ipl-logo

Female Genital Mutilation Summary

1111 Words5 Pages

In the “Cultural Rights or Human Rights: The Case of Female Genital Mutilation”, Henriette Dahan Kalev presents different arguments arranged along a spectrum pertaining to the controversial topic of female genital mutilation (referred to as “FGM” from here on). Kalev describes the practice as the following: “There are various forms of the practice, ranging from a partial clitoridectomy to a full excision of the clitoris, labia minora, and majora followed by infibulation (the stitching of the vulva leaving a small opening for urine and menstrual blood)” (339). To indicate why FGM is a point of contention in society, Kalev adds, “The ‘surgery’ is typically performed by a female ‘midwife’, often in unsanitary conditions with no anesthetic. These …show more content…

Moreover, while Kalev clearly states her disdain towards FGM in the beginning of the article (“…I will present a counterargument demonstrating the need to condemn the practice…) (Kalev, 340), her presentation of other perspectives regarding this ritual are thorough. Even when she is disagreeing with the points that other theorists make, she is critical and thoughtful rather than being outright condescending. In this sense, this article is not only a vehicle for Kalev’s personal views about FGM but also an indicator of how complicated the issue truly is. As an individual who was only vaguely familiar with the concept of FGM prior to reading this piece, not only do I feel more informed about the topic but I am also compelled to learn more about …show more content…

One thing that constantly bothered me while I was reading the article was the fact that unlike Britain (which was used as a specific example of a Western nation) there is no discussion of any single non-Western nation’s (or rejecting) political process regarding FGM. Additionally, the groups that are most inclined to practice FGM were also given extremely broad descriptions [“…some Asian and North and Central African countries, as well as by immigrant groups (mainly Muslim) in some Western countries as well.”] (Kalev, 339). Considering how vast both the continents of Asia and Africa are and how widely practiced Islam is, it’s difficult to get a sense of where FGM is most prevalent based on the given information. However, to Kalev’s credit, she did make it a point to specify that FGM is not performed in all Muslim communities on account of the fact that it is not discussed in any scripture (Kalev, 340). Even so, I am adamant that this aspect of her article could have greatly benefitted from more distinction, especially when the information is presented to individuals who are uneducated about the

Show More
Related
987 Words | 4 Pages

Holloway was impressed by the work Monique preformed as not only a healthcare provider but a midwife. Once, when Holloway was observing and assisting in a birth she realized Monique, “was responsible for the future of this village” (8). While working with Monique, Holloway learned more about the health aspect of this culture, for example; female genital cutting. At first mention of this Holloway was surprised to learn this was a common tradition among adolescent women. Since this tradition is not ordinarily practiced in the United States, she was eager to learn more about the why this procedure is part of their culture.

Read More
1028 Words | 5 Pages

The bias she presents could make her argument ineffective because it deters some readers from acknowledging the article’s

Read More
720 Words | 3 Pages

The practice, according to Ahmed, was not generally observed in her society and was seen by women who practiced Islam as a cultural tradition that was not mandated by the religion. Instead of being a religious requirement, circumcision was viewed as a cultural rite of passage for women. In contrast, male Islam routinely performed female circumcision and considered it as a religious need. Men felt that female circumcision was required to preserve a woman's chastity and purity and to keep her from having sex before marriage. Ahmed claims that female circumcision is not an essential Islamic ritual because of the harm it might cause and because of her own experience with it.

Read More
1071 Words | 5 Pages

In recent years, there have been anti-circumcision movements gaining steam that mindlessly compares the circumcision of a boy with the genital mutilation of a woman. Circumcision is where the foreskin is trimmed to make my dong look awesome and reduce chances for STD's. What is done to women is equivalent to chopping the head of a penis off. Before I go on further into this, just know that a lot of the language can be offputting, and the images, even though just drawings, can be NOT SAFE FOR WORK.

Read More
546 Words | 3 Pages

While the sword can be sheathed by the anatomy of the woman, it ultimately cannot be the aggressor. The vagina is like a fortress- it contains something and merely prevents that something from completing its goal of control. Therefore, any feminists that have penile penetration with a man has already abandoned her cause for equality between the sexes in the bedroom. However, assuming the male heterosexual cares about his partner, there are benefits gained from the abdication of a woman’s influence: greater protection and security. Most women are unfortunately physically weaker than their male counterparts, and while some could provide some form of guard, they would not be as successful as a male with the same

Read More
602 Words | 3 Pages

Mutilation is to injure, disfigure, or make imperfect by removing or irreparably damaging parts. This includes female genital mutilation, flagellation, wheeling but also, circumcision, piercing, and tattooing. Mutilation correlates with the short story of “The Lottery.” People who love and want to continue cruel mutilations such as the stoning in “The Lottery,” mutilation use the excuse of tradition. The stoning in “The Lottery” like many types of mutilation is only done only to satisfy the mind of a belief, entertainment, and other reasons.

Read More
802 Words | 4 Pages

The following will be discussed: how genocidal rape manifests, including prevalence rates, consequences of genocidal rape, socio-cultural, political, and economic factors that affect women’s vulnerability to genocidal rape and the interventions that might be effective in addressing the issue. How Genocidal Rape

Read More
1860 Words | 8 Pages

My sophomore year at Clark I sat at a high table in the Academic Commons on the phone with my mother discussing an article I read for class. The article was an opinion piece that called into question the Western viewpoint on Female Genital Cutting. The article was critical, intense and uncomfortable yet I sat on the phone with my mom for almost an hour discussing the author's arguments, its faults and virtues, my opinion and desire to study information like this forever. In response, she said "You can. Its called Women's Studies".

Read More
739 Words | 3 Pages

The few personal stories from the women who experienced circumcision offer powerful additions to the horrifying nature of genital mutilation and how the poorly done operation forever ruins the women’s hygiene and health. The result of Soraya Mire’s choice to only showcase the graphic parts of female circumcision takes away the cultural meaning and importance of the practice. Soraya Mire’s strong opinion on female circumcision relates closely with the Western approach to viewing external cultures and disagreeing with practices that

Read More
720 Words | 3 Pages

This causes a major difference in her perspective of the events; she attempts to use a reasonable interpretation of events, so

Read More
178 Words | 1 Pages

In large part, the historical relationship of oppressed groups with societally dominant groups can be best examined and explained through the conceptions of power outlined by Foucault in his work The History of Sexuality. According to Foucault, individuals were not unilaterally oppressed and subdued by some singular source, but rather, oppressed individuals found themselves under a plethora of agencies that attempted to classify, control, and define them. By creating “an organic, functional, [and] controlling mental pathology arising out of … sexual practice,” groups such as the medical community, an attempt to control and arbitrate the existence of historically “deviant” groups, promoted the discourse of sexuality such that while these groups

Read More
1010 Words | 5 Pages

The pleasure of women was forced into a box of vaginal intercourse only. Speaking of pleasure, Tuana focuses a portion of her article on the subject and how men and women’s pleasure are treated differently. The goal of sex was supposed to be reproducing and there was an ‘understanding’ that for women, pleasure was not a necessity to achieve this goal. This belief, along with another, create the basis for why Tuana believes the clitoris has been largely ignored in science and medicine. Her reasoning resonated with me, so I am sharing it in its

Read More
1804 Words | 8 Pages

To initiate, the implementation of gender equality laws will help conclude unequal treatment towards women and create opportunities for women to refuse unsafe work and treatments. Also, without the right to make individual choices for body, women 's prosperity, well-being, and potential in society are restricted and gender inequality is therefore perpetuated. According to the academic article, Sexual Health’s Women’s Rights, “120 million girls worldwide have experienced forced intercourse” (Ngcuka) activities against their own individual soul. Many women are suffering from forced physical and sexual violence because of the limited laws and regulations that allow women to refuse unsafe treatments and practices. According to reports, the “ 32

Read More
1861 Words | 8 Pages

Informative Speech: Female Genital Mutilation Specific Purpose: To inform my audience about female genital mutilation and where the controversy of it all lies. Central Idea: Female Genital Mutilation is a tradition in certain parts of the world. Most of the time these procedures aren 't carried out safely and the final outcome of the girls that have been mutilated are to work as sex slaves. INTRODUCTION (Attention Getter)This is Kizibianca of kenya, africa. At a mere fifteen years old she was woken up at 5 am and led outside of her hut by the the local traditional brothers and female elders.

Read More
827 Words | 4 Pages

It’s done in various parts of Asia, Africa, and parts of the Middle East. Typically, the clitioris is removed from the female with no medical personnel and is often unsanitary. An outsider may see this as a violation of the female genitals, which makes it unlawful. However, it is common in these cultures. Whether it is right or wrong is a matter of opinion.

Read More

More about Female Genital Mutilation Summary

Related Topics

Open Document