ipl-logo

Explain Why The Burqa Should Not Be Banned In France

584 Words3 Pages

In April, 2011 the French parliament banned the burqa, prohibiting women living in France to wear the dress in any public areas. My client, S.A.S., has been wrongly victimized by the constitutionality of this law. This outlaw, of the religious dress of the women’s choosing, has caused much controversy. The French Parliament claims that the burqa “isolates” muslim women from French society and “strips them of their humanity,”. However, not allowing these women to express themselves through wearing the burqa further secludes Muslim women living in France. The burqa should not be banned in France, it is not equitable and limits women’s rights in a country that is presumed to be free and impartial for all citizens, as stated in the French Constitution. …show more content…

This ban of a women’s religious dress is in no way constitutional under the current French Constitution. My client and the 1,546 fines have been given out to 908 women wearing the burqa in public (McPartland), have not been given equality without the distinction of religion. The French Parliament stated that this was for Muslim women to, “adapt to the local community,”. These 908 women being fined and being spotlighted by the community do not feel welcomed in their local community, because their religion and traditional religious dress has been attacked. This ban is helping nobody and compromises the integrity of France, as stated by Geoffrey W.G. Leane, “In all likelihood these policies will end badly, not only for Muslim minorities in Europe, but for the legitimacy and integrity of modern European liberal values as well.” Even if this was France trying to convince the public that they were keeping them safe somehow, it goes against the most sacred law of the land, the

Show More
Related

R. V. NS 2012 SCC 72: Case Study

119 Words | 1 Pages

Citation R. v. NS, 2012 SCC 72, [2012] 3 S.C.R. 726 – Niqab removal trial Facts: NS who is a Muslim woman made a complaint of being sexually assaulted by 2 men within family during her childhood. Both men were charged for the assault in 2007. During the opening inquiry in 2008, NS explained she was going to testify with her niqab on for religious purposes Legal issue Removing the witness’s niqab violates section 2 of the Canadian charter of rights and freedom Decision The Supreme Court dismissed the plea and is preparing a list of questions in order to decide whether or not the witness should be allowed to wear the niqab during the trail for religious purposes

Read More

Analysis Of France's Headscarf War By Angelique Chrisafis

313 Words | 2 Pages

This week's readings focus on the issues of freedom and enlightenment. In Angelique Chrisafis’s essay France’s headscarf war: ‘Its an attack on freedom’ we are introduced to the problems many Muslim women in France are experiencing regarding their traditional headscarf, the hijab. Chrysalis explains that the French Republic lays a great deal of importance and focus on the separation of church and state and, therefore, do not allow any religiously affiliated clothing or items to be worn in the public work sector. However, many Muslim women are upset, embarrassed, and feel targeted by the treatment they are receiving at the hands of different institutions in France when wearing their hijab. The on-going battle between the right to religious

Read More

Reinventing The Veil By Leila Ahmed Summary

689 Words | 3 Pages

In her Financial Times article, “Reinventing the Veil,” writer Leila Ahmed uses her background and knowledge as a Muslim feminist to write about the dynamic evolution or revolution of the Islamic veil. Ahmed starts with the 1940s through 1960s, in an era which education was quickly spreading. Many Muslim majority cities were becoming more aware of the cultural significance of the veil and were deciding to opt out. As an educated Harvard academic, Ahmed builds trust with her readers’ and also establishes her credibility. She then appeals to our emotions to form an overall persuasive and organized piece.

Read More

Reinventing The Veil Analysis

797 Words | 4 Pages

* The article “Reinventing the veil” by Leila Ahmed discusses how the concept of hijabs has changed over time. Back then many people had the assumption the veils would

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of The Canadian Charter

1212 Words | 5 Pages

It is meant to symbolize protection of the weak and self-defense but, wearing of such a weapon has been argued to be dangerous to those around such person as it is still a lethal weapon. Teachers believed that the student should not be able to wear the weapon on school grounds as it endangered the safety of nearby students. The Supreme Court of Canada ruled in favor of individuals arguing that such a weapon impeached their rights to safety and as such the Supreme Court banned the wearing of such a weapon in places like school to protect the safety of the people4, even though this violates the religious rights of Sikhs. These cases of the niqab and kirpan show that a person’s religious rights can be violated if it violates another person’s right to safety and

Read More

Similarities Between 'Bloodchild And The Gender Knot'

1063 Words | 5 Pages

In Western nations, arguments against the burqa are sometimes stoked by racist and nationalist discourse that demonizes Muslim women who wear it. It is important to understand

Read More

Zoot Suits Vs Headscarves

1397 Words | 6 Pages

That is, while many of the Pachucos appropriated the zoot suit as a way to cope with feeling powerless and voiceless in a white supremacist society, Muslim women at the beginning wore the headscarves mostly for religious, functional, and personal reasons. For Muslim women in France, at least in the 1990s onwards, there was no literal appropriation involved. Instead, the headscarf was worn because it was a sign of modesty and means of controlling sexuality by their culture and religion, a material and psychic link to their homeland, a form of self-protection, and an expression of religious identity (Scott, 2005: 117). Like Mexicans in the United States, Muslim women in France are also marginalized and discriminated upon. The ideals of the French revolution and French republicanism created an ideology that there is a true self and essence, and the government embarked on a journey under the rubric of that ideology (Scott, 2005: 109; Miller 2010: 41).

Read More

Middle East Dbq

615 Words | 3 Pages

The Middle East’s reaction has been mixed. In document #3 of the DQB, veiling is talked about. The document mentions that non-muslims think of veiling as a form

Read More

Burqa Dbq

774 Words | 4 Pages

The first section I will be talking to you about is the act of prohibiting the wearing of burqas in the United States. The second point I will be discussing about is my point of view on the act of prohibiting Syrian and/or Saudi Arabian refugees from entering the United states without presidential approval. The final section I will be discussing to you about is about Immigrants At a camp at Kohat, Pakistan there were two suicide bombers, disguised with burqas, that struck the camp. The attack killed 41 people and injured about 62 people. In another case there were seven Afghan Taliban terrorists who were wearing burqas.

Read More

Controversial Issues In Canada

1148 Words | 5 Pages

According to the author’s opinion Canadian Muslim women feel the most targeted leading this to be the main issues as it is states for any head wear such as niqab or burka covering the face to be removed when receiving public services regarding identification (Shingler, 2017). Despite, the author being able to relate to the controversial topic he is able to incorporate statements from those who are not in favor of the new bill. In summary, CBC News author Benjamin Shingler uses statements from Quebec’s government and Muslim Canadians grasping a better understanding of both viewpoints. As a result, the issue seen is being examined through a micro-level as looking beyond a problem and looks at cause and effect for individuals throughout society.

Read More

Who Is Joan Wallach Scott's 'The Politics Of The Veil'

373 Words | 2 Pages

In Joan Wallach Scott book “The Politics of The Veil” she talks about how France passed a law to ban women from wearing Veils. Throughout her introduction Scott tends to take stance against the France government meaning she doesn’t approve the the law that ban veil. I think this reading represents an excellent research about how unfair the france politicians are to a certain religion. To prove her argument she presented how different religions were treated, for instance from the reading she conveyed the jewish boys wear the skullcaps and sikh boys wear turbans, and the muslim girls wear hijab however she highlights even though the same rule tend to apply of them however the france government tends to undergo the other religions and

Read More

Politics Of The Veil By Joan Scott Summary

707 Words | 3 Pages

Jonathan Wert 5/7/17 French History Dr. Blackman Politics of the Veil Politics of the Veil, written by Joan Wallach Scott, is about the 2004 controversial headscarf ban in France. Scott opens with, “This is not a book about French Muslims; it is about the dominant French view of them.” Scott examines the political storm surrounding the French ban on headscarves for girls eighteen or younger in public schools. The book is an easy read, filled with first-hand accounts of the racism felt by Muslim women.

Read More

Why Women Should Not Wear The Veil Of Muslim Women

1669 Words | 7 Pages

The issue of the veil has come to represent the essence of Islam, not only to the West, but also to Muslim Conservatives and Fundamentalists. To some in the West, the veil represents repression and constriction of women’s freedom and choice, limiting their capacity for self-determination. However, some Muslims would argue that women must veil because it is a first step towards restoring true Islam and a defiance against the West Interventionist policies (Lazreg, Why Women Should Not Wear the Veil, pg. 113). Additionally, the idea of freedom as the ultimate value, is a western standard and that for some, piety is more important. Lila Abu-Lughod and Marnia Lazreg have contrasting views on the veiling of Muslim women and the affects it has on their lives.

Read More

Canadian Charter Of Rights And Freedom Analysis

1432 Words | 6 Pages

The freedom of religion is stark contrast to that of the government workings and legal affairs, but is still an important factor of canadian life. Religion is a belief system meant to be untouched by law, as long as they remain a peaceful congregation, and though time and time again does hate groups try to level on their rights, the judicial courts of Canada have continued to terminate such issues. The most recent and well known case winning would be of the niqab controversy. Zunera Ishaq, a Pakistani immigrant, had won against the conservative government in two levels of court over the right to wear her niqab at her citizenship oath, before the new Liberal government dropped the former 's appeal to the Supreme Court. The reasoning behind her continued victory was because the courts had viewed the case as a violation to her religious freedom, as the niqab relates to her muslim faith.

Read More

Hijab Informative Speech

843 Words | 4 Pages

(Transition: Why hijab is been perceived as a threat to some people) I. Although Muslims have been in the United States for more than 100 years, women in hijab have been wrongly and negatively in some communities. i. Since 9/11, the media has been featuring the hijab as a symbol of terrorism or violence. As people lean toward getting most of their information from these resources, they will develop a negative picture about Islam in general and women in hijab in particular. For instance, when news feature a women wearing Muslim attire such as hijab while reporting stories related to terrorism.

Read More

More about Explain Why The Burqa Should Not Be Banned In France

Related Topics

Open Document