ipl-logo

Gender Binary In Sexing The Body

1520 Words7 Pages

The gender binary is the reduction of gender into strictly a male or female identity. However, gender is a spectrum and is not limited to two options. The binary is an “effect of a […] taxonomic gender process that perpetually re-sorts (and reinterprets) all complex gender operations […] back into comprehensible dual alignment of bodies” (Roof 3). Individuals who cannot conform to the two categories are oppressed and ostracized. Similarly, a sexual dimorphic system is the regulation of two body types, masculine and feminine, based on genital anatomy and secondary sexual characteristics; it therefore becomes a technology for heterosexual reproduction because biological bodies “must” align with the sexual binary to be acknowledged (Preciado …show more content…

Though Money argues that intersexual individuals face contradictions between their feminine and masculine identities that should be dangerous to their mental health (333), he provides no evidence for a valid argument. In reaction to Money’s statement, Anne Fausto-Sterling in her book, Sexing the Body, redefines infant genital surgery as “cosmetic surgery performed to achieve a social result—reshaping a sexually ambiguous body so that it conforms to our two-sex system” (80). With special emphasis on the cosmetic, not medical, pressure for the surgery, Fausto-Sterling builds confidence in her argument by analyzing multiple studies on both sides of the debate. Surgeries for clitoroplasty or vaginoplasty that reinforced an alignment between gender and sexes were considered successful only if the criteria were based on cosmetic results rather than mental health or wellbeing (82-83, 88-91). In contrast, individuals who were raised as either female or male with unusual genitalia demonstrated a healthy psychological profile, even those whose sex of rearing differed from their sex of choice (96-100, 102-106). Though there is strong scientific evidence that disproves Money’s work, the multiormphic sytem threatens the gender and sexual binary …show more content…

Sexual dimorphism, according to Preciado, is the regulation of masculine and feminine sex assignment constructed on visual criteria of reproductive genitals (102). Because intersex infants have criteria of both masculine and feminine genitals, Money stressed the importance of sex reassignment surgery so that the infants can be reared in compliance with a sexual dimorphic society. He claimed that infants have malleable gender, which can be shaped by extrinsic social cues and a gender-specific upbringing. His “seemingly solid” theory of gender plasticity is advertised as “a relatively simple surgical solution to one of the most vexing and emotionally fraught conundrums in medicine: how to deal with the birth of an intersexual child” (Colapinto Chapter 2). Colapinto’s diction indicates how clinical applications of sexology during the 1960s were not evaluated for their effectiveness and validity, but rather for their endorsement of a dimorphic understanding of sex. Cultural emphasis on dimorphism was an attempt to regulate gender and sexuality for simplicity and tradition. Confronted with the “infinite variability of bodies and desire” (Preciado 105) that opposed the dimorphic gender binary, the traditional system of epistemology is

Show More
Related
2826 Words | 12 Pages

This is what drove all of his decisions in the case of Brenda Reimer. Dr. Money believed that if Brenda was raised as a girl not being told that she was once a boy that she would grow up to be a normal female with the help of surgery and hormone injections. He viewed human newborns as “total psychosexual blank slates” that could be changed despite what they were biologically born as. He told the Reimers when they made the decision to have their son sexually reassigned that for it to work that they must never tell their child and continually reaffirm the fact that they are a girl, and always have been a girl. Over the course of thirty years Dr. Money debated with Dr.

Read More
1376 Words | 6 Pages

Bo Lauren is another person who experienced surgery to fit the standeres of male or feamle. Bo was told they where a boy than found that had genes of girl so the clitoris was shorten and raised as a girl. The family was recommend to move as to not bring attention when changing the gender. Michle is another story of somone born with a penis but later told they had femel chromosomes and had surgery at 1 as welll as getting told to move. Jen in her teens learn that they where an intersex person who got surgery to be able to have sex the clitoris was shorten.

Read More
713 Words | 3 Pages

Those two categories have a particular anatomy. If someone doesn’t fit one or the other, then surgeons normalize them. This idea is too simplistic. Sex is more complicated than that. Dreger argues that nature doesn’t draw

Read More
1902 Words | 8 Pages

Introduction The concept of sex and gender has been socially constructed for a very long period of time, and it was a lot stricter in the past. As author Zimmerman indicated in his reading “Doing Gender” that “Those of us who taught courses in the area in the late 1960s and early 1970s were careful to distinguish one from the other.” (Zimmerman 1987) Nowadays, we know that the society is gradually changing and people are becoming more open-minded than before.

Read More
580 Words | 3 Pages

The chapter summarizes that sex differences in the brain structure and function has a close association to the psychological characteristics, such as sexual orientation. Social experience of humans influences hormones to a great extent. The relation between hormones and sex differences possesses both clinical and social implications. According to medicine, humans with ambiguous genitalia fall under the female sex as it is easier to create female genitalia when compared to male genitalia. Furthermore, surgical procedures used for reconstructuring either male or female genitalia have always worsened the

Read More
1211 Words | 5 Pages

This past October an intersex U.S. Navy veteran, Dana Zzyym, gained national attention after they were denied a passport. Zzyym identifies as neither male nor female, so they were denied the right to a passport after refusing to select a gender box on the application. After the denial Zzyym filed a federal discrimination lawsuit on the grounds that it is a constitutional violation to force an intersex person to select a gender box. Their argument is that gender, or lack of thereof, has nothing to do with travel, so why should it restrict or force people to declare a gender marker they do not identify as. Zzyym’s case finally brings to light how significant two little boxes can truly be, especially for those who live their lives outside

Read More
1212 Words | 5 Pages

Activists never acknowledge those contradictions. Instead, they opportunistically rely on whichever claim is useful at any given moment” (Anderson, 34). He is not only creating this writing because he disagrees with the opposition's opinions but because they don't recognize and address their own contradictions making their beliefs confusing. The definition of gender the author would most likely agree with is that gender should directly correlate to sex that was determined before and during birth essentially only male and

Read More
583 Words | 3 Pages

I chose to read an academic journal by Peter Bray titled, Men, Loss and Spiritual Emergency: Shakespeare, the Death of Hamnet and the Making of Hamlet. In the academic journal, the author Bray writes about how many of Shakespeare’s tragedies, most significantly Hamlet, were written due to being inspired by real life events. Also, he explains how Shakespeare expresses his feelings and thoughts through Hamlet’s soliloquies in Hamlet. In 1596, William Shakespeare’s son, Hamnet, died at the age of eleven years old.

Read More
585 Words | 3 Pages

Lassiter points out that many people understand gender as being natural and inherent, when in reality this isn’t the case. This means that gender roles are created and defined by culture, and the people who don’t fit these predetermined roles are often ostracized. I also learned that the term biological encompasses more than I had originally thought. I’d understood biological sex as dealing with genitalia. Additionally, it is related to one’s chromosomes and hormones.

Read More
802 Words | 4 Pages

Throughout the ages, gender has been socially constructed in some way or another. Gender conditioning begins once the parents are aware of the sexual gender of the child. Society has spoken: Pink pacifiers for the girls, blue pacifiers for the boys. The expectations begin. This list of expectations is also very much dependent upon the influence of cultural conditioning and ethnic identity as evident in Sandra Cisnero's Only Daughter.

Read More
1860 Words | 8 Pages

Perhaps one of the most fascinating yet depressing studies on gender, its fluidity, and how oppressive it can be is the case of David Reimer. In Chapter 3 of "Undoing Gender" by Judith Butler, this situation was studied in detail and psychoanalyzed. When Reimer was extremely young (under a year old), his penis was damaged and had to be removed, so psychiatrist John Money stepped in and told Reimer's parents that they could have sex reassignment surgery, raise David as a girl, and he'd live a normal and happy life. David was thus renamed Brenda and was brought up as female. Around age eight, however, Brenda started exhibiting traditionally masculine behaviors such as wanting to play with trucks and toy guns.

Read More
1777 Words | 8 Pages

The last method that females in general and Melanie in particular have used to construct their gender identities can be seen in light of the heroine’s relationship with the other “male” sex. In The Magic Toyshop, the concept of gender identity can be clarified through studying both male and female identity in terms of analyzing their relationships. Thus, to understand female identity, it seems imperative to refer to the role of male identity in forming female identity. Studying the psychological aspects of male characters, such as Finn and Uncle Philip, provides us with a deep understanding of the process of gender identity formulation. Moreover, it illustrates the dichotomy of male and female.

Read More
495 Words | 2 Pages

“A sex category is achieved through application of the sex criteria, but in everyday life, categorization is established and sustained by the socially required identificatory displays that proclaim one’s membership

Read More
1387 Words | 6 Pages

According to sexologists John Money and Anke Ehrhardt, sex and gender are separate categories. “Sex, they argued, refers to physical attributes and is anatomically and physiologically determined. Gender they saw as a psychological transformation - the internal conviction that one is either male or female (gender identity) and the behavioral expressions of that conviction” (Sterling 4). Although there are biological differences between the two sexes, but gender roles are socially constructed. They determine how males and females should think, speak, dress, behave and interact with society.

Read More
1472 Words | 6 Pages

We are ever since educated that we only have binary sexes – male or female, in schools. Traditions and cultures also suggest perceptions and conventions that creates the “correct” type of male and female. While the majority have their biological sex and gender identity aligned consistently, some just find theirs do not fit perfectly. Schools and the society were not able to explain this phenomenon and thus people related and mixed it to disorders and mental illness, tried to control it and to ‘fix’

Read More

More about Gender Binary In Sexing The Body

Related Topics

Open Document