ipl-logo

How Are Rome And Carthage Similar

546 Words3 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Athens vs rome democracy

Hello, Marsia

Warmest greetings to you.

This week learning journal for your kind review please.

Discussion: Briefly discuss how the governments of Rome and Carthage differed.

When I indulged myself in studying the Punic Wars, I found ancient Rome's fortune was inseparable from its arch-rival, Carthage. For one, no two superpower could be more evenly matched, which I reasoned there must be some strong governmental forces at work behind the two leading contenders in their pursuit of political dominance during the 200s and 100s B.C. Hence, it is worthy discovering their system and comparing how their national structures differ in the following.

To begin with, Rome was known for overthrew its seventh king and established Roman Republic in …show more content…

This aristocracy was characterized and dominated by opposing families...for enterprising citizens, especially rich merchants, there was the possibility to join this aristocracy as wealth was the overriding factor for success in politics."(Catwright, 2016). Simply put, it seemed to me that "the best and the few" kept a tight grip on Carthage.

Taken together, in many ways, the governments of Rome and Carthage were polar opposites, the former gave ordinary people the right to vote and govern the state, though "real political power was centered in the Senate"(n.d.). By comparison, Carthaginian empire was a mixture of various systems that they complemented each other which "created a unique organization rarely seen in the ancient world"(n.d.).

Reference

Ancient Rome. (n.d.). Retrieved on 21st Dec, 2017, http://www.history.com/topics/ancient-history/ancient-rome

Cartwright, M. (2016). Carthaginian Government. Ancient History Encyclopedia. Retrieved on 21st Dec, 2017, https://www.ancient.eu/Carthaginian_Government/

Jarus, O. (2012). Carthage: Ancient Phoenician City-State. Live Science. Retrieved on 21st Dec, 2017, https://www.livescience.com/24246-ancient-carthage.html

Republican Rome. (n.d.). Retrieved on 21st Dec, 2017,

Show More
Related

Monomyth And The Hero's Journey Study Guide

1609 Words | 7 Pages

Carthage myth: Dido had to escape from her brother who did not want her to be a queen, but she became a queen, something strange at that time, also she showed that women are as capable as men being able to rule and sustain her city. We can see that gender inequalities had been a problem for many centuries that even though today it had been reduced, it is still present today. Peace, Justice and Strong Institutions Rome's myth: Regarding to this goal we can see that in Rome's myth we can see that they solve their disagreements on a non-peaceful nor just way. When the law which says the eldest son inherits the kingdom was infringed when Amulius took Numitor’s place as a king, and in revenge Romulus and Remus killed Amulius to return the kingdom to his grandfather. Also, when Romulus killed Remus for

Read More

What Are The Similarities Between Ancient Athens Rome And Han China

415 Words | 2 Pages

Athens, Rome, Han China, and Ancient Egypt all have similar and different geography, history and government. First in Athens they had a Direct democracy. In Athens they picked 500 men to come together and vote. In Rome they had a Republic. Because they had so much land each section had to have their citizens vote for a representative.

Read More

Compare And Contrast Roman And Han Empires

564 Words | 3 Pages

Empires throughout history have all had their own methods to political control. Some very similar others could not be any more different. Some of the great empires such as the Han and the Roman had very similar approaches to political control. Although both the Han and the Roman empires had similar forms of government both bureaucracies, both empires had many individual characteristics as well.

Read More

How Democracy: How Democratic Was The Roman Republic?

218 Words | 1 Pages

How Democratic was the Roman Republic? The Roman Republic was as democratic as they could be for their time. Only prior history of government was ruled by a king. The Romans believed their constitution included everyone.

Read More

Comparing The Dictatorship Of Sulla And The Fall Of The Roman Republic

706 Words | 3 Pages

In the early ages, Rome was ruled by Etruscan kings. However, in 509 B.C.E. Rome declared itself a republic. Although there was no written constitution for the new government, the system evolved over time. In the Roman Republic, there were extreme class distinctions and barriers between the aristocracy and the lower class. Two consuls were elected to lead instead of the king.

Read More

How Did The Punic Wars Contribute To The Rise Of Carthage?

574 Words | 3 Pages

Carthage was the first foreign opponent to come in touch with Rome, they fought series of war against Rome. Carthage rose to become a major force to be reckoned with, during the Punic Wars, which made Rome nervous since there existed the unknown possibility of Rome being knocked off its throne of power. Carthage was known for its strong naval army that no other army dared to go to battle against without having a serious battle plan to overtake them. Most of the momentum to power is much to the credit of Alexander the Great during his conquests after 332 BCE. After the fall of the Phoenician city of Tyre most citizens fled and were spared their lives by Alexander; being the efficient traders they were, they were able to quickly re-establish the wealth they had, which greatly helped them build their defenses and forces to rival that of Rome’s.

Read More

The Barcas: Power Or Partial Power In Carthage

117 Words | 1 Pages

In conclusion, the Barcas held the power or partial power in Carthage essentially from the end of the First Punic war until Hannibal went into exile in 195 B.C. Although they did not hold political positions until the end of Hannibal’s time in Carthage, they still shaped the politics of Carthage for more than fifty years. Moreover, the way in which they conducted their political maneuverings, either led others to love them, in the case of Hasdrubal, or hate them in the case of Hanno. Their rivalry with Hanno and his faction clearly weakened their cause in unifying Carthage against Rome. Had they not possessed the arrogance and power hunger, they most likely would have defeated Rome.

Read More

How Did The Romans Corrupt The Republic

338 Words | 2 Pages

In 509 BCE, the Romans established a government they knew as the republic (Bishop, 77). These chosen leaders and representatives represented the public as a whole, a lot like our government does in the United Sates. The reason for this was because the Romans were tired of the ruling of the Etruscans (77). This group of Etruscans were mostly from southern Italy, most likely were corrupted kings that led the Romans to institute the republic (77). The interesting part here is how human sin nature took over and corrupted the republic.

Read More

Carthage And Rome: The Three Punic Wars

242 Words | 1 Pages

According to Morey (1901), Carthage was a wealthier nation with brilliant leaders, rich in commercial resources. It had a more powerful navy and they showed their greatness in their successes. On the other hand, Rome was better organized and had a more efficient army. It depended on the well-organized political system and the character of its people.

Read More

How Did The Roman Republic A Form Of Government

634 Words | 3 Pages

Roman Republic start: Roman republic was a form of government which was built in the ancient state, centre of the city Rome. It all began when ancient rome governed Roman Republic for 450 years, and consisted with government that allowed for old or senior citizens to elect officials. There were a lot decrees in order to choose a citizen who can elect authoritative such as: Women of any caste not allowed to vote to elect official and men's or women considering low estate, wealth or citizenship weren't able to vote as well. When the Romans conquer their Etruscan conquerors in 509 BCE in the north of Rome. The Etruscans had governed over the Romans for more than 100 years.

Read More

Ancient Rome Vs Usa Research Paper

567 Words | 3 Pages

Rome didn’t have many, if at all any relationships between other city’s. The last difference is that the in the U.S. leader doesn’t have absolute power, unlike Rome. This can be bad because it takes a long time to get anything done unlike in Rome if the leader wanted a road the slaves or workers would go start working on

Read More

How Did Ancient Greece Influence Ancient Rome

1428 Words | 6 Pages

The Ancient Greeks’ renowned use of democracy influenced Ancient Rome’s government structure. The strong belief in Gods and oracles in Ancient Greek shaped the religion of Ancient Romans. The Spartan-like training and leadership style of Ancient Greek war heroes formed the

Read More

Imperialism And Imperial Rome Essay

1669 Words | 7 Pages

Rome’s story is of a group taking countless outside influences and through forging a collective identity from these external forces. According to the legend, the Roman Republic was founded as the elites ousted their last king from power. The removal of the monarchy paved the way for the patricians to build a new government. However, the original design of the constitution gave the patricians the lion’s share of influence.

Read More

The Role Of Democracy In Ancient Rome

534 Words | 3 Pages

Democracy in Ancient Rome Ancient Rome is often portrayed as a highly democratic society for the ancient world. After all, the United States’ government is modeled after some parts of the Roman’s structure of government. But,was Rome as democratic as is is commonly thought to be? Contrary to what people may think Rome’s democracy wasn't exactly so democratic for all of its citizens. One example of Rome’s confusing concept of democracy can be found in The Histories, which was written by the Greek historian Polybius in 119 BCE.

Read More

Roman Government Vs Us Government Essay

1027 Words | 5 Pages

Although one of their best ideas was known as the type of government they established what is now known as the republic, and since then it has been copied by other places, the united states uses and has similarity to roman republic. The U.S government is based partly on the model of Rome’s. the parts and similarity’s that we still use today are things like citizenship, legal code, legislative branch /senate, and others. The republic all started when the romans finally overthrew the Etruscan conquerors they had around (509 B.C.E) once they were free the romans came up or established the republic, a government were the citizens picked a representative to rule on their behalf. The concept of Citizenship in Rome was that males of ages 15 or older, that came from original tribes or places of Rome became citizens.

Read More

More about How Are Rome And Carthage Similar

Related Topics

Open Document