ipl-logo

Hume's Argument For The Existence Of Belief In Miracles

1023 Words5 Pages

You’re Name]
[Course Name]
[Professor Name]
[Date]

Hume’s argument claims that belief should not established in miracles. His statements are on the facts that he does not comply with having any beliefs for happening of the miracles. According to him, the fact that miracles should be focused on for the purpose of establishing any belief in them should not be entertained with any respect. “In Enquiry §X, Hume uses his views about our knowledge of matters of fact to reject belief in miracles.” (Lacewing, 2016) He states in his arguments that miracles should not considered up to such an extent that one should start establishing any kind of beliefs or starts relating values with them .Hume further proceeds with claiming that since miracles happen without any …show more content…

Since belief is a value that has its own value thus is occurrence should also be valid and related to some significant material or reason. Hume explains the occurrence of the miracles with three concepts which are miracle could be an event or an occurrence which has some religions significance, the miracle could be an event which has occurred through God and the miracle could be an event which has occurred while violating the laws of nature of against the laws of God. “David Hume (Hume 1748/2000; cf. Voltaire 1764/1901: 272) famously defined a miracle as “a violation of the laws of nature,” and this definition has been the focus of lively discussion ever since. Hume evidently means to denote something beyond mere changes in the regular course of nature, raising the bar higher for something to qualify as a miracle but also raising the potential epistemic significance of such an event if it could be authenticated.” (Philosophy, 2014) These three concepts are very much clear about what Hume considers about miracles and their happenings. However if we consider each one case with detail, it could be said that the occurrence of the miracle is more likely dependent upon

Show More
Related
3370 Words | 14 Pages

In Dialogues concerning Natural religion Hume explores whether or not faith is rational. as a result of Hume is AN philosopher (i.e. somebody WHO thinks that every one information comes through experience), he thinks that a belief is rational given that it's sufficiently supported by experiential proof. therefore the question is absolutely, is there enough proof within the world to permit North American country to infer AN infinitely sensible, wise, powerful, excellent God? Hume doesn't raise whether or not we are able to rationally prove that God exists, however rather whether or not we are able to rationally return to any conclusions regarding God's nature. He asserts that the primary question is on the far side doubt; the latter is ab initio undecided.

Read More
998 Words | 4 Pages

Miracles in the Production and Destruction of Faith In basic religion classes, students are told that as Catholics, they need to have a faith in God and that their faith may not seem reasonable at times. As the students get older, they are told that in order to strengthen their faith, doubts, and working through these doubts, are an expected part of their lives while miracles may strengthen their growing beliefs. To further complicate the matter, students are taught that too many doubts can bring about a loss of faith, as can doubts from these same miracles. In John Irving’s A Prayer for Owen Meany, Irving discusses this balance between healthy doubts bringing about faith and too many doubts eroding faith.

Read More
848 Words | 4 Pages

Hume, in a literary document, wrote about the idea of a miracle, and explains that no such miracle can exist and, linking to religion with miracles, God cannot exist by reason and rationality (Document 2). His explanations involved mechanics employed in philosophy which view religion paradoxical to the new discoveries. Oppositions continued to harass the reputation of

Read More
1157 Words | 5 Pages

More importantly, Ward’s examination of the definition of miracles helped me understand the importance of clarity in theological discourse. How can one have a discussion if you don’t even know what you’re discussing? He makes clear how miracles serve as transient disruptions of the natural order, offering glimpses into the divine realm. This emphasis on precision in terminology not only deepens our comprehension of miraculous events, but also highlights their profound theological implications. I also learned the necessity of engaging with skepticism in a rigorous and thoughtful manner from Ward’s thorough exploration of objections to miracles from a variety of perspectives.

Read More
214 Words | 1 Pages

Hume's claim against miracles is that it does not matter how strong the evidence for a miracle it may be it is rather more rational to reject the miracle than to believe in it. Hume states that there are two ways in order to decide to believe a piece of evidence. The reliability of a witness is the first factor. A witness can be dishonest or be ignorant about a situation which would make their claims worth little. So Humes says to take in consideration how reliable the witness is.

Read More
1308 Words | 6 Pages

Some have kept up that different religious societies have no miracles, others that the miracles of different religions societies are false (the result of enchantment, divination, or fallen angels). From an impartial stance, it is hard to concur with any finish of this sort. Hume pointed out that each religion proclaims its miracles as signs of reality of its message (An Enquiry concerning Human Understanding, p. 178). In any case, not every society can be true. So if miracles bolster reality cases of a specific religious society, then the miracle stories of one religious society are proof against the miracle stories of another society.

Read More
1594 Words | 7 Pages

In section 10 of An Inquiry Concerning Human Understanding, Hume argues that it is impossible to rationalize God’s existence with miracles, since we can only proportion our beliefs to the evidence, through “experience and observation” (Hume, p. 578). Even if a great many people testify to the occurrence of a miracle, it does not justify believing in it. Miracles, by definition, do not exist in the common world and is “a violation of the laws of nature” (Hume, p. 579). We should regain our skepticism and treat secondhand testimonies as less reliable than personal experience.

Read More
471 Words | 2 Pages

In the movie 12 Angry Men it showed many examples of Hume’s ideas such as skepticism, pluralism, relativism, and reasonable doubt. First let me explain what skepticism is, skepticism doubts the validation of knowledge or particular subject. Pluralism is the position that there are many different kinds of belief—but not all just as good as any other. Relativism is when the position that each belief is just as good as any other, since all beliefs are viewpoint dependent. Reasonable doubt is lack of proof that prevents a judge or jury to convict a defendant for the charged crime.

Read More
1439 Words | 6 Pages

Hume’s Discourse Concerning Natural Religion: Argument by Design as Proof of God? The enlightenment-age philosopher David Hume wrote Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion, which investigates the natural religious arguments of reasoning and experience on God’s existence. One argument brought up by three of Hume’s characters, Demea, Cleanthes, and Philo; is over the validity of the argument from design. Arguably, Hume is closest in his philosophical beliefs to the character Philo, a religious sceptic and arguer against design.

Read More
1945 Words | 8 Pages

The purpose is not to prove that miracles no longer occur. This is to put everything into the right perspective. “We must remember that God can do anything He wants, with anyone He wants, anytime He wants. There are plenty of modern day stories of miraculous events in which God obviously got directly involved in a situation. We need to be careful not to become pharisaical and say this is what God cannot do, what God can do, or what God must do, etc.”

Read More
567 Words | 3 Pages

Morality and ethical principles are important in shaping the direction, value and the behaviors of an individual. Furthermore, moral and ethical principles help shape the future and promote usefulness in the society (Severson 5). The activities undertaken in the daily events are governed by the degree of self-drive in making informed decisions in a selfless manner to assist others. I believe in embracing the right in the light of serving humanity and advocating for what is the best and appropriate for the good of all in the society. It is noteworthy that all the values are promoted at Regis University.

Read More
1664 Words | 7 Pages

In this reference to Transubstantiation, it is very apparent that Hume’s concern is more of a display of his hostility to Christianity both on intellectual and moral grounds than the miraculous dimension of the dogma. Thus in these historical narration he is contending that no human testimony is persuasive enough to establish a miracle so as to use it as a foundation of any system of religion. The section on miracles is divided into two parts corresponding to the two sorts of reason employed by Hume to drive home the above contention. Part one consists of a general proceeding apriori to indicate principles that should govern the acceptance of testimonies of whatever past experience.

Read More
1404 Words | 6 Pages

Hume on the other hand can only confirm what has already happened, being that is the most truthful and logical

Read More
324 Words | 2 Pages

However, there is one type of testimony we shouldn’t listen. Hume claims that testimony on miracles is unreliable. Our knowledge of miracles comes solely from the testimony of people who claim to have seen miracles can never be truthful. They experience them firsthand then try to help us understand them without our own personal experience of it. According to Hume, there was never a miracle confirmed by wealthy and educated people.

Read More
749 Words | 3 Pages

Miracles defined Generally speaking, miracle is seen as an extraordinary event, which is perceptible to the senses, effected by God and functional within a religious context as a sign of the supernatural.i Though there may be several other usages, which do not agree exactly with this definition due to the strictness or looseness of their employment, it can be confidently affirmed that the elements constituting the modern understanding of this religious term are more or less present. The word extraordinary seeks to indicate that such a phenomenon must create a sort of disruption of the normal course of event of nature. As we know, the much empirical science can go is to offer us a provisionary explanation of natural occurrences. It presents

Read More

More about Hume's Argument For The Existence Of Belief In Miracles

Related Topics

Open Document