ipl-logo

Improving Indigenous Health Starts With Reconciliation By Anna Banerji

902 Words4 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Aboriginal health critical reflections

Like many articles on Aboriginal Peoples issues, Anna Banerji’s CBC article “Improving Indigenous Health Starts With Reconciliation” (Banerji, 2015), is a critique on the treatment of Native Peoples in Canada. Her main thesis focuses on the inequality that exists in Canada, by underscoring the biases and discriminations perpetrated on Indigenous Peoples, in terms of basic human rights. Banerji’s advocacy, although commendable, leaves an empty space, in terms of both a governmental (policy) perspective, and her own assertion’s credibility, due to her writing style and content. These ingredients are essential for an understanding by the target audience (Canadians, in general), as it could allow for a powerful critique on the human rights violations …show more content…

These credentials, amongst other impressive associations should lend authenticity to her voice, as an ally of Aboriginal Peoples in Canada, but instead, detract from her perspective because of the articles poor composition.
The article in question, titled “Improving Indigenous Health Starts With Reconciliation,” attempts to outline some of the prominent discriminatory acts currently being endured by Indigenous Peoples in Canada. Citing empirical experiences and voicing issues that range from child starvation and a lack of clean water, to under-funded education and marginalizing medical practices, Banerji attempts to garner attention by using a pathos rhetorical appeal. In addition, she implies an ethos (expert) rhetorical appeal, to underpin her knowledge and authority in Aboriginal …show more content…

The CBC, which represents Canada (by the nature of it’s funding), and its government, bares a responsibility in its publishing practice, to: (1) provide proper editing (spelling, at least), and (2) some sort of editorial counter-argument for the news it delivers. In the case of the Banerji article, the author and/or the CBC are responsible for citing the specific policies that this report refers to. Using broad statements like “The Indian Act,” instead of pointing out specific statutes within the act to premise statements, would give the federal government their voice, and thereby show how Canada’s governmental policy contravenes the Human Rights code with respect to the indigenous population; juxtaposing the treatment of Aboriginal Peoples and those of non-Aboriginal

Show More
Related

To Be Indian In Canada Today By Richard Wagamese Analysis

296 Words | 2 Pages

In his essay “To be Indian in Canada today”, Richard Wagamese relies on logos to explain the struggles and obstacles that come with the Federal Court’s decision to recognize Metis and non-status Indians in Canada as “Indians” under the Constitution Act. He then begs the question, “what does it mean to be Indian in Canada today?”(Wagameses). Being First Nations himself, Richard Wagamese knows firsthand all barriers that come with being Indigenous in Canada today. While using logos Richard Wagamese implements many different statistics and percentages in his essay to show the hurdles that Indigenous people face: “To be Indian in Canada today is to see youth languish in chronic unemployment and malaise, endure high rates of alcohol, drug and solvent

Read More

Who Is Drew Hayden Taylor's Stereotyping Aboriginal People?

1489 Words | 6 Pages

To many people, Canada is known for its equality, freedom and its acceptance of people no matter their race or culture. However, Canada is not always as good and accepting as people think of it to be, especially when it comes to stereotyping Aboriginal peoples. Drew Hayden Taylor, as a half-white and half-Ojibway author, has personally experienced the stereotyping in society against Aboriginal peoples. By providing testimony, using a sarcastic and mocking tone in all three of his essays, and often referring to general stereotypes of Native people, Drew Hayden Taylor’s essays “Seeing Red Over Myths”, “What’s an Indian Worth These Days?” and “Pretty Like a White Boy: The Adventures of a Blue Eyed Ojibway” challenge conventional values and beliefs

Read More

Indian Horse Sparknotes

690 Words | 3 Pages

By portraying indigenous characters in a nuanced and realistic manner, he challenges preconceived notions, enabling readers to recognize the inherent humanity we all share. Through his storytelling, he hopes to break down barriers and facilitate a better understanding of indigenous experiences, histories, and perspectives, thereby contributing to Canada's ongoing discussion of reconciliation and healing between indigenous and non-indigenous

Read More

First Nations Perspectives Case Study

552 Words | 3 Pages

Critical Summary #3: First Nations Perspectives In Chapter eight of Byron Williston’s Environmental Ethics for Canadians First Nation’s perspectives are explored. The case study titled “Language, Land and the Residential Schools” begins by speaking of a public apology from former Canadian Prime Minister Stephen Harper. He apologizes for the treatment of “Indians” in “Indian Residential Schools”. He highlights the initial agenda of these schools as he says that the “school system [was] to remove and isolate [Aboriginal] children from the influence of their homes, families, traditions and cultures, and to assimilate them[…]” (Williston 244).

Read More

Pierre Trudeau Federalism

1515 Words | 7 Pages

In the essay, “Federalism, Nationalism, and Reason”, Pierre Trudeau addresses the history and origins of self-determination and nationalism and its central role in federal statehood, he then discusses the interactions of federalism and nationalism in a Canadian context. Trudeau posits major arguments that will be assessed in this review. First, he postures that that the federal state is driven by self-determination and nationalism, which ultimately makes it unstable due to its foundation in emotionalism rather than reason. Second, Trudeau outlines the historical factors that resulted in the separatist narrative in Quebec and claims that Canadian nationalism cannot combat Quebec’s regional nationalism. Trudeau begins the essay with a historical

Read More

The Kattawapiskak River

1589 Words | 7 Pages

According to Anzovino and Boutilier (2014), “the legislative definition of Aboriginal peoples includes all persons of “Indian” blood who were known to belong to a specific band, living on specific land, with their descendants [and] all persons intermarried with any such “Indians” who resided among them” as well as all children and persons adopted in infancy (p. 90). These persons are immensely proud of their good character, race, beliefs, values and morals. However, they are receiving abuse and a lack of promised assistance from the government. How can Canada act so neglectful and inattentive to those that live north of the suburban area? Are we not all equal and deserve the same rights, especially basic living conditions in order to survive?

Read More

Symbolism In Cottagers And Indians

1345 Words | 6 Pages

The following quote supports and establishes this pretense, “There is widespread racism in Canada, and its name is ignorance; ignorance of history, and inherent biases, and the lack of willingness to do anything about it.”. Maureen contains large amounts of willful ignorance because of institutional and parental influences, while being partially unbeknown to the history that has wronged the indigenous people. Furthermore, this ignorance is easily observable in the following quotation, “No, pity the poor Indians… I mean First nations… Aboriginal.. First Nation …

Read More

Scrip And Census In The Construction Of Métis Culture And History

1284 Words | 6 Pages

Before this article, I was ignorant towards the harm of referring towards Métis peoples as ‘mixed’, but I very quickly learned the history and harm of the term. The “Métis-as-mixed” stereotype can be a very damaging idea as it poses a threat to under representation of who Métis people are and the many obstacles they have had to overcome in order to be considered an individual group. Having this knowledge will be extremely useful in my future as a social worker. I will likely work with Métis peoples and having now been educated on proper terminology and the rich history of Métis peoples, I feel as though this better prepares me to be as understanding as possible. Despite being a short article, the piece published by the Native Women’s Association of Canada (2022), was very impactful.

Read More

Indian Assimilation In Canada

846 Words | 4 Pages

The Indian Act was constructed to reflect the Canadian government’s primary goal of assimilation. The government anticipated that the process of organized assimilation through legislation would reduce the number of status Indians in Canada, remove the government from the responsibility of First Nations affairs, and make available the land that was currently reserved for First Nations. Without the responsibility of the ‘Indian problem’, the Canadian government would no longer be required to spend limited federal funds on its burdensome inhabitants. However, the ‘Indian problem’ did not go away and instead produced gender-based discrimination towards the women of Canada’s First Nations communities, resulting in a loss of status, status rights, and identity for generations to come.

Read More

Impact Of The Indian Act On Indigenous Women In Canada

1990 Words | 8 Pages

Linnea Brodin Mr.Harrison May,31, 2023 2000 words The Detrimental Impact of the Indian Act on Indigenous Women in Canada The Indian Act, a piece of legislation with a complex and controversial history, has had a detrimental impact on Indigenous women in Canada. The Indian Act is a colonial relic of 1876, however, it has a lasting impact on modern-day Indigenous peoples in Canada. The consequences of the Indian act for Indigenous women in Canada have been extensive, causing the loss of Indian status, triggering high rates of missing and murdered Indigenous women, and inflicting intergenerational trauma throughout communities.

Read More

Essay On Aboriginal Access To Health Care

598 Words | 3 Pages

Canada is known for its amazing healthcare and it is considered one of the best in the world. In Canada, healthcare is ‘universal’ to its citizens under the Heath Care Act. However, not everyone has equal access to healthcare, Aboriginals being some of them. Aboriginals have trouble getting the access they need because of socio-economic status, geography, lack of infrastructure and staff, language or cultural barriers an more. Aboriginals on reserve face many barriers when it comes to access to healthcare, they include cost, language, distance, climate, education and more.

Read More

Murdered Indigenous Women

1425 Words | 6 Pages

This paper will address The rate of Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women is disproportionately high in Canada. What factors contribute to this? The main factors that contribute to the higher rates of the missing and murdered indigenous women are are Representation

Read More

Stephen Harper's Residential School Apology Analysis

951 Words | 4 Pages

In the two articles under analysis, the authors are issuing a response to the formal apology speech given by the former Prime Minister Stephen Harper. In 2011, an apology speech was being delivered to the Aboriginal peoples and its survivors of the Residential Schools System in Canada during nineteenth and twentieth centuries. The aboriginal people in Canada have been subjected to very abusive and stressful conditions in residential schools, and as such, the acknowledgment was meant to make amends for the various social injustices that had meted out to them by the Canadian Government. In Lynda Gray’s article, "Why silence greeted Stephen Harper 's residential-school apology," she opines that the Prime Minister’s speech was overall detached

Read More

Homelessness Of Indigenous People

315 Words | 2 Pages

The basis of these problems is a loss of identity and a sense of knowing that their values are oppressed, and their rights are ignored. Likewise, non-indigenous Canadians have become increasingly aware of the unfairness of the richness of indigenous and aboriginal cultures that are taking place.

Read More

The Impact Of The Colonization Of Indigenous People

1151 Words | 5 Pages

The colonization of Indigenous peoples has dramatically affected their health, and health-seeking behaviours, in a myriad of ways. The Indian Act of 1876 was, in essence, created to control the Indigenous population. The Indian Act laid out laws and regulations that tightly regulated the lives of natives economically, ideologically, and politically. This included a wealth of ways in which their identities were stripped away, and in which they were taken advantage of by the Government of Canada. This has resulted in a reduced quality of life for Canada 's indigenous population, as well as adverse health problems, and prejudicial perceptions that we still see the impact of today.

Read More

More about Improving Indigenous Health Starts With Reconciliation By Anna Banerji

Related Topics

Open Document