ipl-logo

Film Review: The Impact Of Sarah Tobias On The Witness Stand

487 Words2 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Female gender stereotypes in movies

The sequence with Sarah Tobias on the witness stand had the biggest impact on the film's overall breadth and subject matter. This vignette exemplifies the challenges that victims of sexual assault confront while seeking justice in a courtroom. The defense counsel asks Sarah embarrassing and intrusive questions that attempt to destroy her reputation and damage the credibility of her testimony. This scenario is significant because it demonstrates the structural barriers that impede victims from seeking justice and emphasizes the urgency of altering the way sexual assault cases are handled in court.

When Sarah and her friend Karen go to the pub, it has the least impact on the overall scope and subject matter of the movie. Both the general message …show more content…

Additionally, Sarah's friends are portrayed as doubting her story and thinking that she is exaggerating when she reports her attack. This reinforces the idea that victims are not believed or taken seriously when they come forward.

The film surprises with its treatment of rape in its portrayal of Sarah as a strong and resilient character. Despite the obstacles she faces, Sarah is determined to seek justice and stands up to the defense attorney in court. This helps to challenge the stereotype that victims of sexual assault are weak and helpless.

Before seeing the film, I thought rape was a taboo issue that needed to be approached carefully.
Nonetheless, the video opened my eyes to the nuances and challenges that survivors of sexual assault experience.

According to my analysis of current American legislation and policy on rape, we have a long way to go before victims are afforded adequate protections. Seeking justice and holding offenders responsible may be challenging for victims since they are frequently treated with skepticism and face an uphill struggle in court.

The video effectively illustrates the disparity between the legal and social treatment of

Show More
Related
515 Words | 3 Pages

In the article “Die Trying”, Katie J.M. Baker points out the difficulties of being a rape victim in Alabama and nationwide. The article “Die Trying” talks about a student named Megan Rondini who attended the University of Alabama in Tuscaloosa who accused T.J. Bunn Jr. of rape. The events that led to sexual assault happened in July 1, 2015 at night where Megan Rondini went to Innisfree Irish Pub with a couple of her sorority sisters and drank five cups of beer. After drinking the beer Megan Rondini blacked out and found herself in T.J. Bunn’s car with his friend going back to his house.

Read More
811 Words | 4 Pages

Women in New England wanted to work at textile mills so they could afford education, support their families, and it was a high-paying job opportunity. Mills became popular in the early 1800s during the Industrial Revolution. They first became a thing in the US when Francis Lowell went to England and memorized how the factories worked since stealing the plans would be illegal; he then remade them in New England. The Industrial Revolution and mills changed how daily life was lived. Before, families attended to their own needs; farmers supplied food, women tended to the livestock, sewed clothing, and did the laundry, and the children helped with any chores around the house.

Read More
660 Words | 3 Pages

He explains that this in turn leads to unfair representation and unresolved rape cases. Krakauer describes this situation through the case of Kelsey Belnap. After providing convincing evidence to the prosecutor, mother Terry Belnap states, “‘We were left with no answers and no further investigation….I really felt that we were brushed off’” (44). Krakauer uses this testimony to show that the prosecutor's lack of care towards the victim in pushing forth their case.

Read More
1255 Words | 6 Pages

After spending nearly a year fighting over the devastating trial, another rape victim has their justice ripped from their grasp. In January of 2015, Brock Turner, a well-known Stanford swimmer committed an act of assault on an innocent victim who couldn’t recall what had happened. Two nearby bikers who witnessed Turner on top of the victim in an alleyway behind a dumpster, chased down and tackled the unforgiving man. Because of the victim’s intoxicated state, Turner’s attorneys used that to their advantage, claiming that only Brock could recollect the events that happened in that evening. The victim received no opportunity to express how the assault had mentally damaged her as his attorneys picked and prodded the victim through questions about

Read More
491 Words | 2 Pages

Whether it's the uncomfortably close camera shots or the faint whisper of breathing, she says what we all should be saying. Sexual assault of any kind is never right. Whether it's rape or a cat call walking down the street, the ability to make someone uncomfortable and unsafe in their own skin is unacceptable. Furthermore the film brings to light the different types of sexual assault. Taking on the responsibility of educating the viewer in how to notice and avoid sexual assault.

Read More
1698 Words | 7 Pages

Rape myths are at the center of the problem of how rape and sexual assault cases are looked at, and treated as in society. Rape myths vary, some excuse the rape, others try to minimize the severity of the situation, while others doubt the act even happened in the first place (Levit and Verchick, 196). Some examples of rape myths include: a victim was “asking for it,” a victim’s previous sexual history, regretful sex is not rape, a woman’s “no” means “yes,” and women lie about rape all the time. Rape myths are targeted towards women, not the rapist. Despite, rape myths being proved false by empirical evidence, they are still prevalent in society.

Read More
1117 Words | 5 Pages

The men and women at the heart of the film were all victims of sexual assault, who chose to retell their tales to bring national attention to the often silenced issue of sexual assault on college campus. However, some survivors not only spoke out about their assault, but became some of the fiercest advocates against sexual violence and rape on college campus, shortly following their assaults. These men and women started anti-rape marches and demonstrations and protests, commanding national attention that extended to the steps of the White House. Though these advocates were forced to endure such a horrible experience, their personal development as a result is clear. If it had not been for their adversity, they most likely would not have spoken out against these issues.

Read More
1265 Words | 6 Pages

Defense attorneys in cases of sexual assault often “attack the victim’s credibility - the time-honored rape defense that so often results in an acquittal” (Krakauer 136). Diminishing the victim’s credibly and highlighting the standing of the accused are both methods that defense attorneys, like Donaldson’s lawyer, use to win cases of sexual

Read More
912 Words | 4 Pages

I also learned from the film that sexual offenders are not always the strangers hiding behind the bushes but people that the survivors of sexual assault knew or had had a relationship with. From this unit I also took away that sexual assault cases are treated objectively in court, based on the facts, and that the survivors, who are mostly but not always woman, are blamed for the assault questioning how much they had to drink or what they were wearing. Rape is extremely unreported to or unrecorded by police and rape kits almost never get

Read More
996 Words | 4 Pages

Every sixty-eight seconds, an American is sexually assaulted, and it is stated that only twenty-five out of every one thousand perpetrators will see the consequences of their actions (RAINN). Now, imagine if the world was a place where victims felt as if they could speak up and receive proper assistance without question and judgment. Imagine if every sexual assault case concluded with justice for the victim. Laurie Halse Anderson tells her own story of sexual violence and the struggles of the aftermath through the eyes of high school freshman, Melinda Sordino, in her work Speak. Throughout the novel, Melinda internally fights with herself on who to protect, herself and other females around her, or her attacker’s reputation.

Read More
1123 Words | 5 Pages

Colleges are protecting their public record and do not wish to affect their brand be publicly admitting the high rates of sexual assaults. The documentary focused on a student attending Harvard Law School and the administrators insisted that the female victim should remain silent and avoid spreading the incident around. They asked questions such as, "Did you give him the wrong message, why did you choose not to fight back". Victim blaming is presented when the administrators are more interested in what the victim did wrong rather than what the offender's actions

Read More
1359 Words | 6 Pages

The documentary, The Hunting Ground by Kirby Dick, was created specifically to spread awareness of the vast problem of sexual assault on college campuses and to attempt to show that the dilemma needs to be solved. The creator wants the viewer to know that the dilemma of these attacks that universities tried to hide in the dark is finally being given the spotlight they deserve. The spark of this idea for this documentary was the many stories of survivors across the nation from many universities, specifically the story of Annie and Andrea who helped other survivors get the justice they deserve. The film is intended for anyone who is unaware of the frequent and nationwide problem of sexual assault, specifically girls because sexual assault is

Read More
557 Words | 3 Pages

The documentary called The Hunting Grounds, had multiple concepts that relate to sociology. Using a sociological perspective, it was very prevalent to see the ways college campuses use patriarchy and gender stratification to keep women who have been sexually assaulted on campus from disclosing information or even getting help about these issues. Through the discrimination against women at these gender institutions the women formed a Feminist movement to bring awareness and help to the victims on campuses all around the world and to stop the assaults from reoccurring. The Hunting Grounds is a documentary that reveals the untold stories of women on college campuses and how these women have fought to have their voice heard about sexual assault on campuses. Sexual assault and rape on campuses has always been a major problem for colleges all over the world yet very little has been done to protect the students.

Read More
1139 Words | 5 Pages

Furthermore, Griffin commonly sites credible studies and explores historical moments to provide context and support for her claims. One article in particular written by Griffin (1971) demonstrates her masterful use of ethos, “Rape: The All-American Crime.” This article was the first of its kind as it discusses rape from a feminist perspective and challenges common beliefs about rape. Up until this point rape and sexual violence was rarely discussed and when it was it was by a man. Griffin begins the article by explaining her credentials, describing her personal experiences with rape culture in America, and illustrating the urgency with which women and victims need to be heard.

Read More
1071 Words | 5 Pages

Allison was at a house party that Beau was hosting, she had a little too much to drink, so she fell asleep on the couch. She later woke up to her pants down and Beau at the end raping her. “She assumed that if he was willing to rape her while she was sleeping, he wouldn’t hesitate to harm her severely in order to keep her from resisting or calling for help.” This fear enters victims when they believe that there is nothing else that they can do it make the offending stop. We often see this type of rape happen at parties where people have had too much to drink and are intoxicated to the point of no recognition.

Read More

More about Film Review: The Impact Of Sarah Tobias On The Witness Stand

Related Topics

Open Document