ipl-logo

Labor Unions DBQ Essay

1510 Words7 Pages

From 1875-1900, America was beginning to rise up from the increase in industrialization. However, dubbed “the gilded age” by Mark Twain, the thriving promise of a better , wealthier life in America was not as it seemed.When labor unions rose to change the harsh working conditions placed on workers, it seemed to be that they found little to no success. This was brought on by the little change that they made, the suffering and hardships they brought on themselves and others, and the little support they received from those around them. Although labor unions were able to change some conditions, most of those changes were minimal. For example, in a chart depicting the “Hours and Wages of Industrial Workers” (doc A), The average daily hours decreased …show more content…

In a political cartoon by Thomas Nast, there is a suggestion that labor unions were wanting more and more than they already achieved from business owners, but not being able to get it. This is inferred from the union man looking shocked at the goose he had cut open moments before. With the caption “the goose that lays the golden egg” (doc C), the union man was looking for more golden eggs only to find none left. There is also a family in the background looking to be suffering due to the union man’s actions. It depicts that because the union man kept wanting more instead of accepting what he already had, he would then suffer for not having anything, like a job, and his family would suffer because now they had nothing to help them survive. This was exactly what was happening in the late 1800’s. For example, the Homestead strike of 1892, union workers went on strike for better working conditions instead of accepting their jobs, and when they turned around to come back, they found out that they had been replaced and were now out of a job. This again shifted labor unions progress backwards, making them unsuccessful once again. This might have been made as a message to the Labor Unions demonstrating that they should stop speaking out against their jobs because they could end up like the man who killed the goose. Nast’s view on these labor unions was probably negative due to the fact that he is telling them to stop what they’re doing, but also sympathetic as if he understands what they are trying to do, but knows it won’t work and is warning them of this. Labor unions were not just suffering because of outside factors, but also those on the inside as well. Frank Leslie’s political cartoon suggests that because all of the union groups are having different opinions and disagreeing, they will not find success. The cooks in the cartoon

Show More
Related
1091 Words | 5 Pages

In Wealth against Commonwealth journalist Henry Demarest Lloyd discusses his opinions towards the unjust relationship between industrials and American workers in the Gilded Age. Throughout this era there are several crucial problems that confirm Lloyd’s thesis. These problems include the consequences of the second industrial revolution, the homestead strike of 1892, the effects on western miners from the industrial revolution, and the panic of 1893. Between these four milestones it is clear to see that Henry Demarest Lloyd’s thesis was true. Throughout the events of the second industrial revolution, the homestead strike of 1892, and the Panic and Depression of 1893 there are reoccurring problems such as unfair wages, unsafe working conditions

Read More
349 Words | 2 Pages

The Amherst Federation of Labour was a radical attempt in the late 1910’s as a way to combat labour pressures occurring in the period. It was an attempt to unionize the entire industry of the town of Amherst Nova Scotia. It was called the “one big union” which is exactly what it was. It was designed to unionize all industrial labour industries within the town. They advocated for a right to strike, improved working conditions, and better wages; quite similar to what most unions advocated for.

Read More
1052 Words | 5 Pages

When they sat down at the negotiating table, the two sides would bring with them very different preconceptions about how the world should work - it was clear the difference between rich and poor and the rich perception was that they were the owners of the poor so they should make up all rules. The Homestead Steel Strike is one of the most remarkable experiences for the trade unions’ history: after the employees tried to negotiate their wages unsuccessfully, the most powerful trade union of the moment called Amalgamated Association also tried to bargain some benefits but ended up making the hasty decision to confront the richest businessman in the US, Henry Frick, the company leader. In 1892 there was an armed battle between guards Frick hired to take care of the Mill he was shutting down and the workers that were against his decision. Lots of people died and the Mill remained

Read More
408 Words | 2 Pages

The feeling, shown in Nast's illustration after the railroad strike of 1877, that amalgamations simply lead to more " communistic values" and general uniformity made it very arduous to genuinely get anything done. Samuel Gompers, progenitor of the American Federation of Labor, argued that the right to strike was absolutely obligatory if any reforms were going to be made and not even this right had been officially granted to the people by regime (Document I). Gompers made it very pellucid that not even the very substratum of organized labor had been established and so up until this point the advances that had been made, were virtually frivolous. In conclusion, from 1875-1900 very few advances were made through organized labor in achieving better working conditions for workers.

Read More
349 Words | 2 Pages

The Gilded Age was a time of greed, money hungry corporation, and an obsession with wealth. Mark Twain’s novel, The Gilded Age, speaks about the business leaders negative impact on their works with the pursuit of wealth. This era saw a raise in economic growth, with an increase in workforce for all ages and genders. ( Topic 6, overview ) Despite the large number of women who still only worked within the home,the Gilded Age, saw a increase of women involved in education and other areas.

Read More
947 Words | 4 Pages

Their financial compensation restricted them from living a life beyond providing labor, examples of which being deepening family relationships, engaging in leisure activities, and learning new skills. The labor movement was able to secure a 40-hour work week, bringing workers closer to full human realization. Today, with greater potential for workplace automation, union members could focus our efforts on shortening the work week further, so that we may grow in other areas of our

Read More
988 Words | 4 Pages

In the 1840’s there was a wave of democratization created after Jackson’s presidency. It was created the value of the common man, and the importance of every person who was in the government. Of course, there were exceptions to this rule as there still certain groups like blacks or women that were viewed as inferior, but the majority of the population felt like they had worth. This led to series of reforms: hospitals for the mentally ill, schools for people with physical disabilities, the temperance movement, and labor unions. This movements fought a better society with better treatment even though there would be no economic incentives to do so.

Read More
355 Words | 2 Pages

The Gilded Age was an age of rapid economic growth. Railroads, factories, and mines were slowly popping up across the country, creating a variety of new opportunities for entrepreneurs and laborers alike. These new inventions and opportunities created “...an unprecedented accumulation of wealth” (GML, 601). But the transition of America from a small farming based nation to a powerful industrial one created a huge rift between social classes. Most people were either filthy rich or dirt poor, with workers being the latter.

Read More
1399 Words | 6 Pages

The workers gather to listen to several speakers over the five days near the McCormick Harvesting Machine Company among those giving the speaks there was both a pled from those who discouraged violence and encourage the crowd to join together against the companies; however, this was also a pled from those who urge worked to take action of violent revolution. The Haymarket Riot turned into a violent event resulting in a controversy trial that supported the discrimination against union members. Perhaps the greatest lasting effect of the riot was that it created a widespread revulsion against union, which caused membership to decline and reduce union influence; because unions became lined to radical ideas and violence in the popular mind. (Avial,2011)

Read More
775 Words | 4 Pages

Gabriel’s Rebellion, a slave rebellion against the oppressive white government, tested the legal authority of Virginia. Gabriel founded his rebellion on the basis of annihilating slavery and gaining rights as a free man. Though, he progressed further than any other attempt at a slave rebellion had, he had the misfortune of being unsuccessful. Rather than the end of slavery, the rebellion saw the end of Gabriel Prosser. He had planned a three wave attack on the city of Richmond, but before he could carry out his plan one of his co-conspirators gave him up, resulting in thirty to forty public hangings (May, 244).

Read More
579 Words | 3 Pages

Workers are sick and tired of the way they are being treated so they are banding together to speak out against these issues and unfair labor policies. These working unions have had to endure so much but now they are also faced with the task of changing society. According to the article, many unions have risen up

Read More
1297 Words | 6 Pages

Furthermore, due to the great depression, industrial workers realized that welfare capitalism was unpredictable as a result of their frequent layoffs and employers mismanagement. Since, the great depression led workers to see that employers only valued welfare capitalism when it was convenient and cheap. By 1933, more than half of the U.S. Steel’s mill hands had been laid off. Nonwhite workers, including black workers and Mexican workers were particularly vulnerable (Cohen, p. 240). This further doomed the

Read More
223 Words | 1 Pages

Unions have long employed their membership size as a bargaining chip when negotiating with employers. If negotiations between employers and unions failed, unionized members could stage walk-outs leading to a decrease in productivity thus straining the company’s operations. Increased membership allows unions to possess leverage over an industry by leading a large-scale strike or halting the operations of a profession like freight truck drivers. Additionally, the philosophy of the unions assisted in the development of national unions that encompassed a multitude of local unions and provided a more significant voice for the members and a greater means of advancing political agendas. 1981 witnessed the Christmas Trash Strike, an effective regional

Read More
733 Words | 3 Pages

The Gilded Age was an era marked by major advances in technology, the forming of robber barons, and the dismal living conditions of masses of working poor. It was an era where the worker’s rights were put on the sidelines for the and industrial growth of the nation, to uphold the image of American exceptionality. This dismissal of the rights, and in some cases dignity, of the majority of the population I believe was a major driving force in the development of contemporary worker’s rights. Through the accounts of the lowest class of workers, immigrants, we will see the common issues faced by the largest percentage population of city dwelling people. People who were clearly in dire need of reform and who often turned to what was typically the only option, unions.

Read More
657 Words | 3 Pages

I believe that the three most important strategies to successful labour relations with a unionized work force are: 1. Consistent and equitable application of policies, procedures including conformance with all applicable law. 2. Proactive performance and absenteeism management . 3.

Read More

More about Labor Unions DBQ Essay

Related Topics

Open Document