Dred Scott Case Essay

"History inevitability", "Dred Scott Case" which is the immediate flashpoint of American Civil War, can be avoided?

The different factors resulted in "Dred Scott Case" which were unavoidable. This event is a historical inevitability rather than a historical possibility.

Ⅰ. The personal factor affects the decision of Chief Justice Roger B. Taney.

A. The place where he from held the inherent idea about slaves.

Tenny think Scott free will is the Fifth Amendment of serious violation, because this is in lack of the premise of the due process of law under the personal property of deprivation. Congress has no power to prohibit slavery, and to the grounds of violation of the constitution, should be designed to limit the expansion of slavery in 1820,

Comparison of different political forces outside the Court seems to inevitably affect the attitude of judges. However, judging from the results of the ruling and the above background reflected in the strong power of slavery, the court's judicial interpretation of the majority of people and their representatives in the historical period seems to be established. As a result, most of the judges in the Supreme Court, on the issue of slavery, tended to abolish the restrictions on slavery than those in Congress at the

There are complex reasons for the occurrence of such a major event, but not a single factor. In fact, although the negative impact of the general, but the decision for the separation of the southern states did not have an indirect or direct role. However, Dred Scott decision for both sides in this country to bridge the differences that do nothing. On the contrary, it gives one of them a complete victory. Worse than that, it weakened the people's sovereignty theory of compromise and pushed the Republicans to a more extreme position, in fact, to accelerate the pace of the country's civil war. To make it worse, these flawed actions were made by the slave