ways.” (I.III.138-141). This quote shows how Polonius is manipulating Ophelia into not ever talking to Hamlet ever again.

Read More
1178 Words | 5 Pages

In 1.2 King Claudius gives speech addressing his brother’s death and the war potential in Denmark without sign of guilt and recognize what he have done to obtain this power. Similarly when Claudius witness the strange action of hamlet he send rosencrantz and guildenstern who are Hamlet best friends to spy on Hamlet even though they are doing what the king is asking they look suspicious to Hamlet which cause the break point in their relationship which cause their death. “To draw him on to pleasures and to gather, so much as from occasion you may glean, whether aught to us unknown afflicts him thus that , opened, lies within our

Read More
794 Words | 4 Pages

This quote describes the fact that Ophelia is incapable of resisting, she has to take part in the plan to test Hamlet because her father and Claudius manipulate her to do so. Hamlet also talks down on her “I have heard of your paintings well enough; God hath given you one face, and you make yourselves another: you jig, you amble, and you lisp, you nickname God’s creatures, and make your wantonness your ignorance” (III. i.144-148). This quotes shows how Hamlet talks to Ophelia and brings her down, but no matter what he says to her she will still love him because Hamlet has Ophelia

Read More
311 Words | 2 Pages

In this passage, Hamlet warns Rosencrantz of the dangers of working with Claudius. He knows that Rosencrantz is spying on him for hopes of winning the king’s “rewards” and “authorities”. As such, he warns that Claudius will hold those favors “in the corner of his jaw”, and thus keep complete control over them rather than give them out. It is important to note that in this scene, Rosencrantz essentially confronts Hamlet for the murder of Polonius, yet Hamlet shows no signs of defensiveness. Rather, he tries to protect Rosencrantz from Claudius.

Read More
939 Words | 4 Pages

Ophelia’s character went through quite a large transformation. In the play her father tells her that she is to stay away from Hamlet and she readily agrees. In the movie Ophelia doesn’t disagree with her father but she also doesn’t agree just to please him. This shows that Ophelia isn’t easily persuaded, even by her own father. Despite her father’s warning about Hamlet, Ophelia met with him in secret at her apartment until her father found out.

Read More
436 Words | 2 Pages

During this scene, we see Ophelia literally melting into Larates arms, this helps show the intent by showing how truly upset she is about her fathers death, and that she's not crazy she just needs time to grief. A version that did not do as well of showing this is the Branagh version. In the Branagh version Ophelia was talking about the flowers, but there was nothing there making her seem delusional, this did not fit well because the setting and context just don't fit with the character

Read More
2136 Words | 9 Pages

Polonius and Claudius are willing to sacrifice the well being of their family members for the benefit of the court, highlighting the way in which loyalty to the ruling class takes precedence over personal relationships. They are both concerned with maintaining and enforcing societal norms, reflecting the way in which the ruling class rules over those beneath them in the societal ladder. This evidence is pungent in the act of Polonius spying on his daughter to ensure she is behaving appropriately. Both Claudius and Polonius serve as antagonists in some form to Hamlet, but they both have different motivations and actions. Polonius is the chief counselor to King Claudius, and father to Ophelia and Laertes.

Read More
897 Words | 4 Pages

The Price of Power Power comes in many different shapes and forms. Whether it is the king of a nation, or a manipulative assassin, or even a pawn granted vengeance, power can be acquired in many ways. This is especially true in Hamlet by Shakespeare, where many different characters acquired their power in many different ways at the detriment of each other and others. In Galatians 5:22, we read about the fruit of the spirit and how God expects humanity to live; in love, peace, goodness, and self control to name a few (Galatians 5:22). In the play, “Hamlet” as Claudius, Hamlet, and Laertes rise to power, it comes at the expense of many others, including themselves, as a consequence for not following the command God has given to humanity.

Read More
1202 Words | 5 Pages

Unfortunately for Hamlet, Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are motivated by greed, not love. From the very beginning they were willing to do or say whatever is necessary to endear themselves to King Claudius. Upon their arrival, Rosencrantz attempts to curry favor by saying, "Both your majesties Might, by the sovereign power you have of us, Put your dread pleasures more into command Than to entreaty," with Guildenstern adding, "But we both obey And here give up ourselves, in the full bent, To lay our service freely at your feet To be commanded" (2.2.25-32). Enacting Claudius' every order may bring them the wealth and social status advancement that they so desperately desire, but only at Hamlet's expense. Conversely, Horatio put himself in danger every time Hamlet was in need.

Read More
192 Words | 1 Pages

He now sees it as his job to disabuse her of the notion that Hamlet could be acting honourable. With good intentions. Despite Ophelia’s defence of the Prince, her father dismisses the Laertes’ words with a cynical metaphor, saying that Hamlet’s apparent earnestness is merely a ply to catch Ophelia, a silly bird Drawing upon his own experiences when he was young, Polonius appears to be judging Hamlet by his own base standards, again echoing what his son had earlier said to Ophelia. A woman should bring honor and fortune to her family, and the image Ophelia gives off for him very much concerns Polonius. Both Laertes and Polonius tell her that the man that she loves is using her.

Read More
716 Words | 3 Pages

(3.1.43-49) Polonius orders Ophelia to distract Hamlet even though he knows the emotional distress it will cause her. He is the reason Ophelia breaks ties with Hamlet, yet he is willing to throw her at him for his own gain. Polonius cannot rationalize that spying on Hamlet is less important than his daughter’s mental stability. His utter selfishness makes him incapable of making rational decisions that are beneficial to both himself, and his children. Polonius gives good advice that he does not take himself, showing his bad decision making.

Read More
277 Words | 2 Pages

For the duration of the play, Ophelia was portrayed as a naïve and submissive woman. Her passivity and powerlessness reinforce the voicelessness of women during the Elizabethan era. For example, “I shall obey, my lord” (I.iii.134) shows that Ophelia concedes to her father’s will, even though she believes Hamlet’s love is genuine. She is willing and expected to obey her father despite the fact that she still loves Hamlet, which emphasizes her character’s submissive nature. Furthermore, in Act I Laertes warns Ophelia that it would be shameful of her to love Hamlet, and she responds with “I shall the effect of this good lesson keep as a watchman to my heart” (I.iii.45).

Read More
1234 Words | 5 Pages

Ophelia was the daughter of polonius, the love interest of hamlet who was brutally torn up mentally throughout the novel. At the beginning of the novel all was well for her as well, her boyfriend was off at college and she was perfectly fine at home with her father. It was until her father took away a note from hamlet to her that things started going downhill. She was a weak person not like hamlet who when faced with injustice takes thing into his own hands to seek justice or revenge. She was a quite simple girl who had a gentler soul.

Read More
672 Words | 3 Pages

This is shown in the quote, “But we both obey, and here give up ourselves, in the full bent, To lay our service freely at your feet To be commanded.” (Act 2 Scene 2 Line 29), and proves that they do not value the friendship between themselves and Hamlet. Once more, Rosencrantz and Guildenstern’s false loyalty is proven when they knowingly agree to send Hamlet to his

Read More
937 Words | 4 Pages

Hamlet views Ophelia as a naive and ignorant girl who is nothing but Polonius and Claudius's puppet. This was revealed when Hamlet said "God has given you one face and you make yourself another. . You jig and amble, and you lisp, you nickname God's creatures and make your wantonness your ignorance." (III, i, 143-146) In this quote Hamlet knows that Ophelia is spying on him for Polonius and Claudius.

Read More

More about Examples Of Obedience In Hamlet

Related Topics

Open Document