ipl-logo

Judith Jarvis Thomson's Defense Of Abortion

623 Words3 Pages

In the article The Rights of a Woman Do Not Outweigh the Rights of a Child, it informs many women with true information about abortion. It quotes, “What is at stake in abortion is the mother’s lifestyle, as opposed to the baby’s life.” By becoming a pregnant woman they have to choice for themselves and the baby. The information this article gives woman is explaining how abortion affects babies not just them. However, abortion is a lifetime decision, “ In nearly all abortions, the woman’s right to live is not an issue, because her life is not in danger.” A baby who has not full developed cannot defend itself, but they should have a mother who can. Additionally, woman who have become pregnant usually give up their baby because of school or …show more content…

It quotes, “Rebuttal #2: Pregnancy is a much different experience than the analogy depicts. Rebuttal #3: Even when pregnancy is unwanted or difficult, it is a temporary condition.” As of number two rebuttal pregnancies are different than the analogy because women fantasies about what they think it will be and not what the situation really is. Rebuttal three tells women how pregnancy is painful for the delivery part but those nine months are just temporary and abortion is permit. “Rebuttal #4: In this scenario, mother and child are pitted against each other as enemies. Rebuttal #5: The child’s presence during pregnancy is rarely more inconvenient than his presence after birth. #6: Even when there is no felt obligation, there is sometimes real obligation.” Rebuttal four, five, and six are all true, however, the scenario is an image many mothers can picture and see the results. Five is very common; the burden of a child is what most mothers should want rather than killing their own child. Lastly, six tells how many mothers want better for their child. A child should bring happiness and show what the mother has been missing

Show More
Related

Analysis Of The Children's Era By Margaret Sanger

835 Words | 4 Pages

“Worry, strain, shock...may all poison the blood of the enslaved mother...poisoned blood may produce a defective baby”(“The Children’s Era”). Margaret Sanger uses these words to show the poor reputation and doomed outlook enslaved women and their children are given. If birth control were available to these women there would be a fewer number of unsuccessful humans. Sanger later pulls on the emotions of her audience by agonizing over the helpless souls of unborn babies who dream of a bright future that is out of their reach. These babies could be protected from harsh situations if provided an option to control birth.

Read More

Summary Of Marquis Arguments On Abortion

598 Words | 3 Pages

Marquis’ argument on abortion solely rests on the claim that the fetus is a person and therefore has a right to live. Thomson, on the other hand, tries to convey the point that this type of argument against abortion is an inadequate account of the morality of abortion. To begin with, Thomson explains her points through a series of thought experiments that she used as analogies to different situations where a woman could be pregnant but wishes to terminate her pregnancy. Thomson’s analogies are unique because she does not mention the personhood-factor—argument on which antiabortion is entirely based. Even though throughout her arguments she never does agree that a fetus is in fact a person, she still grants the probability that they are a person and

Read More

Analysis Of Judith Thomson's A Defense Of Abortion

1079 Words | 5 Pages

However, I do not believe that the burglar thought experiment is an analogy that accurately explains this concept if a mother gets pregnant due to failed contraception. First of all, the burglar in question has ill intent if he plans to break into your house and steal something from you. A fetus has no bad intent and is a victim of circumstance in this situation. A burglar is an adult that has the ability to use reason and understands that there are consequences to his actions of burglary. People that support abortion often cite the fact that abortion is permissible because a fetus has no rational capacities like children and adults do.

Read More

Summary Of The Morality Of Birth Control By Margaret Sanger

1119 Words | 5 Pages

This quotes implies that the child does not choose to be born in an unwanted, unloved, or an uncared for family or home. This is a strong statements to show society that this is why birth control is helpful to the family and the child. With Sanger’s first-hand experience as a midwife, it has really impacted her on the consequences of prenatal malnourishment and/ or neglect (Ward). It is in fact better to prevent lives that would inevitably be unhealthy and/ or unhappy. By using the contraceptives implies a “high sanction for the value of life itself”

Read More

Rhetorical Analysis Of When Abortion Suddenly Stopped Making Sense

1177 Words | 5 Pages

She tries to convince the reader that although the woman may think that she has no other option, there will always be something more appropriate than abortion. In summary, the author says that it is wrong to act impulsively and that women need to think about the consequences before attempting the termination of her child. She explains how the small human inside is “alive and growing” (P 23). Mathewes-Green addresses the concept of the child being “unwanted”, and how that is not true because “we are valuable simply because we are members of the human race” (P 21). The language the writer uses has a strong effect on a woman's heart, especially future and current mothers.

Read More

Judith Jarvis Thomson's A Defense Of Abortion

522 Words | 3 Pages

An act was founded to protect this from happening in 2004 by President George W. Bush. The act is called the “Unborn Victims of Violence Act” and it states that “whoever engages in conduct that violates any of the provisions of law listed in subsection (b) and thereby causes the death of, or bodily injury (as defined in section 1365) to, a child, who is in utero at the time the conduct takes place, is guilty of a separate offense under this section”.

Read More

Mary Anne Warren's Rights Of Abortion

794 Words | 4 Pages

As humans, we are given different rights that are meant to provide us with a chance at a good life. However, these rights can become compromised when it comes to conflicts between a pregnant woman and her fetus. The right of the fetus to live is seen as inferior to the right of the mother to have an abortion. Although each of the rights is different, it is not appropriate to say that one citizen’s rights are more superior than another citizen’s rights.

Read More

A Defense Of Abortion By Judith Jarvis Thomson

502 Words | 3 Pages

Although many liberals, such as Judith Jarvis Thomson, in “A Defense of Abortion” believe that fetus become humans, they believe there is a cut off line. Jones(2002), believes that because “By the tenth week(mark), for example, it already has a face, arms, and legs, fingers and toes; it has internal organs, and brain activity is detectable”(Pg.39), that ten weeks into pregnancy is cut off line. That the fetus before ten weeks is just a clump of cells without soul or life. However, according to Jane English(1975), in “Abortion and the Concept of a Person”, she states that “Animals, for example, are not persons,yet to kill or torture them for no reason at all is wrong. ”(Pg.233)

Read More

Pros And Cons Of Elizabeth Barnes

769 Words | 4 Pages

Instead, Barnes argues that avoiding having children can be a rational choice based on projected outcomes. Her reason is to avoid a violation of her current desires, preferences, and self. This would be reasonable if the arguments she used to reach this conclusion matched such a reasoning. The claim of violation

Read More

Essay On Abortion By Judith Thomson

810 Words | 4 Pages

Most abortion arguments discussed today revolve around the premise that a fetus is a human being at conception. In Judith Thomson’s essay, “A Defense to Abortion”, she argues on the topic of abortions. She defends the mother’s right to choose what happens to her body on the assumption that a baby becomes a human at conception. In the argument, she gives the famous Violinist analogy. I will argue in this essay that her argumentative analogy is not sound because of the difference in social importance.

Read More

Judith Thomson Arguments Against Abortion

1373 Words | 6 Pages

The abortion debate is an ongoing argument involving the legal, moral, and religious status of an induced abortion, an abortion sought with the intent of terminating one’s pregnancy. Typically, abortion arguments are made based on the “pro-choice” or “pro-life” movements. Those who fight for the “pro-choice” movement, state that pregnant women have the right to choose whether they carry the fetus to term or not; whereas, those who argue for the “pro-life” movement, state that the fetus has a right to life and should be carried to term. What about the gray space, the space where perhaps women do not have a choice in the matter? If a woman’s life is at risk or if the pregnancy was the result of rape, then she should have the option of abortion

Read More

Abortion In 'Hills Like White Elephants'

808 Words | 4 Pages

Rocco Commisso Professor B. Shaw English 102 MWF 06 February 2023 Difficult Decisions Abortion is a highly controversial and polarizing issue that can have significant psychological effects on a woman's mental state. The decision to have an abortion can be a complex and emotional one, and the aftermath can vary from person to person. Some women may experience feelings of guilt, shame, or sadness, while others may feel a sense of relief or empowerment. Additionally, the societal stigma surrounding abortion can contribute to negative mental health outcomes for women who choose to have an abortion. It is important to understand that every woman's experience with abortion is unique and to offer support and resources to those who may be struggling with the psychological effects of this procedure.

Read More

The Mother Gwendolyn Brooks Analysis

1024 Words | 5 Pages

When thinking of personal experiences, “The Mother” by Gwendolyn Brooks touches on the emotional topic of abortion. Even though this poem was published decades ago, it can still be seen very relevant to this day. Accepting abortion and the outcome can indeed be a challenging task for many, while others seem to adapt to it without much of a problem. Gwendolyn Brooks’ writing lets us take a look at the mothers view point of abortion and how a mother responds to her new situation. Throughout the poem, the speaker shows signs of grieving concern of the topic of abortion and its outcomes by presenting emotions of regret and memories, shame and guilt, and contradicting herself to almost justify what she has done.

Read More

Thanksgiving In Mongolia

750 Words | 3 Pages

Women in the United States are forced to accept the stigma that they must bear children. This idea can be daunting for many women. “I was afraid I would be an awful mother” (137) states Levy. Having insecurities about childbearing has become increasingly taboo to discuss, for it is seen to be a women’s job by many. Levy is able to empower women by voicing her own anxieties and she gives them the ability to connect with some who feels the same.

Read More

Daniel Stern's Theory Of Motherhood

967 Words | 4 Pages

Whilst active, the “motherhood constellation” becomes the mother’s primary mindset, and supersedes all others (Stern, 1995). The complex is said to be developed during pregnancy and then remain available to mothers when they need access to this way of thinking (Stern, 1995). The constellation consists of four main themes that preoccupy the mother’s thoughts. The first theme is the life growth theme entailing thoughts of the mother’s ability to provide her infant with life and the sustenance it needs to grow. The second theme is the primary relatedness theme, which concerns cognitions about the emotional connection the mother develops with her infant.

Read More

More about Judith Jarvis Thomson's Defense Of Abortion

Related Topics

Open Document