ipl-logo

Michel Foucault Discipline And Punish Analysis

1356 Words6 Pages

Michel Foucault, Discipline and Punish: The Birth of the Prison Wanchen Xie Introduction on the author Michel Foucault was born on October 15, 1926 in Poitiers, France. He wrote a great many works which influenced the philosophy and sociology deeply, for instance, Madness and Civilization. Not only was Foucault an intellectual and philosopher, but he was a political activist as well. He got involved in various protests and campaigns, say, against the war in Algeria, against social issues, as well as prison reform. He got involved in the prison reform in France and visited prisons in America as well. Thus it reflects that his notion was more than purely theoretical with various experiences and provided us a lot social facts to evaluate. Introduction …show more content…

He believed in the whole modern society, diffuse power has been immersed in all aspects of life. It can be captured in the small places. This diffuse power is not necessarily rely on the unified state machine, but in various specific areas. In the 17th and 18th centuries, the mechanisms of discipline gradually extended throughout the entire society. As we can see, modern factories, schools, military barracks, hospitals and prisons are to some extent similar to each other; this is what Foucault calls “the advent of disciplinary society”. Moreover, power is a relationship and network. Traditional theory of power supposed power is an ability or resource which can be competed, transferred. Foucault claims that it is a relationship, this power can be seen in the flow of the process cycle, especially hierarchical observation mentioned in the book. Power is produced in the relation network. Additionally, power is anonymous without main body. Everyone is a point in the power relationship; they can be both executor and monitored …show more content…

Maybe this carceral society cannot be supposed as a general theory of western civilization. Additionally, Foucault thinks it is Enlightenment helped to change to disciplinarian style of Ancient Regime. In reality, according to the query of some scholars, in the aftermath of the defeat of Napoleon, there was a very powerful conservative backlash against liberalism and Enlightenment in Europe, which persisted in some countries well into 19th century, but not the “discipline and punish” model of society that Foucault imagined. Lastly, there are some errors in Foucault’s claiming of the changing timing in the Western penal system. It shows that the number of crimes punished by the death penalty increased to the early 19th century not fell as well as corporal punishment was still often used in 19th

Show More
Related
485 Words | 2 Pages

In our world, there is power everywhere you look from schools, into classrooms, at restaurants, and even at home. There are many forms of power like a coach, teacher, or president but all show power in our society

Read More
776 Words | 4 Pages

But first what is Power? When researching Power words such as authority, control, direct, command and influence all appear. These words all support the following statement “Power is the ability to influence and control the behaviour of others.” The problem with power is that it often leads to those in power abusing it. As Lord Acton famously quoted “Power tends to corrupt and absolute power corrupts absolutely.”

Read More
596 Words | 3 Pages

Penal sanctioning represented for him a tangible example of the ‘collective conscience’ at work, in a process that both expressed and regenerated society’s values.” It is difficult to judge a case like Niveen’s because it lack physical evidence, thus it is entirely based on cultural moral values. Contrary to Foucault’s theory, Durkheim considered punishment irrational, he believed that: “[P]assion… is the soul of punishment.” Niveen’s trail seemed to be driven by passion: the social worker’s passion to penalize a ‘bad mother’. However, the legal process was not so ‘primitive’ for it become totally unreasonable.

Read More
450 Words | 2 Pages

in Veeser 234) Power has been analyzed and discussed by a number of critics and writers in differnet books and articles. Among those one can mention

Read More
1695 Words | 7 Pages

Furthermore, to be sure there is a broad record of the different "exact orders" of the Renaissance and the Classical Age that go before these cutting edge human sciences. Be that as it may, there is little or nothing of the certain social scrutinize found in the History of Madness or even The Birth of the Clinic. Rather, Foucault offers a worldwide examination of what learning implied—and how this importance changed in Western thought from the Renaissance to the present. At the heart of his record is the idea of

Read More
160 Words | 1 Pages

For Foucault, discipline created a form of individuality in which bodies work within the institutional framework of political and economic organisations. He argues that this discipline is implemented to construct and maintain hierarchized relations. Foucault argues that the body is subject to power

Read More
1193 Words | 5 Pages

A general definition of power is ‘the capacity or ability to direct or influence the behaviour of others or the course of event’, however in a book, ‘A Radical View’, published in 1974, Steven Lukes argues the idea that there is actually three dimensions of power, therefore distinguishing between his idea of power and Robert Dahls’s interpretation on power. The three dimensions of power include ‘decision power and issue method’, non-decision making and agenda setting and manipulating the view of others in addition to the system power. Lukes interpretation of power became a significantly huge focus point when deliberating the realism of power. This essay will explore each dimension of power in fine detail and also how each of these concepts

Read More
1814 Words | 8 Pages

Power is an important tool for interaction among individuals and establishing authority in many aspects of life. Power is evident everywhere in the world. Bosses and their subordinates, teachers and peers and also government and its citizens. They are all expected to follow their dominant 's rules. Power can be seen as "The ability to influence or outright control the behaviour of people" (Power (social and political)/Wikipedia).

Read More
919 Words | 4 Pages

(ii) Power and Conflict: The capacity the one person has the influence over the other persons such that other persons act in accordance with his/her wishes can be defined as ‘Power’. Conflicts could be both positive and negative. Good conflicts could be encouraged but bad conflicts ought to be prevented.

Read More
785 Words | 4 Pages

MICHEL FOUCAULT ON SEXUALITY Michel Foucault was a French philosopher, philologist and social theorist. He made discourses on the relationship between power and knowledge and about how they are utilized as a form of social control through social establishments. This essay talks about Michel Foucault’s discourse on sexuality. He put forward his theory of the history of sexuality.

Read More
956 Words | 4 Pages

This again contains corporeal, gory imagery, and again reference is made to the tortured body (A‟pox o‟ your throat), and indicates this is punishment for the Boatswain is “blasphemous” and “incharitable”. These imply that they believe he is guilty because he has put the sovereign‟s power which Foucault regards as the main offence during the time before the modern era. The punishment is a reinstatement of the sovereign‟s power, and is contrasted with the modern offences

Read More
742 Words | 3 Pages

At first glance and brief investigation it becomes clear the philosophy of Michel Foucault predominantly centres around the idea of power and through further inspection how power operates in society, how do people, institutions, governments & nations gain or lose power and furthermore how do they maintain or exercise said power and his central theme or revelation regarding power seems to be that it is closely connected with knowledge. Michel Foucault is regarded as a politically charged activist type of philosopher as through research and documented evidence we find that although his philosophy and intellectual ideas span across and cover a vast array of topics such as how society has oppressed and exiled those deemed insane and psychologically unfit in his critically acclaimed ‘Madness in Civilization’ or his general criticism of the bourgeoisie power structures through neutral seeming institutions such a hospitals and doctor clinics in “The Birth of the Clinic”. Michel Foucault argues that modern medicine which is mainly attributed to the capitalist proletariat class is fundamentally sinister because they claim an abundant amount of power though there is no impartial body to regulate the way in which they exercise power, instead of healing and attempting to genuinely understand and look further to those deemed ‘insane’ they simply label, categorize and recognize and treat the diagnosed symptoms of there patients like mechanical animals. In my interpretation it seems that

Read More
1372 Words | 6 Pages

Firstly the traditional approach. According to Miller, (2015: 118) the traditional approach “considers power to be a relative entity that people or group possess”, which means that each and every individual, group or organization have power within them. Secondly, the symbological approach, which “views power as a product of communicative interactions and relationships” (Mumby, 2014). This means that power emerges through interactions between people or organizations and even so through their relationships, as power is a product of

Read More
891 Words | 4 Pages

Foucault introduces a plague-ridden society, where everyone is registered and held in certain quarters. As Foucault puts it, “Each street is placed under the authority of a syndic, who keeps it under surveillance” (Foucault 61). He notes that this surveillance is necessary to keep order and safety within the town. The lack of any surveillance would result in anarchy and widespread illness. Foucault goes on to explain the larger impact of this system: the disciplinary society.

Read More
1116 Words | 5 Pages

Athena Kennedy Philosophy Professor Berendzen Kant vs. Foucault December 1, 2015 Kant vs. Foucault Humans question their surroundings every day, weather it is “is how I am acting the way I want to portray myself,” “am I doing the right thing in this situation?” All questions can and should be debated, In philosophy we find new ways to questions everything, weather it is another’s opinion or our own, we form new ways of thinking critically and new ways to obtain answers that will satisfy our thirst for knowledge. Philosophers believe that you need to be able to question everything because there is always new knowledge out there for us to absorb and to question. In critical thinking you evaluate an issue you believe is present in order

Read More

More about Michel Foucault Discipline And Punish Analysis

Related Topics

Open Document