ipl-logo

Freedom Of Religion

988 Words4 Pages

Comparison of constitutional provisions on Freedom of religion
In drafting a constitutional article on Freedom of Religion, I will compare the constitutions of India, Kenya and South Africa. The comparison will be based on three main points; namely the content of the right, the limitations on the right and the relationship between the state and religion as determined in the articles. In each I, will highlight what aspects will be essential to the protection of the right and vice versa.
Content
The South African and Kenyan constitution start in a similar way; the right in both consists of the freedom of conscience, religion, thought, belief and opinion . The South African constitution doesn’t provide anything further than stating what freedoms …show more content…

Such provision is not provided neither in the South African nor in the Indian constitution. This is a nondiscrimination clause, the components of which are very important to the full recognition and exercise of freedom of religion.
The Kenyan constitution also states that “a person shall not be compelled to act, or engage in any act, that is contrary to the person’s belief or religion” . This is not mentioned in the other constitutions. However, it is very important to include this in a constitution provision to guarantee freedom of religion. Some religious beliefs prohibit people from being part of the military or receiving blood transfusion. This forms a component of a person’s religion or belief which should be protected.
Finally, the Indian constitution illustrates the entitlement of institutions established for religious purposes. This gives religious institutions the right to establish and maintain institutions, manage its affair, own and administer its own property. This is important to how religious institutions function and shall be guaranteed in the …show more content…

The constitutions did not make this distinction making all aspects of the right subject to limitations. The Kenyan and South African constitutions allow limitations if it is provided by law and can be reasonable and justifiable in a democratic society. This is a very broad limitation that can be extended and applied to many things. The Indian limitation clause, in contrast; provides the right subject to ‘public order, morality and health’. Morality as ground for limitation is very broad; as there is no universal definition of morality, anything may be justified on this ground.
State and religion
The Indian and South African constitution allow state involvement in the exercise of religion in different capacities . While, the Kenyan constitution makes no mention of the relationship between state and religion. The South African constitution allows religious observance to be conducted at a state or state aided institutions so long as it is on equitable basis and voluntary and free.
Under the Indian constitution, the state can make laws that regulate or restrict any economic, financial, political or other secular activity which may be associated with religious practice . It also allows the state to make law that provide for social welfare and reform of Hundu institutions with a public character

Show More
Related
1812 Words | 8 Pages

In discussing freedom of religion in this case, the key principles at odds are free exercise clause versus the establishment clause. In determining, the establishment clause one needs to consider both the participants and location of

Read More
2736 Words | 11 Pages

A. Advise Airtastic about the legal options that are open to it to halt the actions of the protestors. Describe the legal consequences that are likely to follow if the local protestors continued to engage in their destructive actions. (40 MARKS- Your answer should be 1,000-1,200 words for this part) Introduction In this answer I intend to focus on the legal options available to Airtastic to restrict the protestors from obstructing the construction of the wind farm.

Read More
349 Words | 2 Pages

The English Bill of Rights and the US constitution have many similarities and differences. This paper is going to point out differences and similarities between the two historical documents. The main similarity between the documents is that they try to protect the liberties of individuals and to limit the powers of the government. One of the Key differences between them is that the English Bill of Rights addresses issues related to the king rather than the authority of parliament. There are many similarities between the English Bill of Rights and the US Constitution.

Read More
741 Words | 3 Pages

Meaning that while laws cannot interfere with religious belief and opinions, laws can be made to regulate some religious practices. For example, Human sacrifices are a part of some religious rituals, but they cannot be tolerated in the United States.  Chief Justice Waite stated that "If we do not make the Constitution the Supreme Law, and allow each person to make up their mind about what law to obey on religious grounds, we would put religious belief over the Constitution." Meaning this would undermine order and the government would only exist in

Read More
669 Words | 3 Pages

It is important to relate these Supreme Court Cases to religion having its disadvantages, including discrimination, because a court has the important task of balancing the civil rights among

Read More
728 Words | 3 Pages

The foundation condition disallows the legislature from passing enactment to build up an official religion or leaning toward one religion over another. It upholds the "partition of chapel and state. " Some administrative action identified with religion has been announced protected by the Supreme Court. For instance, giving transport transportation to parochial school understudies and the authorization of "blue laws" is not precluded. The free practice statement precludes the administration, in many occurrences, from meddling with a man's routine of their

Read More
1222 Words | 5 Pages

The Bill of rights contained the most important accomplishment of the convention-The Establishment Clause. The Establishment Clause was designed to protect religion from government infringement. It’s survival and proper interpretation, may directly correlate to the survival of the United

Read More
688 Words | 3 Pages

In Cold Blood is a well detailed book about the murder case of the clutter family. Although it has been banned for its sex, violence, and profanity, it has a well written story about a cold blooded murder. The two main characters Perry Smith and Richard Hickock where the two convicts that murdered the clutter family. Having a real story behind it makes it a bit more interesting giving it a real life scenario.

Read More
490 Words | 2 Pages

R2 ¶1. The US Constitution declares the separation of church and state. ¶2. The First Amendment states that the government may not interfere with people’s private religious beliefs. ¶3.

Read More
1212 Words | 5 Pages

Religious rights also are sometimes impeached as sometimes allowing one person to follow their religious rights might hamper another person’s rights. Another way that the Charter may cause the impeachment of one person’s rights to protect another’s rights is seen in the case of equality rights and a person’s

Read More
641 Words | 3 Pages

“Liberty which is essential to its existence, the other, by giving to every citizen the same opinions, the same passions, and the same interests.” One of the many issues is the ability that religion

Read More
1195 Words | 5 Pages

The rise of critical theories against the freedom to express religion openly, widens the gap for reconciliation between cultures of differences, an addition to the current contention involving the traditional understanding of religion and the right to abortion and game sex marriage. Although the term ‘human rights’ has its equivalent in many languages, the understanding of what human rights means is subject to debate and controversy. For some in non-Western societies, the discourse of human rights is a product of the West and Western civilization. It is based on the idea that individuals possess rights simply by virtue of being human (Saeed, 2004, 9). Freedom of religion is seen as one of the element of human rights addressed in major religious traditions of Judaism, Christianity, and Islam.

Read More
1787 Words | 8 Pages

Religious Freedom in the United States Religious freedom looks differently in all different parts of the world. As a result, there are various ways in which one can view these freedoms. Democracy plays a huge role in the formation of religious rights in the United States. It not only gives individual rights, but it also protects and opens doors for groups whose beliefs are in harmony with each other. In fact, the U.S. is classified as one of the most “pluralistic countries in the world”(Smith).

Read More
1251 Words | 6 Pages

As United States enters the 21st century, some important factors such as- social, economic, political changes, that challenge the attitude of religious pluralism has maintained for over two centuries. Prior to 1990, the supreme court had interpreted a constitution, religious freedom restoration act, 1993, means that the government does not have the right to interfere with religious practices unless it was able to show a ’compelling’ need to do. As it can be assumed that the United States is officially, historically and constitutionally a secular state. As a result, both federal and state government as well as, most private employers are forbidden from taking employment decisions with regards to the religions of the

Read More
1116 Words | 5 Pages

People should have the right to defend themselves judicially and should obviously have the right to religious

Read More

More about Freedom Of Religion

Related Topics

Open Document