ipl-logo

Instinctive Judgement Analysis

1390 Words6 Pages

“Intuition and concepts constitute… the elements of all our knowledge, so that neither concepts without an intuition in some way corresponding to them, nor intuition without concepts, can yield knowledge.” - Immanuel Kant ("Immanuel Kant." BrainyQuote.com) “Ways of knowing are a check on our instinctive judgments.” To what extent do you agree with this statement? Instinct is an innate, typically fixed pattern of behaviour in animals in response to certain stimuli. ("Instinct." Oxford Dictionary (British & World English)). Judgment is the ability to make considered decisions or come to sensible conclusions. ("Judgement." Oxford Dictionary (British & World English)). In the context of this prompt, check can be taken to mean to verify, establish …show more content…

The most common use is as it pertains to decision-making where we are required to make a rapid response where we do not have enough time to consider the situation through a rational perspective, which is the main alternative to using our instinctive judgment. Intuition works through your subconscious mind to find a link between the current new situation and past experiences. While you may not remember all the specific aspects of your past experiences or how you managed to overcome them, your subconscious mind remembers the patterns that you learnt. These patterns are matched to new situation and a way to deal with it is projected through your subconscious mind, usually as a feeling you experience telling you if a situation is right or wrong. Intuition is used in so many circumstances where a fast response is needed and is sometimes said to be unable to be justified as …show more content…

The ways of knowing that this prompt draws attention to are intuition, as it is presented in the question, as well as reason, emotion and sense perception as ways of knowing that work alongside and together with intuition. This is an arguable point and therefore presents the question: Do instinctive judgments help and enhance our other individual ways of knowing, work as a check on them or work towards both? Instinctive judgment can be argued to work towards enhancing two of our ways of knowing: emotion and intuition, and is then said to be a check on our ability to reason and

Show More
Related
957 Words | 4 Pages

Over the course of millions of years, it is believed that the human brain evolved to become the intelligent machine that it is today. Decision making is one of many adaptations the human brain has made. . However, there are theories now that humans do not make all decisions in their conscious mind. Something known as the “adaptive unconscious” is thought to process and order data quickly so as make impulsive decisions without the brain even thinking. This can be identified when one gets a gut instinct.

Read More
995 Words | 4 Pages

In the book "Blink: The Power of Thinking Without Thinking", the author Malcolm Gladwell explores the world of intuition and snap judgements, which he refers to as "thin-slicing". In order to support his thesis, Gladwell implements a variety of examples pulled from real experiments conducted by psychologists around the country. Gladwell's thesis of the book is that often snap judgements are far more accurate than well though-out, carefully analyzed reasoning. Gladwell supports his thesis with the use of experiments conducted by other psychologists, or instances that agree with his claims, such as the Coke-Pepsi experiment, or the kouros statue incident. His thesis has an abundant amount of support, due to the fact that he gives several experiments and incidents as evidence.

Read More
381 Words | 2 Pages

In his article “Framing Moral Intuitions”, Walter Sinnott-Armstrong sets out to reject moral intuitionalism by questioning whether moral intuitions can be justified non-inferentially. He defines a moral intuition as a strong and immediate belief (Sinnott-Armstrong, 47) and for it to be justified non-inferentially is to be able to justify it independently of any other belief (Sinnott-Armstrong, 48). His primary aim is to demonstrate that many of our moral intuitions are unreliable and consequently, that no moral intuition can be justified without inference. He does this by citing several studies that demonstrate how moral intuitions can be subject to “framing effects”. Framing effects are the effects that wording and context can have on our

Read More
681 Words | 3 Pages

Instinctual behaviors are those that are instinct such as eating, staying warm, and knowing how to survive. The learned behaviors such as knowing how to interact with other primates and knowing how to parent don 't come instinctualy but come from watching and learning from other primates. They did a study where they raised a monkey without a mother to see if that monkey would be fully capable when an adult. The results showed that that monkey did not know how to raise her own offspring or how to interact with other monkeys. This shows that knowing how to raise offspring and interact with others is not something that is instinctual for primates but more something that is learned.

Read More
642 Words | 3 Pages

We learned that good reasoning, or logical reasoning, is the process of forming conclusions, judgements or inferences from facts or premises. The way we reason effects our ability to inform our conscience. We must ensure that our reasoning is not based on prejudices or stereotypes, and we must be autonomous thinkers. We can do this by informing our conscience and searching for the right thing and most loving thing to do when deciding what to believe and do. We learned that good reasoning is important because

Read More
1040 Words | 5 Pages

Death. While the outcome is the same for everyone, no two people live the same lives. Ivan Ilych was a character in Leo Tolstoy 's novel The Death of Ivan Ilych. Ivan was a selfish lawer who was unhappy with his life until right before he died. Portrayed in the movie Into the Wild, Christopher McCandless was a free spirit he did what he want when he wanted.

Read More
2036 Words | 9 Pages

Knowledge can be a good thing if we use it in a good way, but if you don’t use it wisely it can bring many problems and it might also bring bad consequences. In Frankenstein’s case knowledge was not a good thing. The book Frankenstein, or, The modern Prometheus, by Mary Shelley, was a very intriguing story with many comparisons of the ultimate powers in life. It contained many topics of our everyday life today. Even though it contained many themes of our everyday life, mainly it consisted of knowledge can lead to bad things.

Read More
873 Words | 4 Pages

In the movie “12 Angry Men”, various Ways of Knowing are identified by the TOK course such as emotions, perception and reason. The film demonstrates the role that emotion plays in the aim of knowledge, if we can truly trust our sense to perceive what the world really is, and is arguing through reasoning significant? Emotion plays a role in the search for the truth whether it is the aim for new knowledge or the jury’s search for a solution in the case. “12 Angry Men” displays how emotions can aid our judgment. When the juror’s expressed outrage, it was because they had heard something that they didn’t approve of therefore, they expressed an emotion that reflected their opinion.

Read More
442 Words | 2 Pages

The combination of reason and intuition allows for a well-rounded understanding of the world and others, which is essential for a healthy democracy. In a democracy, citizens are not just decision-makers, but also responsible for creating a fair and just society for all. It can be argued that too much focus on intuition and spiritual understanding can lead to irrational decision making. This can result in neglecting important facts and reason when making important decisions, which can be detrimental to a democratic

Read More
941 Words | 4 Pages

Though many people think that emotion helps make rational resolutions, often times it hurts one’s ability to do so. In To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee, Scout, the protagonist, and her family discover the need for logic when her father takes an important court case. Sadly, most of the people of Maycomb in the 1930s became corrupt because they do not use rationality in their lives. Throughout the novel, Scout and the reader both learn that one should not let their emotions rule their reason when making decisions. Even before the court case began, Scout learns about the recurring theme of logic being more effective than her feelings when forming opinions of others and in communicating.

Read More
459 Words | 2 Pages

Most of these definitions agree that intuition is based on automatic processes that rely on knowledge structures acquired through different kinds of learning [10]. I maintain that appropriating such a broad understanding suffices for my current purposes. After all, different types of intuition make use of partly non-conscious processes, such as pattern recognition, memory traces and currently perceived information, and often the only awareness is of the result [10] (p.

Read More
1288 Words | 6 Pages

Suspension of disbelief is most clearly understood through the view that the rejection of critical faculties or the sacrifice of reason in the development of knowledge. The objective of this suspension as it has different implications based on context: as it is defined in the question, suspension in theatre has the capability to give humans enjoyment or heartbreak which mainly emotional qualities are. However, this end goal may change depending on the area of knowledge in context. For example, the goal of suspension in other art forms like literature may be to teach ethical concepts, so emotional gain is not always the objective. Secondly the title outlines that suspension must be essential to the area of knowledge; hence, the growth of knowledge may not occur unless suspension of disbelief is involved.

Read More
746 Words | 3 Pages

We should first begin with the nuts and bolts. "Instinct" is such a trendy expression, to the point that practically everybody has their very own meaning of what instinct is. I did some exploration on the web, and discovered this clear definition: "Instinct is the capacity to comprehend something instinctually, without the requirement for cognizant thinking." Furthermore, I think this is incompletely valid, yet instinct is something beyond natural.

Read More
704 Words | 3 Pages

If so, we can, therefore, assume that all of the knowledge we bear as of now are all obtained from all of our past daily experiences and this idea contrasts the idea of innate knowledge. It is said that innate knowledge is the knowledge we have ever since we were born. Thus, this knowledge will only be discovered if something triggers it. As for example, a

Read More
812 Words | 4 Pages

In this essay I will write about the strengths and weaknesses of perception as a way of knowing. Perception is the way we perceive the world through our senses. We use all five of our senses, which are sight, hearing, smell, taste and touch to understand the world and interpret it. We can then say it’s a Primary way of knowledge. We can also say that, because the senses is the way our body communicates, we have at least three more senses: kinesthetic sense, which is our awareness of our body’s dimensions and movement; vestibular sense, which is the awareness of the human’s balance and spacial orientation; and organic sense, which is the manifest of the internal organs (for example, hunger or thirst).

Read More

More about Instinctive Judgement Analysis

Related Topics

Open Document