ipl-logo

How Does Lloyd Bitzer Create A Rhetorical Situation

493 Words2 Pages

Joe Johnson
01/04/18
Writ 1122 Online
Yin & Yang

To begin, it is important to lay out the definition that each Lloyd Bitzer and Richard Vatz give to the rhetorical situation. According to Lloyd Bitzer “Rhetorical situation may be defined as a complex of persons, events, objects, and relations presenting an actual or potential exigence which can be completely or partially removed if discourse, introduced into the situation, can so constrain human decisions or action as to bring about the significant modification of the exigence.” (Bitzer) Put into layman’s terms, Lloyd Bitzer believes that there are three main parts that create a rhetorical situation – Exigence, Audience, and a set of constraints. If all three of these elements are present, …show more content…

The audience in a rhetorical situation has to be able to do something to fix the urgency. The constraints are the view, ideas, traditions, values, etc. that constrain the outcome of the rhetoric and decide whether the urgency can be fixed. On the other side of the argument is Richard Vatz. In his piece The Myth of the Rhetorical Situation, he states “I would not say ‘rhetoric is situational’ but situations are rhetorical; not ‘… exigence strongly invites utterance,’ but utterance strongly invites exigence, not ‘the situation controls the rhetorical response…’ but the rhetoric controls the situational response; not ‘…rhetorical discourse… does obtain its character-as-rhetorical from the situation which generates it,’ but situations obtain their characters from the rhetoric which surrounds them or creates them.” (Vatz) In that paragraph, Vatz essentially states the opposite of what Bitzer stated. To boil it down there is one main disagreement between Vatz and Bitzer, this is that Bitzer believes that in the rhetorical situation the situation itself holds all of the power. There must be a situation in order for people to react to it. Vatz, on the other hand, believes that in a rhetorical

Show More
Related
129 Words | 1 Pages

Grant-Davie describes thoroughly the term rhetorical situation and how the development of the definition and its constituents has contributed to the discovery of the motives and responses behind any discourse. The analysis of rhetorical situations could determine the outer or inner influences of the rhetors, the audience, and their particular constraints. Grant Davie supports his claims by using the earlier definitions of scholars and teachers as his foundation. He also addresses his own analysis drawn by life experienced discourses which it also helps the reader understand the causes of rhetorical situations. This is important because it teaches any writer or reader to analyze a situation and think about the options and paths it could lead

Read More
512 Words | 3 Pages

Introduction A rhetorical situation contains three key elements, an exigence, audience and constraints. Together these elements will be attributed to the situation LaFleur was presented with when writing his rejection letter to Ms. Crump. Rhetorical Exigence Given the numerous qualified applicants for the Technical Management Trainee Programme, the company will be unable to accept Ms. Crump into the program.

Read More
494 Words | 2 Pages

"Slavery is theft -- theft of a life, theft of work, theft of any property or produce, theft even of the children a slave might have borne. " Slavery is a very harsh thing that was going on back then. Slavery started in 1619 in Jamestown, Virginia. African Americans didn't have the same privileges as the Caucasian people. Abolitionists, people who were against slavery made a case against slavery.

Read More
793 Words | 4 Pages

Li 1 William Li Mr. McMurtry AP Lang & Comp, Gold 5 29 September 2014 Rhetorical Analysis: Give Me Liberty or Give Me Death Exordium: First Paragraph Introduction Show respects to opponents Narratio: Second Paragraph Rhetorical questions metaphors to invoke audience rethinking about their position stating facts Partitio: The end of second paragraph POV Confirmatio: Third Paragraph Refutatio: Fourth Paragraph Peroratio: Fifth Paragraph

Read More
477 Words | 2 Pages

Early in the chapter “Analyzing Texts and Writing Thesis Statements,” the author discuses the idea that rhetoric is linked to action. The author states, “it is far from ‘empty’ but rather can motivate audiences to produce particular outcomes” (Alfano and O’Brien 8) The author is saying that rhetoric doesn’t just make a person think about one particular subject, it leads them to think and explore other subjects and outcomes. The rhetorical situation (author, argument, audience) is helpful for an author or creator. For example when creating a speech the author would want to make sure that he/she is attending to the audience so that their attention is kept on the speech.

Read More
1054 Words | 5 Pages

Contextualizing the rhetorical situation of John Lewis’ March on Washington speech allows readers to break down four major parts in order to have a better understanding of the rhetoric involved. Each of the four parts, that is the author, the purpose, the audience and the origin( space and time) help to elaborate on the significance of the speech at hand. Specifically in this rhetorical situation, we will delve into the several factors that played significant roles in shaping how The March on Washington was not only presented to John Lewis and his peers, but as well as the country. When looking at the four parts necessary in contextualizing the rhetorical situation, it is important to note any problems or constraints that might have motivated

Read More
1060 Words | 5 Pages

Rhetorical strategies are a variety of parts that make up an essay. The strategies include everything from explaining a process, to structure of writing. Whether the author 's purpose is to entertain, inform, or persuade, ultimately these strategies will strengthen not only the author’s purpose, but also the writing itsef. Typically when authors use these strategies, they are very precise to how they use them, and when deeply analysing a piece of writing, this is very clear. In Bell Hooks’ “Understanding Patriarchy”, she used rhetorical strategies to convey her purpose.

Read More
828 Words | 4 Pages

According to the Rhetorical Situation, three main points represent the rhetorical situation: Author, Message, and Audience. The authors part in this triangle, is communication. Whether the authors purpose is to be persuasive, or to just get the audience to listen, can be shown in how he or she writes. The message only has one purpose, and that is to be informative. However, the author has another choice to make, and that is to make the message be either simple, or complex.

Read More
851 Words | 4 Pages

Effects of Historical Context on Rhetoric Whether it is a drastic contrast or minute variation, everyone has different types of selves encompassed within their overall personality, with each subdivision being applicable to different settings. For example, the manner with which you would engage your peers may not necessarily be the same as how you would interact with your superior. When amongst your peers, you may be more insouciant and possibly blithe; however, in the latter of the situations, you may be more formal and assiduous. The act of tailoring one’s persona to one’s audience is an imperative trait of an effective rhetorician.

Read More
873 Words | 4 Pages

Introduction Hook: I never knew that one day, one idea could have such a big impact. That one thing could change the history, set up the rest of the country to follow suit with this specific topic, and things that need a change in general. Background: Over 50 years ago, on March 7, 1965, now known as bloody Sunday, segregation was still prevalent. At the time it was not allowed for blacks to vote at the time.

Read More
1814 Words | 8 Pages

As Edwin Black explains in Rhetorical Criticism: A Study in Method, applying historical models to artifacts indigenous to the times will always forgo and ignore unique rhetorical opportunities

Read More
384 Words | 2 Pages

When it comes to arguementation, the audience must be aware of the context and meanings of phrases and words. If they are not aware, then you can and will have a hard time winning that argument, becuase they will be confused and will misunderstand you. Rybacki and Rybacki (2012) Rhetorical perspecitice is basically a one person speaking with no audience iteraction.

Read More
396 Words | 2 Pages

Grant-Davie opens his writing with numerous definitions of a rhetorical situation. He then says that these definitions do not grasp the complexity of rhetorical situations. To fully understand a rhetorical situation, he suggests an analysis of the exigence, recognizing that rhetors and audience are both a part of a rhetorical situation, and that there may be multiple rhetors or audience. Grant-Davie then stated the four constituents in rhetorical situations that are exigence, rhetors, audiences, and constraints.

Read More
753 Words | 4 Pages

Rhetorical Analysis On September 30, 1998, two students at the University of Maryland wrote articles in The Diamondback student newspaper, debating whether there should be a bar in the newly renovated Student Union. In “A Nice Cold Beer Can Help after Class,” Dan Sernovitz argues for a campus bar. While Kirsten Frese, in “All a Bar Will Bring is More Problems,” disagrees. Sernovitz relies primarily on pathos and cause and consequence, along with a couple analogies.

Read More
761 Words | 4 Pages

In 1962 President John F. Kennedy held a press conference in which he informed the audience on his stance for the rising steel prices. Kennedy not only wanted to inform the audience, he wanted to get them on his side of the argument. He wanted to show the audience that the rising steel prices were going to have a negative impact on the nation. To do this Kennedy used some of the rhetoric strategies and tools. He used periodic sentences, anaphora, and diction.

Read More

More about How Does Lloyd Bitzer Create A Rhetorical Situation

Related Topics

Open Document