ipl-logo

Hoover's Hands-Off Approach Essay

3862 Words16 Pages

The Great Depression was a milestone in US history. It shows us what a hands-off laissez-faire approach looks like in crisis and what a strong hands-on, intervening government looks like in crisis. It started on Black Tuesday, October 29th, 1929. People couldn’t get their money from banks after the stock market crashed because they didn’t have it. Unemployment rates skyrocketed and America needed a president to lead with a strong grasp over this economic crisis. 2 and a half years later on March 4, 1933, Franklin Delano Roosevelt was sworn into office and he was a man with a plan. He was quite the contrary from his predecessor, Herbert Hoover, who used laissez-faire, hands-off tactics when the country needed it least. FDR would come …show more content…

The Great Depression was a time of peril for the strong majority of Americans. Hoover’s main solution was to not do much, to let time pass and hope the problem goes away. Well, that’s being unfair, he enacted some questionable policies. For example, he signed the Smoot-Hawley Tariff bill that would tax 40% of trade. As a result, GDP fell 8.5% as this just isolated America’s trade partners. (6.4) Even during his speeches, Hoover pushed responsibility away, hoping that the Great Depression would just go away like magic to retain his hands-off philosophy. During his second State of the Union Address, he said “There are many factors which give encouragement for the future. The fact that we are holding from 80 to 85% of our normal activities and incomes; that our major financial and industrial institutions have come through the storm unimpaired…” He’s completely neglecting the 15-20% of the economy that’s clearly not alright. People are losing jobs and some even becoming homeless. His most significant response was making cardboard villages for homeless people called Hooverville that were only needed because he didn’t do anything to help the economy, so they had no jobs. Other than his obligatory speeches, Hoover would not converse with the people. Roosevelt actually utilized new technology, the radio, to have Fireside Chats. Many people compare this to how modern day politicians utilize social media. On his first chat on March 12, 1933, he assured people how the banking system worked, why they couldn’t get their money, and how he was going to fix it. (6.9) Even during his Inaugural Address, he said “Nor need we shrink from honestly facing conditions in our country today. This great Nation will endure as it has endured, will revive, and will prosper.” Here, he’s admitting to what’s happening with the economy and assuring

Show More
Related
1017 Words | 5 Pages

President Franklin Delano Roosevelt’s approach to mend the Great Depression was more effective than that of the previous president, Herbert Hoover. Hoover and Roosevelt had contrasting ideas on how the Depression should be handled. Hoover was a republican businessman, who was brought up in a poor family and had worked his way to become financially affluent, while Roosevelt was a Democrat who came from a rich background. When the depression struck, Hoover was unable to provide suitable economical, political and social assistance to those Americans who desperately needed it most; this eventually resulted in the elimination of his presidency. Despite his affluent background, Roosevelt’s past struggles led him to develop compassion and earnest

Read More
928 Words | 4 Pages

One of his excuses was “ These shocks have in a large sense come from without our borders” meaning that it was some external country that plunged us into the great depression. Even though this was at least partially true, the American people didn't see it that way, and blamed hoover for most of their problems. This is painfully evident in the names of the “Slums” that formed as a result of the depression, commonly known as Hoovervilles. The Public was further outraged by Hoover and his plan to bring america back from the Great Depression. Hoover's plan was essentially a hands off approach, His party believed the country would fix itself given enough time.

Read More
1435 Words | 6 Pages

Research Question: Did Hoover as a president accomplished anything to save American’s economy during The Great Depression? Research Paper Jamie Tieliang Yang US History Period 6 April 9 2015 Ms. Hilaman Windermere Preparatory School Word Count – 1454 Table of Contents Page A. Plan of Investigation…………………………………………………..

Read More
1885 Words | 8 Pages

He wanted people to recover their lost confidence through individualism. He didn’t provide any direct relief. Hoover relied on businesses to sustain employment and investment. Later he realized that there hadn’t been any improvement in the economy and signed bills that provided employment through public works projects. Roosevelt on the other hand, called for individual liberty through an involved government.

Read More
429 Words | 2 Pages

Many blame Herbert Hoover for the Great Depression, but this is a false statement because he stepped into office at the worst time. He had to immediately formulate new policies that would help the US retreat from the Great Depression. He served one term from 1929 to 1933. One item that made him well known for his presidency were the camps that housed the unemployed and the poor, called Hoovervilles. These “shanty towns” were normally on the outskirts of major cities and towns, so the community was close enough to still walk into town.

Read More
1974 Words | 8 Pages

 Hoover is often blamed for not doing anything to end the Great Depression, but he actually did try to use the government to create infrastructure projects, thus creating jobs. Like the Hoover Dam and the Reconstruction Finance Corporation to try to end the Depression. There are two major differences between their approaches.  One is that President Roosevelt was willing to do more than President Hoover to combat the Great Depression.  Roosevelt was willing to let the government become more involved in the economy.

Read More
564 Words | 3 Pages

The wealth during the 1920s left Americans unprepared for the economic depression they would face in the 1930s. The Great Depression occurred because of overproduction by farmers and factories, consumption of goods decreased, uneven distribution of wealth, and overexpansion of credit. Hoover was president when the depression first began, and he maintained the government’s laissez-faire attitude in the economy. However, after the election of FDR in 1932, his many alphabet soup programs in his first one hundred days in office addressed the nation’s need for change.

Read More
339 Words | 2 Pages

President Hoover promised that in every pot there would be a chicken, but like the lyrics from a song in the musical Annie, the people of the day said, “not only don’t we have the chicken, we ain’t got the pot.” President Hoover caused a lot of anger, he caused people to be homeless with no food and little money, and although Hoover promised to fix everything, it was completely unclear to anyone that anything had changed. The Great depression was one of the worst moments in history. President Hoover decided to try and fix the economy, but his strategy was not working.

Read More
462 Words | 2 Pages

Jaiah Jackson U.S. History 2 Mr.Grillo May 31, 2023 The Great Depression marked a significant turning point of the United States, and the leadership of Herbert Hoover and Franklin Delano Roosevelt played a crucial role in shaping the nation's response to the crisis. While Hoover and Roosevelt shared a common goal of restoring the country’s economic prosperity, their approaches differed significantly. This essay will compare and contrast the backgrounds, policies, and leadership styles of these two presidents, to better understand their impact on American History.

Read More
270 Words | 2 Pages

The Great Depression was a time during 1929 to 1939, It was the longest lasting economic disaster. The two presidents in term during this crisis, Franklin D. Roosevelt and Herbert Hoover, approached this problem in different ways. Hoover’s idea on this was to have private citizens help each others, while Roosevelt believed the government should take care of its people with social programs. Looking at these ideas in more depth we can infer ways our country should go. Herbert Hoover served as president during 1929 to 1933.

Read More
1203 Words | 5 Pages

The Great Depression was a difficult time for the United States, and both Herbert Hoover and Franklin D. Roosevelt faced significant challenges in trying to address the economic crisis and its impact on the American people. Hoover, as I mentioned earlier, believed in limited government intervention and a reliance on the private sector to address the crisis. He believed that the best way to stimulate the economy was to encourage businesses to invest and hire more workers. However, his approach failed to turn the tide of the depression, and many people criticized him for not doing enough to help those who were suffering. Franklin D. Roosevelt, on the other hand, had a more interventionist approach to addressing the economic crisis.

Read More
827 Words | 4 Pages

Unfortunately Hoover’s acknowledgment of the problem was not enough for Roosevelt and Hoover to find common ground. Roosevelt clearly disagreed with Hoover’s methods of depending on charity to pull America out of the Great Depression. He verbalised this in his speech, “We refused to leave the problems of our common welfare to be solved by the winds of change and the hurricanes of disaster. ”(Hanes and hanes 9) To reiterate, Roosevelt was saying that he refused to leave the responsibility of the suffering American people up to charities. The government is responsible for its citizens.

Read More
774 Words | 4 Pages

I think that Herbert Hoover did a good thing when he gave that speech because he was able to get people to believe him and agree with him. Our 31st President was not a good Chief Legislator. Whenever Hoover disagreed with Congress’ ideas, and wanted to Veto something, the Veto would almost always, if not always, be overturned by voting in Congress. No matter what Hoover did, he couldn’t win against Congress whenever they argued about something, which is the reason why I believe that Herbert Hoover was a really bad Chief

Read More
1015 Words | 5 Pages

Hoover tried to make policies for his citizens but those policies just made everything worse than it already was. Hoover gave out more taxes, and while he was trying to stimulate the economy, the unemployment rates continued to rise and the country fell deeper into debt. Hoover didn’t do much during this period to help people out, Wikipedia Contributors. “Herbert Hoover.”, states, “The causes of the Great Depression remain a matter of debate, but Hoover viewed a lack of confidence in the financial system as the fundamental economic problem facing the nation.”

Read More
1645 Words | 7 Pages

President Herbert Hoover made efforts to try to fix the great depression. Many people disliked him as a president and complained he didn’t even care. However he at least tired to help people recover from the great depression. Some policies he created were the Hoover Moratorium, the Federal Home Loan Bank Act of 1932, and the Great New Deal. Hoover created the Hoover Moratorium to end the war debts however it didn’t help with the economic crisis.

Read More

More about Hoover's Hands-Off Approach Essay

Related Topics

Open Document