ipl-logo

June Tangney's Essay Condemn The Crime, Not The Person

1305 Words6 Pages

Mistakes Happen

Honesty is always the best policy. The saying that has been ingrained in people’s minds since childhood claims that telling the truth is always best. Whoever first started the saying understood that lying, or simply not telling the whole truth, has negative consequences. If something as small as telling a little white lie has a negative outcome, how much worse must it be when a mistake is kept hidden? Not admitting mistakes can have a very negative outcome for all of the people involved. Although doctors and other professional workers are placed on a pedestal and told they cannot make mistakes, they will, and it is important that those mistakes are admitted and accepted. Everyone makes mistakes. Only someone who is perfect …show more content…

It is said in the essay that a recent trend in sentencing offenders is public shaming. However, it is shown that shame only makes things worse. Shame makes the person focus on themselves. It is a feeling of “I am a bad person” and brings feelings of being worthless. Thus, shame does not “motivate constructive changes in behavior” it only causes people to react defensively and think of themselves. On the other side, guilt causes people to focus on others. It is the thought of “I did a bad thing” and causes feelings of regret and a desire to change and do better. From this, society can see that there is a right and wrong way to react to something wrong that has been done. In the case of a doctor admitting a mistake, if the family reacts very negatively and shames the doctor, the doctor will only be miserable and think about how bad they are. However, if the proper steps are taken to ensure that it is guilt instead of shame that doctors feel, there will be a sense of wanting to learn how to avoid the mistake in the

Show More
Related

Summary Of Shame Is Worth A Try By Dan Kahan

745 Words | 3 Pages

In Dan Kahan’s, Shame is Worth a Try, he claims that the use of shame as punishment is a more effective and economical alternative to imprisonment. Kahan uses a plethora of rhetorical devices in his article. He uses many examples of places in which shame is already being used as a punishment. In the first paragraph, Kahan states that “Nevertheless, courts and legislators have registered have resisted alternative sanctions-not so much because they wont work, but because they fail to express appropriate moral condemnation of crime”.

Read More

Shame Is Worth A Try Kahan Analysis

530 Words | 3 Pages

In Dan M. Kahan’s article Shame Is Worth a Try, he argued that shame can be used as an effective alternative method to punish law-breakers instead of sending them to jail. Kahan explained how shame works by giving several examples of shaming punishment, such as wearing disgraced signs or putting on embarrassing stickers. He stated that shame hurts people’s reputation as well as financial income and that is why it works as an alternative way to punish people. Nevertheless, he then brought up some opposing ideas held by courts and judges and the reason why shame does not work as effectively as expected. He explained that shame may fail short as a punishment in that it does not hurt as much as jail sentence, it can be easily abuse and it is rather

Read More

Role Of Shaming In The Code Of Hammurabi Essay

663 Words | 3 Pages

Shaming isolates, degrades, and causes rejection. By publicly shaming a person, they are being exposed to attention they did not want, and are encouraging others to exclude and reject the person being shamed. Not only did Isabel Laxamana lose her life, the lives of her friends and family also changed. It is easy to shame a person in a large crowd where the abuser can slip away into the group unnoticed. They can also draw support to shame and abuse from a larger audience.

Read More

Public Shaming In Nathaniel Hawthorne's The Scarlet Letter

657 Words | 3 Pages

As a result of public shaming being a more effective punishment, criminals are less likely to repeat the offense. Public shaming could result in a criminal to have a traumatic experience. Unlike other forms of punishment, public shaming allows for a criminal to truly feel what they did was wrong and it “can be a strong motivator for good behavior” (Diana Kwon). A criminal could be sentenced to 4-8 years of jail time and remain unchanged, but with public shaming the criminal receives publicity that is “so unpleasant that it qualifies as punishment” (Greg Beato). Because of this, Some people would argue that with public shaming a punishment is extended beyond the sentence.

Read More

Comparing Shame And Punishment In Nathaniel Hawthorne's The Scarlet Letter

707 Words | 3 Pages

Petty crimes such as drunk driving, non-aggravated assault, and embezzlement can benefit from more judges using shame, but more serious crimes and criminals, like murder and murders need a strict punishment, not just shaming. Someone such as Charles Manson, a ruthless murderous cult leader, wouldn’t benefit from public humiliation and shaming; serious criminals like him need a serious punishment, like a prison sentence which he currently serves. Serious crimes need serious punishments not just shame yet, less serious crimes could reap the benefits of shaming. If judges began using shame for more petty crimes and reserve prison space for serious crimes a serious issue of the rising price for housing inmates could improve. To house just one prisoner per year could cost up to $40,000; thousands of taxpayers dollars go towards prison upkeep and the prisoners.

Read More

How Does Nathaniel Hawthorne Use Public Humiliation In The Scarlet Letter

891 Words | 4 Pages

When a criminal is publicly humiliated they feel as if it's them versus the world because it their actions being brought to people's attention to recognize. The thoughts of other usually takes a toll on a person and they can start to feel overwhelmed. Feeling like this brings them to a place where they feel as the scapegoat. Feeling in distress, results in overload of anxiety, sorrow, and pain that the public should not endure. This can cause a criminal's self-esteem to lower due to the constant reminders of one’s offense.

Read More

Reintegrative Shaming Theory In Preventing Recidivism

172 Words | 1 Pages

This paper will demonstrate the effectiveness of Braithwaite’s reintegrative shaming theory in preventing recidivism among juvenile offenders depending on the crime committed. Although some research has suggested that reintegrative shaming can only be effective before the offender senses they are becoming an outcast within society, research also shows that the stigmatization of labeled offenders is often commenced by the harsh punishments placed upon them by the criminal justice system in the hopes of deterring future crimes. The research presented will elaborate on the effects of reintegrative shaming in attempts to prevent recidivism in crimes such as white collar crimes and drug and alcohol offenses on a college campus. There will also be

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of Shaming Penaltiess

1328 Words | 6 Pages

“Punishments intended to shame offenders for wrongdoing, popular throughout history, are once again on the rise” (Reutter, 2015). Shaming penalties attempt to humiliate and embarrass criminals to serve as a deterrence for criminal activity. Shaming has long been associated with methods of social control throughout the world’s history (Golson, 2011). The three main components of the criminal justice system; policing, the courts, and corrections have played a significant role in this social process, predominantly the correctional system and the courts, from which many of the shaming methods were disseminated (Golson, 2011). The earliest human shaming elements were much less formal and often involved society’s citizens policing themselves in

Read More

High Stakes Lies Essay

1810 Words | 8 Pages

Yet despite a wealth of empirical research, their unique implications remain ambiguous (Cohen, Wolf, Panter, &Insko, 2011). Guilt describes a negative feeling about the adverse impact of one’s actions on others: feeling personally responsible for harming others, violating justice principles, and failing to meet others’ expectations (McGraw, 1987). The importance of guilt in the regulation of social behavior, defining guilt as a negative affective experience that is evoked when one’s behavior falls short of personal or societal standards and that motivates reparatory behavior (Tangney, Miller, Flicker, & Barlow, 1996). On the other hand, guilt also has a positive side: An alternative theoretical account suggests that guilt functions primarily to facilitate prosaically behavior (Baumeister, Stilwell, & Heatherton,

Read More

Public Shaming In The Scarlet Letter

490 Words | 2 Pages

The ineffectiveness of public shaming is linked to the fact that many people do not care about societal expectations as much as predicted, and do not internally feel ashamed of their actions. It is necessary for one to reflect on the past to move forward, a goal that public shaming rarely

Read More

Essay On Scarlet Letter Shaming

434 Words | 2 Pages

In Nathaniel Hawthorne’s The Scarlet Letter, the common punishment for a range of crimes is shame, inflicted by forcing the “criminal” onto the town scaffold and having them face the judging stares of the whole town. Shame is a feeling of self loathing, in a way, and makes one feel like a bad person, when truly, most of the time, they’ve only done a bad deed. This often leaves the shamed feeling hopeless, especially if their actions ruined their reputation. Today, judges are beginning to sentence minor criminals to shame punishments instead of jail time. While some may argue that shame is a cheaper and simpler alternative to jail time, it doesn’t have the intended effects on the criminal, but instead have terrible, unpredicted effects.

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of Public Shaming

896 Words | 4 Pages

It has its pros and cons just like anything else. In an essay “Shame Is Worth a Try,” Dan M. Kahan argues that shame should be used because it is “cheap, efficient, and humane alternative to imprisonment.” This is the main reason public shaming should be used.

Read More

Ralph Waldo Emerson Character Traits

721 Words | 3 Pages

When a person doesn’t tell the truth and lies, then the person could get caught in the act of lying. Lying to a person could lead others into not trusting who they are. The first thing a person has to do to be honest is to be who they want to be and don’t try to please others. Honesty helps all people gain courage and confidence. When a person develops

Read More

Immanuel Kant's Radical Honesty

978 Words | 4 Pages

Lies put unnecessary stress on our lives and ruin our relationships. Why risk our happiness when it’s so easy just to be honest and share our true opinion with people. Telling the truth allows us to show people who we really are because when we are honest, we have nothing to hide. Although it may seem unrealistic to tell the truth 100% of the time, you have to realize that lies only leads to more lies and when it becomes easy for us to be dishonest in small situations, it becomes even easier to be dishonest in bigger ones. If we make it a daily habit to practice honesty in all that we do, we find it much easier to become honest people more

Read More

Definition Essay On Shame

2149 Words | 9 Pages

Yiwei Wang, a communication researcher for the Journal of Social Psychology proclaimed “Guilt motivates reparative actions like apology and confession, while shame prompts harm-doers to hide the offense. Guilt is elicited by conducting negatively evaluated behaviors whereas shame arises from negatively evaluated self after making misdeeds.” (pg. 675 / par, 3) The definition of guilt is to be the culprit of wrongdoing, impacting others by one’s actions. Negativity of one’s misdeed is developed through their personal analysis of themself and the mistake made.

Read More

More about June Tangney's Essay Condemn The Crime, Not The Person

Related Topics

Open Document