ipl-logo

How Can UW-Madison Lose Money By Divesting?

1330 Words6 Pages

However, many of those opposed to divestment say that UW-Madison will lose money by divesting. One reason for this is that divesting entails restricting the freedom of the managers who run the university’s endowment fund. In total, colleges and universities own $12 billion worth of fossil fuel company stocks. Presumably, the the reason that most universities currently invest in fossil fuels is that fossil fuels are a good investment. If renewables were actually a better investment than fossil fuels, as divestment advocates claim, financial experts would likely already be investing in renewables. Furthermore, UW-Madison may have a harder time hiring financial managers after divestment. In 2016, Dartmouth University was considering divesting …show more content…

In 2014, over 1,400 UW-Madison students signed a petition to get UW-Madison to divest its investments in fossil fuel companies. Among their rationale for signing was that the actions and policies of large public universities are closely followed by the media and the public. A Badger Herald article from that year quotes a student who writes, “I think the splash we would make would raise the level of knowledge and discussion that is so desperately needed”. Thus, at the very least, divestment by big public universities such as UW-Madison would get more people talking about climate change. Another student wrote that, “There are many among us at the UW who feel that it is wrong to seek profit by investing in such monumentally irresponsible endeavors”. If UW-Madison’s divestment from fossil fuels created a big enough wave in the media, fossil fuel companies might start to worry even if the divestment had little economic …show more content…

The path to divestment will not be easy. In 2014, a panel of UW-Madison faculty members convened and was split on whether or not to divest. If divestment were to be brought back to the table, it would take a huge initiative from students and staff to push it through. The time, money, and mental focus that would go towards achieving divestment is an opportunity cost. Craig Benson, Director of Sustainability Research and Education at UW-Madison, has a clear vision for how those resources could be used more effectively. Benson was one of the panel members for the 2015 Climate Quest competition at Madison. The competition challenged community members to address a problem caused by climate change. The winner in 2015 was a project to provide sustainable food production to regions of developing nations with high food insecurity. Benson said of the project, “rather than advocate through protests or divestment, we chose to draw on our greatest strengths – the energy, creativity, and talents of our faculty, staff, and students.” Although Benson is specifically referring to the Climate Quest competition, his words echo the belief among anti-divestors that focusing on innovation and research is the most resource-effective way to combat climate

Show More
Related
974 Words | 4 Pages

Bill McKibben is considered to be America’s first environmentalist activist. His project 350.org works to spread awareness of climate change around the world. Without his push to end projects such as the Keystone Pipeline, the planet would quickly reach the uninhabitable state he fears. While it’s too late to reverse the damages already done, he encourages everyone to do their part to keep the world from getting any worse. His efforts, along with activists around the world, have successfully divested $2.6 trillion in oil drilling funds, and while the few oil companies are still hanging on by a thread with support from large private businesses or people like the Koch family, clean sources of energy are becoming increasingly popular in the

Read More
1228 Words | 5 Pages

Loblaw’s approach to these sustainability issue is to join the carbon disclosure project which gave Loblaw’s a score of 82% in 2015. The disclosure report indicates that Loblaw’s uses a specific climate change risk management approach where a boards of directors meet every six months or more to discus concerns. The environment polices discussed are then incorporated in Loblaw’s business. The main focus to address pollution and global warming are reducing electricity usage, fuel consumption, refrigeration leaks and reduce waste (Michaud, 2015). Now, Walmart and Metro are also involved with the carbon disclosure project.

Read More
759 Words | 4 Pages

Logan Carroll Professor Wyant THEO 421 14 April 2023 Purchasing Habits As a St. Thomas student, I have learned the value of ethical and sustainable practices. As a finance major, I have learned that being ethical in business decisions is of the utmost importance. I am glad that in the last four years, I have also heard about businesses becoming more sustainable. In this economy, sustainability is critical for a circular future.

Read More
848 Words | 4 Pages

If you want to make sure the scientists aren’t causing any problems, you take away all their funding”. Duck was not alone in his concerns, scientists who became outspoken on the environmental impacts of the Alberta oil sands, were often criticized by federal government for publicly sharing their findings. For example, when David Schindler was a professor of ecology at the University of Alberta, his research team found that the resource project was contaminating the Athabasca watershed, and some fish were developing deformities. When he published this in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, Schindler was criticized by federal government. “It’s like they don’t want to hear about science anymore,” Schindler stated.

Read More
549 Words | 3 Pages

In the article ‘Why Bother?’ Michael Pollan, a Professor of Journalism at the University of California, examines the dangers of climate change and how ordinary citizens can reduce its effects on the environment. Although most scientists are concerned and have warned nations of its disastrous effects some still deny the existence of climate change. As if melting ice caps and the ever-increasing blue waters were not enough proof, some citizens believe that climate change is an “unproven theory or a negligible contribution to natural climate variability” (Hall 3). Nevertheless, citizens who believe in global warning can change how they live for the better.

Read More
551 Words | 3 Pages

In the New York Times’ Room for Debate series, eight individuals who all are involved in some way with issue of fossil fuel use, as scientists, environmentalists, petroleum industry representatives, etc., are asked for their opinions on the Keystone XL pipeline and if protesting its development is really worth the struggle. The proposed pipeline would carry bitumen, a type of heavy, black oil, from northern Alberta, Canada, where it is extracted from tar sands, to Houston, Texas. In Houston, the bitumen would be sent to oil refineries, refined, and made ready to sell on the global market. The Keystone XL pipeline has attracted so much protest because tar sand oil is an very polluting energy source and has significant implications on climate change, but those in favor of the pipeline say its impact on the climate

Read More
1040 Words | 5 Pages

In “Why Bother?” an article published in the New York Times Magazine, commentator Michael Pollan questions the severity that contributes to environmental problem and how an individual should attempt to make an impact regardless of the miniscule effect it will have presently and in the future. Pollan discusses how an individual's endeavors remain unnoticed when taking into account the consequences of one’s environmentally friendly actions. The concept of being named a liberal is discussed and its correlation towards one's decisions in changing one’s manner. Implementing laws that would promote green behavior is a drastic step to help the environment, but they would be very simple so everyone can comply.

Read More
1603 Words | 7 Pages

Academic Analysis: “Natural Gas Fracking Addresses All of Our Major Problems” In his essay, “Natural Gas Fracking Addresses All of our Major Problems,” Richard Pierce argues that by using horizontal drilling and fracturing of shale formations to obtain natural gas will solve many of our nation’s issues. He cites that by accessing our abundant supply of natural gas, the economy, environment, and geopolitical conditions will improve. He backs these claims by listing examples of recently discovered natural gas basins in the United States and abroad and by showing that the current gas supply has put downward pressure on oil prices. Lower oil prices make many products more affordable and improve the global economy.

Read More
873 Words | 4 Pages

This program would tax the general population and businesses on their excess use of fossil fuels. The money generated from this tax has been consistently argued about were it should be spent, however, a well liked solution has begun to emerge; putting the money towards renewable energy research projects. This would begin to break the debt-based fossil fuel cycle by providing consumers with another alternative (Conners). A carbon tax would force factories, businesses and the general population to become aware of their actions, helping to “change destructive environmental behaviour” (Conners). With an expense placed on carbon emissions, there would be a drop in extreme consumption of fossil fuels, as a result, people and businesses would adjust to more sustainable methods of

Read More
771 Words | 4 Pages

While some are more interested in the money others actually care about their students and their success (16). John Hennessy, the president of Stanford, is a board member for companies,

Read More
1229 Words | 5 Pages

The university becomes about how many students can we enroll and graduate. It does not matter how they leave. Our students become a commodity. To say that TA&T is a business causes us to look at our school strictly through as economic lens, and this produces students, faculty and administration that view education as a form of technical training and a students skills only matter if they can be branded, commodified and traded. This is why the School of Arts and Sciences are overlooked, TA&T, and the administration can make more money when they invest in STEM.

Read More
772 Words | 4 Pages

The biggest thing to keep in mind here is it takes millions to keep a big program on its feet. Take a football program for example; rarely do University

Read More
150 Words | 1 Pages

That means an energy savings of more than $110 billion to the U.S. economy, all thanks to fracking shale formations full of natural gas. In fact, companies such as Dow Chemical and Westlake Chemical have found that

Read More
995 Words | 4 Pages

Exxon had already lost a lot of reputation. Also, there was no way to mitigate the risks caused by the environment. Hence, I am of the opinion that this is not the best place for EM to build an image as a responsible environmental citizen.

Read More
721 Words | 3 Pages

It is predicted that in this century we will deplete all of our fossil fuels, which we heavily rely on today. One of the main reasons that people are not acting on creating more green energy is that they simply do not have a clear understanding of the effects of using nonrenewable resources. Many schools don't teach about anything in the area of climate change, fossil fuels or the ways that the world is changing because of them. Many people also don’t know that we are running out of these resources, and extremely

Read More

More about How Can UW-Madison Lose Money By Divesting?

Related Topics

Open Document