ipl-logo

Is Martin Luther King, Jr. Or Malcolm X More Influential?

2603 Words11 Pages

Is Martin Luther King, Jr. or Malcolm X more influential?
Olivia Stendal
3rd Block
Mr. Zetzman
May 4th, 2023
Introduction and Thesis
“I have a dream that one day this nation will rise up and live out the true meaning of its creed: ‘We hold these truths to be self-evident: that all men are created equal.’” (I Have a Dream). These famous words from Martin Luther King Jr. stated his belief that all men are created equal and deserve nothing less than equality. Similar to King’s belief, Malcom X expressed, “Treat them [enemies] like that and fight them, and you’ll get your freedom; and after you get your freedom, your enemy will respect you.” (Breitman). While King and X individually took a stand against discrimination and pushed for equal …show more content…

On February 21, 1965, three members of the Nation of Islam assassinated Malcolm X in a ballroom while he was addressing the Organization of Afro-American Unity. They were later charged with first-degree murder and sentenced to 20 years to life in prison. While his life was cut short, many believe that Malcolm X's influence lives on as “his philosophy laid the groundwork for later black pride movements, including the Black Panther Party” (People and …show more content…

One reason that people believe in Malcolm X’s greater leadership is his opposition to non-violent strategies as a way to make a change. Malcolm X pushed his fellow Black Americans to “protect themselves against white aggression by any means necessary” (Malcolm X). While having a strong public following that advocated self-defense, this leader demanded change in ways different from Martin Luther King. The audience in support of Malcolm X believed aggression was the best way to achieve a goal and praised that approach to end discrimination. While these two figures had different views and attitudes towards protest strategies, Martin Luther King had a more positive and peaceful influence on society which helped make it a better and welcoming place for all while keeping a more humane approach. Secondly, people also believe that Malcolm X had a greater influence on society due to his difficult early life and his determination. Compared to MLK, Malcolm X grew up in an unstable, lower class family as he was in and out of foster care. Without having true role models in his life, it supports the claim that Malcolm X worked harder for what he got and had greater accomplishments in his life. (Social Justice Activists). To counter argue, MLK always had dreams for a better future for all, and was able to follow in the footsteps of his father and grandfather as

Show More
Related

Malcolm X Ethos Pathos Logos

1450 Words | 6 Pages

Notoriously, Martin Luther King Jr. has been the name of the civil rights movement, the one we all look up to in terms of the end of segregation. But, this respectable man was not the only one to take action in the name of equality, as another infamous speaker, Malcolm X, also drove the civil rights movement in a way of ferociousness and rage. This man, the head of the Black Nationalist movement, gave phenomenal speeches that indirectly propelled the civil rights movement, including Prospects For Freedom, By Any Means Necessary, and Message to the Grassroots. Malcolm X was a man who was an illustrious black nationalist, and was the speaker for the Nation of Islam. He often preached controversial things that regularly contrasted him with Dr.

Read More

Malcolm X Was The Best For America Dbq Essay

441 Words | 2 Pages

The number one reason why I think Malcolm X’s philosophy made the most sense for America in the 1960’s is because he is a realist. He knows what it takes to make things great. So this means that he sees things the way they are in the world. In document K it states that Malcolm X does not favor violence but condemns it when necessary.

Read More

1960s Dbq Essay

1117 Words | 5 Pages

Malcolm X, who had come from a poor home in the North, had focused on the economic aspect of the Civil Rights movement through more violent take on getting his word out. Martin Luther King Jr was a major influence to the Civil Rights movement. Therefore, his non-violent

Read More

Comparing The Philosophies Of MLK And Malcolm X

300 Words | 2 Pages

In MLK’s “I Have a Dream” speech, he states, “ I have a dream that one day this nation will rise up and live out the true meaning of the creed: ‘... all men are created equal.’” He thought the nation

Read More

What Is The Rhetorical Methods Of Martin Luther King And Malcolm X

795 Words | 4 Pages

Martin Luther King and Malcolm X go down in history as the most prominent figures of the civil rights movement. Although they are often put against each other because of their different approaches, they were similar in several ways, such as their ability to make crowds grasp on to their words and follow their lead. So the question to be asked is not whether Dr King or Malcolm X was better, more moral, or logical, but what about them was so alluring to the masses that trusted them as leaders in the movement. Both Martin Luther King jr. and Malcolm X manipulated the emotions of audiences through powerful rhetorical methods, but applied them in different ways.

Read More

Malcolm X Dbq Essay

492 Words | 2 Pages

Malcolm X on the other hand changed things little by little. In document I Malcolm says that whites needed to be taught how blacks were taught. Malcolm was an activist for those

Read More

Malcolm X Dbq Analysis

563 Words | 3 Pages

MLK and Malcolm X both wanted equality but in different ways. Martin Luther King believed in nonviolence to end segregation. However, Malcolm X believed in segregation; where African Americans would govern themselves without bothering the whites. But which idea was better for society? Malcolm X’s philosophy offers a variety of solutions for

Read More

Malcolm X Dbq

656 Words | 3 Pages

Malcolm X doesn’t show that same attitude as Martin Luther King Jr. Malcolm X fights more for an African-American community that is independent. (doc G). X’s intended focus is having an independent community because he no longer wants to be in boy scouts just for African-Americans to get jobs when they can get a job in his envisioned community.

Read More

The Difference Between Martin Luther King Jr And Malcolm X

1974 Words | 8 Pages

However, the action should be taken without nonviolence and with peaceful protest. Dr. King’s nonviolent tactic was a success as it bridged the gap between the colored and white people. Malcolm X was renown for his act of self defense throughout the Civil Rights Movement. His main goal was to prove how whites did not treat black people as human beings. However, through Malcolm X’s several tactics, Martin Luther King’s movement was made more impactful and successful.

Read More

Similarities Between Martin Luther King Jr And Malcolm X

525 Words | 3 Pages

Malcolm X didn’t agree with what King’s views, he believed that MLK’s dream was not a dream but a nightmare. Martin Luther King Jr’s approach to civil rights and equality was non-violent protesting, sit-ins, and getting as much people together as possible while not using violence. However, Malcolm X’s approach to this was almost the opposite. He was against the views of whites and he was willing to do whatever was needed to achieve

Read More

Compare And Contrast Martin Luther King Jr And Malcolm X

760 Words | 4 Pages

Martin Luther King Jr's main goal was to bring about racial equality by working together. While Malcolm X was all about blacks owning and operating their businesses and not needing to rely on others. "In the past six months simply by refusing to purchase the products from companies which do not hire Negroes in meaningful numbers and all job categories, thus allowing income of the black community to increase by more than two million dollars annually" - MLK Jr. "We haven't learned the importance of owning and operating businesses … so Even when we try and spend our money in the neighborhood where we live.

Read More

Malcolm X: From Violence To Peace

950 Words | 4 Pages

Malcolm X: From Violence to Peace “I believe that it is a crime for anyone to teach a person who is being brutalized to continue to accept that brutality without doing something to defend himself” (“Malcolm X - Quotes, Movies & Children”). This quote came from a man who, like others in his time, took strong action to fight against the brutality put upon black people: Malcolm X. Malcolm, like other African-Americans in the 1900s, never had an easy life. From childhood to adulthood, he faced the brutality of racism that never parted with him until his death. He lived a life of crime with a mindset of violence, and then, shortly before his death, changed to a life and mindset of peace. Malcolm X took action to fight against racism as a civil rights

Read More

The Ballot Or The Bullet Essay

1318 Words | 6 Pages

Malcolm X and his ideals are arguably a representation of the transition from the early 1950 's non-violent movement for integration to a more aggressive black power movement. Evidence of this is shown through powerful strands of his novel “The Ballot or the Bullet” including when he writes, “I don 't mean go out and get violent, but at the same time you should never be non-violent unless you run into some non-violence.” (Malcolm 439). In writing that members of the civil rights movement should never be non-violent he does so facetiously. This excerpt indicates a call for violence as a more powerful method for achieving the equality he feels they deserve.

Read More

Malcolm X Leadership Style

1690 Words | 7 Pages

Without Malcolm, the White people would have not favored Martin Luther King Jr. over other Civil Rights leaders. Towards the end of Malcolm’s life, Martin Luther King Jr. began to become more like Malcolm in a militant way. Martin Luther king Jr. “was also re-evaluating his presuppositions and was moving toward a greater understanding of Malcolm X, especially regarding black pride, separatism, and White America’s lack of commitment to genuine black equality” (Cone, 1992, p. 256). These transformations of Martin Luther King Jr.’s ideas, likely led him to accomplish the revolution of Civil Rights. Although, this is a possibility, it is extremely unrealistic.

Read More

Malcolm X Dbq

731 Words | 3 Pages

Malcolm X, born Malcolm Little became a drug dealer and thief after dropping out of the educational system. He later went to prison and after spending multiple years in the prison institution he developed a higher religious level of education from the nation of Islam. He immediately became a member and spoke their beliefs to the people. Malcolm later on found out the true colors of the organization and was unpleased with the actions they associated in. Malcolm X’s decision to break away from the nation of Islam and speak on his own beliefs and his efforts to encourage African American people to defend themselves at any means necessary against acts of racism, was no justification for his assassination.

Read More

More about Is Martin Luther King, Jr. Or Malcolm X More Influential?

Related Topics

Open Document