ipl-logo

How Did Thucydides And Kennes Contribute To The Understanding Of State Behavior

426 Words2 Pages

Examination of How Thucydides and Kennan Contribute to the Understanding of State Behavior and the Concept of Power The Melian Dialogue from Thucydides’ The Peloponnesian Wars, describes the interaction between the Athenians and the Melians regarding the desired surrender of Melos. The Athenians, who were more powerful and influential than the Melians, wanted Melos to submit without a fight. Should the Melians agree to ally themselves with the Athenians, it would be an example of power asymmetry. The dialogue records by Thucydides gives us a better understanding of the concept of power. The Athenians had the strength and therefore did what they pleased, as, if anyone was going to suffer it wouldn’t be them. The arrangement could in no way be an equal one unless the Athenians chose to make it so. Sadly for the Melians, like many nations Athens was only interested in advancing its own people. The Athenians did not want anyone to be neutral. This contrasts greatly to the current world powers, which generally stand up for neutrality, such as the outrage that was felt at the beginning of the first World War when neutral Belgium was invaded by Germany. …show more content…

State behavior is largely created around culture and tradition. If it was Athenian tradition to judge that theirs was the worthy cause, it helps one to understand what motivated the nation to overtake an island that had no power or real benefit to offer. Athens’ goal was to advance its own nation regardless of the cost to other. The ancient world power was focused on success at the cost of other peoples. In contrast, the United States often interferes with other countries in efforts to spread democracy and westernization, with the idealism that this one nation can bring a sort of “salvation” to the

Show More
Related

Pericles Strategies During The Peloponnesian War

1047 Words | 5 Pages

Athens had the means to support the war due to the immense wealth and the resources remitted from Athenian colonies and allies. He figured that they would outlast the Spartans do to their limited wealth and resource base available to them. To ensure that the means of Athens were maintained, she was required “to keep a tight rein on their allies” since without their allies the support being provided and remittance of resources would dry up. During the Spartan raids into Attica in attempts to draw out the Athenian army, the ever present risk that was present to answer the raids due to the honor which called the people to defending their homes and lands. Pericles minimized the risk by not calling an assembly or meeting the people, which could reverse the strategy that he outlined.

Read More

How Did Athens Conquer The Peloponnesian War?

907 Words | 4 Pages

Although Athenian citizens could vote and had a say in the government, it was the king who made the real decision. When the generals came to negotiate with the Melians, they were representing the king's wishes. Athens wanted to conquer other colonies and nations, expanding their empire. Athens thought that any kingdom weaker than them should be conquered. It was thought that the strong had a right to conquer the

Read More

Does Herodotus And Thucydides Present The Victory In The Battle Of Marathon

465 Words | 2 Pages

For instance, he writes, “The Athenians, so soon as they were let go, charged the barbarians at a run.and fought in a manner worthy of being recorded.” Additionally, he includes dramatic elements, like Hippias’ dream and Epizelus’ miraculous blindness, which can be interpreted as attempts to glorify Athenian actions. Lastly, I feel as though he tends to glorify the events, portraying the Battle of Marathon as a heroic struggle with clear moral distinctions between the Greek defenders. In contrast, Thucydides employs a more analytical and philosophical approach, presenting a dialogue that explores moral and ethical dimensions of power and war. The Melian Dialogue is a debate about justice, power, and survival, portraying the Athenians as ruthless and focused on power and survival over morality.

Read More

The Importance Of Citizenship: Why Athens Was The Better System

504 Words | 3 Pages

Unlike the Romans, Athenians had a strict but fair schedule that allowed them to enjoy citizenship equally. Equally, hard workers have brought Athens power just as much as hereditary leaders. According to Document B all citizens should be allowed to speak their opinion and have a share in election because of the hard work they do to make the city powerful. Athenians allowed poor and common men to win a position in government which was a transition from the wealthy having power to everyone having power.

Read More

A Primary Text Analysis: The Funeral Oration Of Pericles

664 Words | 3 Pages

Pericles argues that Athens has become a model for others, and articulates what it is to be a good citizen. This can be seen when he says, “although the eyes of an enemy may occasionally profit by our liberality; trusting less in system and policy than to the native spirit of our citizens; while in education, where our rivals from their very cradles by a painful discipline seek after manliness, at Athens we live exactly as we please, and yet are just as ready to encounter every legitimate danger.” (Thucydides, 2.39) It proves that Ancient Athens’ valued greatness and worked in order to achieve the excellence of the state, by focusing on rebuilding themselves back up after the Persian war. Pericles played a big role in this because he showed his ambitions to rebuild Athens, which lead to the thriving of other subjects such as literature, philosophy, science, art, and religion.

Read More

Achilles Vs Peloponnesan War

1845 Words | 8 Pages

This is see when the civil war breaks out in Corcyra, and when the Athenians decided “put to death all the men of military age…and sold all the women and children as slaves,” and effectively end the Melian race. (Thucydides 5.116) This echoes the actions that the Spartans took against the Plataenas. Athenians prided themselves on being above the Spartans, believing that they had more restraint, and were above senseless killing in a way that the Spartans were not. This occurs earlier when Athenians debate the fate of the Melians they say “then we on our side will use no fine phrases” (Thucydides 5.89) which mimics the Spartan preference for avoiding long speeches something they voiced when they said, “[we] do not understand these long speeches which the Athenians make.”

Read More

Alcibiades's Defeat For The Athenian

431 Words | 2 Pages

First, I want to highlight that the invasion of Melos, the Athenians were under the influence of their military and power success over Melos, especially that they proved to Melians the greatness and the importance of power, not justice. Thus, under the snowball effect, and as the great power they (Athens) wanted to have more and more power, that might played part in the decision making process during the expedition assembly. If the Athenians had not been that sure about their strength and had not such a huge desire to gain a lot of glory being a hegemon, they might have extracted some other meanings from the Melian dialogue. Thucydides emphasized the idea that force without any limits or sense of justice, could generate an uncontrollable desire for infinite gain to enlarge the Empire, especially when there were no logical limits to do

Read More

Why Was Athens Successful

875 Words | 4 Pages

Athens organized a group of Greek city states into the Delian League and eventually lead and dominated all of the city states in the League. Athens’s military prowess allowed them to look down on the other members of the League and treat them as members of an empire instead of equals. This caused some to view them with hostility which sparked the conflicts between Athens and Sparta that lead to the Peloponnesian War. The direct democracy of Athens wasn’t actually as inclusive and steady as the statement at Pericles 's funeral state, “Our Constitution is called a democracy because power is in the hands not of a minority but of the whole people (Doc C).” In fact, of the 450,000 citizens of Athens in 430 BC, only about 40,000 people had the power to vote.

Read More

Athens Vs Sparta Compare And Contrast

721 Words | 3 Pages

Today, many of the world’s government structures were based on the principle of one of Greece’s city-states. Greece became a country advancing well before its time, strong in both military and brain power. This country was able to produce two city-states that became foundations to advancing the rest of the world. The first city-state, Athens, is thought to be the first to implement a democratic government while Sparta became known for their military power. While Athens and Sparta provide the world with advancements they differ in the ways of government structures, social motivations, and cultural differences.

Read More

The Cultural Values Of Athens And Sparta

1488 Words | 6 Pages

Athens and Sparta, located between the Aegean and the Ionian Sea, allied with each other in the Greco-Persian war. Due to the advanced and powerful navy of Athens incorporation with the well-built army of Sparta, they gained victory over the Persian Empire. After the victory, Athens gained wealth and dominance over the other Greek societies causing tensions between Sparta. They both share similarities towards their cultural background but had different views in creating an ideal society in addition to their state’s place in the world. Moreover, they differ from the concepts of a well trained or educated society and a well built military, but share similarities in their government format.

Read More

Thucydides Funeral Oration In The Peloponnesian War

496 Words | 2 Pages

Patterson’s argument that our modern definition of freedom and its three chords: sovereignal, civic, and personal; is clearly seen in Thucydides’ “funeral oration” in the work History of the Peloponnesian War. The first of the Patterson’s chords is sovereignal or sovereignty, the ability for a group of people to govern themselves. Thucydides communicates this idea in the following manner, “and a keen feeling of honour in action that men were enabled to win all this, and that no personal failure in an enterprise could make them consent to deprive their country of their valour,”(Thucydides, 3). Sovereignty here is gain through sacrifice.

Read More

Athenian Morality Essay

1373 Words | 6 Pages

Athenian morality during the Peloponnesian War relied on an element of evidence where, as the position of Athens strengthened, speakers at the Ekklesia were able to easily convince their audience to coerce and punish other peoples by appealing to Athenian power and inherent righteousness. As the power of the Athenians grew, it became harder to argue the righteousness of their fighting because they grew from a city state forced to expand in order to defend itself into a state which was mostly growing out of desire. The imperial pleonexia of the Athenians stood in contrast to the justness they saw in themselves and thus they had to diminish the role of morality in their decision-making to allow for the expansion of their empire. Athenians believed themselves to be the most remarkable people, which was only affirmed in their eyes due to the victories in the Persian Wars, specifically at Marathon and Salamis. As Athenian envoys in Sparta before the start of the war said, “we produced most of the ships, we provided the most intelligent of the generals, and we displayed the most unflinching courage” (Thuc.

Read More

Theme Of Power In The Epic Of Gilgamesh

1085 Words | 5 Pages

Near the end of the story, Lysistrata makes reconciliation by saying, “Now I intend to give you a scolding which you both deserve” (Aristophane 1147). Although the men were scolding Lysistrata initially for devising this entire plan, it is now Lysistrata controlling the situation. This exhibits the extent of power Lysistrata has, and how her effects of power impact others. Initially, the power of Athens was held in the hands of the men, as they were only perceived capable of handling important issues. However, the role of power which Lysistrata held eventually proved to everyone that fighting was unnecessary, and a truce was imperative for the

Read More

The Peloponnesian Civil War: An Analysis

1010 Words | 5 Pages

Their claim to power and how it gives them the right to whatever they want shows their signs of savagery. Them ignoring the natural justice and carrying out their campaign regardless of who or what stood in their way was nothing short of brutal. After the dialogue they proceed to attack Melos which resulted in an Athenian victory, but they still showed no mercy. They killed all the grown men and sold the women and children into slavery in their quest for expansion. Human nature showed its true colors in these two events and proved that without restraint, human nature coupled with power can be

Read More

Justice And Self-Interest In The Melian Dialogue

763 Words | 4 Pages

The replies from the Athenian envoy, shows that everything the Athenians do is for the interest and benefit of their empire. They are just after more power and they will do anything to attain it, even if it means engaging in war and killing innocent people. However, when it comes to the Melians, it’s evident that they believe in morality and actions of justice. Although they are considered to be inferior and weak than the Athens, they believe in fighting for justice instead of throwing all

Read More

More about How Did Thucydides And Kennes Contribute To The Understanding Of State Behavior

Related Topics

Open Document